How to Determine, Assess, and Ensure Data Annotation Quality

1
How to Determine, Assess, and Ensure Data
Annotation Quality

• The popular adage, "Garbage in, garbage out" is
  perfectly applicable to the field of data
  annotation. There is a growing emphasis on
  high-quality data for accurate annotations. As
  mentioned by our co-founder Kamran Shaikh, no
  matter how good the AI model is, the investment
  is wasted if the data is low-quality.
• The best AI and machine learning models emerge
  only from high-quality datasets with complete
  labels. In the words of Wilson Pang of Appen,
  using poor-quality data to train your machine
  learning system is like preparing for a physics
  test by studying geometry. Effectively speaking,
  this means that without feeding it with the
  right data, no AI model will deliver accurate
  output.
• To make data-driven decisions, business leaders
  need to understand the importance of ensuring
  data quality for any form of data labeling and
  annotations. Be it for text, video, or image
  annotations, data-dependent enterprises need to
  be able to define and measure data quality. How
  can this be done? Lets discuss this aspect with
  more clarity.
• Defining Data Quality In Annotation
• Often, we use terms like "accuracy" and
  "consistency" when talking about data quality.
  Effectively, accuracy is all about the proximity
  of data labeling to real-world conditions.
  Consistency refers to adhering to the same
  labeling standards across the entire dataset.

2
Data quality measures can vary for different
tasks. Despite this fact, high-quality datasets
do share some common characteristics. Foremost
among those is the dataset itself. Datasets must
have a healthy balance and variety of data
points. For instance, the dataset for autonomous
vehicle training ideally must balance between
moving and motionless vehicles. Effective
techniques like weight balancing are helpful in
ensuring balance. Another typical characteristic
is how precisely each data point contains the
labels and categories. Besides accuracy in
labeling, data quality is also about how
consistent this accuracy is. To achieve data
quality, experts must have a deeper
understanding of the project requirements and
business needs. Hence, AI technology-based
companies define data quality in the context of
a specific project using a quality rubric.
High-quality data also feature characteristics
like completeness, integrity, and validity. Next,
lets discuss how to measure data quality.
3

• How To Measure Data Quality?
• Companies can utilize multiple methods to measure
  their data quality for proper labeling. Here are
  some effective methods to measure quality data
• Consensus (or Overlap) Method This method is
  useful for measuring data quality for projects
  with objective rating scales. The aim is to
  arrive at a consensus within a group comprising
  both human and machine annotators. To calculate
  the consensus percentage, the sum of "agreeing"
  annotations is divided by the total number of
  annotations. Additionally, an assigned arbitrator
  decides on disagreements over any overlapped
  judgments.
• Benchmarks (or Gold Sets) Method Benchmarking is
  a more reliable method of measuring quality
  against a given standard (or benchmark). With
  automation, data labelers are randomly
  benchmarked to check if their labels measure up
  to a predetermined reference. This reference
  could be in the form of a high-quality image or
  text. This method is effective for creating a
  reference and measuring how a set of annotations
  measure against this reference point.
• Auditing (or Review) Method For this method,
  experts have deployed to either spot-check any
  data label or review the entire training dataset
  for quality. Assigned auditors or reviewers can
  measure the accuracy and consistency of data
  quality across all datasets. This method is
  useful in transcription projects, where accuracy
  can be achieved through a cycle of reviews and
  reworks.
• Cronbachs Alpha Method Finally, the Cronbach
  Alpha method is a measure of internal
  consistency, meaning how closely related are a
  set of grouped items. This mathematical method
  computes the function of the number of test
  items with the average correlation within the
  items.

4

• For data quality, this method can measure the
  average correlation (or consistency) of items
  within a dataset. This can help in determining
  the overall reliability of the data labels.
• How We Ensure Data Quality In Annotations
• As a data labeling company, we partner with
  various companies that need to feed their AI and
  machine learning models with high-quality data.
  Here is how we, at EnFuse Solutions, ensure
  high-quality data for their annotation projects
• Assigning Only Annotation Experts At EnFuse, we
  have a team of trained and experienced
  annotators capable of working with different
  datasets and business domains. The final team is
  assigned to a client project only after a
  complete assessment and understanding of
  customer requirements. Besides technical
  training, our annotators are trained to avoid
  any "unconscious" bias in labeling.
• Domain-Specific Training Data labeling methods
  can vary across different business domains. Our
  data annotation experts undergo detailed
  training that is specific to the client's
  business domain. This enables them to add
  domain-specific context to their annotation work.
• Benchmark Standards At EnFuse, we use the
  benchmark (or gold standard) method to measure
  data quality. Our data annotators are fed only
  with datasets measuring up to this standard.
• Additional QA Inspection After the initial round
  of data annotations, we use the quality
  technique of random sampling to measure the data
  quality. Our team of expert annotators and
  dataset reviewers inspect the data annotation
  work. For critical projects, the final datasets
  are passed through multiple rounds of
  annotations.

5

• Automation Besides using human annotators,
  automated algorithms are also used in specific
  cases to check the accuracy and reliability of
  labeling. These algorithms leverage the Cronbach
  Alpha method to measure the correlation and
  consistency of dataset items.
• Conclusion
• For the success of any AI and machine learning
  model, high-quality data is an essential
  requirement. The availability of high-quality
  data is effective for training ML algorithms and
  making the data model work in real-life
  scenarios.
• As a data solutions company, EnFuse Solutions has
  worked with global customers in creating
  high-quality data that they can use for
  implementing their AI and machine learning
  initiatives. Connect with us if you are looking
  for accurate and reliable data for your next AI
  project.
• Read More About Image and Video Annotation Here
• Why are Image and Video Annotation Challenging
  and Complex?