Title: Test of New Master
1Mergers Acquisitions (MA) Strategic Analysis
Series Primer July 2010
2MA Primer
Introduction
Objectives
- The purpose of this module is to allow new ACs
and Consultants to - obtain a background understanding of MA
- understand what XXX does/doesnt do in an MA
project - review basic analytical tools required in
different MA projects at XXX - develop, through an exercise, an important basic
analytical skill often used in MA projects
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
3MA Primer
Introduction
Agenda
- Trends in MA
- Guiding Principles for Successful MA
- XXX Approach
- Case Examples
- screening
- due diligence
- sale
- Exercise on Synergy Calculation
- Typical Watchouts
- Key Takeaways
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
4MA Primer
Introduction
Agenda
- Trends in MA
- Guiding Principles for Successful MA
- XXX Approach
- Case Examples
- screening
- due diligence
- sale
- Exercise on Synergy Calculation
- Typical Watchouts
- Key Takeaways
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
5MA Primer
Drivers of MA Activity
Strategic
Financial
Other
Macro-economics
- Economy boom or recovery
- Over-capacity in an industry
- Cheap money
- Industry consolidation
- Globalization
- Gain share
- Eliminate competitive threat
- Capture operating opportunities, e.g., scale
efficiencies - Leverage existing business systems
- forward/backward integration
- start-up alternative
- Diversify/balance portfolio
- Retire excess industry capacity
- Improve capital markets evaluation of acquirer
- meet growth targets
- reduce portfolio risk
- Invest idle cash
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
6MA Primer
MA Activity - U.S. vs. Europe
European and US MA activity is experiencing
similar positive trends.
CAGR (1992-1997)
B
Europe
21
US
41
Note Transaction Value (including Net Debt of
Target). Excludes split-offs. Europe includes 50
major countries
Source SDC
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
7MA Primer
Trends
MA Activity
- MA activity has grown rapidly in nominal dollar
terms, peaking in the U.S. in the late 1980s, and
then matching those levels last year - The ferocious merger activity of the late 1980s
was driven in large part by the easy money
afforded by the junk bond market. This resulted
in huge, often unsubstantiated, premiums being
paid for companies without regard to the value
creation opportunities presented (or not
presented, as the case may be) by the
operations/underlying business of the target - Growth in merger activity since 1992 has
coincided with the economys recovery from
recession - Recent MA activity benefiting from
- extended economic health with little recessionary
pressure on horizon - a resulting corporate demand for growth
- increase in international MA activity as
companies pursuing global strategies - Since late 1997, U.S. and European markets have
experienced the resurgence of junk bonds to
facilitate the execution of deals getting larger
and larger
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
8MA Primer
Trends
MA Activity by Country 1996/97
US market dominates the global MA activity.
Percent change
50
41
110
31
50
14
79
57
Note Represents announced deals Source SDC
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
9MA Primer
Trends
US MA Activity by Seller Industry (1992-97)
Value and volume of transactions vary across
industries. For example, in the US, computer
software and service industries tend to do many
small deals. Telecommunications, broadcasting and
leisure and entertainment have high transaction
size.
Source SDC ( March 98)
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
10MA Primer
Trends
Multiples Paid for Acquisitions
Over the last five years, the prices paid for
acquisitions have been increasing, and reinforces
the need for in-depth due diligence and analysis
to ensure a fair price.
Average EBIT Multiple
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
11MA Primer
Trends
Acquisition Success Rates
The majority of acquisitions have been deemed
failures.
Percent of Acquisitions Failing in First Five
Years
Percent of Total
Harvard Business School
Survey of CFOs
London Business School
XXX Company Study
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
12MA Primer
Trends
Common Reasons for Failure
- Poor strategic fit
- combination does not provide competitive
advantage - lack of understanding of the business
- Overpay
- imperfect information/wrong valuation
- too optimistic in forecasts/synergies
- unforeseen industry downturn/emerging technology
- auction environment failure to set/stick to
walk away price - CEO/management ego
- revenue growth vs. profitability
- emotion vs. analysis
- Poor post acquisition integration
- inadequate planning
- failure to exploit revenue/margin potential
- disrupted relations with customers, employers and
suppliers - culture clash failure to involve acquired
people
Strategic, financial and operating causes
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
13MA Primer
Trends
Glossary
- The legal combination of two (or more) formerly
independent entities - The acquisition by an independent entity of a
control stake in another entity. This is usually
achieved by acquiring more than 50 of shares for
a public company - The sale or closure of a particular entity
- Leveraged buy-out An acquisition made possible
financially by large issuance of debt, making the
new entity highly leveraged or geared (i.e.,
with a high ratio of debt to equity) - Investment firms managing private funds by
running business portfolios - Bonds (or debentures, or coupon debt) issued by
an entity without a credit rating or with
entities with non-investment grade rating - Financial markets use the service of credit
rating firms such as Standard Poors and
Moodys to determine entities credit worthiness
(i.e., the ability for an entity to pay back
their debt). Ratings are allocated from AAA or
Aaa (highest) to C (lowest) - Entities with Investment Grade Ratings (AAA down
to B) are considered stable - non-investment Grade entities (below B) present
an investment risk (e.g., third world countries,
highly leveraged companies)
Merger
Acquisition
Divestiture
LBO
Private Equity Firms
Junk bonds
Credit Rating
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
14MA Primer
Introduction
Agenda
- Trends in MA
- Guiding Principles for Successful MA
- XXX Approach
- Case Examples
- screening
- due diligence
- sale
- Exercise on Synergy Calculation
- Typical Watchouts
- Key Takeaways
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
15MA Primer
Principles
Guiding Principles (1 of 2)
XXX believes that a clear and disciplined
approach to the acquisition process is vital to
ensure success.
Proactive Strategic Thinking
Screening
- Acquisitions are made to improve the strategic
position of existing businesses or add to the
core competencies of the corporation - Assess impact of acquisitions on long-term
shareholder value - Use acquisition as a vehicle to accelerate growth
in key business units
Principles
- Look for all companies that potentially
strengthen the corporation - Don't allow a "transaction" mentality to dominate
the process
Activities
- Look for targets that present best fit in terms
of - relatedness
- impact on market position
- Examine key success factors of potential targets
- Examine competitive position of client vs.
competitive bidders
- Define business segments
- Diagnose key competencies and any skill gaps
- Analyze market dynamics
- Study cost of acquisition versus organic growth
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
16MA Primer
Principles
Guiding Principles (2 of 2)
XXX believes that a clear and disciplined
approach to the acquisition process is vital to
ensure success.
Execution
Capture Full Value
Principles
- Make better decisions upfront through careful due
diligence - Strive to identify "deal breaker" issues as early
as possible - Use information and insights to provide
confidence in making a bid
- Clearly communicate corporate vision to target
- Begin integration process as early as possible
- Be objective to ensure a fair decision-making
process - Create a set of short-term and long-term
objectives
- Quantify all potential synergies and cost savings
- Examine margin and revenue forecasts
- Evaluate management of target
Activities
- Provide a blueprint for capturing full potential
value - Support managerial integration team
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
17MA Primer
Principles
Strategy and MA
Acquisitions at both the corporate and business
unit level need to be thought of as an integral
part of a company's growth strategy.
- Corporate objectives
- growth and financial targets
- competitive arena
- Corporate strategy
- strategic position
- management of resources
Growth throughcorporate acquisitions
- Business unit objectives
- business definition
- growth and financial targets
- Business unit strategy
- strategic position
- key success factors
- sustainable competitive advantage
Growth throughbusiness unit acquisitions
Organic growth
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
18MA Primer
Principles
Strategic Framework
The focus of strategic MA activity should be in
areas where there is the highest value creation
opportunity as well as the strongest parenting
advantage.
High
Focus
Value Creation Opportunity
Low
High
Low
Parenting Advantage Is value to our client
higher than value to other parents?
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
19MA Primer
Principles
MA Value Creation Opportunities
MA value can arise from generating the full
value of an undervalued entity or by adding value
to under performing assets.
Buy cheap
Add value
Generate synergies
Take advantage of inefficiencies in the market
Spot new market trends early
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
20MA Primer
Principles
Critical Issues
XXX assimilates the strategic process with
acquisitions by focusing on four key areas.
(I) Relatedness
(II) Strategic Strength
(III) Market Dynamics
- Market growth
- Technology changes
- Product substitution
- Barriers to exit and entry
- Supplier and buyer power
- Cost sharing
- Customer sharing
- Competitor overlap
- Experience sharing
- Strength of key competitors
- Relative cost position
- Strengths and weaknesses of acquirer
Resolving these issues allows an accurate
evaluation of a company
(IV) Value
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
21MA Primer
Principles
Success Criteria - Diagnostic Tool
The ability to improve the strategic position of
the acquirer, and grow or complement its existing
competencies are keys to success.
III) Market Dynamics
RMSgt1.5x
Growth gt 10
RMS1.5-1.0x
Growth 5-10
(II) Strategic Strength(Relative Market Share)
Growth lt5
RMSlt0.5x
Low lt25
Medium 25-50
High gt50
Relatedness (I) (Experience and/or Cost Sharing)
(IV) Value Accurate evaluation based on NPV vs.
Market Price
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
22MA Primer
Principles
Success and Market Share
Acquisitions that increased market share
substantially were consistently more successful.
Incidence of success
Incidence of outright failure
Percent
Market Share Bought
Sources Porter (33 Large U.S. Corps.
Management Interviews)
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
23MA Primer
Principles
Market Impact of Announced Transactions
The stock market rewards companies that make
related and/or focused acquisitions.
Average Percent Price Increases
Definition
Unrelated
Related
Focused
- Minimal cost overlap between acquirer and target
- Medium degree of cost overlap
- Target derives gt70 of revenues from same
business as acquirer
- Significant amount of activity and cost overlap
between acquirer and target - Target complements existing product line and adds
to core competencies of acquirer
Note Two weeks before compared to one week
after announcement
Source Industry Literature Review,
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
24MA Primer
Principles
Examples of Failures (1 of 2)
The MA landscape is littered with unsuccessful
acquisitions which failed to adhere to the core
guiding principles.
Acquisition Thesis
Transaction Value
Reason for Failure
Industry
Acquirer
Target
- Inadequate due diligence
- growth cycle not well understood
- brand strength overestimated
- Leverage distribution channels
Consumer Goods
Quaker Oats
Snapple
1.7B
Entertain-ment
Sony Matsushita
Columbia MCA
4.8B 6.1B
- Own up stream contents for downstream hardware
- Inadequate due diligence
- over valued synergies
- Strategically flawed and poor integration
Sears
DeanWitter
6.7B
- Build a "one-stop" financial supermarket
- Inadequate due diligence
- limited cross-sell potential
Finance
Amex
Shearson
900MM
- Expand distribution capabilities
- Poor integration
- culture clash
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
Sources Industry literature
25MA Primer
Principles
Examples of Failures (2 of 2)
The MA landscape is littered with failures which
failed to adhere to the core guiding principles.
Transaction Value
Acquisition Thesis
Reason for Failure
Industry
Acquirer
Target
Retail
Allied
Federated
6.5B
- Inadequate due diligence
- overvalued potential synergies and brand value
- Strategically flawed
- few synergies between computer hardware and
telephony - Poor integration
ATT
NCR
7.5B
Technology/Telecommu-nications
- Technology/ telephony integration
Novell
WordPerfect
- Poor integration
- culture clash
1.4B
Sources Industry literature
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
26MA Primer
Principles
Examples of Successful Acquisitions (1 of 2)
However, many companies have created enormous
value through successful acquisitions.
Transaction Value
Industry
Target
Acquisition Thesis
Acquirer
Reason for Success
Consumer Goods
Cadbury Schweppes
Dr. Pepper/ 7-Up
2.0B
- Expand geographic distribution
- Careful due diligence
- increased scale and presence as a global player
First Financial Management
- Well-managed integration
- integration of credit card processing services of
consumer and commercial sides
Financial Services
First Data
6.6B
Wells Fargo
Crocker
1.07B
- Expand geographical reach and leverage back-office
- Careful due diligence and integration
- capture of synergies and cost savings
Food
Tyson
Holly Farms
1.4B
- Good strategic fit and due diligence
- capture of cost- sharing potential
Sources Industry literature
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
27MA Primer
Principles
Examples of Successful Acquisitions (2 of 2)
However, many companies have created enormous
value through successful acquisitions.
Transaction Value
Industry
Target
Acquisition Thesis
Acquirer
Reason for Success
- Well-managed integration
- close attention to culture match open
communication of strategic vision
High Technology
Cisco
Stratacom
4.5B
Healthcare
Columbia
HCA
- Build national healthcare group
- Good strategic fit and due diligence
- capture of cost-sharing and scale economies
5.7B
- Expand geographic reach and leverage product
strengths
- Good strategic fit and due diligence
- strong understanding of market dynamic to improve
strategic position
Manufacturing
Crown, Cork Seal
Carnaud(French)
3.9B
Transportation
Union Pacific
Chicago North Western Transportation Company
1.1B
- Good strategic rationale
- pre-emptive strategic move to maintain strategic
position
Sources Industry literature
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
28MA Primer
Introduction
Agenda
- Trends in MA
- Guiding Principles for Successful MA
- XXX Approach
- Case Examples
- screening
- due diligence
- sale
- Exercise on Synergy Calculation
- Typical Watchouts
- Key Takeaways
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
29MA Primer
Approach
Key Activities
Approach to acquisitions follows a series of key
steps.
- Should an acquisition strategy be pursued?
Strategy
- The best candidate based on
- attractiveness and availability
Acquisition target screen
- Validate screening assumptions
Due diligence
Bid structure and negotiations
Integration pre-planning
Target valuation
Integration
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
30MA Primer
Approach
MA Value Chain
XXX has considerable experience in the different
skill sets needed at different stages in the
acquisition process.
Acquisition Screening
Integration
Valuation
Due Diligence
Objective
- Identify potential candidates which present best
fit in terms of - relatedness
- impact on market position
- Understand full strategic value of acquisition
candidate
- Implement strategic vision for merger that gives
direction and impetus for change - Definitive actions and role definitions to speed
integration process
- Make better decisions upfront
- Provide agenda for post-acquisition change
- Improve success in closing deal
- Business/strategic review
- market trends
- customers and suppliers
- competitors
- costs, technology
- valuation/full potential assessment
- Quantify current operating value, stand alone
operating improvements, and potential synergies
- Pre-planning
- combined cash flows
- Transition plan
- Cost reduction
- Revenue enhancement
XXX Activities
- Industry profile
- Target screening
- Target approach
- Ignore market dynamics and competitor impact on
future cash flows - Taking management projections at face value
- Reluctance to interfere in operations of acquiree
- Non-identification of "deal breaker" issues
- Misunderstanding of cost savings and upside
opportunities
Common Pitfalls
- Drawing up incomplete list of candidates
- Use of screen process to develop a strategy
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
31MA Primer
Approach
XXX and Other Advisors' Role
XXX provides a neutral, third-party view and
analysis on the primary strategic and financial
issues.
- In tandem with accountants, analyze financial
projections based on managerial input
Investment Banks
- Value based on prices of comparable businesses
recently bought or sold - Multiple of earnings/cash flow, assets
- Little or no direct input in post-merger
activities
- Comb for potential acquisition candidates based
on availability - Utilize contacts to build a wide list of
potential targets
- Limited external research
- largely dependent on managerial projections
Accounting Firms
- Look for potential acquisition candidates based
on availability - Use contacts to build list of potential targets
- Value based on prices of comparable businesses
recently bought or sold - Construct a basic DCF model
- Little or no direct input in post-merger
activities
XXX Role
- Analyze quality of customer and supplier base
- Look for potential cost savings and upside
synergies - Understand market dynamics to better project
market and company growth objectives
- Construct a discounted cash flow model that
values stand alone, operating improvements and
potential synergies - Provide a reality check on market valuations
- Active involvement in transition plan, cost
reduction and revenue enhancement opportunities - "Hands-on" driver of change process to realize
full value of merged entity
- Determine targets based on corporate objectives
and strategies - Identify acquisitions that enable the acquirer
to - penetrate new markets
- acquire capabilities
- gain scale advantage
- improve relative market position
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
32MA Primer
Approach
Roles and Responsibilities
XXX is an integral part of a dedicated team of
MA professionals.
100
Investment Banks
- How, what and when to say
80
XXX
- Prospectus
- Other document- ation
60
Percent of Professional Time
- Support as needed
- Legal Due diligence
40
Lawyers
- Presentation to both boards
- Portfolio
- Norm bands
- Key issues investigation
- Intrinsic cash flow valuation
- How, what and when to say
- Scripts
20
- Letter of comfort
- Due diligence
Accountants
0
Identify candidate
Due Diligence
Valuation
Development approach
Develop offer and deal structure
Negotiate
Board approvals
Implement
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
33MA Primer
Approach
Acquisition Screening
Finding potentially attractive targets is the
critical first step in an MA process.
Acquisition Screening
Integration
Valuation
Due Diligence
Objective
- Identify potential candidates which present best
fit in terms of - relatedness
- impact on market position
XXX Activities
- Industry profile
- Target screening
- Target approach
Common Pitfalls
- Drawing up incomplete list of candidates
- Use of screen process to develop a strategy
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
34MA Primer
Approach
Acquisition Screening(Common Mistakes)
Inadequate screening of candidates is commonplace.
- Review all potential candidates and determine
which ones present the best fit in terms of - relatedness
- impact on market position
Objective
- Drawing up an incomplete list of candidates,
excluding divisions of large companies and very
small companies - Using the screening process to develop the
strategy - Saying
- "We can't buy it because..."
- "They have turned us down before"
- "The government won't approve it" or
- "It's family/state/competitor/or big company
owned" - Making the wrong contact at the target company
- Being impatient with acquisition process
- Assuming "no" really means "no"
Common pitfalls
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
35MA Primer
Approach
Candidate Screening Process
XXX's approach to screening involves careful
analysis of the market, competitors and the
target.
Broad screen
Fine screen
Thorough analysis
Focus of analysis
Market position
Relatedness
Value creation
Screening criteria
- Industry sector
- Company size
- Company growth
- Market share
- Financial performance
- Key success factors
- Competitive position (costs/customers)
- Opportunity for synergies
- Stand-alone value of synergies/ performance
improvement potential - Management/cultural considerations
Objective
- Rapidly narrow down universe of companies
- Provide shortlist of candidates
- Detailed assessment of remaining candidates
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
36MA Primer
Approach
Screening Criteria
The XXX approach to screening evaluates the
market dynamics and the target's performance and
fit with the acquirer.
Partial examination
Complete examination
Availability of Benefits
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
37MA Primer
Approach
Due Diligence
XXX goes beyond financial analysis to assess
fully the competitive position of the target, and
identify "deal breaker" issues .
Acquisition Screening
Integration
Valuation
Due Diligence
Objective
- Make better decisions upfront
- Provide agenda for post-acquisition change
- Improve success in closing deal
- Business/strategic review
- market trends
- customers and suppliers
- competitors
- costs, technology
- valuation/full potential assessment
XXX Activities
- Non-identification of "deal breaker" issues
- Misunderstanding of cost savings and upside
opportunities
Common Pitfalls
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
38MA Primer
Approach
Approach to Due Diligence
XXX minimizes the risks of acquisitions with a
thorough approach to due diligence.
- Provide access to the XXX world network to
support pre-letter of intent go/no-go decisions - Conduct exhaustive due diligence study of
industry and company dynamics - identify key cash flow drivers
- quantify margin and revenue growth forecasts
- quantify cost reduction potential
- identify "deal breakers" and/or "red flags"
causing bid adjustments - identify and quantify all upside opportunities
- Identify and evaluate potential exit options
- Assist in securing financing through development
and presentation of objective, third-party
business analysis
- Create blueprint for Full Potential strategy
- Generate enthusiasm and momentum for the deal
within the target company
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
39MA Primer
Approach
Typical Due Diligence Issues (1 of 2)
A well-designed due diligence process involves
answering a series of key questions.
What business is the target in? Who are the
current and potential competitors?
Business Definition
Is this an attractive industry from size, growth,
supplier power, regulatory environment, business
concentration and profitability perspectives? Is
this the right time to buy?
Market Overview
How do you make money in this business today and
in the future?
Key Success Factors
How well positioned is the target company?
(market share, management, products, company
performance, customer stability/defections,
etc...)
Company Overview
What are key purchase criteria and how does our
target perform relative to competitors? How
might this change in the future?
Customer Evaluations
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
40MA Primer
Approach
Typical Due Diligence Issues (2 of 2)
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
41MA Primer
Approach
Typical Due Diligence Activities
Understanding of market dynamics, strategic fit,
and company performance requires an in-depth
external and internal review.
External Assessment
Internal Assessment
- Interviews with target company's management in
- marketing/sales
- finance/accounting
- operations
- etc.
- Comprehensive review of target company's customer
base, personnel and operations - Analysis of above information to determine
- market share projections
- potential margin changes
- relative cost position
- salesforce effectiveness
- potential operational improvements
- Blind interviews with customers, competitors,
suppliers and market experts conducted by
experienced, business-minded group members - Exhaustive review of market research reports,
company profile information, articles,
publications and other publicly available sources - Analysis of above information to determine
- overall market growth potential
- customer segmentation
- relative performance of target company vs.
competitors based on customer needs - vulnerability in value chain (including
distribution channels)
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
42MA Primer
Approach
Valuation
XXXs valuation process quantifies the full
strategic value of an acquisition to ensure that
the client can price with comfort and confidence.
Acquisition Screening
Integration
Valuation
Due Diligence
Objective
- Understand full strategic value of acquisition
candidate
- Quantify current operating value, stand alone
operating improvements, and potential synergies
XXX Activities
- Ignore market dynamics and competitor impact on
future cash flows - Taking management projections at face value
Common Pitfalls
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
43MA Primer
Approach
The Value Creation Process
XXXs approach to valuation encompasses three
distinct steps that closely examine the
historical and future financial performance of
the target.
- Investment banking focus
- leverage/gearing
- type of financial products used
Financial deal structure
Percent of Current Market Value (Debt and Equity)
- Integration opportunities
- expanded distribution
- plant consolidation
- eliminate redundant RD
- purchasing leverage
Synergies
Stand alone operating improvement
- Better management of assets
- plant best demonstrated practices
- reduced manufacturing complexity
- outsourcing/move off shore
- reduced working capital
Premium
Current operating value
Market value of debt and equity
- Stand alone cash flow
- domestic demand
- import penetration
- current market share
- price per unit
- variable cost per unit
- fixed costs (RD, advertising, etc.)
- capital expenditures
Current market value
Maximum potential value
Difference between purchase price and
post-integration value to client represents
value creation opportunity
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
44MA Primer
Approach
Valuation Roadmap
The valuation process must answer a set of key
questions regarding capabilities, synergies, and
strategic fit.
Value Potential Synergies
Develop RequiredCapital Structure
Value Target as Stand Alone Business
Develop Core Business Expectations
XXX Role
XXX Role
XXX Role
XXX/Investment Bank Role
- Five year cash flow forecast
- Critical areas of sensitivity
- market growth activity
- key customers/ products
- cost reduction
- capital expenditures
- Detailed financial due diligence
- historical financial analysis
- future protections
- DCF analysis
- Comparable analysis
- Other potential buyers
- strategic
- financial
- Other options
- spin-off
- liquidation
- etc.
- Overall fit with strategy
- Cost reduction potential
- fixed
- variable
- Revenue synergies
- positive
- negative
- Customer and competition response
- Non-recurring costs
- Combined cashflow forecasts
- acquirer
- target
- synergies
- Possible financing sources
- equity
- secured debt
- cashflow loans
- seller financing
Investment Bank Role
- Development of conservative case requirements
provides basis for analyzing debt capacity
- How much is the target worth to the seller?
- How much is the target worth to us?
- Can we afford it?
- Does the increase risk make sense?
- Cash flow
- BDP
- Industry analysis
- 3Cs
- RCP
- Investment appraisal
- Cash flow
Related BVU Modules
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
45MA Primer
Approach
Valuation Potential Synergies
A key component in the valuation process is to
quantify, as best as possible, any upside
opportunities on both the revenue and cost side.
Bottom-Line Improvement
Cost Reduction (Hard synergies)
Variable
Fixed
Revenue Enhancement (Soft Synergies)
- Manufacturing
- Sales Marketing
- Distribution
- G A
- Purchasing
- Labor productivity
- Manufacturing efficiency benefits
- Consumer and trade spending efficiencies
- Transportation efficiency
- Examination of sales distribution channels
- Product cross-selling
- Other
Assessed during due diligence
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
46MA Primer
Approach
Integration
XXX can assist in the integration process and
maximize the value of the target.
Acquisition Screening
Integration
Valuation
Due Diligence
Objective
- Implement strategic vision for merger that gives
direction and impetus for change - Definitive actions and role definitions to speed
integration process
- Pre-planning
- combined cash flows
- Transition plan
- Cost reduction
- Revenue enhancement
XXX Activities
Common Pitfalls
- Reluctance to interfere in operations of acquiree
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
47MA Primer
Approach
Importance of Integration
The ability to successfully integrate acquired
companies is ranked the most important factor
influencing acquisition success.
Degree of Importance
Ability to integrate company
Evaluation of acquisition candidate
Management abilities of company acquired
Prior experience making acquisitions
Compatibility of management styles
Pricepaid
Sample 200 CEO's
Sources Wall Street Journal
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
48MA Primer
Approach
Integration - Key Success Factors
- Early planning
- Take control swiftly
- Constant communication
- Ensure retention of key managers
- Aggressive sharing of corporate vision
- Respect for people and culture
- Adopt merger principles
- fact-based and fair decision making
- objectivity
- two-way communication
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
49MA Primer
Approach
Integration - Develop Short - and Long-Term
Objectives
Explicit expression of corporate mission/vision
by CEO
Long-term objectives
- Articulate immediately when control is taken
- Gives organization focus for new direction
- Maintains impetus for change
Short-term objectives
- Driven by due diligence and valuation
- Reality check
- Directs Transition Team in first weeks after the
merger
Top-down consistent approach
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
50MA Primer
Approach
Typical Timeline
Integration is a complex process that must be
done quickly to produce tangible results.
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
20
0
0
(weeks)
- Preplanning
- future cash flows
- industry analysis
- due diligence
1
3
5
7
9
11
13
15
17
19
- Finance Plan
- debt structure
- capex
- compensation
- Cost Reduction
- distribution
- production
- overhead
- Revenue Enhancement Plan
- cross-selling
- cross-marketing
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
51MA Primer
Approach
Integration - Develop Short - and Long-Term
Objectives
The acquisition premium paid can only be
justified by making swift changes. Yet there is a
reluctance to interfere in the management and
operations of the target.
Real/perceived performance shortfall
Acquiree morale declines and attrition increases
Acquirer becomes impatient and storms acquiree
The "hands-off" doom loop
Morale collapse at acquiree
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
52MA Primer
Introduction
Agenda
- Trends in MA
- Guiding Principles for Successful MA
- XXX Approach
- Case Examples
- screening
- due diligence
- sale
- Exercise on Synergy Calculation
- Typical Watchouts
- Key Takeaways
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
53MA Primer
Case Example - Prepress
Screening/ Due Diligence (1 of 2)
Client
- Prepress's base business is the market leader in
the high-end electronic imaging market
Situation
- Prepress has historically enjoyed high margins
and been able to remain market leader
Complication
- Prepress base business is facing price pressure
from low-end systems. - With 300MM of cash available, Prepress is
looking for growth opportunities to sustain
superior growth rates
Recommendation
- Assess core competencies of Prepress relative to
the competition and identify potential
acquisitions
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
54MA Primer
Case Example - Prepress
Screening/ Due Diligence (2 of 2)
XXX activities
- Strategic assessment of core competencies
relative to the competition - Identify "long list" of industries to discuss
with client - Prioritize "long list" in terms of industry
attractiveness in order to narrow to 3-5
industries - Screen for new acquisitions in higher growth
industries
- From long list" of industries and discussion
with client, attractive industries were selected. - Within designated industries, XXX identified
financially attractive targets that matched
Prepress's strategic focus.
Result
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
55MA Primer
Case Example - Prepress
Search Criteria
Along with the client, XXX developed a set of
criteria with which to evaluate different
industries.
Companies that Purchase Computer Components, Add
Value, and Remarket
Information Capture, and Dissemination
Output Devices
Competitor Industries
Prepress Customers
Another Prepress Industry
Potential Industries
Recording products
X
X
X
Duplication products
X
X
X
X
X
Data enhancement/ manipulation/editing devices
X
X
X
X
X
Data management (storage and retrieval) devices
X
X
X
X
Transmission originators
X
X
Transmission carriers/controllers
X
X
Transmission receivers ("dumb')
X
Intelligent digital processing systems
X
X
X
X
X
Interactive digital systems
Office automation/high potential customers
X
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
56MA Primer
Case Example - Prepress
In-depth Screening
After selection of the criteria, each industry
was analyzed to determine its attractiveness and
potential fit with Prepress's existing business.
Is the industry attractive?
Do we offer a value- added proposition?
- Systems orientation
- What other technologies does this industry
interface with? - Customers
- Who are they?
- How do they buy? (channels, predictability)
- What do they buy?
- Competitors
- Who are they?
- What is their share of their market?
- How important is this industry to them?
- Industry trends/dynamics
- How cyclical/predictable is the industry?
- How profitable is the industry?
- What is the average selling price per component?
- What is the percent value-added?
- Viable acquisition candidates
- Is one of "top 3" players "buyable"?
- Are they profitable?
- What drives industry's profitability?
- What do we bring to the table? Could our
capabilities strengthen the industry? - Could this industry serve as a platform to enter
other markets? - Can we create a new system?
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
57MA Primer
Case Example - Prepress
Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) (1 of 2)
The MRI industry was selected based on its
attractiveness and potential fit with Prepress.
Industry Attractiveness
- 1.4B, worldwide (second largest medical imaging
segment)
Market Size
Growth rate
- 9.1 (fastest growing segment)
- Value-added system, but most manufacturers just
sell component
Systems orientation
Customers
- Fragmented - over 200 equipment suppliers
worldwide - Major players in X-ray, CT, SPECT, and PET do not
dominate MRI - ROS historically 9, weak 3 now
- Highly competitive with intensified price cutting
- Anticipate industry consolidation and merging of
manufacturing, product development, and
distribution functions
Competition
Industry trends/dynamics
Attractive
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
58MA Primer
Case Example - Prepress
Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) (2 of 2)
The MRI industry was selected based on its
attractiveness and potential fit with Prepress.
Prepress Value-added Proposition
Similarity to pre-press
- Same workflow
- Similar manufacturing (value-added resale of
high-technology components linked by proprietary
software and customer circuit boards or chips) - Color imaging becoming increasingly valued system
feature
Linkage to other industries
- Signifies major move into medical imaging market
- Complements current client printer medical market
strategy - Entry vehicle to data storage industry
- No linkage to non-medical/other markets
- System similarity (modular design, user-friendly,
upgradeable, high quality) - Sales process similarity (system sell, proven ROI
benefits) - Customer need similarity (high resolution images,
low maintenance, strong price-value relationship)
Prepress synergies
Attractive
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
59MA Primer
Prepress
MRI Market Segment Competitors
Industry segments were classified and measured to
identify potential targets.
100M
80M
Total 1.4B Players
150M
550M
500M
100
A
Estimated Percent of 1993 Market (1993 Dollars)
B
C
80
I
D
G
E
F
H
I
F
60
E
E
G
H
H
C
G
H
H
40
I
D
G
E
Others
I
B
G
C
D
F
20
C
B
B
A
E
B
A
A
0
Radiology
Cardiology
Other
Peripheral vascular
OB/GYN
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
60MA Primer
Case Example - Prepress
MRI Industry Dynamics
The MRI market was then examined further in order
to identify opportunities.
- Dedicated players dominate market
- make money
- increasing sales
- focused RD expenditures
- G had (5.6) ROS
- what's driving losses?
Track record
- Offered by more hospitals (75) than any other
digital imaging technology - Majority of hospital CFOs operate MRI profit
centers
- Increasingly restrictive global government
regulations for medical spending and reimbursement
Macro-environment
- Ultra high-technology RD
- leverage super-computer advances
- engineer for low cost, compact size, long-term
reliability - Shake-out imminent
- Aggressive price-cutting
- Intensive competition
Industry trends
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
61MA Primer
Case Example - Prepress
MRI Target Acquisition Candidates
After the creation of a market map, individual
companies were assessed for their viability as an
acquisition.
ViableAcquisitionCandidate
Not Viable
Company
Revenue
Market Value
Medical Imaging Parent
Division of Large Company
Market Share Too Small
170MM
200MM
A
165MM
100MM
B
150MM
100MM
F
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
62MA Primer
Introduction
Agenda
- Trends in MA
- Guiding Principles for Successful MA
- XXX Approach
- Case Examples
- screening
- due diligence
- sale
- Exercise on Synergy Calculation
- Typical Watchouts
- Key Takeaways
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
63MA Primer
Case Example - Sand
Due Diligence/Valuation
- A UK-based mining and minerals division of a
diversified company
Client
Situation
- Acquirer has limited opportunities for internal
growth and is seeking growth through acquisition
Complication
- Target ("Ferret") purchased a divested division
from the client several years ago. Initial
hypothesis is that the target is a good
acquisition at the right price
Recommendation
- Industrial sand division was divided into 5
segments by end-user. Based on growth rates in
individual segments, target firm was valued at
approximately 100MM
- Market growth projections
- Market share determination
- Assessment of possible synergies with acquiring
firm - Competitor analysis
- Analysis of business expansion opportunities
- Independent EBITDA forecast
XXX activities
Result
- A competitor bid was accepted
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
64MA Primer
Case Example - Sand
Industry Overview
Every market segment has been volatile. Only the
frac segment has grown significantly, but it is
still below its 1985 peak.
CAGR (1970-1993)
Glass
0.1
Foundry
-1.0
Abrasives
1.3
Frac
8.5
Fillers
-5.6
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
Sources U.S. Bureau of Mines
65MA Primer
Case Example - Sand
Value Chain
Regional presence is crucial for both whole grain
segments. The distribution cost is the largest
part of the frac and foundry whole grain segments.
Manufacturers Margin
Distribution
Processing
Extraction
End-User Price
Foundry Whole grain
40
Foundry Resin coated
150-250
Frac Whole Grain
20-25
Frac Resin coated
160-240
Notes In percent of end user price
Sources Ferret's budget Customers Interviews
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
66MA Primer
Case Example - Sand
Market Map by Sub-Segment
170M
164M
100M
99M
20M
34M
141M
29M
86M
78M
47M
24M
29M
37M
35M
10M
Others
Total 570M
Other
Others
Ferret
Others
Other
Percent of Total
Others
Ferret
Genstar
Ferret
Others
The Morie Co.
Fairmount Minerals
Norton/Alcoa
FosterDixiez
U.S. Silica
Ferret
Unimin
Other
Ferret
Oglebay Norton
Stanblast
Oglebay Norton
Unimin
The Morie Co.
Other
Borden
Borden
U.S. Silica
Badger Mining
The Morie Co.
U.S. Silica
U.S. Silica
Carbo Ceramics
Reed Minerals
In-House resin coated
Unimin
U.S. Silica
U.S. Silica
Unimin
Ferret
Unimin
Unimin
The Morie Co
Fairmount Minerals
Ferret
Primary Glass
Performance Glass
Whole Grain
Resin-coated
Whole Grain
Other
Resin Coated
Copper Slag
Silica Sand
Coal Slag
Ceramics
Fillers and Extenders
Glass
Foundry
Proppants
Abrasives
Note 1995 estimated figures except for Abrasives
(1992 figures) Ferret Abrasive
share excludes Uniwest
Source Tucker Anthony and U.S. Silica
Information Reports
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
67MA Primer
Case Example - Sand
Industrial Sand Market Overview
Summary
- The overall silica sand industry has been notably
cyclical with flat volume growth over the past
twenty-five years downturns generally track
broader economic slowdowns - Each market segment of the silica sand industry
is volatile and only frac has shown significant
long-term volume growth However, frac volume is
still below its 1985 peak - Real industry revenues have fallen by 1.6 since
1980 - Real revenues per ton have fallen by 0.5 since
1980 - Extraction, manufacturing and distribution should
be viewed as different businesses with unique
returns, customers and competitors - Future environmental and health risks appear to
be limited - regulations limiting access to and
use of silica sands are not expected to become
more burdensome in the near future
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
68MA Primer
Case Example - Sand
Ferret's Position
Summary
- Strong historical growth has been due to
acquisitions and internal growth - Ferret has focused primarily on the foundry and
frac segments which account for over 60 of its
contribution - Profitability and cash flow (as a percent of
sales) have recovered from 1993 levels, but are
still well below 1991 peaks - Customers generally regard Ferret favorably -
Ferret has been aggressive in increasing revenues
per ton and is perceived by customers as being
higher priced - Because of high distribution costs, competition
in most product lines is geographically limited
and varies across Ferret's locations and market
segments - Ferret's key competitors do not own captive
distributors - the key competitor in resin-coated
sands, Borden, has no extraction capabilities - Ferret has significant unutilized manufacturing
capacity, but extraction capacity will be
exceeded if the Bridgman permit is not renewed
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
69MA Primer
Case Example - Sand
Investment Rationale
Communication to investors regarding the
acquisition of Ferret should focus on five key
points
- Growth in client's existing markets is limited
- products
- geography
- The US market is very large and is about to
undergo the next phase of change - out-sourcing of foundry resin-coating processes
- growth in frac sands
- cyclicality provides opportunity to consolidate
in downturns - Dramatic change has occurred in the US market
since client's exit - consolidation
- shakeout of many competitors
- emergence of Ferret
- Ferret has taken advantage of the industry
environment to compile a very attractive
combination of reserves and manufacturing
capabilities - Ferret represents an attractive platform for
future growth - product synergies (1 worldwide leader in silica
proppants for the oil gas industry) - further US acquisitions
- international expansion Mexico, South America,
Pacific Rim - diversification across national economic cycles
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
70MA Primer
Case Example - Sand
Valuation Summary
Based on different scenarios a 100MM bid was
made.
Worst Case
Base Case
Best Case
CAGR (1995-2000) Sales GP EBIT Operating Cash
Flow
-0.1 -1.4 -7.5 1.4
3.8 3.1 2.7 8.1
8.4 7.9 11.3 14.3
64.9MM
91.3MM
123.0MM
DCF (_at_12)
Notes Assumes no growth perpetuity
Sources XXX model
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
71MA Primer
Introduction
Agenda
- Trends in MA
- Guiding Principles for Successful MA
- XXX Approach
- Case Examples
- screening
- due diligence
- sale
- Exercise on Synergy Calculation
- Typical Watchouts
- Key Takeaways
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
72MA Primer
Case Example - AMD
Summary (1 of 2)
Situation
- The client, a global asset management company
with over 50B under management, was losing
market share across its businesses - XXX was approached to assist in developing a
strategy to achieve profitable growth
Approach
- Phase I focused on defining the current state of
the current business and its environment - in depth analysis of the clients markets,
channels and customers established that client
was losing share in many markets and was being
out-invested by competitors in core markets - detailed profitability analysis across products,
channels and markets identified that only four
businesses in the clients portfolio of 15 were
making significant contribution to group profits - In Phase II, joint XXX/client teams were formed
in each business to develop detailed five year
business plans. The plans included required
investment, potential strategic moves and
resultant profits, enabling the full potential of
each business unit to be determined on a
comparable basis - The individual business plans were integrated to
quantify the overall opportunity for the company.
Corporate-level strategic options were then
identified, detailed and valued
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
73MA Primer
Case Example - AMD
Summary (2 of 2)
- After detailed evaluation of strategic options, a
decision was made to sell the Asset Management
Division (AMD) business. The asset management
company required significant investment in order
to achieve profitable growth, and the parent
company was able to achieve higher returns by
investing in other businesses within its
portfolio - XXX continued to support the client through the
sale process by - developing the offer memorandum, the business
forecast and the management presentation - identifying the best new parent and quantifying
their full-potential price - supporting the bid negotiations
Conclusion
- The division was successfully sold, realizing
500M more in value from the transaction than the
parent would have been able to extract from the
business through continued ownership.
Impact
XXX denotes the MA advisor or consulting company
74MA Primer
Case Example - AMD
Profitability by Business
The clients profits were concentrated in three
businesses.
XXX