Title: Ecuador is classified as a developing country and therefore has healthcare standards that vary from those of the United States, including the precautions and measures taken during labor, intrapartum and post partum. A large majority of births in Ecuador
1 A Comparison of Neonatal Outcomes in Ecuador
and USA Carla M. Breccia, author
Rutgers-Robert Wood Johnson Medical School,
Piscataway, NJ 08854
- Conclusions
- There is an increased percentage of birth
asphyxias and infectious causes of neonatal death
in Ecuador. - This can be partially attributed to low rate and
frequency of maternal, fetal and neonatal
monitoring in Ecuador and the conditions most
children in Ecuador are born into that increase
airborne and indirect transmission of pathogens - These causes of neonatal death in Ecuador are
ones that can be prevented with improved
standards of care and healthcare setting and can
be explained, at least partially, by the hospital
conditions as hypothesized - As Ecuador continues to develop, its health care
standards are improving rapidly and with this
will hopefully come a continued decrease in
infant mortality rate and improved conditions of
public maternity hospitals. -
http//fotos.lahora.com.ec/cache/3/39/393/3938/150
-embarazadas-mueren-al-ano-antes-o-despues-del-par
to-20110218100756-3938af2d4702cfb0b466c534e225f944
.jpg
- Purpose
- to get a better understanding of prenatal
conditions in Ecuador - to see if the differences in standard of care in
the two countries translates into differences in
infant mortality - to see if the differences in standard of care in
the two countries translates into differences in
causes of neonatal death
Results
- Introduction
- Ecuador is classified as a developing country
and therefore has healthcare standards that vary
from those of the United States, including the
precautions and measures taken during labor,
intrapartum and post partum. A large majority of
births in Ecuador take place in public maternity
hospitals, where ten to fifteen women are giving
birth in the same room, all of whom are monitored
at rates that fall well below standards set by
the World Health Organization (Burkhalter et al,
2006). Burkhalter et al. found that only 31.7
of the time healthcare workers wash their hands
prior to putting on sterile gloves, only 36.6
suction the newborn after birth and only 9.8
establish skin-to-skin contact between child and
mother. - The Ministry of Health of Ecuador recognized
these deficits in their healthcare standards and
implemented the Healthy Maternity program.
This program aimed to improve child and maternal
care by altering the way in which hospitals
received funding to be based on the number of
services provided monthly (Hermida and Robalino,
2002). In addition to this program, a quality
assurance study aimed to improve the instruments
available for both maternal and child care,
hourly monitoring of the mother and child during
labor and post partum and education of mothers on
the warning signs of a sick child. This program
markedly improved hospital compliance with
clinical standards. - Other efforts that the country of Ecuador
makes to continue improving maternal and child
care focus on sexual and reproductive rights.
Unlike most other countries in Latin America,
Ecuador guarantees sexual and reproductive health
rights to all of its citizens (CFHI, 2006).
Programs such as Centro Médico de Orientación y
Planificatión Familiar (CEMOPLAF) and La
Fundación Ecuatoriana Equidad (EQUIDAD) work to
provide services (medical and educational) to
mothers, children and families who may not have
access to similar care. - These interventions appears to be effective,
seen with the drop in maternal mortality rate
from 90 per 100,000 in 2010 to 87 in 2013 and the
steady drop in infant mortality since 1989
(worldbank.org).
Figure 1 Birth Rate in Ecuador vs. USA
In this figure we can see the steady decline in
birth rate in Ecuador over the past 23 years,
while the same rate in the USA has stayed
relatively constant.
This is an image of the Dr. Eduardo Estrella
National Museum of Medicina
Figure 2 Infant Mortality Rate in Ecuador vs. USA
Methods A large amount of pregnant women were
observed throughout my travels in Ecuador as well
as in the public clinic. This large number of
pregnant women was not represented at Hospital de
los Valles, the private hospital where I did most
of my shadowing, which puzzled me. I inquired
about this observation to our program coordinator
and he informed me about the public maternity
hospitals, most specifically Maternidad Isidro
Ayora in Quito. Unfortunately, I was not able to
shadow at la Maternidad, but I feel as though I
got a good description from our program director
and from pictures. Upon learning about the
conditions of these hospitals, it sparked my
interest to see if there was a large difference
in neonatal infections and mortality rates
between the USA and Ecuador. Upon returning home,
a literature search was done to find concrete
numbers that could be compared. After finding
the values, they were compared and conclusions
were drawn.
In this figure we can see the steady decline in
Infant mortality rate in Ecuador over the past 24
years, while the same rate in the USA only
slightly decreased.
Figure 3 Causes of Neonatal Fatality in USA in
2008
This image is of me and my classmates while
traveling in Ambato with Chimborazo in the
background.
- References
- .Birth rate, crude (per 1,000 people). (n.d.).
Retrieved November 2, 2014, from The World Bank.
website http//data. - worldbank.org/indicator/SP.DYN.CBRT.IN
- Birth rate - crude (per 1000 people) in Ecuador.
(n.d.). Retrieved November 2, 2014, from Trading
Economics website http//www.tradingeconomics.com
/ecuador/birth-rate-crude-per-1-000-people-wb-data
.html - Black, R. E., Cousens, S., Johnson, H. L., Lawn,
J. E., Rudan, I., Bassani, D. G., Jha, P., ...
Child Health Epidemiology Reference Group of WHO
and UNICEF. (January 01, 2010). Global, regional,
and national causes of child mortality in 2008 a
systematic analysis. Lancet, 375, 9730, 1969-87 - Burkhalter B, W Edson, S Harvey, M Boucar, S
Djibrina, J Hermida,P Ayabaca, M Bucagu, S
Gbangbade, and A McCaw-Binns. 2006. Quality of
obstetric care observed in 14 hospitals in Benin,
Ecuador, Jamaica, and Rwanda. Operations Research
Results. Published for the U.S. Agency for
International Development (USAID) by QAP. - Conde-Agudelo, Agustin, Belizán, José M.
(n.d.). Maternal morbidity and mortality
associated with interpregnancy interval cross
sectional study. BMJ. - Hermida, J., Robalino, M. E. (January 01,
2002). Increasing compliance with maternal and
child care quality standards in Ecuador.
International Journal for Quality in Health Care
Journal of the International Society for
Quality in Health Care / Isqua, 14, 25-34. - Mortality rate, infant (per 1,000 live births).
(n.d.). Retrieved November 2, 2014, from The
World Bank. Websitehttp//data.worldbank.org/indi
cator/SP.DYN.IMRT.IN - Sexual health as a human right Ecuador's unique
model. (n.d.). Retrieved November 4, 2014, from
Child Family Health International website
http//www.cfhi.org/web/index.php/program/show/id/
- Woodhouse C, Lopez Camelo J, Wehby GL (2014) A
Comparative Analysis of Prenatal Care and Fetal
Growth in Eight South American Countries. PLoS
ONE 9(3) e91292. doi10.1371/journal.pone.0091292
-
Figure 3 Causes of Neonatal Fatality in Ecuador
in 2008