Penulisan Jurnal Internasional Bereputasi - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

View by Category
About This Presentation
Title:

Penulisan Jurnal Internasional Bereputasi

Description:

Devanto S. Pratomo, Ph.D Fakultas Ekonomi dan Bisnis & Tim Peningkatan Publikasi International Karya Ilmiah Dosen (PPIKID) Universitas Brawijaya – PowerPoint PPT presentation

Number of Views:1872
Avg rating:3.0/5.0
Slides: 75
Provided by: Deva154
Learn more at: http://ppikid.ub.ac.id
Category:

less

Write a Comment
User Comments (0)
Transcript and Presenter's Notes

Title: Penulisan Jurnal Internasional Bereputasi


1
Penulisan Jurnal Internasional Bereputasi
  • Devanto S. Pratomo, Ph.D
  • Fakultas Ekonomi dan Bisnis
  • Tim Peningkatan Publikasi International
  • Karya Ilmiah Dosen (PPIKID)
  • Universitas Brawijaya

2
Biodata
  • Name Devanto S. Pratomo
  • nick name de-de atau Dev
  • Occupation Academic Staff FEB-UB
  • Date of Birth Malang, 3/10/1976
  • Specialization Labour Economics, Applied
    Econometrics
  • email devanto_at_ub.ac.id
  • Awards SEAMEO Jasper Research Award 2013
  • Dosen
    Berprestasi II UB 2010
  • Best Paper Award JIEB UGM 2010
  • Background Study S1 (SE) FEB UB Economics
    Development,1998
  • S2 (MSi) UGM, Yogyakarta, 2001
  • S2 (MA) Georgia State, US, 2003
  • S3 (Ph.D) Lancaster University, UK, 2009

3
Key Publications
  • 1 The Effects of Changes in Minimum Wage on
    Employment in Indonesia Regional Panel Data
    Analysis
  • International Research Journal of Finance and
    Economics (62 2011), SCOPUS
  • 2. Minimum Wage Effects throughout the Wage
    Distribution Evidence from Indonesia
  • European Journal of Economics, Finance
    Economics (44 2012), SCOPUS
  • 3. Do Migrants Get Stuck in the Informal Sector?
    Findings of a Household Survey in Four Indonesian
    Cities
  • Bulletin of Indonesian Economic Studies (with
    Chris Manning), Taylor Francis Publ, 49(2)
    2013, ISI/SCOPUS
  • 4. The Roles of Network of Migrants The Case of
    Returned Migrants in East Java
  • Journal of Interdiciplinary Economics,SAGE Publ,
    25(1/2) 2013, SCOPUS
  • 5. Does Minimum Wage Affect Hours Worked of Paid
    Employment in Indonesia?
  • International Journal of Social Economics,
    Emerald Publ, 41(5) 2014, SCOPUS

4
  • Pentingnya Publikasi
  • Karya Ilmiah
  • (Jurnal Ilmiah)

5
  • Jurnal Ilmiah
  • Dipublikasikan secara periodik
  • Menyebarluaskan penelitian baru, temuan baru,
    metode baru
  • Melalui peer review process
  • Sebuah platform untuk mendistribusikan
    pengetahuan (knowledge) (see Noble Prize Winner)

6
Jurnal International (Dikti, 2014)
  • Jurnal internasional adalah jurnal yang memenuhi
    kriteria sebagai berikut
  • a. Karya ilmiah yang diterbitkan ditulis dengan
    memenuhi kaidah ilmiah dan etika keilmuan
  • b. Memiliki ISSN
  • c. Ditulis dengan menggunakan bahasa resmi PBB
    (Arab, Inggris, Perancis, Rusia, Spanyol dan
    Tiongkok)
  • d. Memiliki terbitan versi online
  • e. Dewan Redaksi (Editorial Board) adalah pakar
    di bidangnya paling sedikit berasal dari 4
    (empat) negara.

7
Jurnal Internasional Bereputasi
  • Jurnal internasional bereputasi adalah jurnal
    yang memenuhi kriteria jurnal internasional
    dengan kriteria tambahan
  • (1) terindek pada Web of Science dan/atau Scopus
  • (2) mempunyai faktor dampak (impact factor)
    dari ISI Web of Science (Thomson Reuters) atau
    Scimago Journal Rank (SJR)
  • Tambahan Tidak tergolong jurnal predator

8
Scopus bibliographical database containing
abstracts and citations for scientific journals
maintained by Elsevier. 20,000 of 21,000 titles
are peer reviewed journals Scopus mengeluarkan
Scimago Journal Rank (SJR)
9
(No Transcript)
10
Impact Factor (by Thompson Reuter)
  • The impact factor is frequently used as
    a proxy for the relative importance of a journal
    within its field, with journals with higher
    impact factors deemed to be more important than
    those with lower ones.
  • The impact factor was devised by Eugene Garfield,
    the founder of the Institute for Scientific
    Information. Impact factors are calculated yearly
    starting from 1975 for those journals that are
    indexed in the  Journal Citation Reports.

11
  • The impact factor is calculated by dividing the
    number of current citations to articles published
    in the two previous years by the total number of
    articles published in the two previous years.
  • Semakin tinggi impact factornya, maka semakin
    penting jurnal tersebut bagi ilmu pengetahuan.

12
(No Transcript)
13
Setiap tahun dunia mempublikasikan lebih dari 2.5
juta artikel ilmiah (Scopus)
Sumber Scopus dalam Yusuf (2013)
14
Tahun 2014, Indonesia mempublikasikan 5,665
artikel, Malaysia 25,883 (400 lebih banyak)
15
(No Transcript)
16
Terindikasikan, publikasi Indonesia bukan murni
made-in-Indonesia
Sumber Scopus dalam Yusuf (2013)
17
Ada keterkaitan kuat antara produktivitas
publikasi dengan kondisi ekonomi suatu negara
. Publikasi pada Jurnal Internasional bereputasi
merupakan salah satu tolok ukur daya saing bangsa
.
18
Mengapa perlu publikasikan karya kita?
  • Academic/Researcher Career (Pangkat dan Jabatan)
  • Establish a name and Reputation (also good for
    University) Iklan Diri (dari topik penelitian
    dan sitasi)
  • Mengundang collaboration dengan peneliti lain
  • Semoga bukan hanya untuk syarat Wisuda/syarat
    lulus S3
  • Pertama dan Terakhir

19
(No Transcript)
20
  • Anatomi Jurnal Internasional

21
  • Filosofi dalam menulis Jurnal
  • tulisan harus ringkas, padat, tetapi tetap harus
    lengkap dan jelas.
  • Artinya (1) pembaca mengerti apa yang ditulis
    tanpa harus bertanya kepada penulisnya,
  • dan (2) jika pembaca ingin menguji/melakukan
    penelitian yang sama, dengan membaca artikel
    tersebut pembaca telah dapat melakukannya
    (sitasi).
  • Berbeda dengan menulis tesis/disertasi detail,
    panjang lebar dan selengkap-lengkapnya

22
Focusing on a Topic
  • Asking questions while planning the research
  • - Is the topic of enough interest?
  • - Will the results be of interest to others?
    Terkadang kita merasa topik tersebut menarik
    tetapi bagi orang lain belum tentu menarik
  • - Is the topic likely to be publishable?
  • Does the study (1) develop new ideas in the
    scholarly literature, (2) fill a gap, (3) extend,
    (4) replicate ?

23
  • Hampir semua jurnal memiliki struktur sama
  • Title (Cover Page)
  • Abstract (and Keywords)
  • Introduction/Background
  • Literature Review (tidak harus)
  • Data and Methodology
  • Results and Discussion
  • Conclusion
  • References

24
Title
  • Judul menarik, berbeda dengan judul yang
    sudah banyak kalau perlu agak bombastis/lebay.
  • Korenman, Sanders, and David Neumark. "Does
    marriage really make men more productive?."
    Journal of Human Resources (1991) 282-307.
  • Chen, Jonathan. "Indonesia's presidential
    dilemma can Jokowi avoid the accountability
    trap?." (2014).
  • Filmer, Deon, and David L. Lindauer. "Does
    Indonesia Have a'Low Pay'Civil Service?."
    Bulletin of Indonesian Economic Studies 37.2
    (2001) 189-205.

25
Abstract
  • versi pendek dari artikel hendaknya berisi
    semua informasi yang diperlukan pembaca untuk
    mengetahui
  • (1) Tujuan penelitian
  • (2) Cara melakukan penelitian (methodology)/data
  • (3) Hasil yang diperoleh
  • Hasil kuantitatif perlu disampaikan (kalau ada)
    tetapi hanya hasil kunci saja, tidak perlu detail
  • tanpa paragraf
  • tanpa referensi
  • Ditulis terakhir
  • Usually 150-400 words (according to journal)

26
Contoh
  • This paper examines the inequality in education
    in Indonesia measured by Gini coefficients across
    different urban-rural, provinces, districts and
    gender . The main data used in this study is the
    2010 Population Census, comparing with the two
    previous censuses in 1990 and 2000. Using 2SLS
    regression, this paper also checks whether
    inequality in education across 494 districts in
    Indonesia are related in any systematic ways to
    some indicator of economic development, such as
    per capita income and poverty level. The analysis
    finds that education inequality in Indonesia has
    been declining during three decades. The gender
    gaps on inequality have become diminished.
    Finally, the educational inequality is negatively
    related with per capita GDP and positively
    related with poverty at district levels.

27
  • This study examines the role of social networks
    in the overseas migration decisions of workers
    from East Java, Indonesia. The data for this
    study are obtained from a survey of 363
    respondents in Sumberejo village, located in
    Malang district in East Java. This district is
    well known as one of the main contributors of
    Indonesian labour migrants to overseas. Using a
    multinomial logit specification across different
    labour market outcomes, this study finds that
    labour recruiters or middlemen play the most
    important role in labour migrants decisions to
    work overseas, although middlemen are in fact are
    not allowed by regulation. The number of friends
    and relatives respondents feel close to is also a
    significant factor, but not as high as middlemen.
    Relatives have a positive and significant effect
    for the respondents who worked in the formal
    sector, while friends have a significantly
    positive effect for the respondents who worked in
    the informal sector.

28
  • EFFECT OF WATER MANAGEMENT ON YIELD OF TOMATO
    PLANT
  • ABSTRACT
  • A green house experiment was conducted to study
    the effect of water management on the growth and
    yield of tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill.)
    plant. The treatments included the amount of
    irrigated water and the growth phase at which the
    watering was done. The ammount water addition
    was calculated based on the percentage of crop
    factor (kc) to evapotranspiration, and the
    combination treatments were (1) the amount of
    water addition the same with the
    evapotranspiration throughout the growth of
    tomato crop, 100 kc (2) 100 kc at vegetative
    growth and 70 kc at generative growth (3) 70
    kc at vegetative and 100 kc at generative
    growth (4) 70 kc at vegetative and 70 kc at
    generative growth (5)) 100 kc at vegetative and
    40 kc at generative growth (6) 40 kc at
    vegetative growth and 100 kc at generative
    growth and (7) 40 kc at vegetative and 40 kc
    at generative growth. The experimental results
    showed that addition of water at the combination
    level of 70 kc at vegetative and 100 kc t
    generative growth reduced the number of fruit
    yield, the number of healthy fruits and the
    number of marketable fruits. The addition of
    water at a combination level of 40 kc at
    vegetative growth and 40 kc at generative
    growth decreased plant height, leaf number and
    total fruit yield. The addition of water at a
    combination level of eiither 100 kc at
    vegetative growth and 70 kc generative growth
    or 40 kc at vegetative growth and at 100 kc
    generative growth was enough to produce a high
    yield (1307 g/plant and 1320 g/plant) which were
    not significantly different with that of the
    plants had no suffer from water shortage (100
    kc)..
  • Key words Water stress, irrigation, crop factor,
    evapotranspiration

29
Introduction
  • create reader interest (background information)
    mengantarkan pembaca untuk masuk ke fokus
    penelitian kalau pembaca sudah tertarik pada
    bagian depan akan memutuskan untuk melanjutkan
    membaca bagian belakangnya (penulis pun demikian)
  • focus on an issue, a problem or a question
    relevant to the study (tidak lari kemana-mana)
    tips general to specific akhirnya mengarah ke
    objective of this study (Tujuan penelitian)

30
Yang ada di Introduction(1)
  • Selain latar belakang
  • review beberapa previous research (dan teori)
    penting (dari sini research GAP itu muncul)
  • discuss deficiencies in previous research on the
    topic Berani untuk menjelaskan kelemahan
    previous study
  • how it differ from previous study
  • propose a new/different way of investigating the
    same topic/aspect of the topic Its your
    contribution

31
  • Example This articles contribution is its
    examination of intergenerational socioeconomic
    mobility it compares the earnings of migrants
    with those of their parents, and the earnings and
    occupations of the children of migrants with
    those of their parents.

32
  • Example This study contributes to the literature
    by employing the sample selection corrections
    based on a multinomial logit for a potential
    selection bias from a non-random sample This
    study also extends the hours worked specification
    by analyzing the effects of minimum wage on hours
    worked separately across individuals in different
    groups of workers, in terms of gender
    (male-female workers) and their residences
    (urban-rural areas).

33
Yang ada di Introduction (2)
  • Sebutkan tujuan penelitian dengan jelas di bagian
    ini.
  • This study focuses on two main objectives. The
    first objective is to measure the educational
    inequality in Indonesia across educational levels
    in Indonesia based on 2010 Population Census. The
    second objective is to see the relationship
    between educational gini and labour market
    performance as measured by the unemployment rate
    and average wage across districts in Indonesia.

34
Yang ada di Introduction (3)
  • Explain flow of the rest/outline di bagian paling
    akhir
  • Example The rest of this paper is organized as
    follows. Section 2 reviews the previous minimum
    wage studies using panel data sets. Section 3
    discusses the methodology used in this study.
    Section 4 explains the main data sources for this
    research. Section 5 analyses the main findings.
    Finally, section 6 provides conclusions.

35
Kelemahan Penulis Introduction
  • Tidak secara eksplisit menjelaskan
    kontribusinya/research gap nya biasanya karena
    kurang membaca
  • Penulisan tidak general to specific, sehingga
    jadi lari kemana-mana

36
Research Method/Data Method
  • Esensi harus jelas sehingga jika orang lain
    akan melakukan penelitian serupa bisa
    melakukannya tanpa harus bertanya pd penulis
  • Biasanya disajikan secara naratif (running
    style, kurangi pointers)
  • Descriptive Statistics mutlak diperlukan (kalau
    pendekatannya kuantitatif)

37
(No Transcript)
38
(No Transcript)
39
  • Statistical analysis Clear what the analytical
    to be used
  • Kalau metode itu sudah seringkali dipakai, dan
    sangat-sangat umum maka seringkali cukup hanya
    memberikan reference. Namun apabila metode itu
    tidak terlalu umum harus dijelaskan
  • Semua simbol/notasi matematis harus dapat
    dipahami/dijelaskan

40
Results and Discussion/Findings
  • refer to previous work/comparison with other
    studies/theory
  • mengapa berbeda atau sama dengan peneliti
    sebelumnya 
  • This is consistent with Hill and Thee (2012)
    discussion that many migrants with senior
    secondary education continue their post-secondary
    education in the cities as the universities are
    concentrated in urban areas.
  • Unlike previous studies, the result shows that
    there is no significant impact of the minimum
    wage on total paid employment because of the
    non-compliance problem in Indonesia.

41
Kelemahan Penulis Findings
  • Asyik bercerita tentang hasil temuannya tapi lupa
    untuk mengkaitkan dengan penelitian
    sebelumnya/teori. Karena dari situ sekali lagi
    menjelaskan posisi penelitian kita. Sehingga
    tidak terlihat referensi sama sekali disitu.

42
Conclusions
  • Four basic steps to take in writing an ideal
    conclusion (the 4S model)- running style
  • 1 Summarise your research
  • 2 Spell out your contribution ( also
    implication)
  • 3 State the limitations of your study
  • 4 Suggest potential areas of further research

43
  • This article has focused on the determinants of
    occupational change and associated earnings among
    different cohorts of migrants moving from rural
    areas to cities in Indonesia.
  • Our findings for Indonesia confirm that
    ruralurban migration is an important source of
    occupational mobility. In answering the question
    posed in the title of this article, our analysis
    suggests that migrants do not get stuck in the
    informal sector.

44
  • Our limitation is there is a problem of selection
    bias as with most studies of migration since
    data were collected from only those migrants who
    remained in the city, and not from those who
    returned to their villages
  • This subject,too, should be the focus of further
    research.

45
Kelemahan Penulis Conclusions
  • Terlalu singkat atau terlalu rinci
  • Memasukkan saran/implikasi kebijakan tetapi tidak
    terkait dengan hasil/temuan
  • Terlalu banyak angka (kuantitatif)

46
  • References Gunakan prinsip relevansi,
    keterbaruan, artikel di Jurnal diutamakan, dapat
    dilacak secara online, ikuti pedoman jurnal ybs
    dan reference yg ada di teks harus sama dgn di
    daftar reference (Reference bukan Daftar Bacaan)
  • Tips Ada Kecenderungan Jurnal Bereputasi akan
    melihat apakah penulis memakai referensi dari
    publisher jurnal yang bersangkutan. (Memperbesar
    Kemungkinan Diterima)

47
  • Kelemahan Penulis Indonesia
  • References didalam teks tidak sama dengan di
    daftar references. References di Jurnal berbeda
    dengan Daftar Bacaan.
  • Kurang relevan/keterbaruan/tidak mengikuti
    perkembangan
  • Tidak dapat dilacak
  • Menggunakan references yang tidak seharusnya
    (diktat kuliah, pustaka dalam artikel penulis
    lain, wikipedia)

48
Penggunaan Bahasa Inggris
  • Menulis Jurnal/Publikasi Ilmiah dalam Bahasa
    Inggris adalah sebuah SKILL, yang harus/dapat
    dilatih
  • A good paper does not come out perfect first time
    for anyone, so do not feel bad, and do not skimp
    on revisions!
  • Syarat utama Sediakan waktu yang cukup
    (terkadang harus sediakan waktu ekstra) dan juga
    kemuan yang keras untuk berlatih
  • Ingat The quality of the writing reflects the
    quality of the research

49
  • Karena keterbatasan kemampuan bahasa/waktu,
    banyak yang menggunakan translator/mesin
  • Karena penulisan jurnal ilmiah international
    hanya sebagai tujuan jangka pendek kelulusan,
    insentif dsb.
  • Kelemahan Tidak semua translator adalah baik,
    Bahasa Indonesia tidak mudah untuk
    diterjemahkan. Need to check and recheck.
  • More important PROOFREADER!!!  check your paper
    to catch and correct these and other common
    errors

50
Kesalahan Umum
  • Penggunaan Google Translate
  • classification of the RPR (-) and RPs (),
    indicating pertumbuhhan buffalo are not prominent
    in the reference area (district) but the
    potential developed in the study area (district)
  • There is a decrease in buffalo population in the
    five years since the population dropped 1,297
    observations tail
  • The data is collected in unlucky regency

51
Kesalahan Umum
  (Table 2-5)
  • Text sudah diubah dalam bahasa inggris, tetapi
    tabel tidak dirubah
  • Koma dirubah menjadi titik, dan sebaliknya

Table 1.The Change of Domestic Output Volume
No Sectors Baseline (Trillion IDR) The change of domestic output volume () The change of domestic output volume () The change of domestic output volume () The change of domestic output volume ()
No Sectors Baseline (Trillion IDR) Sim 1 Sim 2 Sim 3 Sim 4 
1 Food Crops 446 -6,73 -5,83 1,57 -6,73
2 Sugarcane Plantation 26 0 11,54 7,69 0
3 Other Agricultural Crops 713 -4,42 -1,19 7,46 -4,42
4 Sugar Industry 53 0 3,77 1,89 0
5 Food and Beverage Industry 669 1,20 3,44 3,44 1,20
6 Fertilizer and Pesticide Industry 46 0 2,17 2,17 0
7 Other Industries 4.517 0,30 1,7 5,24 0,30
8 Services 16.771 -10,07 3,87 17,39 -10,12
52
Kesalahan Umum
  • Kata sambung tidak di awal kalimat. But, And
  • Hindari Penggunaan kata Author, Writer,
    Researcher, I, We

53
Plagiarisme
54
Definisi
  • Plagiat merupakan perbuatan secara sengaja atau
    tidak sengaja dalam memperoleh atau mencoba
    memperoleh kredit atau nilai untuk suatu karya
    ilmiah, dengan mengutip sebagian atau seluruh
    karya dan/atau karya ilmiah orang lain, tanpa
    menyatakan sumber secara tepat dan memadai
    (Permendiknas No 17 tahun 2010, Pasal 1 Ayat 1).

55
Plagiat terjadi apabila seseorang
  • (1) salah pengertian mengenai tatacara penulisan
    rujukan, misalnya yang penting sudah tertulis
    di daftar pustaka atau yang penting sudah
    diberi referensi. Itu tidak selalu cukup!
  • (2) Biasanya terlalu bergantung atas suatu sumber
    rujukan,
  • (3) kemampuan menggunakan bahasa yang lemah, dan
  • (4) kecerobohan dalam melakukan pencatatan.

56
Secara umum, seseorang melakukan plagiat karena
  • Tidak tahu bahwa plagiarisme adalah tindak
    kejahatan akademik (Dont know).
  • Tahu bahwa plagiarisme adalah tindak ilegal, tapi
    tidak tahu bagaimana cara menghindarinya (Dont
    know how).
  • Tahu bahwa plagiarisme adalah tindak ilegal, tapi
    tidak peduli (nikmat, cara gratis mendapat nilai
    dan menjadi sarjana) (Dont care)
  • Managemen waktu yang buruk.
  • Merasa yakin bahwa orang lain tak akan
    mendeteksi apa yang dilakukan.

57
  • Kita akan terhindar dari plagiarisme jika
    menyatakan secara jelas dan secara benar setiap
    saat kita menggunakan
  • Ide, pendapat dan teori orang lain.
  • Mengutip (memberi tanda ....) pada tulisan atau
    perkataan orang lain (kalimat langsung) dengan
    tetap menyebutkan sumber.
  • Melakukan paraphrase (menuliskan/mengucapkan ide
    orang lain dengan kalimat kita sendiri) dan tetap
    menyebutkan sumber.

58
  • Paraphrase menulis ulang intisari dari sumber
    lain. Tidak perlu diberi tanda kutip, tapi wajib
    dibutkan sumbernya
  • Teknik melakukan paraphrase menurut Knowles
    (2007)
  • Baca dan baca lagi bacaan asli hingga anda
    mengerti.
  • Ganti sebanyak mungkin kata dari bacaan asli
    dengan sinonim yang cocok.
  • Ganti bentuk tata bahasa (misal kalimat pasif
    menjadi kalimat aktif).
  • Hindari menggunakan kata-kata yang sama dengan
    kata-kata pada bacaan asli, kecuali kata-kata
    yang tidak ada sinonim-nya (misal unsur kimia,
    nama tempat, nama orang, penyakit, dll).

59
  • Self-Plagiarism (Autoplagiarism)
  • Plagiat yang dilakukan dari tulisan kita
    sendiri.
  • Kita seringkali tergoda untuk tidak menuliskan
    referensi karena berasal dari tulisan kita
    sendiri
  • Republishing the same paper published elsewhere
    without notifying the reader nor publisher
    (conference paper dengan ISSN dan Jurnal)

60
  • Potential S-P Publishing a significant study as
    smaller studies to increase the number of
    publications misalnya dari 1 disertasi dibagi
    menjadi 2 atau 3 tulisan.

61
  • Pilihan Publikasi Journal

62
Issue
  • Speed of publication (Kecepatan) vs Kualitas
  • Issue predator vs Scopus Indexed
  • quickly, some fees, not hard vs hard, more time
    but free of charge
  • Tantangan Balancing need to publish quickly
    vs. selecting a good journal to publish in

63
Predator Journal (Questionable Journal) scholarly
oa.com
64
  • International Journal by Inul Daratista Agnes
    Monica

65
(No Transcript)
66
Important on decide a journal
  • Top-tier journals usually reject more than 50
    percent of the papers submitted to them some have
    rejection rates as high as 70
  • Third (low) tier journal rarely reject a paper
    unless the entire study is flawed or the data are
    improperly interpreted
  • Experience gained from previous publishing helps
    very well

67
Some Tips (1)
  • Syarat utama Sediakan waktu yang cukup
    (terkadang harus sediakan waktu ekstra) dan juga
    kemuan yang keras untuk berlatih
  • Writing is Skill

68
Some Tips (2)
  • Start with a conference paper
  • Examine and study carefully a sample of journal
    papers, this will give you some insights into the
    expectations and standards for a refereed journal
    paper
  • Decide on a journal paper which is relevant to
    your area of research
  • Draft an outline of your paper and discuss with
    co-author/colleague
  • Produce the first draft
  • Pass paper to your colleagues for comments
  • Submit paper Remember Editor is the King
  • Etika Penulisan Tidak mengirimkan manuscript ke
    lebih dari satu jurnal

69
Review Results
  • Accept "Which almost nobody gets, -)
  • Accept with revision "Just make some minor
    changes."
  • Revise and resubmit (major revision) "They're
    still interested in you!"
  • Reject and resubmit Though not as good as revise
    and resubmit, "they still want the paper!"
  • Reject
  • Don't put off the revisions
  • If you are invited to revise, "Do it, do it fast
    and don't delay".

70
Example JDS
  • 19-Mar-2010 Dear Dr. Pratomo, I refer to your
    paper entitled  "The Effects of Changes in
    Minimum Wage on Employment in Indonesia Regional
    Panel Data Analysis" which you submitted to the
    Journal of Development Studies, and regret to
    inform you that we are unable to publish the
    paper in its present form. The reports of three
    referees are provided below although they see
    merit in what you are doing all recommend major
    revisions. The reports are quite detailed but a
    number of specific concerns arise more than once.
    Some of the concerns are sufficiently serious to
    merit rejection.  However, as the issue is of
    interest and the literature (in general journals)
    is limited, we will give you an opportunity to
    resubmit if you can substantially revise the
    paper to address the concerns. The revisions
    required are substantial and involve a complete
    rewrite (you should get it proofed by an
    English-language reader before resubmitting),
    whilst addressing the data and econometric
    concerns may result in a substantially different
    paper

71
Where to Publish
  • Good to seek advice from authors who have
    published previously
  • Know the prestige and policy of the journal
  • Ensure manuscript to match with journal
    requirements
  • As a strategy try avoid journals that have a very
    high rejection rate
  • Tips Bahasa Adakah penulis dari negara yang
    Englishsecond language

72
Example of Good Journals
  • Elsevier http//www.elsevierdirect.com/index.jsp
  • Springer http//link.springer.com/
  • Wiley http//onlinelibrary.wiley.com/
  • Taylor and Francis http//www.tandfonline.com/
    ()
  • Sage http//online.sagepub.com/ ()
  • Emerald http//www.emeralddinsight.com/ ()
  • Inderscience http//www.inderscience.com/index.php
    ()
  • World Scientific http//www.worldscientific.com/

73
IJSEC 41(5) 2014
  • The research paper on Does Minimum Wage Affect
    Hours Worked of Paid Employment in Indonesia is
    well written by the author(s). Notwithstanding
    the merit of the paper, the scope and relevance
    of the paper can be further enriched, if the
    following aspects are considered. 1. The
    economic literature on minimum wages is
    longstanding and vast. The paper should elaborate
    more rigorously an in-depth review of the field,
    which continues to be characterized by
    (dis)agreement on how a minimum wage affects
    employment. There is no clear and no
    quantitatively relevant relationship between
    minimum wage development and employment. As
    always in a debate between different theoretical
    approaches, the empirical results are mixed
    depending on the theory used as a basis for the
    research. The author is advised to provide a
    section on review of exiting studies in tabular
    form for the comparison and develop a conceptual
    framework.The paper should provide a section on
    review of exiting studies in tabular form for the
    comparison and develop a conceptual framework.
    2. The paper is well written. However, it
    requires more elaboration of findings and
    conclusions. 3. The paper should include a
    section of policy implications for the research.

74
  • Terima Kasih
About PowerShow.com