Title: Are You Considering Selling Your Imaging Center or Practice? Or Merging With Your Healthcare System? Part 1 of 2
1Are You Considering Selling Your Imaging Center
or Practice? Or Merging With Your Healthcare
System? Part 1 of 2
- Richard S. Cooper, Esq.
- McDonald Hopkins LLC
- 600 Superior Avenue, E., Suite 2100
- Cleveland, OH 44114
- (216) 348-5438
- rcooper_at_mcdonaldhopkins.com
- mcdonaldhopkins.com
Kirk A. Rebane, ASA CFA Haverford Healthcare
Advisors 43 Leopard Road, Suite 102 Paoli, PA
19301 (601) 407-4024 krebane_at_haverfordcapital.com
haverfordhealthcare.com
2 3- Outline a plan to develop a strategic framework
to identify high potential arrangements, and use
set processes to execute the integration strategy - Explain the various impacts of health reform and
ACOs on radiology and imaging providers and their
catalyst for transactions - Articulate strategic advantages and opportunities
that can flow from the relationships forged
through such transactions - Develop a strategic framework to evaluate the
merits of alternative buyers/partners,
transactions and structures
4- General Business Issues that Drive a Radiology
Organization to Consider a Sale or Merger
5- Improving market share to better leverage payor
contracts - Benefitting from economies of scale
- Increasing access to capital and technology
- Expansion of service lines
- Improved recruiting
- Ability to sub-specialize
- Ability to afford sales and marketing
- Ability to cross-train personnel
- Access to new customers and business
6- Macro Industry Drivers of Transactional Trends
7- Factors contributing to the record levels of
healthcare industry MA activity and valuations - Aging of the population In 2009, there were 39.6
million people over age 65, representing 15 of
the U.S. population and 1/3rd of healthcare
consumption. By 2030, those over 65 years old
will increase to 72 million. - Diagnostic imaging remains an extremely valuable
service that represents a very small percentage
of healthcare expenditures, but influences a very
large percentage of physician decisions. - Despite years of consolidation, the diagnostic
imaging industry remains highly fragmented.
8- Economic recovery Transactions that had been
delayed by the recession have created a pent-up
demand for acquisitions by buyers and an
over-supply of willing sellers. The credit
markets are continuing to thaw. - Sellers will be motivated to sell prior to tax
rate increases capital gains tax rates revert
from 15 back to 20 on January 1, 2013. In
addition, the 2010 healthcare reform legislation
included an additional 3.8 Medicare Tax
surcharge on investment income, so the capital
gains rate will actually be 23.8. - Big pharma, other large healthcare companies and
foreign companies are entering/re-entering the
domestic healthcare industry by paying top dollar
for acquisitions.
9- New technologies are creating new markets.
- Private equity is attracted by the industrys
strong fundamentals and the non-cyclical nature
of the industry. 12 of private equity deals
completed in 2011 were investments in healthcare.
10- Healthcare reform has created the need whether
real or perceived for consolidation of
providers and service lines into healthcare
systems. - Radiologists who are increasingly challenged by
their private practices financial situation are
turning to their hospitals in search of clinical
integration, operational combinations and even
employment. - Not-for-profit hospitals have been experiencing
extreme pressure on operating and non-operating
cash flows, and have faced increasingly
restrictive and expensive tax-exempt debt. Many
hospitals continue to operate with negative
margins.
11- Proposed budget cuts total more than 125 billion
to 360 billion from Medicare, Medicaid and other
health programs over the next ten years, forcing
hospitals to continue to look for new sources of
revenue. - Traditional operational strategies to improve
liquidity and generate capital, including revenue
cycle improvements, expense reduction programs,
operational efficiency efforts, and deference of
capital expenditures, have been fully implemented
in many cases there is no more cash to squeeze
out for many hospitals. In addition, deferred
capital investment in plant and IT will need to
be satisfied at some point some cost cuts are
unsustainable.
12- Not-for-profit hospitals that are not looking at
expansion as the solution to healthcare reform
instead are increasingly looking to capitalize on
the hidden value in their non-core assets, such
as the imaging center operations, with an
objective of raising much-needed cash. - The allocation process for scarce capital
resources (including cash capital, management
resources capital and space capital) can result
in the classification of imaging operations as
non-core.
13- Hospitals are seeking to monetize non-core and/or
underperforming assets and service lines
throughout joint ventures or outright sales - Generates immediate and substantial cash proceeds
for a healthcare system - Can reduce a health systems ongoing cost for
ancillary services - Allows for the redeployment of capital both
financial and human capital into more optimal
strategic areas for the system - Ensures the ancillarys offerings will be at the
technological cutting edge - Enables the avoidance of capital investment in
the ancillary - Preserves employment in the community, often
critical to a mission statement - Maintains or improves current service levels
- Lets management focus on core assets/business of
the institution
14- From a buyers perspective, former hospital
assets or service lines can be attractive for
several reasons - Third party specialty operators can often operate
businesses more efficiently and profitably, with
no degradation in quality, than a hospital - Third party specialty operators often have lower
cost structures, primarily due to wages and
benefits - Third party specialty operators often have a
clinical expertise, and can demonstrate better
clinical outcomes at lower costs than hospitals - Hospital-oriented assets or service lines often
benefit from a continuing referral stream of
business - The third party acquirer can still benefit from
trading on the goodwill and name of the hospital,
proactively through co-marketing and co-branding - Therefore, we anticipate that healthcare industry
deal activity and valuations will remain at their
current high levels for the foreseeable future
15- The Impact of Healthcare Reform on Radiology and
Imaging Transactions and Joint Ventures
16- Regardless of the ultimate fate of the Affordable
Care Act, healthcare reform is becoming a
powerful catalyst for consolidation and
integration in the healthcare industry.
17- Healthcare reform will impact consolidation in
several key areas - Decreasing revenues Payment rates will decrease,
indirectly encouraging consolidation by forcing
healthcare participants to find new ways to
decrease costs and increase negotiating clout
with both suppliers and payors - Increasing costs The cost of doing business will
increase as healthcare entities spend more on
compliance, technology and physician employment - The ACO-type of model will encourage network
formation and greater clinical integration by
rewarding integrated healthcare systems that can
reduce costs and improve quality - Independent healthcare entities may have
restricted access to payor contracts and patient
populations
18- At least for now, the ranks of the insured are
expected to rise dramatically as the political
uncertainty over healthcare reform slowly
changes. Focus on population management will
drive providers to consolidate in order to
integrate services, generate economies of scale
and minimize leakage out of the system. - The rise of ACOs due to healthcare reform are
causing healthcare systems to acquire ancillaries
and physician practices in an attempt to broaden
and fill-out service line offerings and to
ultimately create one-stop-shopping providers.
19- Historical reimbursement cuts, expected lower
reimbursements in the future and tighter control
over utilization have weakened the financial
performance of many current industry providers.
Finding a partner or a suitor may be the only way
to salvage the business. - Early detection can reduce downstream healthcare
costs. Therefore, diagnostic companies such as
imaging centers are seen as valuable components
of an overall healthcare organizations strategic
plan.
20- Providers must demonstrate to both government
payors and commercial payors that they can
provide high-quality care at a lower cost. There
is a paradigm shift toward outcome measurement
and evidence-based medicine. Such efforts will
require not only a diverse array of service
offerings within an organization, but also the
financial strength and breadth of management to
analyze and demonstrate outcomes. - Larger organizations that have greater critical
mass will be able to compete more effectively in
this environment - Larger entities can spread fixed costs over a
broader revenue base - Larger entities will have better access to
affordable capital - Larger entities will be better able to develop
sophisticated systems that can measure quality
and allow for sharing of best practices
21- Successful Transaction Requirements
22- Successful organizations understand their
options, have developed a strategic framework to
identify high potential arrangements and use set
processes to execute the integration strategy - Take an inventory of non-core and/or
underperforming assets and service lines - Determine the strategic implications of disposing
of, or entering into a joint venture on, the
identified assets and/or service lines - For those assets and/or service lines that
survive the strategic test, conduct a preliminary
valuation in order to quantify the monetization
opportunity
23- From a sellers perspective, it is important to
- Find the partner or buyer which is best able to
meet your organizations strategic objectives - Maximize the value and purchase terms of a
transaction - Minimize organizational disruption during the
sale process - Structure a process that facilitates regulatory
approval - Consummate a transaction which leaves a service
line consistent with your mission statement
24- From a buyers perspective, it is important to
- Find the target best able to achieve your
organizations strategic objectives - Obtain the best possible price and deal terms
- Consummate a transaction which results in an
organization consistent with your mission
statement
25- The selling process should include
- An assessment of all strategic options
- Transaction planning and strategy development
- Development of acceptable confidentiality
agreement - Development of confidential information
memorandum - Development of acceptable buyer list
- Information exchange coordination and process
- Proposal evaluation and negotiation
- Due diligence coordination efforts
- Negotiation of definitive purchase agreements and
ancillary agreements
26- The buying process should include
- Development of acquisition target criteria
- Transaction planning and strategy development
- Development of acceptable confidentiality
agreement - Target identification
- Assessment of strategic and financial
implications to your organization with respect to
each identified target - Financing analysis
- Valuation and transaction structuring
- Development and negotiation of offer
- Due diligence coordination efforts
- Negotiation of definitive purchase agreements and
ancillary agreements
27 28Type of transaction
Options Description Full Liquidity Future Control
Capital raise Raise money to expand No Yes
Recapitalization Sale of partial percent Some Some
Sale with equity Sale to larger company and reinvest Significant Minimal
Sale of 100 percent Sale of company Yes No
Joint venture Strategic partnering usually no take-out event No Depends on ownership percentage and terms
29Type of buyer
Type of Buyer Future Involvement Deal Terms Confidentiality Financing Other
Financial Consulting or employment required Equity reinvestment typical Price may be limited by available funds Rigid structure Less of a concern unless similar portfolio companies Cash flow Focused More certain to close Increased capital can aid growth and competitiveness Preserve name and legacy
Strategic Employment not required or shorter period May value higher based on synergies Tougher terms Greater concern Revenue Focused Less certain to close Greater disruption to business via transition Greater economies of scale benefits
Management Employment not required Flexible on terms and structure Less of a concern Limited financing Less certain to close Least disruptive
30Asset vs. stock
Type of Deal Buyer Perspective Seller Perspective Other Considerations
Asset Purchase Only assume specific liabilities Write-up value of assets get tax deduction Requires wind-up of business Greater tax on proceeds Transfer of licenses may be prohibited Use of 338(h)(10) election
Stock Purchase Greater liability risks may lead to lower value Better tax treatment Better liability protection Easier to execute Requires greater buyer due diligence
31Auction vs. targeted sale
Process Pros Cons Other Considerations
Auction Better value Better terms Loss of confidentiality Disruption to business Use of advisors and their skills
Targeted Synergies Less leverage Financing
32- ASRT Code
- VAD0052056
- AAPC Code
- 26338HKFCB