Title: What can you as a pharmacist do to help your patients?
1Discussion QuestionsWhat to Do About High Drug
Costs
- What can you as a pharmacist do to help your
patients? - What can our institution do to better control
costs? - What policies could help moderate drug costs?
- What role can the formulary play in these efforts?
30th Nov. 2013
230th Nov. 2013
3Many People Involved in Pharmaceutical
Supply-Chain
30th Nov. 2013
4WHAT is Economic Evaluation?
- Definition Economic Evaluation is ...
- the identification, measure, and comparison of
the costs (i.e. resources consumed) and outcomes
(clinical, economic, and humanistic) of
interventions (pharmaceuticals, non-drug
therapies, public health programs)
30th Nov. 2013
5WHAT is Economic Evaluation?
- Economic Evaluation is NOT JUST economics
- Economic Evaluation is multi-disciplinary, it
combines - Economics
- Epidemiology
- Biostatistics
- Medicine
- Pharmacy
- .
30th Nov. 2013
6Why study Economic Evaluation?
- The pressure of cost containment.
- The need for methods to evaluate medical
interventions. - Purpose of economic evaluation
- ? efficient resource allocation
- NOTE equity is often not addressed
30th Nov. 2013
7Who uses Economic Evaluation?
- Managers in hospital or health care plans
(formulary decision) - Pharmaceutical companies
- Government / Policy makers
- Researchers
30th Nov. 2013
8Who uses Economic Evaluation? (cont.)
- Hospital managers (including HMOs and FFS)
- What drugs should be included on the hospital
formulary? - Which drug delivery system is the best for the
hospital? - Pharmaceutical companies
- What is the best drug for a pharmaceutical
company to develop? - Shall the company continue a clinical trial?
- What is the economic benefit of a new product?
30th Nov. 2013
9Who uses Economic Evaluation? (cont.)
- Government
- Which drugs should be included in a Medicaid
formulary? - Is it cost-effective for Medicare to cover annual
mammography? - Researchers
- All of the above
- How to improve the analytical credibility of
economic evaluation ?
30th Nov. 2013
10Costs can be described in many ways
- Cost / unit (cost/tab, cost/vial)
- Cost / treatment
- Cost / person
- Cost / person / year
- Cost / case prevented
- Cost / life saved
- Cost / DALY (disability-adjusted life year)
30th Nov. 2013
11Outcomes
- Both positive and negative outcomes should be
addressed - Positive outcomes drugs efficacy measure
- Negative outcomes ADR and treatment failure
30th Nov. 2013
12Pharmacoeconomics
- is a set of methods to evaluate the(ECHO)
- 1.Economic,
- 2.Clinical, and
- 3.Humanistic
- 4.Outcomes of pharmaceutical products and
services(or any health care service)
30th Nov. 2013
13Outcomes Relationship
30th Nov. 2013
14Pharmacoeconomics allows us
- to compare the economic resources
consumed(inputs) to produce the health and
economic consequences of products or
services(outcomes).
30th Nov. 2013
15Application of Pharmacoeconomics
- Pricing of a new drug
- Re-pricing of an old drug
- Generation of a data for promotional material
- Legislative requirement for drug licensing and
medical reimbursement - Justify clinical pharmacy evaluation
- Used to justify use of pharmacy products and
pharmaceutical care - Principle of Pharmacoeconomic also influences
health care decision making and individual
patient care - Earlier clinical decisions were solely based on
outcomes. Now cost, outcome, humanistic - outcome are also considered
30th Nov. 2013
16Cost of drug
- This is the total resources consumed in producing
the drug or drug formulation. It is the amount
paid to the suppliers.? - To evaluate the economics of drug therapy,cost is
categorized into - i. Direct cost.
- ii. Indirect cost.
- iii. Intangible cost
30th Nov. 2013
17Direct cost
- i.) Direct medical cost
- This is what is paid for specialized health
resources and services. It includes the - Physicians salaries
- Acquisition cost of medicine
- Consumables associated with drug
administration - Staff time in preparation and
administration of medicines - Laboratory costs of monitoring for
effectiveness and adverse - drug reactions.
- ii.) Direct non medical cost
- This includes cost necessary to enable an
individual receive medical care such as
lodging,special diet and transportation lost
work time(important to employers) such as acute
Otitis media in pediatric patients with
professional parents who lost work time during
the treatment of their kid.
30th Nov. 2013
18Indirect cost
- This is the cost incurred by the patient,
family,friends or society. Many of these are
difficult to measure,but should be of concern to
society as a whole. - This includes productivity loss in the society
unpaid care givers lost wages expenses of
illness borne by patients, relatives, friends,
employers and the government and loss of leisure
time.
30th Nov. 2013
19Intangible costs
- These are costs related with the patients pain
and suffering worry and other distress of the
family members of a patient effect on quality of
life and health perceptions. - For example patients of rheumatoid arthritis,
cancer or having terminal illnesses in which
quality of life is suffered due to adverse
reactions of the drug treatment. - These are difficult to measure in monetary terms
but represent a considerable concern for both
doctors and patients. - Quality adjusted life year (QALY)is one method by
which intangible costs can be effectively
integrated in PE analysis
30th Nov. 2013
20Costs
- Direct costs costs to deliver services
topatient both medical and non-medical - Indirect costs cost of treatment to patient or
society - Intangible costs quality of life
30th Nov. 2013
2130th Nov. 2013
22Types of Economic Evaluation
30th Nov. 2013
23Cost of Illness Evaluation
- Also termed, cost consequence model
- Description Estimates the cost of a disease on a
defined population - Application Provides a baseline against which
various prevention/treatment options may be
compared - Example Cost of peptic ulcer disease
30th Nov. 2013
24Cost Minimization Analysis
- Description Identifies the least
expensive/costly alternative assuming the
alternatives are equal in either consequence or
outcome - Application Can only be utilized when
consequences or outcomes are identical - Costs include more than the price of meds
- Costs of treatment failure
- Costs of adverse effects
- Drug monitoring or other healthcare services
30th Nov. 2013
25Cost Benefit Analysis
- Description Measures benefit in monetary units
and computes net gain following considering the
costs of the intervention - Calculated Benefit ()/Cost ()
- Application Compare programs or agents with
different objectives - Example Clinical pharmacy service vs. other
institutional service - Determines whether benefits gt cost
30th Nov. 2013
26Examples CBA
- AIDS prevention and awareness programs
- Smoking cessation intervention
- Diabetes drug adherence
- Breast cancer screening
30th Nov. 2013
27Cost Effectiveness Analysis
- Description Compares alternatives based on a
single therapeutic effect measured in physical
units - Calculated Cost ()/Clinical Outcome (not in )
- Clinical Outcomes Could consist of a higher
positive effect, or less negative effect - Application Compare drugs/programs that differ
in clinical outcomes but use same unit of benefit - Example Antihypertensive Drug A vs Drug B on
mmHg blood pressure (/mmHg) - Application Focus on Incremental Cost
Effectiveness Ratio (ICER).
30th Nov. 2013
28Incremental Cost Effectiveness Ratio (ICER)
is an equation used commonly in health economics
to provide a practical approach to decision
making regarding health interventions. It is
typically used in cost-effectiveness analysis.
ICER is the ratio of the change in costs to
incremental benefits of a therapeutic
intervention or treatment
ICER (C1 C2) / (E1 E2)
where C1 and E1 are the cost and effect in the
intervention or treatment group and where C2 and
E2 are the cost and effect in the control care
group.
30th Nov. 2013
29Difference in cost
Consider the four possible results arising in a
CEA. First, if costs are lower and health
benefits higher for one drug relative to another,
the former is said to dominate and would be the
preferred treatment (quadrant II). Second, the
opposite applies, i.e. the new drug is more
expensive and less effective, and thus is
considered inferior and not recommended (quadrant
IV).
The third and most common case is where the new
drug is both more effective and more expensive
than the standard (quadrant I) on the basis of
ICERs, a judgment must be made regarding whether
the additional benefits are worth the extra costs
of the new drug and, therefore, whether it is
cost effective This might be defined by a
previously agreed ICER threshold value. The
fourth case is similar to the third, with the
roles of the new therapy and the standard
reversed (quadrant III) the question now is
whether the extra benefits provided by the
standard justify the additional costs of
retaining it as the preferred treatment when the
option of a new, cheaper but less effective drug
exists
Asia Journal of Pharmaceutical and Clinical
Research Vol2, issue 3, July-Sept 2009
30The cost-effectiveness plane
Med Decis Making 1990 10212214.
31Cost Utility Analysis
- Description Compares alternatives based on
therapeutic effects measured in utility units
(not physical units). Utility scores integrate
patient preferences and quality of
life/functional status - Calculated Cost ()/QALY (quality adjusted life
years) - Application Compares drugs/programs that are
life extending with serious ADRs or those
producing reductions in morbidity - Example Cancer chemotherapy regimens
- 4 years at 25 QOL 1 year at 100 QOL
30th Nov. 2013
32Considerations for Designing or Evaluating
Pharmacoeconomic Studies
- Costs
- E.g., Direct medical/nonmedical, indirect,
opportunity, intangible - Perspective
- E.g., Patient, Provider, Payer, Society
- Discounting-Value of money changes depending on
when it is exchanged (i.e. Inflation) - Sensitivity Analysis-Challenges results by
altering certain variables independently - Accuracy and transparency
- E.g., Alternatives, study population, study
design
30th Nov. 2013
33Cost-Effective ? Cost-Saving!!!
30th Nov. 2013
34Cost-Saving vs. Cost-Effective
- Cost-saving
- An intervention that has a lower total cost than
an alternative intervention - Cost-effective
- An intervention that is sufficiently effective
relative to its total cost when compared with an
alternative intervention
30th Nov. 2013
35How Can PE and Outcomes Enhance My Practice?
- PE is an aid to decision making with strong
potential to - Mitigate the influence of marketing
- Puts practitioner in the drivers seat
- Help set practice priorities
- Enhances position of practitioner from payers
perspective - Medicare plans to decrease pay-out to stem tide
of budget deficit - Private payers actively are developing quality
report cards
30th Nov. 2013
36Types of Economic Evaluation
Methodology Cost measurement unit Outcome unit
Cost minimization Dollars Various- but equivalent in comparative groups
Cost benefit Dollars Dollars
Cost effectiveness Dollars Natural units (life years, mg/dl blood sugar, LDL cholesterol)
Cost utility Dollars Quality adjusted life years
30th Nov. 2013
37Common Misconceptions When Applying
Pharmacoeconomic Principles
- Cost-effective care is initially the cheapest
alternative in a manner similar to other
investments, least cost option may lead to
greater costs downstream - Cost-effective care is outcome that generates
biggest effect in a manner to similar
investments, smaller increments of outcome may be
achieved at a lower overall cost
30th Nov. 2013
38Perspective
- The point of view considered in economic
analyses influences the outcomes and costs
considered to be most relevant - Provider
- Patient
- Payer
- Society
30th Nov. 2013
39Treatment of Pain Resulting from Osteoarthritis
- Pain results in significant disability and
resource utilization - affects 15 of US population
- results in gt 100,000 hospitalizations annually
- G NSAIDs
- effective pain relief
- 24 30 the cost of Cox-II inhibitors
- associated with a significant risk of adverse
effects - Dyspeptic symptoms
- More serious non-dyspeptic effects- symptomatic
ulcers, ulcer hemorrhage, ulcer perforation - Cox- II inhibitors
- effective pain relief
- substantially more expensive than NSAIDs
- associated with lower risk of GI side effects
Spiegel MR et al. Annals Internal Medicine 2003
13810(795-806)
40How should I treat my patient?
- NSAIDs are inexpensive compared to Cox-II
inhibitor - But wont the more expensive agent pay for itself
many times over by preventing an expensive GI
bleed in my patient? - Dyspeptic symptoms are decreased by 15
- Clinically significant ulcer complications are
reduced by 50
Spiegel MR et al. Annals Internal Medicine 2003
13810(795-806)
30th Nov. 2013
41Risk of GI bleed How Much Can It Be Altered?
- Not all osteoarthritis patients have an equal
risk of developing a GI bleed - Is paying extra for GI protection justified in
all patients? - How much can the risk of GI bleed be altered by
using a Cox-II inhibitor instead of an NSAID? - What value is really purchased for the extra
cost? - The relative risk reduction of GI complications
with Cox-II inhibitor catches our eye- but actual
risk reduction is small - 1-2 for overall ulcer complications
- 1 for serious hemorrhage and perforation
Spiegel MR et al. Annals Internal Medicine 2003
13810(795-806)
30th Nov. 2013
42Cost-effectiveness analysis
Population Drug Total Annual Cost Qualys Gained Incremental cost per Qualy gained
No Hx of GI ulcer Naproxen 4,859 15.2613 -
No Hx of GI ulcer Cox-II inhibitor 16,443 15.3033 275,809
Hx of GI ulcer Naproxen 14,294 14.7235 -
Hx of GI ulcer Cox-II inhibitor 19,015 14.8081 55,803
Spiegel MR et al. Annals Internal Medicine 2003
13810(795-806)
30th Nov. 2013
43Cardiovascular Effect of Cox-II Inhibitors
Population Drug Annual Cost Qualys Gained Incremental cost per Qualy gained
All patients Naproxen 5,037 15.2539 -
All patients Cox-II 16,620 15.2832 395,324
Spiegel MR et al. Annals Internal Medicine 2003
13810(795-806)
30th Nov. 2013
44Clinical Decision Making
- Risk reduction for GI complications seen with
Cox-II inhibitors is unlikely to offset their
increased cost in the management of average risk
patients with osteoarthritis pain - With no history of GI bleed, choose naproxen
- With history of GI bleed, choose Cox-II inhibitor
Spiegel MR et al. Annals Internal Medicine 2003
13810(795-806)
30th Nov. 2013
45Clinical Decision Making
- In all patients with osteoarthritis, the decision
to use Cox-II inhibitor should be made with
awareness of the effect of the added risk for
cardiovascular events on cost-effectiveness - Currently, there is not enough information
available, but it may be prudent to avoid these
drugs in patients with cardiovascular history,
even in patients with history of GI bleed
Spiegel MR et al. Annals Internal Medicine 2003
13810(795-806)
30th Nov. 2013
46Cost-effective Outcomes
- Decrease drugdrug and druglab interactions
- Increase the percentage of patients in
therapeutic control. - Reduce the overall costs of the treatment by
utilizing more efficient modes of therapy - Reduce the unnecessary use of emergency rooms and
medical facilities - Contribute to better use of health manpower by
utilizing automation, telemedicine, - and technicians
- Decrease the incidence and intensity of
iatrogenic disease, such as adverse - drug reactions
J Clin Oncol 23(10)21239
47Primary reason for pharmacist intervention
- Decrease potential adverse event
- Increase efficacy
- Reduced morbidity or mortality
- Symptom control
- Cost savings
- Decrease actual adverse drug effects
- Assist compliance
- Formulary reasons
30th Nov. 2013
48Change in drug therapy or management
- Change in dosage of drug
- Drug treatment initiated
- Drug treatment discontinued
- Alteration to patient monitoring
- Change from one drug to another
30th Nov. 2013
49Impact of pharmacist-initiated change in drug
therapy or management quantified
British Journal of Clinical Pharmacology 57(4),
513-521
50Benefit of pharmaceutical care
- The potential savings quantified arose from
pharmacist-initiated interventions that resulted
from only 3.8 of pharmacists clinical practice
time. - Benefits of other activities performed were not
quantify drug information, patient medication
counselling, staff education, drug use
evaluation, research, student education and
training, dispensing and administrative. - On the five areas quantified in this study
every dollar spent on a pharmacist, approximately
23 save.
British Journal of Clinical Pharmacology 57(4),
513-521
30th Nov. 2013
512nd ATS Workshop PCEHM guidelinesits
application to critically ill patients should
caution the following
- evidence for the effectiveness of interventions
in the ICU is often lacking - care in the ICU often does not provide for a cure
but stabilizes patients - ICU patients vary substantially, and the costs
and outcomes associated with therapy vary
depending on the type of ICU - ICU outcome measures are not suited for economic
analyses and are often difficult to measure - assigning a value to the quality of end-of-life
care and its impact on family members of ICU
patients is difficult - costs are not define and measured in consistent
ways
ATS American Thoracic Society PEGM Panel on
Cost-effectiveness in Health and Medicine
30th Nov. 2013
52For ICU pharmaceuticals v.s. economic
- This tactic for cost minimization runs the risk
of determining drug therapy based only on
acquisition costs. - When competing drugs are considered
therapeutically equivalent, may dilute the
benefits of newer drugs - We need to evaluate the impact of cost-reduction
efforts on the quality of care
30th Nov. 2013
53Provide optimal pharmacotherapy at an
appropriate cost in critically ill patients
- Anti-microbial
- Sedatives and neuromuscular blockers
- The Drug-Use and Disease-State Management (DUDSM)
Program
CritCare Med 2003 Vol. 31, No. 1 (Suppl.)
30th Nov. 2013
54Anti-microbial
- The percentage of the drug budget spent on
antibiotics ranges from 10-60 or gt60 - Even with a selective list of available drugs,
there needs to be guidance on drug selection,
dosing, and monitoring in the form of protocols
or algorithms to enhance the chance of success. - The patient is evaluated for conversion of
parenteral to oral antibiotics after 4872 hrs of
intravenous antibiotic therapy.
30th Nov. 2013
55Sedatives
- A large percentage of ICU patients receive
sedatives to treat agitation, and the costs of
managing these patients are predicted to be high. - The clinical and economic impact of sedatives in
ICU patients, drug costs were significantly
reduced in the protocol-driven group. - Ventilator times and lengths of stay were shorter
in the follow-up group, without a compromise in
the quality of care.
30th Nov. 2013
56Neuromuscular blockers
- Minimizing the usage of neuromuscular blocker
exposure is important because prolonged paralysis
has been reported with these agents and the
additional costs associated with this problem is
in excess of 66,000 per patient.
30th Nov. 2013
57DUDSM Program
- The DUDSM program identifies therapeutic
opportunities for optimizing drug use from
analysis of high-volume drug use, cost, disease
state, and resource utilization. - The DUDSM ICU guidelines focus on agent
selection, indication for use, mode of
administration, and monitoring process. - Guidelines for new therapeutic entities are
created to set practice patterns as agents are
approved for general marketing vs. after practice
patterns are established.
30th Nov. 2013
58The benefits of pharmacist in ICU
- SCCM best practice model document
the presence of a critical care pharmacist can
decrease adverse drug events and reduce cost of
care
SCCM Society of Critical Care Medicine
30th Nov. 2013
59Flowchart of the formulary decision-making
process
30th Nov. 2013
60Application in the formulary process with CEA
- The CEA is constructed to identify the most
cost-effective therapy when the goal is provide
the highest-quality pharmaceutical care within a
fixed budget. - To be informative, the drug alternatives in the
analysis should include all reasonable options
and baseline comparator. - It can be used to evaluate the economic impact of
a formulary decision if head-to-head data are
available.
30th Nov. 2013
61Cost and Effect measured
- Cost measure in dollars and compared with the
effects or improvements of treatments. - Effect final outcome and intermediate outcome.
- - final outcome lives saved, life-years
saved, - cases prevented, rates of specific side
effect - - intermediate outcome the relationship
- between the intermediate and final outcome
- measure can be estimated.
30th Nov. 2013
62AMCP guide of formulary submission checklist
- Product information
- Supporting clinical information
- Supporting economic information
- Cost impact assessment
- Outcomes impact assessment
AMCPAcademy of Managed Care Pharmacy
30th Nov. 2013
63Medication formulary system management
- Should be based on clinical, ethical, legal,
social, philosophical, quality-of-life, safety,
and pharmacoeconomic factors that result in
optimal patient care. - Must include the active and direct involvement of
physicians, pharmacists, and other appropriate
health care professionals. - To declare that decisions on the management of
medication formulary system should not be based
solely on economic factors.
ASHP policy 9830
30th Nov. 2013
64Evidence of the economic benefit of clinical
pharmacy services
- Drug therapy evaluation (benefitcost
ratio31.921) - Drug information
- Adverse drug reaction monitoring(benefitcost
ratio2988.571) - Drug protocol management
- Medical rounds participation
- Admission drug histories
Pharmacotherapy 200323(1)113-132
30th Nov. 2013
65Evidence of the value of the pharmacist
- In a study evaluating the effect of pharmacists
providing pharmaceutical care services on the
economic outcomes of patient care, an average
benefit of 16.70 of value to the health care
system was realized for each 1 invested in
clinical pharmacy services.
Pharmacotherapy 1996 16(6)1188-208
30th Nov. 2013
66Evidence of the value of the pharmacist-for
cost saved
- Pharmacists collaborating with physicians to care
for high-risk patients reduced the number of
prescriptions per patient and saved nearly 600
per year per patient in drug costs. - Pharmacists providing disease management services
in their community saved an average of 2700 per
year per patient in total medical costs.
Journal of Family Practice. 1995 Nov.
41(5)469-78
Clinical Therapeutics 1997 19(1) 113-23
30th Nov. 2013
67Evidence of the value of the pharmacist - for
adverse events avoided
- As hospitals increased the number of pharmacists
providing pharmaceutical care, medication errors
have decreased by over 65. - Pharmacists providing pharmaceutical care
services in an intensive care unit decreased
adverse events by 66 and saved 270,000 by
avoiding adverse events.
Pharmacotherapy. 200222(2)134-47
JAMA 1999 Jul 21 282(3)267-70
30th Nov. 2013
68Applications in Practice Roles of the Pharmacist
- Assist in the design and implementation of
research studies - Evaluate pharmacoeconomic literature
- Apply results to clinical decision making
- Individual patient care
- Formulary/utilization management
- Disease management
- Resource allocation
30th Nov. 2013
69???????? ???????
8?25?,???????????(Amgen)??,??104????????????(Onyx)
,??????????????????Kyprolis???,??????????(AstraZen
eca)????AmplimmuneAmplimmune??????????????????? ?
????????????????,?????????????????????????,??????
?????????????,?????????????????????????????,??????
??????????????????,??????????????????
??,??????????????????????????2012????39?????,?11??
?????Kyprolis??????,Kyprolis???????????,??????????
?????????????,??????????,??????????,??????Kyproli
s???????5??,????5???? ??,??????????????,?????????,
?????????Kyprolis????????Proteolix???????,????????
?????,?????????????2009?,??????(Bristol-Myers
Squibb)?24?????Medarex,??Medarex??????????????,???
?????????12???? ??,??????,???????????????????,????
????????????????????Kyprolis,????????????????????
????Kyprolis?????30???,???????????????????????Ampl
immune,???????????????????????????????(Bahija
Jallal)??,?????????,?????????? ?????,???????,?????
????????????????????(Bayer)???????Nexavar???,?????
??????????????????,???????Nexavar????,????????????
??????????????,???????????????,???????4??,??100???
????????,??????????????,?????????????????Kyprolis
The Economist Newspaper Limited 2013
70GUIDELINES FOR PHARMACOECONOMICS EVALUATIONS
- The perspective of the study should ideally be
applicable to the society. - Demographic characteristics of the target
population should be identified. - Conceptual and practical reasons for choosing the
comparator should be set out and justified. - Treatment paths of the options being compared
should be identified and fully described. - The study should use recognized techniques of
analysis and should be justified. - Clinical outcome measures should be identified.
- All relevant costs should be identified,
collected and reported. - Discounting should be undertaken considering the
time lapse. - Sensitivity of analysis should be conducted and
reported. - Comparisons with results from other studies are
handled with care
30th Nov. 2013
71Conclusions
- Pharmacoeconomics can guide choices among
alternative medications, treatment regimens and
services based on a combination of costs and
outcomes. - Is a young science, which is still testing its
methodology. - The science will improve with application and
value of the analysis to clinicians. Principle
and methods balances the cost and outcomes and
provides the best possible health care to the
with available resources. - Time and money can only be spent once- choice is
inevitable. Whether done unconsciously or with a
consistent process, healthcare professionals are
constantly evaluating patients care choices
acting on them. - Results and interpretation of pharmacoeconomic
studies are influenced by the perspective of the
studythere is no one right answer.
30th Nov. 2013
72Thanks for Your Attention
!!