Writing portfolio and the teaching and learning of writing as a process: Opportunities and challenges - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

1 / 17
About This Presentation

Writing portfolio and the teaching and learning of writing as a process: Opportunities and challenges


Writing portfolio and the teaching and learning of writing as a process: Opportunities and challenges Albert Wong An examination-oriented mentality An examination ... – PowerPoint PPT presentation

Number of Views:1503
Avg rating:3.0/5.0
Slides: 18
Provided by: Alber54


Transcript and Presenter's Notes

Title: Writing portfolio and the teaching and learning of writing as a process: Opportunities and challenges

Writing portfolio and the teaching and learning
of writing as a process Opportunities and
  • Albert Wong

An examination-oriented mentality
  • An examination-oriented mentality prevailed in
    local schools and it shaped and determined
    teaching practices across the curriculum (Morris,
  • How far is this true with the teaching of
    language in general and the teaching of writing
    in particular?

The teaching of writing in primary schools
  • One-shot writing
  • Ss were allowed time to write one draft only
  • Little or no time was provided for the students
    to revise their texts
  • Writing was treated as a form of testing as
    opposed to a way of learning
  • The whole purpose of writing was entirely

  • (Tse, 1993)

The teaching of writing in secondary schools
  • One-shot writing
  • Most teachers did not allow extra time for
    students to revise their texts
  • Teachers generally believed that errors determine
    the quality of writing
  • The purpose was to teach students to produce
    error free sentences

  • Sengupta (1996)

The current traditional approach to teaching
  • Silvas observation that the formalist
    oriented current traditional approach is still
    dominant in ESL / L2 writing material and
    classroom practices today appears to be
    applicable to the situation in Hong Kong in the

  • Silva (1990)

  • A portfolio is a purposeful collection of
    student work that exhibits the students efforts,
    progress and achievements in one or more areas.
    The collection must include student participation
    in selecting contents, the criteria for judging
    merit and evidence of student self-reflection.
  • Paulson,
    Paulson and

  • Meyer (1991 60)

Key features of a portfolio approach to teaching
/ learning and assessing writing
  • Continuous and cumulative as opposed to one-shot
  • Emphasis on the learning enhancement purpose of
  • Increased attention to formative rather than
    summative aspects
  • More frequent provision of descriptive comment
    and constructive feedback
  • Less reliance on assessment by teachers alone and
    more involvement of self and peers
  • Increased focus on teaching writing as a process

  • Holroyd (2000)

Key features of a process approach to teaching /
learning writing
  • Multiple draft
  • Provision of formative feedback (written or
    verbal or both)
  • Provision of opportunities for alternative
  • Focus on revision as opposed to editing
  • Increased attention given to idea generation and

A Case Study

The context of research
  • A secondary school in a suburban district
  • A relatively young school with Band 3 intake
  • Four English teachers teaching Form 4
    participated in the study
  • Graduate teachers trained to teach English as a
    major subject
  • Teaching experience ranges from 1 to 4 years
  • Mixed language ability classes
  • Naturalistic research setting

The portfolio
  • All Form 4 classes participated
  • A trial run taking 3 teaching cycles
  • The theme was on travelling
  • 3 short writing tasks leading to a longer writing
  • Ample scaffolding provided by way of pre-tasks
    with a specific focus on learning vocabulary and
    idea generation
  • Students wrote 3 drafts for each of the writing
  • Teachers provided both written and verbal
    comments for each writing task

Key features of implementation
  • A co-meeting every cycle
  • Teachers worked in close collaboration in line
    with the lesson study approach (Hiebert
    Stigler, 1999)
  • Teachers made use of quizzes as check points
  • Students kept process logs
  • Students were taught to make use of mind maps to
    plan their writing

  • Students became more confident writers
  • They were able to write longer texts with richer
  • A number of students were able to overcome their
    writers block (Rose, 1984)
  • Students were more prone to responding to the
    formative feedback provided by the teachers and
    making revisions to their texts

  • Teachers were provided with useful and timely
    feedback on the effectiveness of their teaching
    and were able to adjust their teaching to cater
    for individual learner differences
  • Teachers were able to understand their students
    much better
  • Teachers were able to work collaboratively with
    and learn from their peers

Constraints and opportunities
  • Time and effort
  • Provision of further scaffolding to support
    writing / learning
  • Focus more on reading to write
  • Greater learner autonomy
  • A greater focus upon alternative assessment

  • Writing as a means of learning as opposed to
    writing for display
  • What time can buy
  • Teacher collaboration
  • Building on existing strengths
  • Teacher autonomy
  • Catering for individual learner differences
  • Benefits in the affective domain of learning
  • A balanced focus on the process and product of

  • Thank you
Write a Comment
User Comments (0)
About PowerShow.com