pearls - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

View by Category
About This Presentation



palliative care – PowerPoint PPT presentation

Number of Views:666
Slides: 74
Provided by: rjsunnycrest


Write a Comment
User Comments (0)
Transcript and Presenter's Notes

Title: pearls

Pearls in Pediatric Palliative Care
All You Really Need to Know
My Background
  • Pediatric Residency, Maine Medical Center
  • Pediatric Oncology Fellowship, UCONN
  • Maine Childrens Cancer Program, 1985-1998
  • General Pediatrics, 1998-Present
  • ABP, EPEC, ABHPM Certified
  • Medical Director, JP, 1999-present
  • SMMC Chief of Pediatrics, 2001-present

  • Medical
  • What is palliative care?
  • The right to be free from pain
  • The right dose is the dose that works
  • When all else fails
  • Two roads to death - be prepared
  • Newborns feel pain, too
  • Psychosocial
  • Breaking bad news
  • Hope
  • Miracles
  • Listen to the children

The Broad Need for Services
  • Statistics pediatric deaths from chronic
    non-malignant diseases (CDC, US DHHS, NCHS, OAE)
  • USA total 1999 33,089 (2517 Cancer)
  • Maine total 1999 84 (14 Cancer)
  • USA total 1979-1998 45,030/yr (3069 Ca)
  • Maine total 1979-1998 151/yr (14 Cancer)

From CDC Wonder ( WONDER
provides a single point of access to a wide
variety of reports and numeric public health
Cure vs. Palliation
  • Cure
  • fundamental hope is eradication of disease
  • assumes cure is worth a sacrifice
  • Palliation
  • fundamental hope is comfort
  • consequences of any intervention that relieves
    suffering are acceptable
  • Skills gap

A Better Viewpoint
Curative / Life-Prolonging Therapy
Relieve Suffering - Palliative Care
Integrating Curative Palliative Care It Can
Be DoneGail Austin Cooney, MD, FAAHPM
  • A vision for best practices would include the
    concept of integrated care that would provide
    these ideals
  • Cure when possible
  • Disease modification and management
  • Informed decision making
  • Coordinated care
  • Symptom control a priority
  • Optimize quality of life
  • End-of-life care

Pain Philosophy
  • Freedom From Pain A Matter of Rights?
  • T. Patrick Hill, M.A.
    Ca. Invest., 12 (4), 1994
  • Pain Isolates We are probably never more alone
    than when severe pain invades us.
  • Pain is Elusive Despite the fact that it is the
    result of biochemical processes, it is also ... a
    subjective experience, felt only within the
    confines of our individual minds.

Pain Philosophy
  • Pain is unlike disease, and that to treat its
    symptoms clinically, physicians need above all to
    understand how the ravages of pain can reach
    beyond the body to the soul of the person,
    assaulting its very integrity.
  • There exists a principle on which rests the
    human right to be free of pain and the
    corresponding obligation of health-care
    professionals to honor it. All patients are
    vulnerable, but none is more vulnerable than the
    patient in severe pain. The measure of medicine
    in general and of a physician in particular is
    ultimately their respect for the patients right
    to be free of pain.

Barriers to Effective Opioid Use
- Weissman, David E. Home Health Care Consultant
  • ... the most pervasive and difficult to
    overcome relate to the fears among patients,
    families, and health professionals of opioid
    analgesics, which are the cornerstone of drug
    therapy for moderate to severe pain.
  • These fears include an exaggerated estimation of
    opioid addiction and tolerance, fear of opioid
    side effects -- most notably respiratory
    depression -- and ethical and regulatory concerns
    about using opioids.

The Right Dose - Legal
  • Maine Board of Licensure in Medicine
  • Chapter 11Use of Controlled Substances for
    Treatment of Pain
  • -- March 22, 1999
  • Preamble The Boards recognize that principles of
    quality medical practice dictate that the people
    of the State of Maine have access to appropriate
    and effective pain relief.
  • The Boards encourage physicians to view effective
    pain management as a part of quality medical
    practice for all patients with pain, acute or
    chronic, and as especially important for patients
    who experience pain as a result of a terminal

State of the Art
  • Federal State Model Policy for the Use of
    Controlled Substances for the Treatment of Pain
    -- May, 2004All physicians should become
    knowledgeable about effective methods of pain
    treatment, as well as statutory requirements for
    prescribing controlled substances. Accordingly,
    this policy have been developed to clarify the
    Boards position on pain control and to
    alleviate physician uncertainty and to encourage
    better pain management.Appropriate pain
    management is the treating physicians
    responsibility. As such, the Board will consider
    the inappropriate treatment of pain to be a
    departure from standards of practice and will
    investigate such allegations, recognizing that
    some types of pain cannot be completely relieved,
    and taking into account whether the treatment is
    appropriate for the diagnosis.

  • In August 2004, the Drug Enforcement
    Administration (DEA) published on its Office of
    Diversion Control Web site a document entitled
    Questions and Answers for Health Care
    Professionals and Law Enforcement Personnel." The
    document contained misstatements and has
    therefore been removed from the DEA Web site. DEA
    wishes to emphasize that the document was not
    approved as an official statement of the agency
    and did not and does not have the force and
    effect of law.DEA recognizes that the proper
    use of controlled substances in the treatment of
    pain remains an extremely important issue.
    Accordingly, DEA intends to address this matter
    in the future.-- Drug Enforcement
    Administration, 2004

Who is Helping the DEA?
  • 21 Health Organizations
  • University of Wisconsin Comprehensive Cancer
  • American Academy of Pain Medicine
  • Federation of State Medical Boards
  • Jason Program Website

Bottom Line
  • Do what is right for your patient (and you)
  • Communicate effectively
  • Assess the medical situation carefully
  • Provide whatever is needed for pain relief
  • Consider abusive personalities
  • Consider signing a contract
  • Arrange follow-up appropriately

All in 15 minutes
The Right Dose - Medical
  • Opioids The right dose is the dose that works
  • Pain and the Reticular Activating System The
    respiratory depressant effect of opioid agonists
    can be demonstrated easily in volunteer studies.
    When the dose of morphine is titrated against a
    patients pain, however, clinically important
    respiratory depression does not occur. This
    appears to be becausepain acts as a
    physiological antagonist to the central
    depression effects of morphine.
  • Wall, R.D., ed. Textbook of Pain. Churchill
  • Naive Pts. vs. Tolerance

Parenteral Narcotics
  • Morphine
  • 0.1 mg/kg IV bolus, Q 1-2hr
  • 0.05 mg/ kg/hr, CI - IV or SQ
  • Hydromorphone (Dilaudid)
  • Approximately 6 times stronger than morphine
  • Fentanyl
  • Approximately 10 times stronger than morphine
  • Wide dosing range
  • 1-2 mcg/kg IV slow push
  • 0.5-1.0 mcg/kg/hr, CI - IV or SQ
  • Total hourly dose as a transderm patch

Patient-Controlled Analgesia
  • Age gt 4 years (if able to play computer games)
  • Home or Hospital
  • Adequate observation

Medication Base Rate Bolus Dose
Lockout Max/Hr Morphine .03 mg/kg
Same 6-10 min .15 mg/kg Dilaudid
5 mcg/kg Same 6-10 min
25 mcg/kg Fentanyl 1 mcg/kg Same
6-10 min 4 mcg/kg
Equianalgesic Narcotic DosingSource McCaffery
M, Pasero C. PAIN Clinical Manual, 2nd
Edition, Harcort Health Sciences Website, 2000.
Oral/Rectal Dose (mg) Analgesic Parenteral Dose (mg)
3 Morphine 1
20 Codeine 12
3 Hydrocodone --
0.75 Hydromorphone 0.15-(0.3 w/ PCA)
2 Oxycodone --
2 Methadone 1
25 mcg/hr Fentanyl Patch 1 mg/hr IV MSO4
-- Fentanyl 10-20 mcg
XX Meperidine XX
When All Else Fails
  • 16 year old girl, 50 kg, with far advanced
    abdominal malignancy and intestinal obstruction.
    Receiving morphine at 100 mg/hr without relief.
    Her parents would like her to be awake for the
    arrival of a relative tomorrow, but dont want
    her to suffer.

  • You have increased the morphine, and the pain is
    well controlled, but severe nausea and dark,
    bilious vomiting begins. You have placed an NG
    tube to drainage, and tried Zofran, Trilafon, and
    Octreotide, all without relief. Pain escalates
    despite morphine at 1000 mg/hr, with further
    increases ineffective.
  • What are your options?

  • Discuss goals of care
  • Try a different opioid
  • Add an anxiolytic
  • Explore psychologic religious issues
  • Surgical and radiotherapy consults to relieve
  • Pain consult
  • Inform patient family there are no further

Comfort Sedation
  • Barbiturates in the Care of the Terminally
    IllTruog, Robert D., et. al. NEJM, Vol. 327, No.
    23, 1678-81
  • Barbiturates
  • Reliably produce sedation and unconsciousness
  • Are used in the execution of prisoners by lethal
  • Ethical Considerations
  • The Principle of Double Effect --
    Distinction between intended effects and
    unintended although foreseen effects.
  • Commonly called terminal sedation

Barbiturates Are Justified
  • To relieve physical suffering when all reasonable
    alternatives have failed
  • To produce unconsciousness before terminal
  • Produce deep sedation and unconsciousness as a
    means of relieving nonphysical suffering

Terminal Sedation Opinions
  • Terminal sedation ethical implications in
    different situations - Hallenbeck JL. J Palliat
    Med. 2000 Fall3(3)313-20
  • Sedation is supported in a case of severe
    distress in a patient very close to death, but
    not in a case of of psychic distress
  • In providing sedation the physician's primary
    intent should be to alleviate suffering -
    Sedatives should be titrated to observable signs
    of distress
  • Not all suffering is appropriately treated with

Terminal Sedation Opinions
  • Family experience with palliative sedation
    therapy for terminally ill cancer patients -
  • J Pain Symptom Manage. 2004 Dec28(6)557-65
  • Although the majority of families were
    comfortable with this practice, clinicians should
    minimize family distress by regular monitoring of
    patient distress and timely modification of
    sedation protocols, providing sufficient
    information, sharing the responsibility of the
    decision, facilitating grief and providing
    emotional support

On Our Own Terms- Bill Moyers
  • In rare cases some patients who are very ill do
    not respond to pain medications or may be
    suffering in other ways that make comfort
    impossible. In these circumstances there is a
    last resort therapy that can be used terminal
    sedation. With terminal sedation, a patient will
    be given medications that induce sleep or
    unconsciousness until such time as death occurs
    as a result of the underlying illness or disease.
    These measures are often accompanied by the
    withholding of artificial life supports like
    intravenous feeding and artificial respiration.
    Like the use of medications that cause a "double
    effect," the intention with terminal sedation
    must be to relieve suffering only, not to cause

Last Days of Living - Medical Aspects
  • Weakness Fatigue
  • Dehydration
  • Respiratory Distress
  • Temperature Changes
  • Increased Secretions
  • Pain May Increase
  • Anxiety
  • Two Roads to Death

Two Roads to Death
Myoclonic Jerks
Last Days of Living - Social Aspects
  • Family Preparation
  • DNR
  • Letting Go
  • MD Presence at Time of Death
  • Mechanism of Death
  • Autopsy
  • Follow-up

Pain in Newborns -- Compassion Common Sense
Yeah, Baby!
State of the Art
Prevention and Management of Pain Stress in the
Neonate -- American Academy of
Pediatrics Committee on Fetus and
NewbornCommittee on DrugsSection on
AnesthesiologySection on Surgery -- Pediatrics
Volume 105, Number 2 February 2000, pp 454-461
  • Management of pain must be considered an
    important component of the health care provided
    to all neonates, regardless of their gestational
    age or severity of illness.

  • Pain in newborns is often unrecognized and
  • If a procedure is painful in adults, it should be
    considered painful in newborns, even if they are
  • Compared with older age groups, newborns may
    experience a greater sensitivity to pain and are
    more susceptible to the long-term effects of
    painful stimulation.
  • Adequate treatment of pain may be associatedwith
    decreased clinical complicationsand decreased

Neonatal Pain Scales
  • Validated and Reliable Scales Exist
  • Measure Physiologic Parameters
  • Heart rate, resp rate, BP, O2 sats,
    sweating,vagal tone, plasma cortisol catechols
  • Measure Behavioral Parameters
  • Facial expressions, body movements, crying
  • Examples

  • Crying
  • Requirement for oxygen (to keep SaO2 gt95)
  • Increased heart rate and BP
  • Expression
  • Sleeplessness
  • Inter-rater reliability gt.72

0 1 2
Crying No High PitchConsolable Inconsolable
FiO2 No lt 30 gt 30
Increased Heart Rate BP No 11-20 ? gt 20 ?
Expression Calm Grimace Grimace Grunt
Sleepless No Frequent Awakening Constantly Awake
PIPP Scale -Premature Infant Pain Profile
  • Facial Actions
  • Brow bulge
  • Eye squeeze
  • Nasolabial furrow
  • Physiological Indicators
  • Heart rate
  • Oxygen saturation
  • Context
  • Gestational age
  • Behavioral state
  • Inter-rater reliability gt.93

PIPP Scale - part 1
Indicator Finding Points
Gestational age gt 36 weeks 0
32 weeks to 35 weeks 6 days 1
28 weeks to 31 weeks 6 days 2
lt 28 weeks 3
Behavioral state active/awake eyes open facial movements 0
quiet/awake eyes open no facial movements 1
active/sleep eyes closed facial movements 2
quiet/sleep eyes closed no facial movements 3
Maximum Heart Rate 0-4 beats per minute increase 0
5-14 beats per minute increase 1
15-24 beats/minute 2
gt 25 beats/minute 3
Indicator Finding Points
Minimum O2 sat 0-2.4 decrease 0
2.5-4.9 decrease 1
5-7.4 decrease 2
gt 7.5 decrease 3
Brow bulge lt 9 of time 0
10-39 of time 1
40-69 of time 2
gt 70 of time 3
Eye Squeeze lt 9 of time 0
10-39 of time 1
40-69 of time 2
gt 70 of time 3
Nasolabial furrow lt 9 of time 0
10-39 of time 1
40-69 of time 2
gt 70 of time 3
PIPP Scoring
PIPP Score SUM (points for all 7
indicators) Interpretation minimum score 0
maximum score 21 The higher the score the
greater the pain behavior Reference Stevens B
Johnston C et al. Premature Infant Pain Profile
Development and initial validation. Clinical
Journal of Pain. 1996 12 13-
  • Developed at Erasmus MC-Sophia Netherlands
  • Designed for post-surgical infants 0-3 yrs old
  • Complicated but Effective
  • Assessment form
  • Treatment Algorithm

  • Indifferent medical staff who regard pain
    assessment as a nursing issue only. Medical staff
    commitment is essential, however, because they
    have to develop an analgesic algorithm linking
    pain assessment to pain treatment. Furthermore,
    they should have a genuine interest in patients
    pain scores during daily rounds.
  • No time or money to appoint one or more contacts
    on the ward, i.e. staff taking care of training
    of all nurses, and reaching a common decision
    with regards to frequency and patient population
    when pain assessment should take place.

NonpharmacologicTreatment 0f Procedural Pain in
Avoid Painful Procedures
  • Painful procedures should be minimized and, when
    appropriate, coordinated with other aspects of
    the neonates care.
  • Obtaining blood by venipuncture may be less
    painful than heel lancing.56-58
  • Consider implanted catheters

Endogenous Analgesia
  • Generalized tactile
  • Touch ( swaddling)
  • Orotactile
  • Touch suckling
  • Orogustatory
  • Touch feeding

Tactile skin-skin contact
Percent of time
Grimace Cry
Gray, et al, Pediatrics 2000
Non-nutritive sucking
  • Tested during heelstick procedure
  • Heelstick caused no effect on respiratory rate
    and oxygen saturations
  • Sucking reduced time of crying and heart rate
  • --Corbo, et al. Biol Neonate, 2000

Effect of Oral Sucrose Solutionon Venipuncture
Abad, et al, Acta Paediatr, 1996
Time crying (sec)
Breastfeeding is Analgesic in Healthy Newborns
-- Gray,, Pediatrics Vol. 109,
No. 4, April 2002
Analgesic Medications
(No Transcript)
  • Medical
  • The right to be free from pain
  • The right dose is the dose that works
  • When all else fails
  • Two roads to death - be prepared
  • Newborns feel pain, too
  • Psychosocial
  • Breaking bad news
  • Hope
  • Miracles
  • Listen to the children

Breaking Bad News
  • From How to Break Bad News, by Robert Buckman,
    MD, 1992
  • Bad news is any information whose consequences
    are worse than the patients expectations
  • Why this topic is important

Should We Tell the Truth?
  • 1672 -- Samuel de SorbiereTruth is a good idea
    that wont catch on.
  • 1960s -- 90 of MDs preferred not to inform
    their patients of a diagnosis of cancer. Methods
    of deceitwere published. Truth destroys hope.
  • 1980s --50-97 of pts want to know the truth.
  • Now --Patients have absolute rights to their
    medical information. Physician practices have
    changed. How to tell is the debate.

Empathy - Respond to patients feelings
  • Steps
  • Identify the emotion open-ended questions
  • Identify its cause
  • Respond in a way that shows you understand the
    connection between 1 and 2
  • ? Example

  • A reasonable plan the patient will follow is
    better than an ideal plan the patient will
  • Any plan is far better than no plan.

Hope Never Leaves
  • What is Hope?
  • Why Hope is Important
  • Helping Your Patients

  • To look forward to with confidence or
  • "Beware how you take away hope from another
    human being."- Oliver Wendell Holmes, 1809-1894

Hope Its Spheres Dimensions
-- Dufault, K. and Martocchio, B. NursClinNA. 1985
The Neurobiology of Hope
-- Gottschalk, L.A.,, The Cerebral
Neurobiology of Hope and Hopelessness.
Psychiatry, V.56, Aug 1993
Activity Regions of Hope Memory - Frontal Cortex
Language - Temporal Perception - Parietal
Vision - Occipital Emotions Hippocampus ?
Psychopathology -
Hope Persists
  • different stages that people go through when
    they are faced with tragic news --coping
    mechanisms to deal with extremely difficult
    situations. These means will last for different
    periods of time and will replace each other.
  • The one thing that usually persists through all
    these stages is hope.
  • Just as children in the concentration camp of
    Terezin maintained their hope years ago, although
    out of a total of about 15,000 childrenonly
    around 100 came out of it alive.
  • Elisabeth Kubler-Ross, MD On Death and Dying,

Ever-Present Hope
  • we were always impressed that even the most
    accepting, the most realistic patients left the
    possibility open for some cure.It is this
    glimpse of hope which maintains them through
    days, weeks, or months of suffering. It is the
    feeling that this all must have some
    meaning.(or) that this is just like a nightmare
    and not trueIt gives the terminally ill a sense
    of a special mission in life which helps them
    maintain their spirits for others it remains a
    form of temporary but needed denial.
  • Elisabeth Kubler-Ross, MD On Death and Dying,

Ever-Present Hope
  • Everybody has it
  • It allows them to live
  • Hope is required to experience life during the
    process of dying
  • It has two forms
  • Provides meaning in illness death
  • Provides temporary denial

Helping Your Patients
  • Remember that there is no greater loss than the
    loss of a child
  • Allow for Hope and Share It
  • Tell the truth (Miracles Do Exist)
  • Hope Shifts
  • Timing
  • Embrace Life

Allow for Hope
  • we found that all our patients maintained a
    little bit of it (hope) and were nourished by it
    in especially difficult times. The showed the
    greatest confidence in the doctors who allowed
    for such hope realistic or not an appreciated
    it when hope was offered in spite of bad
    news.While we maintained hope with them, we did
    not reinforce hope when they finally gave it up,
    not with despair but in a stage of final
  • Elisabeth Kubler-Ross, MD On Death and Dying,

Miracles Do Exist - I
  • JS, 4 year old boy with stage IV neuroblastoma,
    considered incurable. Chemotherapy achieves a
    partial response. Bone marrow transplant
    performed, and an abdominal mass is found only
    three weeks later. Biopsy shows neuroblastoma. No
    further therapy. JS is alive and well without
    disease 5 years later, past his Collins risk
    period for relapse.

Miracles Do Exist - II
  • CB, 11 year old boy with ALL. Induction therapy
    fails. Told he was incurable. He receives
    intensified, investigational treatment, which
    fails. Told he was incurable. Palliative steroids
    were given, and he enters remission, but develops
    a systemic aspergillos infection. Told it was
    incurable. Receives an investigational antifungal
    agent and clears the infection. He then receives
    a bone marrow transplant, but 6 months later
    relapses. Told it was incurable. He was treated
    with palliative therapy, and enters remission. He
    then relapses after 6 months of more treatment.
    We decided we wouldnt tell him he was incurable,
    because he might think we were stupid. He lives
    another year with good quality of life before
    dying of his disease.
  • --
    Listen to the Children

Hope Shifts
  • We May Assume
  • Hope for Survival
  • Western Medicine
  • Life is not worth living if one is bedridden
  • Comatose people experience nothing
  • What Can Be
  • Hope For Survival
  • Alternative Medicine
  • Miracles
  • Comfort
  • Peace for self others
  • Events
  • Babys Birth, Wedding
  • Hope for Hope

  • Be aware that life is dynamic
  • Stages of Facing Tragic News
  • Denial and Isolation
  • Anger
  • Bargaining
  • Depression
  • Acceptance
  • I dont feel like talking now
  • Managing Unrealistic Hope

Embrace Life
  • Just Living
  • Building Memories
  • No Regrets
  • Relationships Strengthening, Creating, Mending

Thanks for Listening
The Jason Program13 Industrial Park RoadSaco,
Maine 04072 Phone (207) 294-8255Fax (207)
Visit us on the web at Files
available at
Thanks for Listening
  • Be the practitioner you would want if you were