Propsoal Comaprison Summary

1
Project IEEE P802.15 Working Group for Wireless
Personal Area Networks (WPANs) Submission Title
Proposal Comparison Summary Date Submitted
May 12, 2004 Source Matt Welborn Company
Freescale Semiconductor Address 8133 Leesburg
Pike Vienna, VA USA Voice703-269-3000,
E-Mailmwelborn_at_xtremespectrum.com Re
Abstract Summarize the two PHY proposals with
respect to the requirements described in the TG3a
Selection criteria document. Purpose Provide
technical information to the TG3a voters
regarding PHY proposals. Notice This document
has been prepared to assist the IEEE P802.15. It
is offered as a basis for discussion and is not
binding on the contributing individual(s) or
organization(s). The material in this document is
subject to change in form and content after
further study. The contributor(s) reserve(s) the
right to add, amend or withdraw material
contained herein. Release The contributor
acknowledges and accepts that this contribution
becomes the property of IEEE and may be made
publicly available by P802.15.
2
Introduction

• Goal Summarize the two proposals with respect to
  the requirements described in the TG3a Selection
  criteria document
• Approach Collect reported results from the
  various proposal documents and requirements from
  selection criteria.
• Disclaimer The author of this document is also
  one of the authors of the DS-UWB (Merger 2)
  proposal. Opinions/comments are so labeled

3
Source Documents

• Merger 1
• 03/268r3
• 04/220
• Merger 2
• 04/137r2
• 04/099r2
• 04/140r4
• Selection Criteria
• 03/031r11

4
3.1 Unit Manufacturing Cost
5
3.2.2 Interference Susceptibility
6
3.2.2.6-7 Generic In-band Interference
7
3.2.3 Coexistence
8
3.3.1 Manufacturability
9
3.2.2 Time to Market
10
3.3.3 Regulatory Impact
11
3.4 Scalability
12
3.5 Location Awareness
13
4.1 Alternate PHY Required MAC Enhancements and
Modifications
14
5.1 Size and Form Factor
15
5.2 PHY-SAP Payload bit-rate and Data Throughput
16
5.3 Simultaneously Operating Piconets
17
5.4 Signal Acquisition
18
5.5 System Performance
19
5.6 Link Budget
20
5.7 Sensitivity
21
5.8 Power Management Modes
22
5.9 PHY Power Consumption
23
5.10 Antenna Practicality