Core Values of Peer Review: Initial Implementation Steps

1
Core Values of Peer ReviewInitial
Implementation Steps

• Alan L. Willard, Ph.D.
• Chair, Review Policy Committee
• Chief, Scientific Review Branch
• NINDS
• National Institutes of Health

2
Core Values of NIH Peer Review

• Scientific and Technical Competence
• Fairness and Objectivity

3
Trans-NIH SRA Retreat Theme

• "Core Values of Peer Review in Changing Times"

4
Kick-off Addresses

• Dr. Norka Ruiz-Bravo, OER
• "The Mission of NIH and OER The Role of Peer
  Review"
• Dr. Toni Scarpa, CSR
• "Peer Review in a Rapidly Changing Biomedical
  Environment"

5
Small Group Discussion Topics

• Review of Multi-Institutional Applications
• Recruitment and Training of New Reviewers
• Shortening the Review Cycle
• Confidentiality and Conflict of Interest
• Writing the Resume of Discussion
• SRA Career Development and Progression

6
Large Group Discussion Topics

• Sure Fire Approaches to Recruiting Reviewers and
  Achieving Diversity in Review Panels
• Managing Complex Reviews

7
Plenary Talks

• Mr. Kevin Eikenberry
• "Leading to Achieve Core Values in Review"
• Dr. Lloyd Fricker
• "NIH Peer Review The Perspective from
  Academia"