????? ????????? ?????? ???????????. ?????????? IF-scoring rules

1
????? ????????? ?????? ???????????. ??????????
IF-scoring rules

• ????????? ?.?¹., ??????? ?.?².
• ¹???????????? ??????????????? ????????????
  ????????????????? ???????????, ????????, ??????,
• ²??????????? ?????????????, ???????, ???????
• The new generation of citation metrics.
  Construction of IF-scoring rules
•               
• Moskovkin V. M¹., Golikov N. A².
• ¹ NRU Belgorod State University, Belgorod,
  Russia,
• ² Independent researcher, Kharkov, Ukraine
• ????????????? ???????????
• ???????? ??????????? ????????? ? ???????????
  ????????
• 10-12 ??????? 2013 ?. ??????, ????? ???

2
??? ?? ???????? ?????-???????? ?????? ???????????

• ??? ???????? ? ?????? L.Waltman N.E.van Eck
  (2012) ? 2010 ? 2011 ??. ????? ?????? ?????????
  ??????, ?????????????? ? ????????
  Scientometrics ? Journal of Informetrics,
  ?????????? ???????????? ?????? J.E.Hirsch (2005).
• ????? ?????????? ????????? ?????? ?????? ??? ??
  ???????? ?????-???????? ?????? ???????????
  m,g,e,w,hg,q ? ??.

3
?????????? h-index ? ??? ???????? ??????
???????????

• ?????????? h-index ?? ??????????????? ??????
  ???????? ? ?????? L.Waltman N.J.van Eck (2012).
  ?? ?? ????????????? ????????? ??????????
• ???? ??? ?????? ????????? ?????? ? ???? ??
  ?????????????? (?? ?? ??? ???????????) ?????????
  ?? ??????? ????????????????, ?? ?? ????????????
  ???? ???????????? ????? ?????? ??????????
  ??????????
• ???? ?????? X1 ????? ???? ????, ??? ? ??????? Y1,
  ? ?????? X2 ????? ???? ????, ??? ? ??????? Y2,
  ????? ????????????????? ??????, ????????? ??
  ?????? X1 ? X2 ?????? ????? ?????????? ???? ????,
  ??? ? ????????????????? ??????, ????????? ??
  ?????? Y1 ?Y2.
• ?? ?? ????? ????? ????? ??? ???? ?????-????????
  ?????? ??????????? (Marchant, 2009)

4
?????????? ?????????? ?????? ???????????

• ?????? ?????????? ?????????? ??????? ???????????
  ?? ?????? scoring rules (summation-based
  rankings) ???????????? ????????? ??????
• 1. ?????????? (?????) ????? ????????? ???????
  (??????) ???????????????? ?????????????? ?????
  ???????????? ??? ?????????.

5
?????????? ?????????? ?????? ???????????

• ??????? ??????? ????????? ???? ??????-???????
  ????????? ??????????, ??????????? ?????????? ?
  ??????????? ???????? (? ?????? ???? ?????? ?????
  ????????????????, ????????? ????? ?? ???????????,
  ??? ?????? ??????? ????????????? ???????? ?
  ???????????, ?????? ????? ????? ?? ???
  ?????????????, ? ?.?.).

6
?????????? ?????????? ?????? ???????????

• 2. ????????? ?????? ??? ????????????? ??????. ?
  ??????? ???????? ???????????????? ??????? ? ?????
  ??????, ??? ?????? ???????? ??????????
  ????????????? .

7
?????????? ?????????? ?????? ???????????

• . 3. ????????????? ??????? ?? ?????????? ????????
  ??????, ???????? ?? ?? ???????????? ?????????
  ?????????? ? ?????? 1.

8
??????? ??????? ???????

• ? ?????????? ????? ?????????????? ?????????
  ???????????
• ?????? ??????? (??????) ??????
• ?????? ??????? (??????) ???????? ???????????? ?
  ???????
• ?????? ?????? ??????????? ?? ??????

9
??????? ??????? ???????

• ?????? ??????? (??????) ???????? ???????????? ?
  ???????
• ?????? ??????-???????? ????????? ???????
  ????????
• ??????? ??????-???????? ???????? ???????????? ?
  ???????

10
??????? ??????? ???????

• ???? , ??
  , ????
• ??

11
??????? ??????? ???????
Quoted publication 1 journal
Quoted publication 1

Impact factor
Impact factor
Impact factor
Cited publication journal
Quoted publication 2 journal
Cited publication
Quoted publication 2
Impact factor
Quoted publication 3 journal
Quoted publication 3
12
??????? ??????? ???????
Ji1
Pi1

IFi1
IFi
IFi2
Ji
Ji2
Pi
Pi2
IFi3
Ji3
Pi3
13
????????? ??????

• ??? ????????????? ???????????? ???????
  ??????????? ????????? ?????????? ??????? ?????
  ?????? ?? ??????? ???????? ?????????? ???
  ???????? ???????????? ??????.

14
????????? ??????

• ? ?????? ?????? ??????????, ???????? (??????) ?
  ??????? ???? ???????????? ??????????, ?????-????
  ??????? ???????????? ??????-?????? ???????,
  ?????? ?????????? ?????????? ??????, ?
  ??????-??????? ???????? ? ??????? ????
  ???????????? ?????? ?????????? ??????.

15
????????? ??????

• ?????? ???? ??????, ????? ???? ???????? ???? ??
  ???????????? ?????????? (Scopus, Web of Science)
  ???? ?? ???????? ?????????? (Google Scholar).
  ???????? ??????? ???????????? ??? ?????? 2-??
  ???????.

16
????????? ??????

• ??? ??????? ???????????? ???????? ????????????
  ???????????, ???????????? ???????????????? ???? ?
  ????????? ??????????????? ??????????. ? ????
  ?????????? ??????? ???????????? ???? ????????
  ?????????, ??????????? ???????????????? ?????????
  ?????????? ?? Google Scholar ? ?? ?????????.

17
????????? ??????

• ????????? Scrapper, ?????????? ?????????? ??
  Google Scholar, ????????? ????????? ???????
• 1. ????????? ?????????? ?? ??????? ?????????????
  ?? Google Scholar. ??????????? ?????????
  ?????????? ???????? ??????, ??? ??????????,
  ?????? ? ??????? ???? ???????????? ?????? ? ??.
  ????????? ?????????? ?????????? ? ???? ??????.

18
????????? ??????

• 2. ??????? ?? ??????? ?? ?????? ?????????
  ?????????? (????? by cited) . ?? ?????? ?????
  ?????? ?? ???????? ?????????? ?????? Google
  Scholar - ?????????? ?????????? ??????.

19
????????? ??????

• 3. ????? scrapper ???????????? ??? ????????
  ????????? ?????? Google Scholar, ??????????
  ???????? ?????????? ?????????? ??????, ?????????
  ?????????? ?????????? ? ???? ??????. ???????
  ??????, ??? Scholar ????? ????? ???? ? ??????
  ?????? ????????? ???????? ???????.

20
????????? ??????

• 4. ? ????? Scimago ??????? ??????????? ? ????????
  ??????? ?????? ???????????? ??????? ???????? ?
  ?? ??????-?????????.

21
????????? ??????

• ??? ??? Google Scholar ?????????? ?? ???????
  ???????????????? ?????? ? ??? ? ?? ?????????????
  API ??? ????? ?????????????, ?????????????
  ??????????? ???????? ????????????? ???? ??
  ??????????? ?????? ??????

22
????????? ??????

• ???? ?? ???????? ??? ?? ??????????? ??????
  ?????????? ??????? ???????? ? Google Scholar, ???
  ?????????????? ?????? ?????? ??????????? ??
  ???????? ????? ??????, ?????????? ? ?????????????
  ???????. ?? ???? ?? ??????? ???? ???????????
  ?????????? ?????? ?? ????????.

23
??????????????? ????????? ?????????? ??????

• 1. ???????????????? ???????? ????????, ?????
  ????????????? ??????????? ?? Scholar ????????
  ??????? ???? ?????????? ???????? ? ??????????
  ???????? ?? ?????? Scimago. ??? ???? ????????
  ?????????? ? ???????, ????????????????, ????
  ?????? ? ???? ?? ???????? ????????, ????????????
  ??????? ???????? ??? ??????????????? ????
  (???????? ? ?.?).

24
??????????????? ????????? ?????????? ??????

• 2. ????? ???? ????????? ? ????????? ???????
  ???????????? ?????????????? ????????,
  ???????????? ???????? ??????????? ? ???????
  ????????, ???????????? ???????? ???
  ??????????????? ????.

25
??????????????? ????????? ?????????? ??????

• 2. ???? ???????????? ????????????? ?? ????????? ?
  ???????? ????? ?????? ??????????, ?? ?????????
  ?????????????? ???????? ??? ????????????? ???????
  (????? ?????????). ? ???? ??????, ???? ?
  ????????? ?????? Scholar ???? ??????????? ??
  ???????? ?????????????? ?????? ??????, ??
  ??????????? ??, ??? ????????? ?? ?????? ?
  ???????? ?????????.

26
??????????????? ????????? ?????????? ??????

• ? ??????, ???? ?? ??????????? ???????? html,
  ?. ?. ?????????? plain text, ?? ????????????
  ????????????? ??????? ?? ????????? ???????? ??
  ?????? Scimago ? ??????? ?? ???????????. ????
  ???? ??????????? ??????????, ?? ??????
  ???????????????.

27
??????????????? ????????? ?????????? ??????

• 3. ???? ?? ???? 1 ??? ?? ???? 2 ?????????
  (??????? ?? 2-? ?????????? ???????), ??????????
  ?? ??????????, ?? ?????? ?????????? ??????????
  ??? ?????????????? ? ??????????? ????????? ? ?
  ?????????? ???????? ?? ?????????, ???? ??
  ????????????? ????? ??????????? ??????-??????.

28
??????????????? ????????? ?????????? ??????

• ?????????? ? ????? ???? ?????? ?????????????
  ????????? ?????????? ?????? ?????? ? ? ?????????
  ????? ?? ??????.

29
??????????????? ????????? ?????????? ??????

• ???? ???? ?????????, ??? ???? ????????????
  ?????????? ?????? ??? ????????????? ????????????
  ?????? ?? ???????? ??? ??? ????? ????? ????????
  ?????? ??????????????? ??????????

30
??????????????? ??????????

• ??????? ??????????? ??? ?????????? ??? ???????
  ????????? ?? ?????? ?????? ?? ??? ??????? Google
  Scholar (http//scholar.google.com/citations?hlen
  userjls0BsYAAAAJview_oplist_workspagesize100
  ) ????? 69 ???????? ?????????? ?????????? ???
  ??????? ???? ???????????????? ???????? ????????,
  ???? ???????? ??????? ??????????? 5239

31
??????????????? ??????????

• ??????? ??????????? ??? ?????????? ??? ??????
  ???????? ?? ?????? ?????? ?? ??? ??????? Google
  Scholar (http//scholar.google.com/citations?hlen
  usereA9-8zsAAAAJview_oplist_workspagesize100
  ) ????? 40 ???????? ?????????? ?????????? ???
  ??????? ???? ???????????????? ???????? ????????,
  ???? ???????? ??????? ??????????? 2257

32
?????????????? ??????? ? ?????? ????????????????

• ?????????????? ???????? ???????????? ???????
  ????????????? machine learning. ????????
  ????????????? ??????? unsupervised learning ???
  ????????????? ??????? ????? ? ?????????????? ??
  ??????????? ??? ????????? ??????? ? ?????
  ???????? ? ???? ????????????.

33
?????????????? ??????? ? ?????? ????????????????

• ??? ?? ???????? ???? ????????????? ????????
  ?????????? ?????? ???????????????? ??????????????
  ? ?????? ?? ?????? ????? ????????? ????????
  supervised learning ??? ?????????? ???????,
  ????????? ?????????? (predication) ? ??? ??? ????
  ?????????????? ????????? ??????????? ???
  ???????????????? ??????.