Title: OCTOBER%2029,%202008
1PROCUREMENT POLICY COUNCIL
- OCTOBER 29, 2008
- 900 am to Noon
2PPC Agenda
- Finance Transformation Jeff Mandel / Sharon
Minnich - BMWBO Kathryn Waters-Perez
- Materials Walt Quade
- Services Roxana Dietz
- Agency PO/Contracts Jeff Mandel
- Contract Attachments Sue Rojas
- Procurement Handbook Updates Sue Rojas
- SRM Joan Kraft / Cheryl Kleeman
- E-Marketplace Updates Scott Cross / Sue Plecker
- Quality Assurance Paul Wolf
- Training Jeff Mandel
- Note This PPC Presentation will be available on
our Agency Dashboard web site following this
Meeting -
3Project Purpose and Goals
- Purpose
- To further transform the Commonwealths current
financial administration operations using leading
practices, processes and technologies - Goals
- Identify and Implement Strategies to Reduce Cost
- Use Available Resources More Efficiently
- Improve Accuracy
- Reduce Transaction Processing Time
- Improve Invoice Processing Imaging
- Improve Cash Management Revenue Processing
- Design Quality Assurance Function
- Develop a Strong Internal Audit Function
- Develop Training Organization
4Project Scope
The following processes, activities, and systems
are being addressed through the Finance
Transformation project
Policy Process Procure to Pay Chart of Accounts/GL Revenue/Cash Management Accounts Receivable Budgetary Accounting Comprehensive Annual Financial Report (CAFR)/Financial Reporting Internal Audit
Talent People Change Management and Communications Knowledge Transfer to Commonwealth Project Staff Organization Realignment and Transition Education and Training Change Management and Communications Knowledge Transfer to Commonwealth Project Staff Organization Realignment and Transition Education and Training
Systems Information SAP ECC 6.0 Configuration SAP Workflow Scanning, Imaging and Indexing SAP ECC 6.0 Configuration SAP Workflow Scanning, Imaging and Indexing
5Current Status
- Between March and June, the following activities
were completed - Process reviews including procure to pay,
revenue, accounts receivable, reporting/CAFR,
chart of accounts, grants, budgetary accounting,
special accounting and audits - Workshops with OB, agency and key stakeholders
- Workshops produced approximately 100
recommendations focused in the following areas - Process
- Technology
- Organization structure
- Or, a combination of the above
- In July, recommendations were validated and
analyzed, and grouped into the following
categories - Short-Term able to be completed by May 2009
- Medium-Term able to be completed by July 1, 2010
- Long-Term beyond 2010 and dependent on other
technology not owned by the Commonwealth - In August and September, the recommendations were
prioritized, reviewed and ranked by the Steering
Committee - Detailed process and technical design is underway
for prioritized recommendations - Build Phase October through May 2009
6Financial Transformation
Procure-to-Pay Recommendations
- Centralize the receipt, mailing, sorting,
scanning, and imaging of all PO and non-PO paper
invoices received from vendors and grantees - Process PO-related invoices according to current
three-way match business rules unless blocked. If
exceptions are found in three-way match, invoice
is blocked in SAP and sent via workflow to Agency
PO Line Item Reconciler for resolution - Route Non-PO invoices (including grants) to
agencies to provide appropriate account
information and approval. Once coding is entered
and approved, a document to be created in SAP and
sent via workflow to PO Invoice Processing group
for review, approval, and payment - Phase in non-PO invoice processing between May
and September 2009 - Use special process for Utility invoices that
allows agency to view image, enter account
assignments and select payment (advancement
account, p-card, via treasury)
Invoice Processing
7Recommendations
Procure-to-Pay Recommendations (contd)
- Use exception processing workflow to agencies and
return of documents to Comptrollers for PO
invoice processing - Require all purchase requisitions to be reviewed
by agency fiscal staff - Implement risk-based approach for comptroller
involvement in service solicitations - Eliminate Comptroller involvement in reviewing
approved agency service contracts based on
involvement in solicitation process - Change thresholds for PO review and approval from
5,000 to - 20,000 for PO against DGS statewide and agency
contracts - 10,000 for all other PO types
- Increase use of Purchasing Card Program by adding
DGS contracts that accept p-card to SRM. Enhance
the reporting and posting capabilities
Workflow
8 Recommendations
Procure-to-Pay Recommendations (contd)
Anticipated Agency Benefits
- Faster payment to vendors
- Ability to track and monitor invoices from the
point of receipt through payment completion - Reduce errors or incorrect postings involved in
processing, as entry will be made at the agency,
allowing flexibility based on fund changes - Decision on payment mechanism can be made at the
agency (e.g., advancement accounts) - Agency confirmation of changes more prompt and
accurate due to familiarity with the facilities - Significant staff time currently dedicated to
exceptions processing for marginal amounts or
other minor non-matching issues can be redirected
to other value added activities - Agencies become more empowered as end users in
accordance with Commonwealth procurement policy
9 Recommendations
Procure-to-Pay Recommendations (contd)
Anticipated Agency Impacts
- All paper invoices - Will no longer receive paper
invoices at the agency. Will receive an image of
the invoice for processing. - Non PO invoices - Enter data into system rather
than manually recording on the paper invoice.
Invalid entries will not move forward for
processing. Every agency will be responsible for
identification of staff who will be invoice
receivers and verifiers and delivering the
training to these staff (materials for training
will be provided by the project). - PO invoices - Blocked PO invoices will be work
flowed to agencies for exception processing.
This will require communications and job aides
for all line item reconcilers in agency. - Procurement - Workflow will require agency fiscal
staff to review/approve purchase requisitions to
ensure proper coding - Interfaces for payment currently no anticipated
changes but analysis still in process
10Financial Transformation Project Recommendation
- Shopping Cart Approval Requirement
- Fiscal officer approval regardless of dollar
value - Options discussed
- Create special role for Agency Fiscal
- Allow agencies to rework existing workflow
- Decision Use existing workflow
- Analysis by agency
- Discuss with user group during Dec 10th 2008
meeting - Meet with agencies as needed
- Must be implemented by May 2009
11MBE/WBE Utilization
Role of BMWBO
- Promote contracting and subcontracting
opportunities for Disadvantaged Businesses
(DBs).
12Procurements with Deminimus Disadvantaged
Business (DB) Participation
BMWBO
- BMWBOs Evaluate submitted proposals as they
relate to DB utilization and provides the agency
with scores.
13BMWBO
BMWBO provides a memo to user agencies along with
DB scores
- Memo states if certain vendors are selected which
have been identified as having deminimus
participation BMWBO is to be notified of such
selection - BMWBO will evaluate best and final offers (BAFOs)
as they relate to DB utilization and provide the
agency with revised scores
14BMWBO Example of Memo
- COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
- DEPARTMENT OF GENERAL SERVICES
- MEMORANDUM
- DATE November 29, 2008
- SUBJECT Notification of Unsatisfactory
Disadvantaged Business Participation - RFP DPW-00000000000
- TO Casey Miller
- Department of Public Welfare
- FROM Kathryn Waters-Perez, Director
- Bureau of Minority and Woman Business
Opportunities - The Bureau of Minority Women Business
Opportunities has received the Disadvantaged
Business Participation submittals received in
response to the RFP. The explanation for the
scoring is found on the attached. - The following Proposers provided submittal with
unsatisfactory or zero DB participation - Company ABC
- Did it Wrong, Inc.
- Should your final evaluation result in selection
of one of these Proposers for contract
negotiations, BMWBO must be immediately notified
and given an opportunity to work with you in
attempting to increase DB utilization for this
contract. BWMBO should be invited to participate
in contract negotiations in an effort to increase
Disadvantaged Business Participation. Please
contact me before initiating any contract
negotiations with the selected offeror. - Following contract negotiations and the contract
being executed, the Disadvantaged Business name,
address and amount of commitment made by the
contractor must be forwarded to us.
15BMWBO
- Contract Negotiations
- If necessary, BMWBO will negotiate any changes in
DB utilization as a part of pre-selection and/or
contract negotiations when DB participation is
deminimus.
16BMWBO Contact Information
- BMWBO
- 611 North Office Bldg.
- Harrisburg, PA 17112
- (717) 783-3119
- E-mail RA-rfpbmwbo_at_state.pa.us
- Procurement Liaison
- Gayle Nuppnau
- (717) 346-3819
- E-mail GNuppnau_at_state.pa.us
17Materials - Fuels
- Liquid Fuels
- Current Contract Structure
- Bid differential price (margin, transport) by
county - Commodity price floats on daily index
- Two methods of delivery by county truck
transport for over 5000 gal., tank wagon for
under 5000 gal (Just Discussed). - Disadvantages
- Manages only small portion of our total unit cost
(approx. 5) - Full exposure to the daily volatility of the
market - Provides little control over drastic increases in
spend - FY 04-05 19.5 million
- FY 05-06 25.9 million
- FY 06-07 38.0 million
- FY 07-08 44.7 million
- Daily price changes cause frequent invoice
payment problems
18Materials - Fuels
- Full Truck Transport Strategy 5000 gallon plus!
- Working through suppliers we plan to lock fuel
purchases for large users through NYMEX. - Approx. 40 of end use customers nationwide use
this strategy. - Bid differential price, then make commodity buys
when price is advantageous. - Can make buys for front month or several future
months if prices are attractive. - Target buy is 50 of volume for largest volume
truck transport users and average up or down
based on spot market.
19Materials - Fuels
Truck Transport Strategy- 5000 gallon plus.
(Cont.)
- Advantages of fuel hedging strategy
- Gain control of total commodity cost
- Reduce market exposure and variability.
- Smooth out large spikes in pricing.
- Can use this strategy to buy incremental
components of usage, reduces risk. - Diversified Portfolio of fuel purchase
quantities and prices. - Flexibility to purchase one or multiple months of
usage when market prices reach low - BOP will do the POs, will provide higher quality
usage data, visibility of delivery frequency. - DGS will make payment to vendors via P-Card and
cost allocated back to Agency when the card is
reconciled.
20Materials - Fuels
- Small Fuel Delivery Program
- We have many small tanks (500 gal. or less)
located in remote areas. - Suppliers bite off more than they can chew,
causes problems with on-time deliveries. - Limits supplier base, discourages new entrants.
- Invoice Payment problems.
- Recent Petroleum past due balance of over 1.25
million. - Vast majority of invoices less than 5000.
- GR entry problems.
- Supplier confusion.
- Those who receive deliveries closer to 5000 gal.
and/or pay bills on time subsidize those who
dont.
21Materials - Fuels
- Small Fuel Delivery Program
- ITQ Contract for deliveries less than 5000 gal.
- This is a contract of convenience.
- Qualify suppliers by county.
- Agencies follow procurement procedures based on
low dollar amount. - Agencies obtain Small Procurement Policy and
obtain quotes from qualified suppliers in county,
select best price. - Invoicing
- Quoted prices firm, less potential for errors.
- Mandated utility card use for orders under 5000
should remove bulk of past-due payment issues.
22Contract Update
Contract Number Contract Title Status Commodity Manager Material
440003137 Medium Duty Trucks In Award Process Craig Wolford Work Trucks
4400003207 Road patching Equipment In Award Process Craig Wolford Kettles, patchers, Reheaters
2550-02 Diesel Engines To be Renewed Craig Wolford Engines
6675-02 Surveying Equipment To be Renewed Mary Randolph Surveying Equipment
4400001174 Floor Polishers In Award Process Mary Randolph Floor Polishers and Vacuums
4400001741 Wheelchairs To be Renewed Mary Randolph Wheelchairs
3930-01 Forklifts Bidding Currently Craig Wolford Lifts
7350-05 Commercial Food Equipment Bidding Mary Randolph Commercial Food Equipment
New Police Lighting and Accessories Bidding Craig Wolford Accessories for Police
23Contract Update
Contract Number Contract Title Status Commodity Manager Material
5610-49 Cement In Award process Joel Shiffler Cement
5684-02 Corrugated metal Pipe In Award Process Joel Shiffler Pipe
5610-36 Bituminous Plant Mix Bid being prepared Joel Shiffler Plant Mix
5710-01 Bituminous Liquid patch Bid Being Prepared Joel Shiffler Liquid Plant Mix
4600010918 Sign Stiffeners Renewed Joel Shiffler Sign Stiffeners
4400003307 Rock Salt Bags Approved Joel Shiffler Bagged Salt
NEW Fuel Management In process Joel Shiffler Fuel Additives
4400002702 Energy Mgt Services ITQ Joel Shiffler Electricity, natural gas
9140-01 Heating Oil 2 Award in Process Joel Shiffler Oil
9130-03 Unleaded gas Award in Process Joel Shiffler Gas
24Contract Update
Contract Number Contract Title Status Commodity Manager Material
9140-08 Liquid Fuel Award in Process Joel Shiffler Fuel, Large Volume
9140-02 Heating Oil 4 Bid in Progress Joel Shiffler 4 Heating Oil
4400003333 Waste Oil Awarded Joel Shiffler Waste Heating Oil
440003238 Carpet Awarded JP Duvall Carpet
8415-01 Gloves Awarded JP Duvall Gloves
4400002988 VWR MISC LAB Equip Awarded Jim Pinci General lab Equip not covered by 4600012524
4400002959 Detection Equipment Awarded Jim Pinci Testing Equipment for Atomic, Chemical, Biological Material
4600013480 Janitorial Awarded Jim Pinci Consumables and paper Product
25Shared Services - Roles Responsibilities
- BOP-003 Delegation Request (Updated)
- APPROVALS The agency is responsible for
obtaining any approvals required due to the
nature of the material or service or both being
procured, in addition to compliance with any
applicable Management Directives, Information
Technology Bulletins and/or Commonwealth policy. - Method of Procurement ? RFP ? IFB ? ITQ-RFQ
- BOP-003_REV._10-2008
26Shared Services - Roles Responsibilities
Denied Delegations Roles Responsibilities
27IT Procurements
- IT Contracting Office
- Consistent with Executive Order 2004-8, the
Office of Administration has established the IT
Contracting Office (ITCO). - Three attorneys will oversee the legal aspects of
all IT project procurements that fall within the
COP process. - Nora Doyle -General Government Operations
Public Safety - Sonja Zucker - Environmental
- Crystal Fox - Health Human Services
28IT Procurements
- Primary Functions of IT Contracting Office
- Providing guidance related to the proper
procurement method for IT Services. - Establish training programs for DCIOs, the CIOs
any agency personnel who wish to participate. - During the procurement process, documents will be
provided to ITCO through the DCIO in conjunction
with the COP review. - Review documents related to RFQs and RFPs prior
to posting - During contract negotiations they will work with
the issuing office to ensure requirements, terms
conditions and service level expectations are
achieved. - At the request of an agency they will review
software licenses and advise agencies related to
general IT matters.
29IT Procurements
- DGS will assist agencys in meeting the project
timeline developing procurement strategy and
preparing the final RFP documents receiving
proposals facilitate the evaluation lead the
negotiation team and processing the necessary
documents for the contract award. - All these activities are joint efforts that will
be heavily influenced by the Office of
Administrations and the Agencys expertise and
experience as the administrator of their current
contract. DGS will not participate as a voting
member of the technical evaluation committee. - After the contract is successfully awarded, the
Agency will retain responsibility for managing
the contract with the awarded supplier, including
contract maintenance, administration of the
contract, including ensuring delivery of expected
savings and/or service improvements and
contractual obligations, leverage and focus
supplier capabilities, ensure rapid resolution of
issues and provide consistent direction to the
supplier. - DGS should be informed of any contractual changes
necessary or if the supplier defaults their
contractual obligations to the Commonwealth.
30Enterprise ITQ System
- Enterprise ITQ System Phase 1 to be complete by
Jan. 2009 - Phase 1 ITQ Administrators can get into the ITQ
and create ITQ contracts, and that Suppliers can
register (or use their SRM registrations) and
pre-qualify. - Phase 2 ITQ administrators can get into the ITQ
and evaluate the Suppliers applications, and
approve or deny the applications, and supply any
ancillary functionality that works with the Phase
1 functionality but was not vital to Phase 1. - Phase 3 Local Municipalities and Agencies can
get into the ITQ and use the supplied
functionality to find Suppliers that can perform
the jobs that the Local Municipalities and
Agencies need, and supply any ancillary
functionality that works with the Phase 2
functionality but was not vital to Phase 2.
31IT ITQ
- IT ITQ Expires June 2009
- OCT 2009 Finalize TCs with suppliers
- NOV-DEC Review new IT ITQ with Suppliers and
Tech Council - JAN 2009 Allow suppliers to begin qualification
process - JAN 2009 New ITQ web site available (proposed
date) - APR 2009 Begin issuing RFQs under new IT ITQ
- JUN 2009 End all work under old IT ITQ
- For work slippage only
- Can go past end of contract by 90 days
- Needs DGS approval
- JUL 2009 New ITQ effective date
32IT
- WSCA Cell Phone Contract
- Implemented
- Met with TMOs on details
- Moving to shared minutes
- Suppliers gave TMOs presentation of
implementation - What procedures will be available?
- PCs, Laptops, Rugged Laptops and Thin Clients
- All punch-out sites up and running, all contracts
approved - Dell Lease Payments
- Professional AV
- Multiple award contracts
- Peripherals Networking
- 2 suppliers on Peripherals
- Recommend to get 2 quotes on orders over 2500
- Web Sites to be fully functional in next 30 days
- P-card enabled
- Networking is multiple award
- Servers Storage
- Interim Agreement in Place, pending approval
33IT
- New Procurements in Process
- 3rd Party Maintenance
- Enterprise IT Help Desk
- Enterprise Software (3 companies)
- Film and sundry supplies
- IPAM
- Time Management
- Radio Repair and Equipment
- E\Procurement Policy Council Meeting\PPC_October.
29.2008_docs\IT Contracting Office10.08.pdf
34Agency PO/Contracts Background
- Issue Inconsistent interpretation of MD 310.3
within comptrollers- Encumbering and Lapsing of
Appropriations following the implementation of
SRM - Background Prior to SRM, agencies created the
following document types to commit funds - Agency Standard Contract with follow on PO.
(contract no commitment, PO commitment) - Agency Encumbered Contracts with follow on PO.
(contract no commitment, CO creates a funds
reservation entered into the contract, and a PO
to commit with manual reduction of the funds
reservation) - Multiple year or single year PO. (PO commitment)
- Due to the multiple step process and room for
error, the Agency Encumbered Contract document
type was eliminated with the SRM implementation.
Agencies were given the option of a contract with
POs or multiple year POs to encumber funds. - Inconsistent interpretation of the MD
- Perception by CO is that funds must be encumbered
at the time of award and only means to do so is
via the PO as contract does not trigger
encumbrances. Certain offices require a contract
and single year POs to be created for every year
of the contract immediately upon award. - Question/issue Why create the contract if all
POs have to be created at same time? Defeats
purpose of contractextra work.
35Agency PO/Contracts Responses
- Contacted several agencies to see how they
processed ongoing services contracts. - LI Creates multi-year purchase orders.
- DPW Creates agency contracts for some services
that are purchased on an as needed basis. For
ongoing services, multi-year purchase orders are
created. - PSP Creates multi-year purchase orders. They
know their budget for future years, but dont
want to create a contract, then cut a PO every
year. They would rather cut one PO for the full
term so they dont have to remember to create a
new PO in each consecutive year.
36Use of Agency Contract
- Recommended Decisions for Document Types
- An agency contract was to be created when
- More then one entity was purchasing off of it ,
i.e. districts creating their own POs at time of
service - Agency cannot commit the future year funds or are
not ready to commit the funds. - then create a PO at the time you are ready and
another one thereafter - Requirements (materials or services) quantity and
timing unknown or uncertain over future years - A multiple year PO was to be created when
- The agency wanted to commit all funds at time of
the award
37Examples
- Scenario 1 - Intergovernmental Agreements (IGA)
for services mandated to be provided that will
continue for the next several years, but because
they are contingent on State funding, the exact
amount to be allocated may not be known years in
advance. - IGAs currently take 6-8 weeks for approvals in
SRM and because some of the work must be done
when school is not in session, agency cannot
afford a lapse in services at the start of the
FY. - Solution - Multiply a single year times 5 and
enter an agency contract for 5 years with an
annual PO to establish exact funding done
immediately at the start of the new FY. With
this scenario, there would not have a lapse in
services and when a PO is issued, would only have
Comptroller to approve instead of the original
6-8 weeks for full IGA. - Scenario 2 - Purchase of educational materials
(curriculum) where it is known there will be a
multiple year need for the item(s) plus
instructional services but do not know exactly
how many schools would be serviced each year as
it would be contingent on the annual budget
allocation. - Solution - Manage this with a handful of
contracts, not the much higher number we would
use for IGAs. In this case, again, it would
prevent a lapse of services and allow agency to
cut a timely purchase order without risking a
lengthy break in services. Even though these
contracts would only have three or four approvers
(based on cost) instead of the six with IGAs,
consistently run into the backlog in many of
these offices as we try to push through the new
purchase orders. This would reduce everyones
workload as the PO would only go to Comptroller.
- If any one of the agency contracts prove to be
too small, could amend to add services or
quantities mid-FY cycle so as not to risk the
break in services at year end.
38Contract Attachments
- This list of required attachments was created to
assist in maintaining the correct documents
within contracts. They were derived based on - Minimum Right to Know requirements
- SRM compatibility
IFB Contract Attachments (Multi Award Hierarchy Contract) Electronic Bid utilizing doc builder eMarketplace Internal File IFB Contract/Purchase Order Attachments Electronic Bid utilizing doc builder eMarketplace Internal File
RFP Contract Attachments (paper submittal not using doc builder) SRM eMarketplace Internal File RFP Contract Attachments (using doc builder) SRM eMarketplace Internal File
Contract Attachments Location Contract
Attachment Documents
39Procurement Handbook Changes
Non-contract purchases under 10K (reinstated)
- Part I Chapter 7 Thresholds and Delegations
- Section B Thresholds for Specific Procurements
- Agencies are authorized to procure on a non bid
basis, up to 10,000 for the following - Repair, maintenance, modification, or
calibration of equipment services to be performed
by, and repair parts supplied by, the
manufacturer of the equipment or by the
manufacturer's authorized dealer - Software license maintenance agreements and
extensions of software licenses - Agency leasehold construction improvements
40Complete Procurement Handbook Changes
Political Contribution Letter for Sole Sources
(new)
Relating to the PO or Contract issued to the
Supplier, a Political Contribution Letter is to
be sent to the supplier reminding them of their
responsibility to file a report of Political
Contributions, by February 15 of each year. This
report is to be sent to the Secretary of the
Commonwealth for all political contributions
exceeding 1,000 during the preceding year.
Sole Source Procurements of Materials,
Services and Construction.
70 Thresholds
Part I, Chapter 6 Methods of Awarding
Contracts In order for a proposal to be
considered for selection for BAFO or selection
for contract negotiations, the total score for
the technical submittal of the proposal must be
greater than or equal to 70 of the highest
scoring technical submittal.
41Procurement Handbook Pending
BMWBO Changes
- Part 1, Chapter 3 Responsibilities
- Currently, the agency evaluates the STD-168 over
250K - At any dollar amount, an STD-168 MBE/WBE
Subcontractor and Supplier Solicitation form,
will be sent to the supplier to complete, sign
and return to the agency. - - The agency will evaluate their responsibility
for a value of up to 50K and BMWBO will review
if the contract is over 50K. - Part 3, Chapter 7 Competitive Sealed Proposals
(RFP Process) - Will read the same as Part 2, Chapter 7
- BMWBO assigns the minimum weight for DB
participation at 20 of total points - Agency establishes a maximum point value for
each major evaluation criterion prior to RFP
issuance - - Cost criterion must be a minimum of 30 total
points
42Procurement Handbook Pending
BMWBO Changes
Part 1, Chapter 20 Non Discrimination Currently
the Form GSMWBE-16 is completed only on
construction contracts. They will be needed for
any contract over 50K. - The Form GSMWBE-16,
"MBE/WBE Subcontractor and Supplier Certification
Solicitation and Commitment Form", is to be
included in contracts with sole source
contractors when the total procurement is
estimated to be more than 50,000 annually for
single or multiple year awards. The contractor
must complete Form GSMWBE-16. - Before
processing a contract in the amount exceeding
50,000 (or such higher amount as BMWBO may
establish for a particular agency), including
those amendments and change orders that directly
affect MBE/WBE participation, the purchasing
agency is required to forward the
bidder-completed GSMWBE-16 to BMWBO which will
determine the contractor's responsibility in
regard to nondiscrimination unless exempted from
the BMWBO Program requirements. - If BMWBO
determines the contractor is nonresponsive and/or
not responsible, and the agency decides to make
an award, the agency must consult with its Office
of Chief Counsel, and its agency head or
appropriate Deputy Secretary and fully justify,
in writing, its reasons for proceeding with
award. The agency must forward a copy of this
justification to BMWBO. Part 2, Chapter 3
Delegated Formal Competitive Sealed Bidding -
This section of the Handbook is under review to
eliminate the need for agencies to send
solicitations to suppliers. BMWBO will require
suppliers to provide an email address so that the
supplier can receive Ealerts.
43Procurement Handbook Pending
Modifications to Document Builder MBE/WBE
The following issues are being addressed - List
the number of documents required - Link to BMWBO
website
RFP Template
- Part 1, Sections 12 and 13 will update the
phone, fax and website for BMWBO - Part 1, Section 19 will address confidential
information and the Right To Know requirements - Part 2, Section 9a revises the number of
Disadvantaged Business submittal copies to 2 - Part 3, Section 4 adds the 70 rule for
technical proposals, language to disclose the
weights for technical, cost and Disadvantaged
Business scoring and bonus points - Part 4, Section 6 adds through any renewal or
extension of the contract - Appendix B Domestic Workforce Utilization
Certification form was revised - RFP Template
Archiving templates from DGS website
- Templates commonly found on the DGS website are
being archived to allow agencies to find
templates from prior years - DGS templates only
will be saved - Agencies are recommended to
archive their own agency specific documents -
Templates can be found at PUForms/ArchivedForms
44Procurement Handbook Pending
Publishing RFP Weights
- It is DGS intention to publish RFP weights
- Using this process makes debriefings easier and
clearer - Suppliers cannot claim the scoring
weights/criteria were inappropriate, as they were
pre-published
Treasury
- Developing a new chapter on Department of
Treasury which will include Right To Know
requirements.
Green Procurement
Part 1, Chapter 22 Green Procurements -
Currently drafting policy on Environmentally
Preferable Purchasing - Developing tools and
website resources along with training -
Identifying 3-5 commodities for pilot projects
45Procurement Handbook Pending
Subscriptions
Part 1, Chapter 1 General Provisions -
Clarifying the scope surrounding subscriptions.
GSA Schedules
- There are schedules (contracts) available from
the Federal government - They are used on a
limited basis - DGS will be reviewing policy to
allow limited usage of GSA Schedules - Establish
DGS as a initial checkpoint prior to
purchase www.gsa.gov
46Requisition Pricing
- Purpose
- Some agencies are occasionally changing the Do
not adopt to As net price setting in the Line
Item Details section of an R3 requisition.
- Changing Settings
- Requisitioners should not change the valuation
setting of Do not adopt. - This setting is necessary so that contract
pricing is maintained throughout the documents. - When a requisitioner pulls up a contract item,
the correct price will be pulled into the
document.
47Bidding Guide
- To create your bid
- Go to www.pasupplierportal.state.pa.us
- Go to Supplier Log On
- Select Bidder Tab
- Select Process Bids
- Locate Bid Opportunity
- Select Create Action Icon
- To complete your bid
- Go to General Data Tab
- Select Attributes and respond to all
questions/statements - Add Attachments by selecting Browse locate
file upload by selecting Add - Enter Price
- Submit the Bid
- The Submit button will not be available until
the Check button is invoked.
- To delete a bid completed incorrectly
- 1.Search for previously submitted bid. Once it
appears, click the pencils for Change mode - 2. Select the Hold button
- 3. Select the Change button, Delete button
should appear - 4. Select the Delete button
- Support Options
- Live Support exists for suppliers available via
the Customer Support Center - Email ra-srmhelp_at_state.pa.us
- Phone 717-346-2676 (local)
- Phone 877-435-7363(outside Harrisburg)
- www.pasupplierportal.state.pa.us
Document can be found Bidders Guide - Checklist
for Creating, Responding and Deleting a Bid
48Live Auction
- Live Auction Cockpit (LAC) refers to an auction
that takes place online in real time via the
SRM portal. Live auctions are held to get the
best available market price at the time of the
bid. Throughout the bidding process the price is
driven down, which often results in a lower price
paid than traditional sealed bids or
negotiations. A matrix is available for use which
will allow a user to decide if Live Auction is
the right tool.
DGS offers this service to agencies To access the
EUP Live Auction EUP
49Live Auction Decision Tool
The Decision Tool is utilized to determine the
viability of performing a Live Auction.
50Why conduct an Auction?
- To get the best available market price at the
time of the bid - Auctions drive down costs, often resulting in a
lower price paid than traditional sealed bids or
negotiations - Real cost savings of 10 or more can be realized
- For example An item which is purchased in a
significant quantity, and there is pricing
flexibility in the market - To improve and streamline the strategic
e-procurement process - Precise specifications will be provided to
potential suppliers - Historical spend data can be used to develop
business forecasts - Negotiation time is reduced from weeks to minutes
- Auction events are easily duplicated
- Auction events are visible and the results
measurable - The live web-based event is viewed in real time
- SRM reporting offers detailed analysis across
auctions - Increased competitiveness within the public
sector - Ongoing cost reductions and improved productivity
are essential in government activities - Results and benefits are measurable and easily
reported - Many suppliers appreciate the openness of auctions
51Three Auction Profiles used by DGS
52Material Requirements Planning Overview
- Purpose of todays overview
- Provide an understanding of MRP its use
- Provide information for use when making
purchasing decisions - Clarify misconceptions regarding the methods of
procurement for inventory
MRP OR NON MRP, THAT IS THE QUESTION
53MRP Transactions in R3
54Inventory MRP Facts
- MRP use is limited for the Commonwealth
- MRP Process Plans, Creates Planned Orders,
Converts Planned Orders into Requisitions, and
Creates Purchase orders - Takes into consideration such things as re-order
point, prior and future consumption,
replenishment, lot size, lead-time and use - In order to use MRP an agency must have an
established MRP Controller, Inventory Planner,
and material masters set up for MRP requirements. - Material masters should be listed as contract
line items when a statewide or agency contract is
created
MRP does not simply mean an order for
inventory - MRP is a process -
55Process Flow - Inventory via MRP
56Inventory Purchases
- There is a misconception that SRM cannot be used
to order inventory items SRM can be used to
order inventory - Many contract replication requests use the
justification MRP - 4600010375 with Hershey Creamery for Ice Cream
- Only Corrections ordered for inventory and POs
were not generated through MRP - No need to maintain contract in both places
should be SRM only - R3 Document type NNB New Standard PO
57SRM for Inventory
- SRM can be used for inventory purchase orders not
procured via the MRP process - After the product ID (material master) has been
entered the Order as Direct Material indicator
appears
If non-valuated, use normal process - account
assignment is required
58High Level Process Flow - Inventory Non-MRP
59SRM CSC Background
- SRM Customer Support Center (CSC)
- Operated by DGS Bureau of Procurement (BOP)
- Established in Aug 2006
- Created to provide interim support during and
post - go-live SRM implementation
- Provides two separate services
- Supplier Registration and Support
- SRM Agency Support
60Current CSC Flow
61Call Volume From Agencies
- CSC SRM Agency Support
- Averages 403 Automated Call Distribution (ACD)
calls per month (93 per week) - Approximately 20 are not answered due to
conflicting priorities
62Other Influx to CSC
- Incoming calls directly to Commodity Specialists
- Average 50 per week
- Remedy Tickets
- Average 28 per week
- Emails to SRM Resource Account
- Average 20 per week
- Additional time needed to research issues
- Average 25 hours per week
63Initial Agency Inquiries
- Original types of inquiries received from
Agencies by CSC were SRM related - How do I set my attributes?
- How do I enter ship to addresses?
- I cant find a vendor.
- How do I create a shopping cart?
- What is a product category?
- How do I reference a contract?
64Current Agency Inquiries
65Agency Assistance
- Agencies can reduce the number of inquiries to
the CSC by - Limiting inquiries to only those related to CSCs
core mission ? SRM questions only -
- Call Commodity Specialists directly for sourcing
issues - Encourage procurement professionals to utilize
the Self Service Resources - End User Procedures
- SRM Website FAQs, AIT Library, Resource Guide
- eNews
- Encourage associates to take advantage of the
various Procurement Training Programs offered by
BOP
66Password Reset
- Password Reset Login Screen
- Suppliers insert user name in Logon ID.
- Suppliers click on Reset Password.
- Password reset e-mail comes from
- ra-srmhelp_at_state.pa.us. (Recommend checking
SPAM settings.)
67SRM Core System
- Support Packs
- What is a Support Pack?
- Support packs contain all the current fixes
from SAP in one bundle rather than applying
individual notes on an as needed basis. - Support packs normally fix things, but on
occasion may create a problem. - IES will do testing of the Support Packs
- All changes as a result of the support packs
should be found at this time and IES will
communicate this information to the agencies. - If end users notice anything different in the
core or SRM systems once the support packs are
put into production they should report the issue
through the helpdesk/remedy ticket process. - Tentative Schedule for Latest Support Packs
- Development - November 10, 2008
- Quality - November 17, 2008
- Production - December 6, 2008
68SRM Core System
- Upgrades
- ERP 6.0 Upgrade
- Effects all systems including ESS
- Cut-over dates for system unavailability
- PA Supplier Portal Thursday, October 30th 500
PM thru Monday, November 3rd 600 AM - MyCommonwealthWorkplace Friday, October 31st
400 AM thru Monday, November 3rd 600 AM - .xml Supplier Transmittal of Invoices Thursday,
October 30th 500 PM thru Monday, November 3rd
600 AM - Screen change document
- Handout
- Sent via eNews on 10/22/08
-
69SRM Updates
- Guid Error Public Advertising Supplier
- The contact information for the public
advertising supplier was deleted from the vendor
record in error - This caused a Guid (Globally Unique Identifier)
error on bids created prior to 8/12/08 using the
public advertising supplier - This error is undetectable until workflow is
initiated - This error is uncorrectable
- Resolution
- The public advertising supplier record was
corrected - Do not reuse or copy a bid created prior to
8/12/08 - Create a new bid
70Supplier Enablement - ERS
- Evaluated Receipt Settlement (ERS)
- A shortened, easier process to pay suppliers
- Upon receipt of order receiving agency enters GR
- Overnight process generates an electronic invoice
- 2-way match PO quantity GR quantity
- Treasury processes payment via ACH
- Eliminates need for issuing and processing
invoices - No action is needed by the comptroller
- Turnaround time for payment is reduced
- Goods Receipts must be accurate and timely!
- Failure to enter GR Supplier will not be paid
- Late entry of GR Supplier payment will be
delayed - Incorrect GR entry Supplier will be paid an
incorrect amount and purchasing agency must
process a credit memo
71Supplier Enablement - ERS
- Evaluated Receipt Settlement (ERS) - Pilot
Program - Cut over date - September 10, 2008
- Suppliers
- Todd Heller, LLC -Contract 4600013343 Glass Beads
- Ennis Paint, Inc. Contract 4600010851 Traffic
Line Paint - Agency Transportation
- Current activity 4 POs were created and 5
payments successfully processed - End of paint season not much activity
anticipated - Investigating expanding the pilot to include
- Calcium Chloride
- Rock Salt
- Corrugated Boxes
72Assignment of Payments in SRM
- Method for assigning payment on invoices related
to SRM-generated POs to an Assignee rather than
the Assignors default remit-to address. - CVMU creates a 902 Partner Record within the
suppliers master data. - To request a 902 Partner Record - purchaser
must - Complete 902 Partner Record Request form (found
under Procurement Forms on the DGS website) - Request must include the following info
- Complete name and address of Assignee
- Vendor number of the Assignee
- Signed letter from the Assignor documenting the
assignment of payment - Must be on Assignors letterhead
- Multiple Assignees require separate request forms
for each - Submit documents to CVMU Resource Mailbox at
ra-co-bfm-cvmu_at_state.pa.us. - If approved, the Partner Record will be created.
If disapproved, the form will be returned to the
requester with the reason for rejection. - EUP is available on the DGS website 902 Form
EUP - 9/18/08 eNews
73Procurement Connection Group
- Objectives
- Provide information and guidance to agency users
on current and future procurement related
matters. - Provide support in resolving issues relative to
procurement functions. - Give agencies an opportunity to offer input into
DGS procurement projects and contracts. - Provide a forum for agencies to have open
discussion on issues that are affecting them and
how they do their business and will allow for
sharing of ideas and individual agency successes. - Schedule
- First meeting held Wednesday, October 15, 2008
- Meetings will occur every 8 weeks
- Agendas
- Agencies are encouraged to submit agenda items
for discussion. - Meeting notices will be sent requesting agenda
items - Opportunity for smaller group discussions on
specific topic areas - Agenda items can be submitted any time
- Submit to Cheryl Kleeman via email -
ckleeman_at_state.pa.us
74eMarketplace Updates
- Procedure for Simplifying Contract Search in
eMarketplace - Has been added to Tips Tricks under the
Help section on eMarketplace
75eMarketplace Updates
76eMarketplace Updates
A list of all contracts will display by Parent
Number, Description, and Ending Date. You can
sort by any of these fields by selecting the word
at the top of the column. You can search for
your contracts here, or Export to Excel for
easier sorting and searching capabilities.
77eMarketplace Updates
- Contracts fitting your criteria will be
highlighted on the spreadsheet as shown below.
To view the vendors contracts for that parent
contract,select the highlighted numbers under
the Parent column.
78eMarketplace Updates
- This will take you back into eMarketplace and
display a list of contracts that belong to the
Parent contract you selected.
79eMarketplace Updates
- Tabulation Award Information
- Agencies may elect to post solicitation
tabulations award information to eMarketplace - Instructions will be sent via email to the PPC
and all registered users on eMarketplace - Instructions on how to upload these documents on
eMarketplace will be added to the EUP created by
the Training Section the Help section on
eMarketplace
80eMarketplace Updates
Solicitation Tabulations Required information
for input
81eMarketplace Updates
Awards Required information for input
82eMarketplace Updates
- Sole/Single Source Section
- Secretarys initiative to have sole/single source
information public - New section to be added to eMarketplace
- Source Justification Form will be a web-based
form with routing approvals - Specific information will be made public (will
review info on another slide) - Seeking agencies to volunteer to assist us in
testing before go live
83eMarketplace Updates
Procurement Description will appear for public
viewing
84eMarketplace Updates
85eMarketplace Updates
86eMarketplace Updates
87eMarketplace Updates
88Quality AssuranceProcurement Review Background
- As part of the Financial Transformation (FT)
Project Comptroller Operations (CO) is in the
process of redefining many core functions. While
they will remain a part of procurement document
review, their role will transition to more of a
financial focus vs. a comprehensive and all
inclusive review of procurement documents,
solicitations and contract processes. - Future State
- Selective review
- More post audit vs. 100 inspection prior to
document release - Focus more on financial aspect vs. procurement
process - This change in roles and responsibilities places
increased accountability on agency procurement
personnel to - Ensure accuracy and compliance upon document
creation, transactions performed, as well as
oversight of the procurement process.
88
89Background
Background
Future State with Quality Assurance
Procurement Review
BOPsQuality Assurance Procurement Review
90Background
- As the lead procurement agency responsible for
policy, systems and processes, Bureau of
Procurement (BOP) should assume an increasing
role formerly managed by CO. - Title 62, Chapter 3 Section 11, of the
Pennsylvania Consolidated Statutes, allows the
Department of General Services (DGS) to monitor
the implementation of its regulations for the
procurement of all supplies, services and
construction by Commonwealth agencies. - Policies and Procedures are stated in the DGS
Procurement Handbook.
90
91Background
- Massachusetts, Texas, South Carolina and
California have programs established to assess
procurements made by their state agencies. - BOP intends to establish a Quality Assurance
Procurement Review to ensure compliance and offer
assistance to agencies.
92Process Cycle
BOP Conducts Procurement Review
Agency Develops Implements Corrective Actions
BOP Agency Review Findings
Identify Opportunities for ImprovementPolicies,
Procedures, Systems Training Requirements
93Quality Assurance Review Process
PRE-VISIT PREPARATION
POST-VISIT EVALUATION
- Document Site Visit
- Record Rankings
- Finalize Summary Package
- Identify Corrective Actions Opportunities for
Improvement
- Identify Candidate
- Perform Electronic Review
- Create Agency Outreach Package
- Set Up Site Visit
RECALIBRATE AS REQUIRED
SITE VISIT
- Implement Changes
- Stay Current on Changes, Additions, Deletions,
Modifications to Policy Procedures
- Review Reports Documentation
- Evaluate Compliance
- Complete Review Documents
94Scope
- The Intent of the Quality Assurance Procurement
Review is to - 1) Identify the Agencies level of compliance
with Title 62 and the procurement procedures - established by DGS and documented in the
Procurement Handbook - 2) Determine if the procedures stated in the
Procurement Handbook require clarification - 3) Identify agency training requirements
- 4) Mitigate risk
- 5) Provide an objective assessment of the
agencys compliance and the associated risk - 6) Assist the agencies with the development and
implementation of Corrective Actions to - mitigate risk
-
- 7) Promote compliance by providing continuous
communications to inform the agencies on - new/revised policies and procedures and training
programs
94
95Benefits
- Benefits of the Quality
- Assurance Procurement
- Review
- Ensures Compliance with the Procurement Handbook
- Identifies Opportunities for Improvement
- Identifies Training Requirements
- Provides Process and Tools to Manage Change
- Provides Mitigation Strategies
- Provides Prevention Strategies
- Promotes Feedback Mechanism
95
96Pilot
- BOP is soliciting for an Agency to participate as
the pilot, assisting in the development of the
process - Pilot to begin early 2009
- Contact Paul Wolf
97Training
- Negotiations Course
- Developed for Commodity Specialist and Agency
Purchasing Agents. - Currently with OA-HRD for articulation.
- Made available via WBT and administered via E-LMS
mid-November. - BW/SRM Course
- Expanded to Purchasing Agents. A training
announcement with scheduled offerings will be
sent to Policy Council Members and Training
Officers for dissemination in the near future. - RFP Process Course -
- Pilot course scheduled 12/2/2008
- One day instructor led course.
- Agencies contacted for plot participation.
- Mix of DGS/BOP Commodity Specialists and Agency
Procurement Professionals. - Penn State Supply Chain Management
- 15 Students completed Penn State Program.
- BOP awarded certificates at recognition ceremony
in September
98Procurement Policy ProcessPurchasing
Certification
- Purpose
- As business owner BOP has developed formal,
4-day, ILT to give new and less experienced PAs
fundamental understanding of COPA procurement
policies, procedures and processes - This classroom training, coupled with practical
work experience, will raise the standards of all
COPA Procurement Professionals. - It will also establish a uniform knowledge base
for all PAs, which will reduce inconsistencies
among agencies and ensure that all purchases are
performed according to Procurement Handbook
guidelines. - As such, the training was determined to be
mandatory and we will also be requiring
experienced Purchasing Agents to attend. - Recap of Procurement Policy and Processes Pilot
Course - - Session held 9/8-11.
- Varying levels of experience - few weeks to gt20
years - Thanks for participation and feedback.
- 10 Students
- 7 agencies
- Survey responses were very positive
- Feedback incorporated into curriculum and
Knowledge Review - Agency Purchasers who are not PAs (ex. AAs and
AOs) will be able to attend this course.
99Procurement Policy ProcessPurchasing Agents
Training
- Future Training Schedule Location-
- Conducted on quarterly basis in new BOP Learning
Center. - 1st sched