Con EdisonNYSERDA Demand Management Workshop

1
Con Edison/NYSERDA Demand Management Workshop
Con Edison Headquarters 4 Irving Place March 29,
2007
2
NYSERDA ADMINISTERED CON EDISON INCENTIVE
OPPORTUNITIES

• Con Edison Commercial Industrial Gas Efficiency
  Program
• Con Edison System-Wide Program (SWP)
• System Benefits Charge Program (SBC)

3
COMMERCIAL INDUSTRIAL (CI) GAS PROGRAM

• Pilot Program for Firm Gas Customers
• 1st Come -1st Serve until
• September 27, 2007, or
• Funds All Committed

4
CON EDISON SYSTEM WIDE PROGRAM (SWP)

• Customers who pay the MAC
• SWP demand management program from March 16,
  2006
• Incentives expire March 31, 2008

5
SYSTEMS BENEFIT CHARGE ELECTRIC PROGRAM

• NYSERDA - non-utility administrator state-wide
• Energy, Environment and Economy
• Electricity focused
• SBC III 6/06-6/11

6

• CI Gas Efficiency Program

7
CI GAS EFFICIENCY

• 1,000,000 for Installations Studies
• Boilers Water Heaters
• Space Heating
• Cooking
• Chiller Replacements
• CHP Upgrades
• Pipe Tank Insulation
• Industrial Custom Gas Improvements

8
CI GAS EFFICIENCY

• Targets
• Buildings
• Food
• Restaurant
• Institutional Kitchens
• Processing
• Laundries
• Industry

9
CI GAS EFFICIENCY

• Operations and Maintenance
• Boiler and Furnace Tune Ups
• Steam Trap Replacement

10
CARNEGIE LINEN - Bronx

• NYSERDA program participation
• FlexTech, ECIPP
• Efficiency Improvements
• New boilers, heat recovery, tunnel washer
• Incentives
• 109,000
• Annual Savings
• 150,000 therms, 200,000

11

• NYSERDA System-Wide Programs/Enhancements Since
  April 2006

12
PEAK LOAD REDUCTION PROGRAM

• Reduces load by funding energy efficiency and
  demand response projects
• Demand response funding is for technologies that
  enable customers to participate in ICAP/SCR
• Incentives available for controllable appliances
• Service Providers or end users may apply

13
PEAK LOAD REDUCTION PROGRAM PROGRAM TIMEFRAME

• Currently Active (PON 1097)
• Program open through March 31, 2008, or until
  funds exhausted (37M)
• Projects have two years from PO date to be
  completed

14
PEAK LOAD REDUCTION PROGRAM ENERGY EFFICIENCY
INITIATIVES

• 600/kW reduced in Con Edison
• Typical Measures Lighting, Chillers, etc.
• Energy storage eligible (ice storage, battery,
  etc.)
• Fuel switching eligible (gas driven compressors,
  gas or steam cooling, etc.)
• Measures must have peak savings (no nighttime
  setbacks, VFDs, etc.)

15
PEAK LOAD REDUCTION PROGRAM ENERGY EFFICIENCY
COOLING INCENTIVES

• Steam or Gas Retention
• 600/kW up to incremental cost compared to
  electric
• 0.55 kW/ton used for baseline calculation
• Electric to Steam or Gas Conversion
• 1,000/kW up to incremental cost if COP gt1.02
• Super Efficient Electric Chillers
• Bonus of 1,500/kW for savings efficiency of 2
  better than code

16
PEAK LOAD REDUCTION PROGRAM DR INCENTIVES NON
GENERATION

• Interval Meters - 1,500/meter statewide
• Load Control Technologies - 200/kW
• Common Measures EMS hardware upgrades
  programming, communication infrastructure, etc.
• ICAP/SCR participation required

17
PEAK LOAD REDUCTION PROGRAM DR INCENTIVES
GENERATORS

• 150/kW reduced in ConEd only
• Incentives available for installation of new
  generators or upgrades to existing generators
• No base loaded generators
• Common Measures New generator install,
  switchgear to connect additional loads, emissions
  reduction, etc.
• Must work within proposed DEC DG rule

18
PEAK LOAD REDUCTION PROGRAM DR GENERATION
EMISSIONS LIMITS

• All new generators must meet Federal New Source
  Performance Standards (Currently Tier 3 for
  diesel units lt560 kW)
• Generators clean enough to qualify count towards
  the DECs MW cap for DR generators

Existing Generator Emissions Limits
19
TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE PEAK-LOAD CURTAILMENT
PLANS

• Currently Limited to
• Con Edison Service Territory
• Buildings gt1MW or 1M electric bills
• Manufacturing gt500kW or 500k electric bills

• Incentives
• 2/kW of the facilitys peak summer demand
• Paid to Service Provider

20
TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE PEAK-LOAD CURTAILMENT PLANS
Curtailment Plans and all associated deliverables
must be provided at the time of application. The
package consists of

• Three-page Application
• Peak Load Curtailment Plan
• Proof of registration of the load with the NYISO
  after December 1, 2006 (opening of solicitation)
• Copies of one year of electric bills

21
TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE PEAK-LOAD CURTAILMENT PLANS
The Peak Load Curtailment Plan consists of

• Executive Summary
• One section for each measure to include
• Action to be taken
• Curtailable load from action
• Expected impact on comfort and/or operations
• Estimated dollars from the NYISO if load is
  curtailed
• Supporting engineering calculations demonstrating
  kW curtailed for each measure

22
AGGREGATED DEMAND REDUCTION PROGRAM

• Selected 4 contractors to market, develop
  implement projects
• DR, Permanent and DG projects
• Payments in two phases
• Similar incentive structure as PLRP w/additional
  performance payments
• Approx 80-85 at project completion/field
  verification -remainder over the monitoring
  period

23
AGGREGRATED LOAN REDUCTION PROGRAM

• DEMAND MANAGEMENT STRATEGIES
• Similar to PLRP
• Permanent Efficiency
• Curtailment/Shifting for Demand Response (DR)
• DG for DR
• Interval Meters for DR
• Additional to PLRP
• Peak Coincident DG
• Peak Coincident DG with Heat Recovery

24
AGGREGATED LOAD REDUCTION PROGRAM
Peak Coincident DG

• Distributed Generation operating to displace grid
  electric on non-holiday weekdays May 1 October
  31 from Noon thru 6PM
• All generators subject to SEQRA Review and must
  meet RFP specified (NTE 1.5 lbs/MWh NOx)
  emissions limits
• DEC DG rulemaking in progress MV to include
  NYSERDA CHP Integrated Data System

25
AGGREGRATED LOAD REDUCTION PROGRAM

• Process Issues
• Projects in Customer Facilities that pay MAC (or
  pay SBC for DG for DR projects)
• Contractor submits Customer kW Reduction
  Commitment Letters and Facility Data Sheets
• Contractor submits Technical Assessment (TA) to
  NYSERDA for each customer facility within 90 days
  of Customer kW Reduction Commitment Letter
• Projects must be completed, fully
  operational/field verified within 24 months of
  the later of the submittal of Customer kW
  Reduction Commitment or the TA

26
Aggregated Load Reduction Program

• Qualified Contractors
• Consumer Powerline
• Murtaza Kapadia 212-796-7109 or
  mkapadia_at_consumerpowerline.com http//www.consumer
  powerline.com
• Endurant Energy
• Clint Plummer, 201-683-6038 or clint.plummer_at_endur
  antenergy.com
• EnerNOC
• Douglas Nordham, 212-523-0519 or
  dnordham_at_enernoc.com
• http//www.enernoc.com/
• Innoventive Power
• Craig Gruber, 973-762-5510 or cgruber_at_innoventivep
  ower.com
• http//www.innoventivepower.com

27
Contacts NYSERDA PLRP/ALRP

• NYSERDA toll-free number 1-866-NYSERDA
• Albany
• Chris Smith ext 3360
• Andrew Tighe ext 3515
• Peter Savio ext 3334
• Lee Smith ext 3313
• NYC 212-971-5342
• Brenden Millstein ext 3014
• Lauren Pera ext 3016

28
ENHANCED COMMERCIAL AND INDUSTRIAL PERFORMANCE
PROGRAM (ECIPP)

• Current Solicitation PON 1101
• Up to 30 million available for electric and gas
  energy efficiency projects
• Three Tiers

29
ENHANCED COMMERCIAL AND INDUSTRIAL PERFORMANCE
PROGRAM (ECIPP)

• Tier I Formerly Smart Equipment Choices (SEC) -
  Prescriptive Incentives
• Tier II Custom Path
• Incentive of 2 cents per kWh saved
• Study based (No MV)
• Capped at 100,000

30
ENHANCED COMMERCIAL AND INDUSTRIAL PERFORMANCE
PROGRAM (ECIPP)

• Tier III Formerly Commercial Industrial
  Performance Program (CIPP) Energy Efficiency
• Incentives calculated based upon one full year of
  energy savings at
• Lighting 5 cents/kWh saved
• Motors/VSD/EMS 10 cents/kWh saved
• Cooling (Chillers) 20 cents/kWh saved
• Gas Savings 1 per therm

31
ENHANCED COMMERCIAL AND INDUSTRIAL PERFORMANCE
PROGRAM (ECIPP)

• Tier III, cont.,
• Additional Incentives for Con Edison Service
  Territory
• Lighting 200/kW
• Chillers 500/kW
• Requires Measurement and Verification (MV)
• Requires ESCO/Third-Party

32
ENHANCED COMMERCIAL AND INDUSTRIAL PERFORMANCE
PROGRAM (ECIPP)

• Caps for Energy Efficiency
• 1 million Customer Cap
• 5 million ESCO Cap
• 30 of Total Project Cost

33
ENHANCED COMMERCIAL AND INDUSTRIAL PERFORMANCE
PROGRAM (ECIPP) TIER III - CHP PERFORMANCE
PROGRAM

• Build off existing, successful DG-CHP
  demonstration program and PON 984
• Performance based, standard offer incentives for
  CHP
• MV required for payment kWh, system coincident
  kW, mmBtu recovered.

34
ENHANCED COMMERCIAL AND INDUSTRIAL PERFORMANCE
PROGRAM (ECIPP) TIER III - CHP PERFORMANCE
PROGRAM
Eligibility

• Host Site must pay MAC
• Engines and turbines -gtsummer peak demand
  reduction
• Fuel cells and microturbines are ineligible
• Multifamily facilities are ineligible
• 500 kW installed capacity
• Aggregation of sites not allowed

35
ENHANCED COMMERCIAL AND INDUSTRIAL PERFORMANCE
PROGRAM (ECIPP) TIER III - CHP PERFORMANCE
PROGRAM Eligibility (cont.)

• Applicant limit of 3 SPC Agreements
• Detailed Energy Analysis (DEA)
• Clean DG
• 1.6 lbs/MWh NOx
• Distance to nearest receptor
• Annual FCE of 60 based on LHV

36
ENHANCED COMMERCIAL AND INDUSTRIAL PERFORMANCE
PROGRAM (ECIPP) TIER III - CHP PERFORMANCE
PROGRAM

• Electricity generation 0.10 x kWh annual
• Peak Demand reduction 600 x kWp X PR2
• kWp ave. power produced during summer
  capability period, net parasitic electricity use
• PR power ratio (actual kW/contracted kW) gt 0.6
• Capped at 750/kW or 900/kW (less than 0.6
  lb/MWh NOx)
• Limit of 2 million per project

37
ENHANCED COMMERCIAL AND INDUSTRIAL PERFORMANCE
PROGRAM (ECIPP) TIER III - CHP PERFORMANCE
PROGRAM
1.8 MW installed capacity
38
ENHANCED COMMERCIAL AND INDUSTRIAL PERFORMANCE
PROGRAM (ECIPP) TIER III - CHP PERFORMANCE
PROGRAM

• Questions/Comments
• 1-866-NYSERDA (697-6237)
• Jaime Ritchey, extension 3517
• Mark Gundrum, extension 3256
• Scott Smith, extension 3344

39
RESIDENTIAL PROGRAMS

• Home Performance with Energy Star
• New York Energy Star Labeled Homes
• EmPower
• Coming in April
• Multifamily Building Performance Program (EB, NC,
  CHP, PV, Meters etc)
• BE COOL

40
BE COOL

• Residential Portion of Con Edison SWP Funds
• In Partnership with NYC and NYPA
• Concentration on Multi-Family Buildings
• Bounty Program
• TTW Air Conditioners
• Room Air Conditioners
• Air Sealing Tutorial (no holes left behind)

41
BE COOL HISTORY

• Keep Cool Launched in 2000
• Ran Consecutively for 4 years
• Over 250,000 A/C units turned in for Bounty
• 48 MW of Peak Demand Savings
• Contributed to shifting 100 MW to off peak
• 28 gWh/year of savings

42
BE COOL - HISTORY

• Stay Cool Ran from Summer 2004-2006
• Retail Partner Program . . . NO Bounty
• Provided Incentives to Retailers for increase in
  market share of ENERGY STAR A/Cs
• Resulted in 78 ENERGY STAR Market Penetration
• Low Operating Budget / No Bounty

43
BE COOL

• Program Launch April 2007
• Anticipate 150,000 Replacements (w/ Bounty)
• Midstream and Retailer Incentives
• Advertising and Outreach
• 27 MW Peak Demand Reductions
• Savings of 16 gWh/year
• Consumer Behavior Change Will Produce
• 30 MW Reduction

44
CONTACT

• Luke Falk
• Project Manager
• NYSERDA
• LLF_at_NYSERDA.ORG
• 212.971.5342
• www.getenergysmart.org