Storage Networking: Fibre, iSCSI, NAS

1
Storage NetworkingFibre, iSCSI, NAS

• Graeme Holmes
• Cristie Data Products Ltd

2
Agenda

• The Need For SAN
• Storage Technologies
• Storage Management

3
The Need for SAN
4
The Need for SAN

• Server consolidation
• Non-disruptive capacity increase
• More efficient resource utilisation
• Reduction in hardware/licencing costs
• Reduced footprint

5
Current Situation

• Direct Attached Storage
• Locally attached disk
• SCSI protocol

• Islands of Storage
• Available storage on server B cannot be utilised
  by server A
• Limited, disruptive scalability
• High Management Costs
• Inflexible

6
DAS - Scalability

• Limited to the servers predetermined capacity
• External expansion with SCSI is limited to 15
  devices per channel
• 12M Distance limitation
• Expensive, disruptive to scale
• High management costs
• Still has over/under utilisation issues

7
Centralised storage - NAS

• Network Attached Storage
• Consolidate File Servers
• No need to buy servers to add capacity
• File level storage only
• Databases require block-level storage
• Storage traffic moves onto LAN
• Limited scalability
• Management

8
Centralised Storage - SAN

• Dedicated Storage Network optimised for I/O block
  transfers
• Centralised storage management
• Block level storage
• File applications
• Storage traffic off the LAN
• Flexible and scalable
• Any server can have access to any available
  storage
• Non-disruptive scalability

9
SAN Benefits

• Grows storage independently of servers
• Centralised high-availability storage reduces
  storage management overhead
• Scalable - Supports thousands of interconnected
  devices
• High aggregate bandwidth, multiple paths
• 2Gig, 4Gig fibre, Gigabit Ethernet
• Application clustering possible on wider scale
• Disaster Recovery

10
SAN - Disaster Recovery

• To assure continued operations, data can be
  mirrored within the
• same subsystem
• to adjacent subsystem
• to a subsystem in a remote location

• Storage mirrored or replicated
• Block level transfer

11
Fibre, iSCSI and NAS
12
Fibre Topologies

• Point-to-point
• Only two FC devices connected directly together
• No sharing of media - devices each benefit from
  total link bandwidth

13
Fibre Topologies

• Arbitrated Loop
• 127 addresses or 126 devices per loop
• Blocking, shared media
• 100MB/sec speed.
• Lowest cost Fibre protocol

14
Fibre Topologies

• Switched Fabric
• Connect millions of devices
• Non-shared media
• 200MB/sec between nodes

15
Other Protocols

• Methods of connecting FC islands
• FC-IP Fibre Channel over TCP/IP tunnelling
  protocol that encapsulates and transports FC
  frames over TCP/IP
• iFCP Internet Fibre Channel Protocol allows
  connection of FC devices over TCP/IP at any
  distance

16
Fibre SAN Management

• Heterogeneous Environments, Shared Storage
• Management Achieved by
• Port Zoning at the switch level
• LUN masking within the storage array.
• Zones prevent devices outside zone from
  communicating into zone.

17
Benefits of Fibre SAN

• Massively scaleable
• High Performance
• I/O intensive applications
• Backup
• Centralises management of storage

18
Considerations

• High hardware and software costs
• High implementation costs
• New skills required
• Distance limitation for Disaster Recovery

19
iSCSI

• A serious alternative?

20
iSCSI - What is it?

• Final specification approved early 2003
• Encapsulates block-level SCSI commands in a
  TCP/IP frame
• iSCSI storage NIC connects storage resources over
  Ethernet
• A method of creating Storage Networks over IP
• Two key components
• Initiator an iSCSI driver embedded in the server
  
• Target a gateway device that routes data between
  server storage

21
iSCSI
User
IP Network
IP packet
IP packet
iSCSI Initiator Adapter
iSCSI Target Adapter
Storage Device
Server
22
iSCSI Benefits

• Leverages existing investment in technology and
  skills
• Relatively low implementation costs
• Similar speeds to fibre channel
• 10 Gig Ethernet, 40 Gig announced
• No distance limitations

23
Considerations

• Relatively new standard
• Lower performance than FC
• Perceived as less secure than fibre channel
• OK for controlled environments
• IPSec required for large LAN deployments

24
TCP Off-load Engines

• iSCSI on standard NICs
• Uses CPU for TCP iSCSI processing
• Software iSCSI with TCP offload
• TCP processing by TOE card
• Hardware iSCSI
• TCP iSCSI processing by TOE card

25
Off-load Engines
26
NAS

• Where does it fit?

27
NAS

• File-based storage architecture
• Resources attach directly to LAN
• NAS Headers
• NAS device which uses portion of SAN storage
• File Server, Home Directories, image storage etc
• File level storage only
• Databases require block-level storage

28
NAS Advantage

• Familiar technology
• Minimal training
• Relatively low-cost way of adding disk space
• Provides some flexibility
• Additional units can be easily added

29
Fibre or iSCSI?

• Performance vs Cost

• High performance requirements for business
  applications
• Implement FC iSCSI
• Existing FC SAN costly to expand
• Use iSCSI storage to cater for non-intensive
  applications, migrate from FC to iSCSI
• Reduce Storage TCO
• Implement iSCSI SAN

30
Storage virtualisation

• Pooling of disparate systems into single
  consolidated view a storage pool
• Removes LUN limitation and resizing issues
• Also enables snapshotting, replication etc
• Re-deploy existing storage arrays
• In band Feature rich
• Out of band Out of data path

31
Storage Management

• Disparate systems, protocols, vendors leading to
• Increased management overhead
• SNIA developed SMI-S (Bluefin)

Storage Networking Industry Association Storage
Management Initiative Specification
32
SMI-S - what is it?

• Create common interface enabling software and
  hardware work together
• Common Information Mode (CMI) and Web Based
  Enterprise Management (WBEM) used to describe
  common storage models and functions
• Vendors write interfaces to allow their hw/sw to
  share data
• Reduction in number of storage management tools
  required
• EMC, HP, IBM, CA, HDS backed

33
Summary

• Fibre SAN
• Best performance
• High cost, new skills
• iSCSI SAN
• Simpler implementation
• Leverage existing investment in technology and
  skills
• Virtualisation
• Lower storage TCO
• Improve data availability
• NAS
• Mixed NAS/SAN environments
• Storage Management
• New standards being developed

34
Thank you