Title: Support for Students with Disabilities in Professional Practice: Perspectives of Stakeholders.
1- Support for Students with Disabilities in
Professional Practice Perspectives of
Stakeholders. - Dr. Clodagh Nolan, Ph.D., M.Sc., M.A., Dip. COT.,
PG.Dip, Stats. - Director of the Unilink Service Lecturer
Discipline of Occupational Therapy, TCD - Declan Treanor, M.Sc., M.A., B.Sc., PG Dip Ed,
AdvCertEd - Director of the Disability Service, TCD
2Presentation Aims
- Background Need for research
- Results Findings from research
- Recommendations for the future
3Background
4(No Transcript)
5Student Journey from pre-entry to employment or
further education
6Project
- 1. An evidence-based research strand to determine
what are the main issues, concerns all have in
the placement process for students with
disabilities - 2. Development of placement planning procedures
and supports for students on professional courses
(guide for students) - 3. Present findings at this symposium
- http//www.tcd.ie/disability/projects/Phase2/Place
ment-support/symp.php
7Student Cohort
8Course breakdown
9Need for the Research
10 11Need for the Research
- Over the last decade the number of student with
disabilities have risen from 450 in 2000, to over
7,947 in 2012 representing 4 (6.4 TCD) of
student population (AHEAD 2012) - In Trinity the numbers on professional courses
has increased from 67 in 2006 to 245 in 2012-13 - Twenty three per cent are studying in
professional courses.
12Background Literature
- Increase in the numbers accessing professional
courses with a disability in line with the
widening participation agenda (Ryan, 2011
Rankin, Nayda, Cocks Smith, 2010 Griffiths,
Worth, Scullard Gilbert, 2010 Cailbourne
Cornforth, Gibson Smith, 2011 Wood Marshall,
2010 Stevenson, Clegg, Lefever, 2010) - Students often acquire a disability when they are
in college - in particular mental health
difficulties (Dooley Fitzgerald, 2012 Nolan,
2011) - Students can manage the academic environment of
university because supports are readily available
however it is during the professional placement
that issues with their disability emerge- as they
are performance based (Tee, et al, 2010)
13Literature
- Reasonable accommodations, are widely understood
within the academic environment but are less
defined in professional practice (Morris
Turnbull, 2007 Murphy, 2008, 2011 Tee, et al,
2010) - Perception that the quality of the educational
programme is lacking due to the students
disability which results in staff resentment
and difficult working relationships between the
university and the placements (Andre Manson,
2004)
14Literature Contd.
- DISCLOSURE
- No legal obligation for a person to disclose a
disability (Murphy, 2008 Morris Turnbull,
2007 Storr, Wray Draper, 2011) - Disclosure for students is a on-going process-
burden on the student (Griffiths, Worth, Scullard
Gilbert, 2010 Stanley, Ridley, Harris
Manthorpe, 2011) - The student should have the choice require time
control over when to disclose in a supportive
environment (Cailbourne Cornforth, Gibson
Smith, 2011) - Failure to disclose or delayed disclosure is a
potential barrier to learning (Storr, Wray
Draper, 2011)
15Literature Contd.
- Failure to disclose can often result in
disadvantaging the student and result in unsafe
and risky behaviours (Andre Manson, 2004 Tee,
et al, 2010) - Universities may not always be aware of a
students disability and even if they are, they
may have no permission to disseminate personal
information (Hirneth MacKenzie, 2004 Morris
Turnbull, 2007) - Responsibility to act if a student discloses to a
practice educator or any member of the University
Staff (Disability Act, 2005) - There is a need to have clear policies in
monitoring, evaluating an communicating
reasonable accommodations in practice (Ashcroft
Lutfiyya, 2013)
16- ENABLERS IN SUPPORTING DISCLOSURE
- Enabler to disclosure is the length of time in
placements the longer the better for disclosure
(Tee, et al, 2010) - More likely to disclose if the environment is
positive and receptive to disclosure with
collaborative relationships and the risk of hurt
is minimized (Andre Manson, 2004 Morris
Turnbull, 2007) - Framework for honest feedback and discussion of
issues enables and empowers students to disclose
(Tee et al. 2010) - Having Positive Role Models who have good
experiences encourages disclosure and confidence
to disclose (Griffiths et al, 2010) - Change focus from disability to the impact of the
disability and learning requirements (Ashcroft
Lutfiyya, 2013)
17Literature Contd.
- BENEFITS OF DISCLOSURE
- The balance between personal benefit and
emotional cost or risk to patient safety provides
a rationale for disclosure and non-disclosure
(Morris Turnbull, 2007) - Being trailblazers for disabled people in their
profession (Stanley, Ridley, Harris Manthorpe,
2011) - Disclosure contributes to a better self image and
self-confidence (Stanley, Ridley, Harris
Manthorpe, 2011) - Provides flexibility in the workplace, such as
option to work at a particular time of day,
reduced hours, accessibility location of office
(Stanley, Ridley, Harris Manthorpe, 2011)
18Literature Contd.
- REASONABLE ACCOMMODATIONS
- It is essential to make reasonable adjustments in
supporting students with disabilities (Storr,
Wray, Draper, 2011) - All of the studies identified more time as the
overriding reasonable accommodation that students
with disabilities required while on placement (to
allow them to practice skills and work tasks
(Murphy, 2011 Storr, Wray Draper, 2011 Tee,
et al, 2010) - Learning contracts and more frequent support was
also cited as being particularly important (Tee,
et al, 2010) - Suggested accommodations should always be
tailored to each individual student and their
practice context (Tee, et al, 2010)
19Literature Contd.
- Other reasonable accommodations can include
counselling, health service and Unilink support
(Storr, Wray Draper, 2011) and that these
supports need to be accommodated within the
placement hours - Practitioners on the ground moving towards a
therapist role from an educators role and needing
support to accommodate the students needs- input
reasonable accommodations (Hirneth MacKenzie,
2004)
20Questions we need to ask-Issues in the Literature
- Do professional competencies need to be
interpreted for students with disabilities and do
we need to foster positive change in attitudes to
students with disabilities? - Do all competencies need to be demonstrated in
every area of practice and is there flexibility? - Do we need to get the right balance between
accommodating the students needs and providing a
fair assessment? - How do we (Staff/ Students) negotiate appropriate
accommodations to support students as learners? - How do we allow extra time for students to reach
competencies given that they are developing
coping strategies as learners, given that in time
they will become proficient? (Murphy, 2011) - Who has responsibility for training both practice
educators and students in disability matters?
21Questions we need to ask-Issues in the Literature
- How do we encourage disclosure in order to
receive reasonable accommodation and how do we
balance this with the fear of disclosure and its
perceived reprisal. - How do we support educators to be educators as
opposed to utilizing their therapist skills when
challenges arise (Hirneth MacKenzie, 2004)
22Methods
- Exploratory descriptive study to
- 1) Elicit information and staff perspectives on
supporting students with disabilities on
professional placements - 2) Gain information on how students with
disabilities perceive their difficulties
concerns while on professional placements, and in
addition to explore ways that they would like to
be supported.
23Methods
- Survey Monkey hosted the 3 surveys
- Pilot Each survey was developed by experts
involved supporting students with disabilities
and they were piloted with individuals from the
target groups - Target group-all departments within TCD that have
a professional practice component registered
students with a disability - Ethics approved by the Faculty of Health Sciences
Ethics Committee
24Courses with Professional Practice
Business Studies a language
Clinical speech and language studies
Deaf Studies
Education (B.Ed, (B.Mus.Ed)
Social Work (B.Sc, M.Sc)
School of Dentistry (Dental Hygien (Dip), Dental Science, Dental Nursing, Dental Technologist, Pg Dip Clinical Dental Technology)
Human nutrition and dietetics
Medicine
Nursing (Midwifery, Childrens, General, Psychiatric)
Occupational Therapy
Physiotherapy
Radiation Therapy
25- Section One Results from Staff
26Staff Respondents
- Practice Education Coordinator (n 8) 72.3
- Head of Department (n3) 27.27
- Practice Education Coordinators (n68)
27Demographics Heads of Dept/Practice Education Co-ordinators (N11)
Category of role applies to you? (n11) Practice Education Coordinator (n 8) 72.3 Head of Department (n3) 27.27
Approx. years working as a practice education coordinator? Less than 2 years n0 2-5 years n4 33.33 6-10 years n3 25 11-15 years n1 8.33 16-20 years n1 8.33
Approx. how many students with disabilities are you aware of having placed or supported? 1-3 students n1 12.5 4-10 students n2 25 11-15 students n2 25 16-20 students n1 12.5 20-30 students n0 30-40 students n0 40-50 students n0 More than 50 students n2 25
28Demographics Practice Education Coordinators (n68)
Category of role applies to you? (n61) Practice Educator/Preceptor n 18 32.73 Practice Tutor n20 36.36 Regional Placement Facilitator n5 9.09 Student Supervisor n18 32.73
Approx years working as a practice educator/student supervisor? (n67) Less than 2 years n9 13.43 2-5 years n21 31.34 6-10 years n28 41.79 11-15 years n6 8.96 16-20 years n3 4.48
Approx. how many students with disabilities are you aware of having supervised or supported through practice education? (n66) No students n20 30.30 1 student n10 15.15 2 students n8 12.12 3 students n12 18.18 5-10 students n13 19.70 11-15 students n2 3.03 16-20 students n1 1.52
29Were you aware of the nature of the disabilities of the students you supervised in the workplace? (n40) Aspergers Syndrome n3 Attention Deficit (Hyperactivity) Disorder n4 Blind/Visually Impaired n8 Deaf/Hard of Hearing n13 Dyspraxia n3 Mental Health Difficulties n25 Neurological Condition n7 Speech and Language Disability n2 Physical Disability n7 Significant On-going Illness n17 Specific Learning Difficulty n23 Other n4 (Narcolepsy, Musculoskeletal conditions)
30Training
Training received by PECs and PEs in supporting
students and staff with disabilities.
31(No Transcript)
32Theme 1
33Reach the standard sub themes
- 1. Ability to carry out day-to-day duties
- They wont meet the standards required from
them. - 2. Duty of care
- The safety of the patient/client, e.g. when a
student has dyslexia, hand writing can be
difficult to read for the oncoming nurse and
other healthcare professional colleagues. - 3. Time and level of input required
- If a student requires more than the usual level
of support on clinical, they may be unwilling to
take (as many) students the following year. - I often have concerns about the impact on the
placement providers service provision to
clients if a student requires more support than
is reasonable to expect them to provide.. This
can have a negative impact on the placement
providers willingness to take students on
placement in the future)
34Reach the standard sub themes
- 4. Future as a professional
- At the end of the day we need to meet the needs
of the patients and if the disability prevents
you from meeting the standard of care required by
patients I don't think you should be in this job.
This applies to people with serious mental health
issues. the system needs to capture those who
are not capable of delivering safe effective
care, regardless of disability status. - 5. Fairness and assessment
- In my area of work competency to a specific
procedure is required therefore it is difficult
to change the goal posts for safety reasons. - 6. Student awareness and well-being
- I think the students insight into their own
needs ability to address these is a significant
issue for achieving competence. For some students
this was not an issue, for others it was.
35Appropriate level of support
36Emergence of a health issue
- Where things really begin to break down is
usually when the disability is not disclosed and
is then disclosed mid-placement. This usually
means the student is struggling, there is no
official information on disability and there is
no information on reasonable accommodations. - When I am aware informally of condition but
student is not comfortable disclosing to me. - The dyslexic students are easy...it is the ones
with undeclared mental health issues where there
is no LENS report that are very difficult. - There were some occasions when I would have
suspected that a student I or another colleague
supervised had a disability e.g. mental health
condition, but as we cannot ask and college
cannot inform us and the student was not obliged
to tell us, we had to proceed with a difficult
placement without any supports. - Unsure about to what extent I can talk to them
about low mood etc. in my role as supervisor.
37- Section Two Results from Students
38Demographics
of student responses Numbers of students (n)
Year of Students (n60) Junior Freshman (1st Year) Senior Freshman (2nd Year) Junior Sophister (3rd Year) Senior Sophister (4th Year) Postgraduate 25.0 21.7 25.0 23.3 5 15 13 15 14 3
Professional Course Category (n61) Business/Education/Social Studies/SLT/Deaf Human Nutrition/Dentistry/Medicine Nursing and OT/PT/RT 29.5 24.6 45.9 18 15 28
Choice of placement setting (n50) Yes, choice No, no choice 28 72 14 36
39Demographics
of student responses Numbers of students (n)
Number of weeks of professional placement completed by students (n54) No placements completed to date 2-4 weeks 6-10 weeks More than 10 weeks More than 20 weeks More than 30 weeks 16.7 9.3 11.1 14.8 11.1 37.0 9 5 6 8 6 20
Number of professional placements completed by student participants (n41) One placement Two placements Three placements Four placements Five placements Six placements Seven placements Eight placements 26.8 2.4 19.5 17.1 2.4 4.9 0.0 26.8 11 1 8 7 1 2 0 11
40Breakdown of disability type of student
respondents (n61)
41(No Transcript)
42Why I disclosed? The Benefits?
43Benefits of Disclosure
- Helps get appropriate support
- Everything makes more sense to your supervisor
if they know whats going on. They can't read
minds. - My practice educator took an interest into my
disability and tried to develop my learning
styles .... This was the first time I got to know
my disability really. - Encourages awareness and understanding
- The staff are more understanding to why I may
appear very tired in the evenings on my long
shifts. -
- My supervisor was aware of my needs and though I
did not have to take any time off or adjust my
caseload, knowing that the support was there for
me took a lot of stress out of the placement.
44Benefits of Disclosure
- If something happens
- Because if something happens they know how to
deal with it - It is always important to let someone know if
you have a disability for health reasons - It's a safe decision, if anything was to happen
the tutor is aware of all medical conditions
45Why I did not disclose?
46Fear Judgement
- Being judged
- I didn't want to be judged on anything other
than my ability to do the work. - I felt that I would be judged for it/ that it
would be held against me when it came to
grading. - Singled out
- It makes you singled out for extra attention for
CPC and removes you from clinic setting. - It would change the way tutors or other
professionals interacted/taught me. - Mental Health difficulties
- I would be afraid that they would use my mental
health against me or down the future. - As it was a mental health setting I felt
slightly awkward if I were to say I have one as
well.
47Obstacles
48Negative Attitudes
- Stigma
- I would not recommend students with mental
health difficulties disclose because of comments
made by practice educators on my placement with
regards to people with mental health problems
(not about me personally). - One of my disabilities is mental health in
nature which led to a shift in the behaviour of
my supervisor which I felt very conscious of and
uncomfortable with.
49Negative Attitudes
- Changing expectations
- People undermined my ability and gave me a
lighter caseload then what might otherwise have
been given. - Making a bigger deal
- I personally felt people were making a bigger
deal out of my concerns then what they were which
was a bit unsettling. - Powerlessness
- Occasionally I didn't feel I had the power
to.... or was brave enough to confront the
problem..... most of the time my problem was
ignored and was hard to explain, especially when
words wouldn't be a strength of mine..... Most of
the time I felt isolated while on placement as no
one knew my disability and sometimes I felt I
didn't know it....
50- Legal and Policy background
51What does the law say what is our duty?
- Equal Status Acts 2000-2011, the Employment
Equality Acts 1998-2011 and the Disability Act
(2005). - The Employment Acts is most relevant to those on
professional courses and gives added protection
to disabled students. Significant legislative
provisions promoting equality prohibiting
discrimination.
52- Section 16(3) (a) for the purposes of the
Employment Equality Acts, a person who has a
disability is fully competent to undertake and
fully capable of undertaking any duties if the
person would be so fully competent and capable on
reasonable accommodation being provided by the
persons employer.
53- Section 16(3) (b) the employer shall take
appropriate measures, where needed in a
particular case, to enable a person who has a
disability - (i) to have access to employment
- (ii) to participate or advance in employment
- (iii) to undergo training.
- Unless the measures would impose a
disproportionate burden on the employer
54What does the law say what is our duty?
- Reasonable Accommodation Provision needs include
- Practical Measures
- Constructive Dialogue individual must be party
to the accommodation. Employers enquiry can only
be adequate if employee can fully participate.
55Reasonable Accommodation
- The challenge over time in Colleges is to develop
professionally defined workable reasonable
accommodation that are appropriate for the
workplace and easily managed by the disabled
student on placements so that these can be taken
in to the world of work by graduates.
56Fitness to Practice
- Fitness to practice has been defined as an
individuals ability to practice their profession
in a way which meets appropriate standards,
meaning that a person has the skills, knowledge,
attitudes, character and health to perform
necessary functions safely and effectively
(adapted from HPC, 2005).
57Fitness to Practice
- The College Fitness to Practise policy states
that if a student has a disability, and there
are concerns over fitness to practise, section 4
of Schedule 1 shall apply, and the guidelines
outlined therein should be followed prior to any
fitness to practise hearing.
58- Section 4 of the College Policy refers to the
need to provide reasonable accommodation to
students with disabilities.
59- Recommendations and next steps
60As a Result of these findings
- Encourage Practice Educations Coordinators,
Practice Educators to be more pro-active in
supporting and planning for the needs of students
with disabilities - To extend the needs assessment process to the
workplace setting which will allow for the
development of clearly defined and individually
tailored practice place reasonable
accommodations. - Trialling of these practice place reasonable
accommodations will require constructive
dialogue and piloting for the development of
online resources.
61- Promote the benefits of a supportive and
inclusive environment that will encourage
students to seek support (and disclose their
disability) and plan for their needs in placement
with both the coordinators and practice
educators. - Competencies, proficiencies and learning outcomes
need to be clearly defined and ensure that they
are accessible to students with disabilities.
62- Strategies need to be developed around disclosure
and non-disclosure at any point during the
placement. Perceived disability also requires
attention and practice educators need to become
confident in discussing issues with students. - Establish training resources (including
programmes) on understanding reasonable
accommodations, confidentiality, awareness of and
sensitivity to disability issues such as
disclosure and managing disability
63- Practice Educators to provide a job description
for students to enable them to plan ahead of time
for their needs. - The research findings and the literature suggest
that students where possible should visit the
placement setting ahead of the placement to learn
about the placement and identify any potential
concerns or issues. - Establish role models (i.e. professionals with
disabilities) within the professional groups who
could act as mentors for students.
64- Any Questions?
- Thank you for listening!
65References
- Anderson, A. Wylie, N. (2011). Beyond the ADA
How Clinics can assist law students to bridge the
accommodation gap between the classroom and
practice. Clinical Law Review, 15(1), 1-53. -
- Andre, K., Manson, S. (2004). Students with
Disabilities Undertaking Clinical Education - Experience. Collegian, 11(4) 26-30.
-
- Ashcroft, T.J., Lutfiyya, Z.M. (2013). Nursing
Educators Perspectives of students with - disabilities A grounded theory study. Nurse
Education Today. - http//dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.nedt.2013.02.018
-
- Association of Higher Education, Access, and
Disability (2012). Survey on the Participation
Rates of Students with Disabilities in Higher
Education for the Academic Year 2011/2012. - Retrieved from http//www.ahead.ie/userfiles/file
/PR_2012.pdf -
- Barnes, C. (2007) Disability, Higher Education
and Inclusive Society. British Journal of - Sociology and Education, 28, No.1 135-145.
- Carpenter, C., Suto, M. (2008). Qualitative
research for occupational and physical
therapists A practical guide. Oxford Blackwell
Publishing. -
66-
- Conway, Ann (2009). Widening participation in
higher education and the resultant diversity of
learners A review of government policies, the
academy and market demands that may influence
this trajectory. Paper submitted for term review
as part of the EDD at the University of
Sheffield. http//arrow.dit.ie/cgi/viewcontent.cgi
- CORU (2013). Framework for a Code of Professional
Conduct and Ethics. Health and Social Care
Professions Council. -
- Claiborne, L.B., Cornforth, S. Gibson, A.
Smyth, A. (2011). Supporting Students with
Impairments in Higher Education Social Inclusion
or Cold Comfort? International Journal of
Inclusive Education, 15(5), 513-527. - Cooley, B. and Salvaggio, R. (2002). Ditching the
dis in Disability Supervising students who
have a disability. Australia Social Work. Vol.
55, No. 1 - Disability Rights Commission. (2007). Evaluating
the impact of the Disability Rights - Commission. September 2007. Report for the
Disability Rights Commission. - Disability Service Trinity College Dublin
Research Protocol.http//www.tcd.ie/disability/ban
ner/Links/Forms2020docs/index.php
67- Dooley, B., Fitzgerald, A. (2012). My World
Survey. National Study of Youth Mental Health in
Ireland. Headstrong University College Dublin. -
- Fitness to Practice in the Medical Profession
A Report to Universities UK and the Council of
Heads of Medical Schools by Eversheds Solicitors
(July 2001) -
- Griffiths, L., Worth, P., Scullard, Z., Gilbert,
D. (2010). Supporting Disabled Students in - Practice A Tripartite Approach. Nurse Education
in Practice. 10, 132-137. -
- Health Professions Council (2005) A disabled
persons guide to becoming a health professional.
Consultation document London The Health
Professions Council. -
- Hirneth, M., MacKenzie, L. (2004). The Practice
Education of Occupational Therapy - Students with Disabilities Practice Educators
Perspectives. British Journal of Occupational
Therapy, 67 (9), 396-403. - Kielhofner, G., Fossey, E. (2006). The range of
research. In G. Kielhofner (Ed). Research in
occupational therapy Methods of inquiry for
enhancing practice (pp. 20-35). Philadelphia
F.A. Davis Company. -
-
68- Morris, D.K., Turnbull, P.A. (2007). The
Disclosure of Dyslexia in Clinical Practice
Experiences of Student Nurses in the United
Kingdom. Nurse Education Today. 27, 35-42. -
- Murphy, F. (2008). The Clinical Experiences of
Dyslexic Health Care Students. Radiography. 15,
314-344. - Murphy, F. (2011). On being Dyslexic Student
Radiographers Perspectives. Radiography. 17,
132-138. - Neergaard, M.A., Olesen, F., Andersen, R.S.
Sondergaard, J. (2009) Qualitative description
the poor cousin of Health research? BMC Medical
Research Methodology, 952 doi10.1186147-2288-9-5
2 -
- Nolan, C. (2011). The Development and Piloting
of the Trinity Student Profile. A Self Report
Measure for Students experiencing mental health
problems. PhD Thesis. University of Dublin,
Trinity College. -
- Rankin, E.R., Nayda, R., Cocks, S., Smith, M.
(2010). Students with disabilities and Clinical
placement Understanding the perspective of
healthcare organisations. International Journal
of Inclusive Education. 14(5), August, 533-542.
69- Saladana, J. (2011). The coding manual for
qualitative researchers. London SAGE - Publications Ltd.
-
- Stanley, N., Ridley, J., Harris, J. Manthorpe,
J. (2011). Disclosing disability in the context
of professional regulation A qualitative UK
study. Disability and Society. 26(1), 19-32. -
- Stein, K.F. (2013). DSS and Accommodations in
Higher Education Perceptions of Students - with Psychological Disabilities. Journal of
Postsecondary Education and Disability, 26(2),
145-161. -
- Stevenson, J., Clegg, S. and Lefever, R. (2010),
The discourse of widening participation and its
critics an institutional case study, London
Review of Education, 8(2), p.105 115 -
- Storr, H., Wray, J., Draper, P., (2011)
Supporting disabled student nurses from
registration to qualification A review of the
United Kingdom literature. Nurse Education Today.
31, e29 e33. -
70- Tee, S. R., Owens, K., Plowright, S., Ramnath,
P., Rourke, S., James, C. Bayliss, J. (2010).
Being Reasonable Supporting disabled nursing
students in practice. Nurse Education in
Practice, 10, 216-221. -
- Tee, S.R., Cowen, M. (2012). Supporting
students with disabilities Promoting - understanding amongst mentors in practice. Nurse
Education In Practice, 12, 6-10. -
- Trinity College Dublin Fitness to Practice Policy
(2009-11) http//www.tcd.ie/about/policies/fitness
-to-practice-policy.php
71Useful Resources
- Useful Resources
- Association of Higher Education, Access, and
Disability (2012). National Guidelines for
Working with Nursing and Midwifery Students with
a Disability or Specific Learning Difficulty in
Clinical Practice. - Disability Service Trinity College Dublin (2013).
Supporting Trinity College students with
Disabilities into Employment. - Doyle, A. (2010). Clinical Placement Handbook for
Students with Dyslexia. Trinity College Dublin. - Howlin, F. Halligan, P. (2011) Supporting
Nursing and Midwifery Students in Clinical - Practice A Resource Guide for Clinical and
Academic Staff. University College Dublin - Guide to Disclosure, AHEAD Press, 2011
- Demystifying Disability in the Workplace, AHEAD
Press 2009