Title: Whats Emerging in Emerging Markets The New Frontier
1Whats Emerging in Emerging MarketsThe New
Frontier
CFA Society of Dayton December 9, 2009 Lawrence
Speidell, Founder, CEO Portfolio
Manager Frontier Market Asset Management
2Its not about the money
3(No Transcript)
4Its about people
5Its about people
6Its about people
7Its about people
8Its about people
9Its about people
10Peraliya, Sri Lanka
11Frontier Market Opportunities
- One World or Two
- Convergence
- Stock Opportunities
- Inefficiencies
- Reasons for Optimism
12One World or Two
13Emerging/Frontier Countries Under 10,000
GDP/capita
14Frontier Countries Not in MSCI Emerging Markets
Index
15Power Consumption versus Population
http//www.worldmapper.org/display.php?selected11
7
16One World or Two
17One World or Two
18One World or Two
Cuyahoga River 1971
19The Poor World Human Capital and Financial
Opportunity
20Economics Growth
Source IMF, November 2009
21Convergence
1791
686
192
22Convergence
The GUM Department Store 1991
23Convergence
The GUM Department Store 1991 and 2002
24Chinathe Country
25Pudong
26Night Life
27The Once and Future King(s)?
From Wall Street to the Great Wall Burton
Malkiel 2008
28China, U.S., India 1,2,3 by 2050
Source Siegel, Jeremy, Future for Investors
(2005), Sunit Singhania, 2008
29Emerging Exports
30Chinas Banks
31China Stimulus
- Stimulus package US586 billion, over two years gt
16 of Chinas 3.5 trillion GDP. An equivalent
package in United States would exceed US2.25
trillion - public housing
- rural development
- highways, rail, airports, power grid
- health care and education
- the environment
- technological innovation
- Sichuan province post-quake reconstruction
- increasing agriculture subsidies and social
security payments - nationwide VAT reform
- (10) abolishing the credit quota system and
supporting credit growth for priority sectors.
32Chinas Road Construction
33Urbanization 10x Productivity
Urban 2005 2030 China 40.5 60.5 India 28.7
41.4
Source GaveKal 0604
34Middle Class In China
352,000 to 12,000 is the sweet spot for
consumption(Penetration of durable goods
relative to annual income)
12,000 90,000 RMB
2,000 15,000 RMB
36Middle Class In China
37Economics Banking
38Financial Opportunity NO Sub-Prime Mortgages
39Middle Class Resource NeedsOil
Source BP Statistical Review of World Energy,
U.S. Census global population database,
respective state statistics bureaus for GDP.
40Comparison of Chinese and US Autos as Percent of
Population
Middle Class Resource NeedsOil
Source Morgan Stanley FactSet
As of 31-Dec-05
41Comparison of the Pace of Chinese and US
Passenger Vehicle Penetration
Middle Class Resource NeedsOil
Source Morgan Stanley FactSet
As of 31-Dec-05
42Wages
Source Lockheed Corporation
43Wages
44Demographics
45A Virtuous Circle of Frontier/Emerging Market
Trade
China needs Africa has to sell
Zambia DRC
Angola Cameroon E. Guinea Gabon Nigeria DRC
Ghana Niger South Africa Zimbabwe
Mauritania South Africa
South Africa
E. Guinea
Source Deutsche Bank, 7 December 2006
46Education Strathmore University, Nairobi
47Work Ethic
48Technology
Source Human Security Centre, UBC
49Entrepreneurship
50China in the Frontier
51Middle Class - Bangladesh
Bashundara City Mall, Dhaka, Bangladesh
52 Vietnam versusIndia
53Middle Class
54Stock Opportunities
55Bata Shoe, Bangladesh
- Founded 1894 in Czechoslovakia by Bata siblings
- Survived nationalization during Communism
- Operations in Bangladesh since 1962
- Worlds largest shoe manufacturer in over 50
countries - 2009e PE 10.3x, ROE 53, Yield 6.7, Earn.
Growth 25 - Auditor KPMG
56Checklist Bata Shoe - Bangladesh
57- Swissport, Tanzania
- ChinaTanzania Relationship
- Sidecar Investment
- 2009e PE 5.2x, ROE 53, Yield 15.3, Earn.
Growth 15 - Auditor PWC
58BRD Groupe Societe Generale, Romania
- Leader in underpenetrated market loans/GDP 40
- Prudent banking during boom
- Profitability and market share gains
- 2009e PE 10.3x, ROE 18, Yield 2.4, Earn.
growth 20 - Auditor Ernst and Young
59Botswana Stock Exchange
60Inefficiencies
- Few Chartered Financial Analysts
- Locals more Important than Foreign Investors
- Bangladesh 3 in 2008 versus 6 in 2007 per
Equity Partners Limited - Kenya 10 per Kestrel Capital
- Malawi 40 per Trust Securities
- Vietnam 40 per Ho Chi Minh Stock Exchange
- Uzbekistan 75 foreign per Eastkom Securities
61Inefficiencies - Local Behavior in Bangladesh
- Our retail investors are just trying to follow
the others, keen to know what the so called
gamblers are going to buy - I heard this share's price will jump, because
some gambler is going to buy it - In our market, we have some stocks like Apex
foods, Apex tannery, Apex footwear, Apex
Spinning, Apex weaving etc. These companies are
doing different kinds of business. Some are
involved in textiles, some in foods and some in
footwear. - If there is a good news for say Apex footwear-
that is involved in footwear business, all
companies that name begin with Apex will start
rising. - They are acting as a group even though the
business is different and the owners are
different for some companies.
62One World or Two
63One World or Two
64One World or Two
65Volatility is lower than Emerging Markets
66Risk Volatility is low
67Correlations are low among frontier countries
The average correlation of 20 Frontier Markets
with Bangladesh is 0.29. The average correlation
of 20 Frontier Markets with Botswana is 0.35
68Correlation is low
69Liquidity
Firm Capacity estimate based on holding 10 days
volume
70Valuations Frontier Markets are Attractive
71Valuations Frontier Markets are Attractive
72Valuations Frontier Markets are Attractive
73Numbers
74Optimism Emerging and Frontier Market
Capitalization Benefits to being Early Mover
111 billion Frontier Markets
Emerging Markets
Represents free float market capitalization as
of June 1st 2009. Source MSCI, BGI.
74
Source MSCI, BGI
75Optimism versus the Tyranny of the Media
Source Human Security Centre, UBC
76Optimism Fewer Conflicts
Source Human Security Centre, UBC
77(Frontier Countries in Blue)
Source The Heritage Foundation, 2008
78Optimism Pew Survey
79Optimism Pew Survey
Kenya
80Optimism Pew Survey
81Optimism Determination
82Optimism Determination
83Optimism Determination
84Optimism Determination
85Optimism Determination
86Optimism Determination
87Its about people
88Conclusion Reasons for optimism
89Our Investment Process Bottom-up Driven
90Risk Control Through Diversification
- 40-50 stocks in up to 30 countries
- Limit stocks to 10 and countries to 25
-
- Portfolio Characteristics (Weighted Averages)
- Price / Earnings Ratio 8.3x
- Price / Book Ratio 2.0x
- Return on Equity 26
- Estimated Growth Rate 24
- PEG Ratio P/E to Growth 0.35
- Average Dividend Yield 5.5
- At time of initial investment
91Risk Control Through Diversification
- 47 Stocks in 23 Countries
92Performance
Inception Date October 1, 2006. Net performance
is calculated for a typical investor, individual
returns may vary with contribution date and other
factors. Past performance is not indicative of
future returns. Performance is preliminary and
un-audited, and subject to change.
93Education Strathmore University, Nairobi
94 People
95Review the fundamental basis of conviction in
secular domestic growth in frontier markets. What
are the risks identified and does this differ on
time horizon per region?
- Demographics The strong growth of frontier
countries is underpinned by the young population.
Except in Eastern Europe - Technology The frontier countries have
leapfrogged over generations of developed world
technology (in wireless phones, for example).
Submarine cable just arrived in Mombasa. Rising
protectionism could hurt - Labor Costs are low (50/mo in Dhaka versus 250
in Shanghai), and education is improving (MBAs at
Strathmore University in Nairobi) Rising
protectionism could hurt. Economic softness has
cut remittances - Natural Resources Abundant in many frontier
countries and largely unexplored in all of them.
Prolonged recession will postpone demand - Politics and policies are improving Peaceful
transitions of power are becoming the norm, and
advice from global institutions (World Bank
IMF) is improving. Stress from the global
financial crisis could cause regression - Capital Inflows of FDI, portfolio investment and
aid have been strong, especially from China.
Recession has reduced flows, especially in E.
Europe where foreign currency borrowing caused
problems
96Convergence
97Coping With Challenges
98Coping With Challenges
99Relative Economics
Source World Bank and CIA World Factbook,
Frontier Markets include those countries
included in the MSCI Frontier Index, the SP
Frontier Index and the SP Extended Frontier 150
Index and excludes those countries also
classified as Emerging Markets. 1. GNI per Capita
is for 2007 except Bahrain (2005), Kuwait (2005),
Oman (2004), and UAE (2005). Qatar is excluded
from the GNI per Capita calculation. Population
is for 2007 GDP Growth Rate is for 2007 except
Bahrain (2005), Kuwait (2005), Oman (2005), Qatar
(2005) and UAE (2005) Population Growth Rates are
2008 estimates
99
100Emerging/Frontier Growth IMF July 2009Two
Worlds?
101One World or Two
102Risk Correlation is low
103Risk Commodity Correlation is low
104More Peacekeepers and Tribunals
Source Human Security Centre, UBC
105 One World or Two
- Average 5 year historic and forecast GDP Growth
105
SourceIMF and BGI
106Emerging Exports
107China Exports 40 GDP, but Net Exports only
10
108Emerging Market Exports
109Our Philosophy
- We are value investors in Frontier Stock Markets.
- In these markets, there are few foreign investors
and simply getting annual reports can be
challenging, but the rewards for careful and
patient analysis can be great. - We seek companies with good growth prospects
offering quality products and services, solid
management, and transparent accounting practices. - We look for companies that Graham and Dodd would
like for their value and Warren Buffet would like
for their growth.
110Research Trip Bulgaria, Romania, Slovenia,
Croatia, Serbia (July 2009)
111Takeaways
- Short term pain BUT Long term --
- Improving demographics and politics
- Tax and employment policies
- Low labor cost
- Location as gateway to Old Europe
112Stock Opportunities
- Great Businesses
- Simple operations
- Growth potential
- Sidecars and monopolies
- Strong Management
- Experienced
- English speaking
- Trained abroad
- Good Information
- Annual Reports (Big 4 Audits)
- Investor Relations Websites