Title: ?? ??? ??a?s?? ??a t?? ?efa?a?a?? ?p???e?a
1CURRENT DEVELOPMENTS IN THE REGULATORY FRAMEWORK
OF THE EUROPEAN BANKING SYSTEM Prof.
Christos Vl. Gortsos Secretary General,
HBA November 2007
2- TABLE OF CONTENTS
-
- A. Introductory Remarks
- B. The European financial regulatory framework
- C. Operation and supervision of credit
institutions - D. Operation and supervision of capital markets
- E. Consumer protection
- Payment and settlement systems
- Combating financial crime
3A. INTRODUCTORY REMARKS 1. Levels of regulatory
intervention in the financial sector a.
International level (Basel Committee on Banking
Supervision, IOSCO, FATF, OECD, CPSS) b.
Community level c. National level Currently,
the principal source of regulatory intervention
in the financial sector are the legal acts
adopted at Community level within the context of
achieving the integration of the internal market
in the European Community.
4- A. INTRODUCTORY REMARKS
-
- 2. Reasons for regulatory intervention in the
European financial sector - a. Necessary prerequisites negative integration
- Financial services trade liberalisation
- b. Adequate prerequisites positive integration
- Ensuring the stability of the banking system
capital markets insurance market - Ensuring that markets are fair, efficient and
transparent - Combating of financial crime
- Protection of consumers of financial services
- Efficiency of payments systems
5-
- B. THE EUROPEAN FINANCIAL REGULATORY FRAMEWORK
-
- 1. What rules are applied to credit institutions
-
- Operation and supervision of credit institutions
(under C) - Operation and supervision of capital markets
(under D) - Consumer protection (under E)
- Operation of payments and settlement systems
(under F) - Combating of financial crime (under G)
- Insurance mediation
- Personal data
- Tax law and accounting law
- Commercial law
- Labour law
- Environmental liability
6- B. THE EUROPEAN FINANCIAL REGULATORY FRAMEWORK
-
- 2. How the rules are produced
-
- Legislative procedure
- Co-decision procedure
- Lamfalussy procedure (under 3 below)
-
- Self-regulation
- Codes of ethics
- European Payments Council
- Ombudsman
7 B. THE EUROPEAN FINANCIAL REGULATORY
FRAMEWORK 3. Lamfalussy procedure The
Lamfalussy procedure concerns the way of
producing rules in European financial law and was
adopted by the Community institutions in 2002,
initially in the capital markets sector. Its
extension to the banking and insurance sectors
was then decided in 2004 The Lamfalussy
procedure consists in four levels Level 1 Aim
Adoption of a general regulatory framework and
determination of the issues as to which technical
implementing measures should be adopted by the
European Commission Procedure Adoption of
Community acts by the classic procedure of
co-decision of the Council and the European
Parliament on a proposal of the European
Commission
8 B. THE EUROPEAN FINANCIAL REGULATORY
FRAMEWORK 3. Lamfalussy procedure
(cont.) Level 2 Aim Concretization of the
framework principles of Level 1 Procedure
Adoption of technical implementing measures in
the form of a Directive or Regulation by the
European Commission. Provision of technical
assistance by sectoral technical committees
Level 3 Aim Joint interpretation and consistent
implementation of the measures of Levels 1 and 2
at a national level Procedure Co-ordination of
actions by the sectoral committees and issuing
relevant guidelines Level 4 Monitoring by the
European Commission of the compliance of the
Member States with the measures adopted
9B. THE EUROPEAN FINANCIAL REGULATORY FRAMEWORK
Level 1 Level 2 Level 3
Type of legal act Basic legal act Implementing measures Recommendations / Guidelines
Legislator European Parliament / Council European Commission CEBS/CESR/ CEIOPS
Support mechanisms EBC/ESC/EIOPC (as advisory committees) EBC/ESC/EIOPC (as advisory and regulatory committees) CEBS/CESR/ CEIOPS (as advisory committees)
10- B. THE EUROPEAN FINANCIAL REGULATORY FRAMEWORK
- White Paper on Financial Services Policy
(2005-2010) - Better lawmaking
- EC regulatory and supervisory structures
- Ongoing and future legislative activities
(2005-2010) - The external dimension
11C. OPERATION AND SUPERVISION OF CREDIT
INSTITUTIONS
- 1. Committee of European Banking Supervisors
(CEBS) - The current issues
- Liquidity risk (under a)
- Review of the large exposures regime (under b)
- Supervision in third countries (under c)
- Options and discretions in the CRD (under d)
- Definition of own funds (under e)
-
12C. OPERATION AND SUPERVISION OF CREDIT
INSTITUTIONS
- 1. Committee of European Banking Supervisors
(CEBS) - (a) Liquidity risk
- CEBS has been invited to provide the European
Commission - a survey of the regulatory framework adopted by
the members states and - an analysis of selected topics related to
liquidity risk management. - The objective is to identify those issues which
may require changes in the current regulatory
framework and promote regulatory and supervisory
convergence at EU level
13C. OPERATION AND SUPERVISION OF CREDIT
INSTITUTIONS
- 1. Committee of European Banking Supervisors
(CEBS) - (b) Review of the large exposures regime
- CEBS has been invited to provide the European
Commission with feedback in the following areas - purpose and metrics of the large exposure regimes
- a range of specific issues (i.e indirect
concentration risk) - The objective is a wider ranging review of the
current large exposures regime
14C. OPERATION AND SUPERVISION OF CREDIT
INSTITUTIONS
- 1. Committee of European Banking Supervisors
(CEBS) -
- (c) Supervision in third countries
- This issue relates to general guidance issued
under article 143 of the Directive 2006/48/EC on
the equivalence of arrangements for consolidated
as well as for supplementary (conglomerates)
supervision in third countries
15C. OPERATION AND SUPERVISION OF CREDIT
INSTITUTIONS
- 1. Committee of European Banking Supervisors
(CEBS) - (d) Options and discretions in the CRD
- CEBS is invited to conduct by May 2008 an indepth
- technical analysis on the exercise of options and
discretions - identified in its supervisory disclosure
framework by - indicating for each of them
- the use of the options and discretions in each
Member State - the extent to which further harmonisation might
be achieved in terms of reducing the number of
discretions and options of the CRD.
16C. OPERATION AND SUPERVISION OF CREDIT
INSTITUTIONS
- 2. Directive 2007/44/EC as regards procedural
rules and evaluation criteria for the prudential
assessment of acquisitions and increase of
holdings in the financial sector - The Directive will streamline the criteria and
timescale of the assessment procedure applied by
European supervisory authorities in cases where
qualifying holdings are acquired in the financial
sector - The adoption of this Directive is a decisive step
towards strengthening European competitiveness in
particular by promoting cross-border
consolidation
17C. OPERATION AND SUPERVISION OF CREDIT
INSTITUTIONS
- 3. Commissions Consultation on reorganisation
and winding up of credit institutions (Directive
2001/24/EC) - The purpose of Directive 2001/24/EC is to ensure
that a credit institution and its branches in
other Member States are reorganised or wound up
according to the principles of unity and
universality - Main issues of the consultation
- the problems of cross-border reorganisation and
winding-up of banking groups, and the obstacles
to the transferability of assets in a crisis
situation and - gaps and ambiguities in the current Directive
identified so far
18D. OPERATION AND SUPERVISION OF CAPITAL MARKETS
- Markets in financial instruments (MiFID)
- CESR Level 3 measures
- Protocol on the supervision of branches under
MiFID - The protocol aims in fostering greater
cooperation between authorities in the exercise
of their core supervisory functions over
investment firms and credit institutions that
provide cross-border investment services. The
protocol sets out a framework for co-operation
between competent authorities under two different
models (a) joint supervision conducted through
common oversight programmes, and (b) requests for
assistance based on efficient allocation of
supervisory tasks.
19D. OPERATION AND SUPERVISION OF CAPITAL MARKETS
- Markets in financial instruments (MiFID) (cont.)
- CESR Level 3 measures
- Passport under MiFID Recommendations for the
implementation of the Directive and Statement on
practical arrangements regarding the late
transposition of MiFID - The purpose of the recommendations is to have a
common approach on the notification procedures
and on the future collaboration between the home
and the host authorities that will be necessary
in order to guarantee efficient and consistent
supervision on cross-border activities. The main
aims of these recommendations are, inter alia,
the clarification of some aspects regarding the
supervision of tied agents, MTFs and
representative offices, the elaboration of
pragmatic solutions for the transition from the
ISD passport to the MiFID passport, and the
prioritisation of those aspects where investment
forms need clarity in the short term.
20D. OPERATION AND SUPERVISION OF CAPITAL MARKETS
- 1. Markets in financial instruments (MiFID)
(cont.) - CESR Level 3 measures
- Protocol on MiFID Passport Notifications
- This Protocol provides a framework for the
co-operation of competent authorities with regard
to the implementation of the passport
notification provisions of the MiFID. It
supplements the provisions of the CESR
Multilateral Memorandum of Understanding (1999)
which provides the general basis for mutual
cooperation of CESR Members. - Q A on best execution
- This process-driven approach aims to promote
market efficiency and investor protection by
fostering competition between trading venues and
promoting investor confidence by ensuring that
firms are obtaining the best possible result for
their clients order.
21D. OPERATION AND SUPERVISION OF CAPITAL MARKETS
- 1. Markets in financial instruments (MiFID)
(cont.) - CESR Level 3 measures
- Inducements under MiFID
- Recommendations clarifying the range of
application of the regime, specifying a common
approach to the understanding of the different
categories of payments within Article 26 of
Directive 2006/73/EC. - List of minimum records
- The recommendation sets out the content of the
list of minimum records that competent
authorities need to draw up in accordance with
Article 51 (3) of Directive 2006/73/EC and that
investment firms have to keep.
22D. OPERATION AND SUPERVISION OF CAPITAL MARKETS
- Markets in financial instruments (MiFID) (cont.)
- CESR Level 3 measures
- Publication and consolidation of markets data
- These guidelines and recommendations are meant
to facilitate the understanding of certain
requirements of the MiFID and its Implementing
Regulation on publication and consolidation of
market information. They also intend to
facilitate a consistent implementation of the
relative provisions without imposing further
obligations on investment firms, MTFs or
regulated markets. - MiFID transaction reporting
- Guidance to three aspects of transaction
reporting is provided, i.e. (a) practical
solutions for the reporting obligations for
branches, (b) clarification as to what
constitutes execution of a transaction for
transaction reporting purposes, and (c)
operational solutions for some aspects of
reporting channels.
23D. OPERATION AND SUPERVISION OF CAPITAL MARKETS
- Markets in financial instruments (MiFID) (cont.)
- CESR Level 3 measures
- Non-equities transparency
- In this paper CESR concludes that it has not
been identified an evident market failure in
respect of market transparency on bond markets
and so it believes that any increase in
transparency would need to be carefully tailored
to ensure that liquidity provision and levels on
competition are not damaged. In other words, a
thorough cost-benefit analysis should be
undertaken by the Commission before any
regulatory action.
24D. OPERATION AND SUPERVISION OF CAPITAL MARKETS
- 1. Markets in financial instruments (MiFID)
(cont.) - CESR Level 3 measures
- Report on commodity and exotic derivatives
- This paper is part of CESRs response to the
Commissions request for assistance on commodity
and exotic derivatives in order to determine (a)
which relevant entities, activities and
instruments should be covered by the scope of EU
financial markets regulation in these areas, and
(b) whether current regulation needs to be
adapted to take into account the specificities of
the commodities and commodity derivatives
markets. - New arrangements for the reporting of derivatives
trades in accordance with MiFID - CESR developed in cooperation with the industry
new arrangements for transaction reporting. These
include, (a) reporting on non-securities
derivatives (including commodity derivatives) and
(b) an alternative way for the identification of
securities derivatives on some derivatives
markets (the Alternative Instrument Identifier).
25D. OPERATION AND SUPERVISION OF CAPITAL MARKETS
- 2. Clearing and settlement in the EU
-
- Giovannini barrier 3
- Corporate Actions
- Monitoring of market implementation of the
Market Standards on Mandatory Distributions - Announcements,
- Information from (I)CSD to participants,
- Information from Custodian banks and/or (I)CSD
participants, - Data relating to announcements,
- Resources,
- Processing of payments.
26D. OPERATION AND SUPERVISION OF CAPITAL MARKETS
- 3. TARGET2-Securities
- On 6 July 2006, the Governing Council of the
European Central Bank decided to further explore
in cooperation with central securities
depositories and other market participants, the
setting up of a new service called
TARGET2-Securities for securities settlement in
the euro area - The objective of the project is to allow the
harmonised settlement of securities transactions
in euro which are settled in central bank money.
Synergies for the market with other facilities
operated by the Eurosystem will be sought, in
particular in connection with the future TARGET2
payment system - The Governing Council of the ECB intends to hold
another public consultation by the end of 2007,
requesting comments on fully articulated user
requirements. Only after this public consultation
the Governing Council will decide on the
development phase
27D. OPERATION AND SUPERVISION OF CAPITAL MARKETS
- 3. TARGET2-Securities (cont.)
- Objectives
- Provide a single venue where all EU assets can be
exchanged for euro - Reduce cost of cross-CSD settlement via a single
settlement platform and standardized
communication protocols - Reduce complexity and associated operational
costs and risks by harmonizing market rules and
practices for clearing and settlement related
corporate events - Benefits of T2S on post-trading
- Increased market liquidity and access to wider
investor base lead to lower cost of capital for
issuers - Increased market liquidity and lower cost of
portfolio diversification lead to better return
for investors
28D. OPERATION AND SUPERVISION OF CAPITAL MARKETS
- 4. Investment Management
- White Paper on enhancing the Single Market
framework for investment funds - European Parliament Draft report on Asset
Management II - CESRs Consultation paper Content and form of
Key Investor Information (KII) disclosures for
UCITS - CESR makes specific recommendations on a number
of key points, including objectives and scope of
KII, format and general content, risk-reward,
past performance, charges. -
- Purpose Review of the Directive 85/611/EC by
the end of 2008
29D. OPERATION AND SUPERVISION OF CAPITAL MARKETS
- 4. Investment Management (cont.)
- Private Placements
- European Commissions feedback statement on its
consultation on the functioning of private
placement regimes in Europe, and on the case for
a common EU regime - The Commission concludes that the possibilities
for private placements differ widely across EU
Member States and that there is a good level of
support for a European regime, in particular for
non-harmonised open-ended investment funds, to
which the Prospectus Directive does not apply.
30D. OPERATION AND SUPERVISION OF CAPITAL MARKETS
- 4. Investment Management
- Hedge Funds
- Hedge Fund Working Group Consultation Paper -
Draft Code of Conduct of the London-based hedge
fund industry - The proposed standards are rooted in the UK/FSA
background but aspire to become globally
applicable. They are presented in a consultation
document in order to allow hedge fund managers
and other stakeholders to be involved in the
development of the standards.
31D. OPERATION AND SUPERVISION OF CAPITAL MARKETS
- 5. Other issues
- Investor protection and transparency
- Level 3 - Commission Recommendation on the
electronic network of officially appointed
mechanisms for the central storage of regulated
information referred to in Directive 2004/109/EC
of the European Parliament and of the Council - Other Level 3 issues under consideration
- The implementation of the options given by the
Transparency Directive to Member States - Further consideration of the mechanisms for the
storage and filing of regulated information - QA document on the inconsistencies in the
practical application of the Transparency
Directive - Prospectus
- Assessment of the application of the Prospectus
Directive and the level 2 Regulation - Level 3 measures under preparation
32D. OPERATION AND SUPERVISION OF CAPITAL MARKETS
- 5. Other issues (cont.)
- Market abuse
- Level 3 measures under preparation. Issues
identified for further work (October 2007 June
2009) include - List of sanctions and measures applicable under
the MAD, in order to accommodate concerns about
the diversity of measures and sanctions applied
in Member States. - Harmonisation of requirements for insiders
lists. - Suspicious Transactions Reporting
- Stabilisation Regime
- Twofold notion of inside information
- Mapping of the existing thresholds in Member
States and other practices of CESR Members as
regards notifications of transactions by persons
discharging managerial responsibilities and
consideration of whether there is a case for
recommending adjustment of the threshold. - Develop guidance on the definition of inside
information with regard to commodity derivatives
to the extent possible.
33D. OPERATION AND SUPERVISION OF CAPITAL MARKETS
- 5. Other issues (cont.)
- Credit Rating Agencies
- IOSCO Code of Conduct Fundamentals for Credit
Rating Agencies - (CESR intends to monitor the compliance by CRAs
with the Code and submit its report probably by
mid 2008) -
- European Commission Issues an Additional Request
for CESR to review the role of Credit Rating
Agencies. Main issues for consideration - - Transparency of Credit Rating Agencies (CRAs)
rating methodologies, - - Human resources allocated to rating and
monitoring, - - Periodic monitoring of the ratings and
timeliness of rating actions, - - Potential conflicts of interest (i.e.
remuneration structures of CRAs)
34E. CONSUMER PROTECTION
- 1. Proposal for a Directive on credit agreements
for consumers - Main issues
- The principle of responsible lending a. duty to
provide explanations and b. obligation to assess
the consumers creditworthiness - Provision of exhaustive pre-contractual
information - Introduction of new provisions on the way of
calculating the Annual Percentage Rate of Charge - Right of withdrawal period to exercise the right
of withdrawal is 14 days - The Plenary of the European Parliament is
expected to adopt the Directive in December 2007
or January 2008
35E. CONSUMER PROTECTION
- 2. Future expected developments in the field of
consumer protection - Green Paper on Bank Accounts and Customers
Mobility the aim is - a. to improve customer mobility in relation to
bank accounts, - b. to boost competition in financial services
and - c. to allow customers to make full use of the
internal market. - Green Paper on the Retail Financial Services
- a. Report on the Green Paper on retail financial
services to be delivered by the European
Parliament - b. Single Market Review to be published by the
Commission it will include the findings of the
consultation on retail financial services
36E. CONSUMER PROTECTION
- 2. Future expected developments in the field of
consumer protection (cont.) - White Paper on Mortgage Credit the objectives of
the White Paper will be - a. to facilitate lenders cross-border activity,
- b. to facilitate customer mobility,
- c. to enhance product diversity and
- d. to improve and modernize consumer protection.
- Concrete measures will be proposed as regards
early repayment, information requirements, annual
percentage rate of charge, advice, property
valuation, assessment of consumers
creditworthiness, foreclosure procedures and land
registers registration.
37E. CONSUMER PROTECTION
- 2. Future expected developments in the field of
consumer protection (cont.) - Review of the Directive 2002/65/EC concerning the
Distance Marketing of Consumer Financial Services
on the conclusion of cross-border contracts
Conduct a study from an economic perspective in
cooperation with stakeholders affected by the
Directive, examining whether or not the Directive
has achieved its objectives.
38F. OPERATION OF PAYMENT and SETTLEMENT SYSTEMS
- 1. SEPA
-
- SEPA is the area in which
- Citizens, firms and other economic agencies will
be able to make electronic - payments in euro in the European Economic Area
with the same conditions, - rights and obligations, regardless of their
country of establishment -
- The political dimension of SEPA
-
- Focus on the Eurozone SEPA will be delivered to
the countries of the Eurozone as a priority -
- Countries which do not belong to the Eurozone
will be able to participate in the - pan-European systems of payments and will be able
to adopt the relevant - standards and practices to contribute to the
single euro payments market
39F. OPERATION OF PAYMENT and SETTLEMENT SYSTEMS
- 1. SEPA (cont.)
- The EPC is a self-regulatory decision-making
organisation of the European Payment Industry - The development and delivery of competitive 'SEPA
Payment Schemes' are a competence of the EPC - The adoption of the 'SEPA Payment Schemes' will
be - a decision of the EPC and the national banking
systems, so that they can develop the basic
prerequisites (e.g., capability of delivery) in
due time - a decision of each bank so that it can provide
its clientele with SEPA payment services - The adoption of 'SEPA Schemes' at a national
level to supplement or replace existing
'infrastructures' at national level is a decision
for the national banking communities - Within the framework of PE-ACH, the possibility
of merging the national ACHs is a decision for
the users and/or shareholders
40F. OPERATION OF PAYMENT and SETTLEMENT SYSTEMS
- 1. SEPA (cont.)
- Launching of SEPA payment instruments
-
- 1.1.2008, SEPA for Cards (at least one card
payment product with EMV chip) - 28.1.2008, SEPA credit transfers for citizens and
business - 1.11.2008, SEPA direct debits for citizens and
business -
-
41F. OPERATION OF PAYMENT and SETTLEMENT SYSTEMS
- 2. TARGET2
- The Trans-European Automated Real-time Gross
settlement Express Transfer (TARGET) system went
live in January 1999, at the same time as the
introduction of the euro -
- In October 2002, the Governing Council of the ECB
decided to develop the next generation of TARGET
(TARGET2) - In 2003, three national central banks of the euro
area - the Deutsche Bundesbank, the Banque de
France and the Banca dItalia - offered to
jointly build and operate the SSP on behalf of
the Eurosystem
42F. OPERATION OF PAYMENT and SETTLEMENT SYSTEMS
- 2. TARGET2 (cont.)
- Under TARGET2 the decentralised structure of the
current TARGET system will be replaced by a
single technical platform, the so-called Single
Shared Platform (SSP) - TARGET2 is envisaged to start operations on 19
November 2007
43G. COMBATING FINANCIAL CRIME
- 1. Anti Money Laundering
- (a) Directive 2005/60/EC (3d AML Directive)
- The Third Anti-Money Laundering Directive
incorporates into EU law the June 2003 revision
of the Forty Recommendations of the Financial
Action Task Force (FATF) - The Directive is applicable to the financial
sector as well as lawyers, notaries, accountants,
real estate agents, casinos, trust and company
service providers. Its scope also encompasses all
providers of goods, when payments are made in
cash in excess of 15.000. - Those subject to the Directive need to
- identify and verify the identity of their
customer and of its beneficial owner and monitor
their business relationship with the customer - report suspicions of money laundering or
terrorist financing to the public authorities
-usually, the national financial intelligence
unit and - take supporting measures, such as ensuring a
proper training of the personnel and the
establishment of appropriate internal preventive
policies and procedures. - introduce additional requirements and safeguards
for situations of higher risk (e.g. trading with
correspondent banks situated outside the EU). - Member States should implement the Directive
until December 2007
44G. COMBATING FINANCIAL CRIME
- 1. Anti Money Laundering
- (b) Commission Directive 2006/70/EC
- Commission Directive lays down implementing
measures for Directive 2005/60/EC - of the European Parliament and of the Council as
regards - the definition of politically exposed person
- the technical criteria for simplified customer
due diligence procedures and - for exemption on grounds of a financial activity
conducted on an occasional or very limited basis - Member States should implement the Directive
until 15 December 2007
45G. COMBATING FINANCIAL CRIME
- 2. Combating Terrorist Financing
- Regulation (EC) 1781/2006
- Regulation (EC) No 1781/2006 on information on
the payer accompanying transfers of funds lays
down rules for payment service providers to send
information on the payer throughout the payment
chain. This is done for the purposes of
prevention, investigation and detection of money
laundering and terrorist financing. - The Regulation transposes Special Recommendation
VII (SRVII) of the Financial Action Task Force
(FATF) into EU law and is part of the EU Plan of
Action to Combat Terrorism. - Member States shall lay down the rules on
penalties applicable to infringements of the
provisions of this Regulation and shall take all
measures necessary to ensure that they are
implemented. Such penalties shall be effective,
proportionate and dissuasive.They shall apply
from 15 December 2007.
46G. COMBATING FINANCIAL CRIME
- 3. Weapons of Mass Destruction (WMD)
proliferation financing - In June 2007, the FATF adopted guidance regarding
the implementation of financial provisions of the
United Nations Security Council Resolutions
(UNSCRs) to counter the proliferation of weapons
of mass destruction (WMD). -
- In October 2007, the FATF adopted guidance
regarding the implementation of activity-based
financial prohibitions of United Nations Security
Council Resolution 1737. This guidance is not
binding and is not directly related to any of the
Financial Action Task Force (FATF) 40 9
Recommendations, and therefore it is not
considered in the FATF mutual evaluation or
assessment process. It is intended solely to
assist jurisdictions in developing guidance for
financial institutions to facilitate
implementation of the activity-based financial
prohibitions contained in S/RES/1737(2006).