Title: Global Supply Chain Financial SolutionsHow Do You Structure a Transaction
1Volatility - The New Norm?
- Global Supply Chain Financial Solutions-How Do
You Structure a Transaction? - Moderator John Ahearn, Citi
- Terry D. Novetsky, Kaye Scholer LLP
- James Parsons, Bluecrest Capital Management Ltd.
- Roland Hartley-Urquhart, Morgan Stanley
Bankers Association for Finance and Trade
2Agenda
- What is Distribution Finance?
- Discuss need for Distribution Finance
- What are the benefits to the parties involved?
3Distribution Finance in the Supply Chain Flow
DISTRIBUTION FINANCE
1. Invoice deliver goods
Portfolio of (Distributors/Buyers)
Seller (Anchor Tenant)
3. Invoice acknowledgment
2. Invoice download
BANK
5. Distributors/Buyers pay bank on due date
4. Provides liquidity on day x
4Distribution Channel The Conflict
- Many large corporate Sellers find that there is a
lack of liquidity and financing options in their
distribution chain, which can frustrate their
efforts to - Increase credit lines to permit distributors to
buy more of their products and thus generate
additional sales - Improve Seller cash flow and cost efficiencies
related to additional sales - Build distributor loyalty and gain a marketing
advantage - Sellers are seeking to expand sales and gain
market share in fast growing markets, especially
emerging markets - Regional and small distributors (Buyers) face a
working capital squeeze between the time they
have to pay the corporate Seller and collecting
from their end users - Distributors access to local bank or other
working capital solutions can be restrictive,
expensive and tied to local market events - Sellers are reluctant to fund extended terms to
Distributors due to balance sheet, metric
implications and risk - Sellers face the need to build internal staff to
conduct fundamental credit risk analysis and
proactively manage credit in a new market where
their sales growth is highest
5Distribution Finance The Solution
Seller
Distribution Finance (DF) is a
portfolio-oriented receivables purchase and
servicing program using automated technology,
that allows a large corporate Seller (banks
Anchor Tenant client) to
- Differentiate product via value-added program for
buyers to work with a bank - Extend longer sales terms to their customers
- Facilitate a scalable, quickly deployable program
across various countries where the Buyers are
located, including emerging markets - Manage their cash flow in a more precise and
efficient manner - Maintain or improve Days Sales Outstanding (DSO)
via receivables sales - Reduce credit and collections management
- Enhance risk management via dedicated receivables
management service - Introduction of financial institution payment
discipline
Distribution Finance addresses the inherent
conflict Sellers face by maximizing top line
growth while optimizing balance sheet usage and
capital costs
6Distribution Finance The Solution cont.
Buyer
- More flexible credit terms via longer payment
terms, enhancing liquidity and working capital
management - Reduce cost of working capital funding given
portfolio risk nature of program - Establish payment record with bank that could
lead to a lending relationship - Improve ability to carry and manage inventory,
facilitating downstream sales - Improve information flow and reduce administration
Bank
- Highly specialized product offering that sets
bank apart from the competition - Return on capital tends to exceed other plain
vanilla Trade product offerings - New technology - risk management and product
performance - Increased cross-sell/penetration to small and
medium enterprises (SME) market by screening
Buyers before on-boarding as clients - Critical component of end to end Supply Chain
- Sticky recurring revenue stream
7Transaction Flow with Purchase Order Approval
1. Purchase Order (PO)
Flow Description 1) Buyer issues purchase
orders 2) Seller requests purchase order credit
approval 3) Bank credit approves purchase
order 4) Seller ships goods and invoices to
Buyers 5) Seller sends invoice data to Bank 6)
Bank sends weekly invoice acceptance request
which includes the payment due date 7) Buyers
accept invoices 8) Funding instructions issued
from 3rd party servicer to bank treasury 9) Bank
sends funds to Seller 10) Buyers remit payment on
due date
Buyers
Seller (Anchor Tenant)
4. Shipment / Invoice
Buyers
Buyers
BANK
2. PO Approval Request
3. PO Approval
- Operations
- Bank
- Approves Invoice Funding
- 3rd Party Processor
- Facilitates Electronic Data Interchange (EDI)
between Buyer, Seller and Account Debtors - Collection of Account Debtor Information
- Payment Reconciliations
- Payment Tracking, Reminders Account and
Portfolio reports/metrics - Financial reporting
6. Invoice Payment Due Date
9. Funding (Day 30)
5. Invoice Data Files Sent
7. Affirm Payment Due
8. Funding Instruction
BANK Funding
10. Payment (e.g., Day 60 or 90)
8Supply Chain Finance Structure and Recent Market
Performance 18th Annual Conference on
International Trade Chicago, 30 October,
2008 Roland Hartley-Urquhart
9Working Capital Management
Why do it?
- Timely and relevant topic for our clients
- With debt capital markets under stress, companies
are turning attention to the top half of the
balance sheet to achieve higher levels of - Liquidity
- Sales growth
- Earnings
- Supply chain finance is a toolkit of products
that can achieve these key corporate objectives
10SCF Benefits by Working Capital Component
Strategic Drivers
11Sales Finance Key Issues
- Before structuring the deal, key points to
consider - Whats the relative credit cost?
- Bilateral lines with dealers vs. sales financing
- How much customization by jurisdiction?
- Global, regional or local approach?
- How far do you go?
- Balance between helping distributors and stuffing
the channel - Strength of the trade credit culture within the
sellers organization - Is there an opportunity for financing cost
arbitrage? - Use of receivables as a seller financing tool for
crossover credits - Sellers appetite for risk?
- How adaptable are distributors to economic
decline? - Longer inventory turns
- Seller pressure to reduce
- First loss capacity
- Availability of trade credit insurance?
12Relative Capital Cost Drives Adoption
The rift between the credit haves and have-nots
is growing
13Sales Finance Toolkit
Any number of approaches can get the job done
- Range of Potential Sales Financing Products
- ABL / first lien
- Not global
- Revolving credit
- Use of global receivables as part of the
borrowing base - One-off receivable sales
- Elimination of concentration risk
- Reverse factoring with notification
- Receivable securitization
- Enhancement tools
- Over-collateralization
- Multi-tranche
- Trade credit insurance
14Distribution Finance
Structuring Considerations
- Key Risks Assessed
- Servicing risks
- Overall position of sellers business
- Sellers credit and collection policies
- Dilution risk
- Portfolio performance
- Legal structure
- True sale, bankruptcy remote
- Dynamic performance triggers
- Credit enhancements
- Trade credit insurance
- Dilution reserves
- Equity and sub tranches
7
15Receivable Finance Structure
Example of multiseller conduit
- Source Moodys Investor Services
16Markets in Turmoil
Declining volume evidence of severe market
dislocation
17ABCP Market Revival
Relief in store from Fed's Commercial Paper
Funding Facility (CPFF)?
18ABCP Market Revival
Spreads tighten after CPFF announcement