MANAGING TWO AND THREEWHEELER EMISSIONS

1
MANAGING TWO AND THREE-WHEELER EMISSIONS

• N.V.IyerAdvisor (Technical)
• Bajaj Auto Ltd, Pune, India
• National Workshop on the Improvement of Urban Air
  Quality of Pakistan13 - 15 December,
  2004Lahore, Pakistan

2
PRESENTATION CONTENTS

• Problem definition
• Emission standards
• New vehicles
• In-use vehicle
• Smoke PM Emissions
• Two-stroke v/s Four-stroke
• Fuel conversion programmes
• Fuels lubricants
• The way forward

3
MOTORYCLE REGISTRATIONS AROUND THE WORLD
(Source Data World Motorcycle Facts Figures,
HONDA, 1997) Slide Michael Walsh
4
DEFINITION OF THE PROBLEM

• Vehicle fleets in most Asian countries comprise
  2-3 wheelers - a majority powered by 2-stroke
  engines
• Major 2-stroke engine pollutants are Particulate
  Matter (PM) and Hydrocarbons (HC) causing serious
  air quality and health problems
• Two wheelers account for a significant proportion
  of vehicular air pollution, particularly HC and
  PM
• There is an urgent need to develop and implement
  strategies to clean up 2 - 3 wheelers

5
EMISSION STANDARDS

• An important strategy is to adopt emission
  standards for new and in-use vehicles
• examples India, Taipei,China, Thailand and EU
• Emission standards must be evolved in a
  transparent manner involving all stakeholders
• May consider leapfrogging to Indian standards
  which are among the most stringent

6
NEW MOTORCYCLE EMISSION STANDARDS IN TAIPEI,CHINA
AND INDIA
NOTES (1) ALL VALUES ARE IN g/km. (2)
TAIPEI,CHINA STANDARD FOR CO IS WITH COLD START.
(3) FIGURE FOR TAIPEI,CHINA SHOWS 2004 LIMIT FOR
2-STROKE VEHICLES ONLY. FOR 4-STROKES THE LIMIT
IS 2 g/km
7
All limit values in g/km
8
(No Transcript)
9
SOURCE OF SMOKE AND PM EMISSIONS FROM TWO-STROKE
ENGINES (1/2)

• Lubricating oil introduced through intake
  air-fuel mixture either by mixing with petrol or
  by injection
• The entire quantity of oil passes through the
  engine in every cycle of operation (the
  once-through system)
• Small oil droplets of incompletely combusted
  lubricating oil emitted through exhaust appear as
  visible smoke and PM
• Over 98 percent of PM is soluble organic fraction
  (unlike largely carbonaceous in diesel PM)

10
SOURCE OF SMOKE AND PM EMISSIONS FROM TWO-STROKE
ENGINES (2/2)
Smoke and PM emissions exacerbated by Use of
inferior grades and excessive quantities of
lubricating oil Use of adulterated fuel
Improper maintenance of engine
Source Masami (2000), World Bank
11
CONTROL OF PM EMISSIONS OF 2-STROKE ENGINES
(1/2) (Source JAMA)
PM emission can be controlled by - Reducing the
oil dosage, - Use of superior low smoke
oil - Use of oxidation catalytic converter
12
CONTROL OF PM EMISSIONS OF 2-STROKE ENGINES
(2/3)

• No country has emission standards for PM
• EU working towards developing test procedures and
  standards for 2-stroke PM emissions.
• Findings so far are (Source Rijkeboer et al,
  2004)
• Current CVS techniques used for diesel PM would
  be inadequate since large variations occur on
  account of dominant nucleation mode
• Two-stroke particles differ significantly from
  diesel particles and contain large volatile
  fractions
• Understanding of the health effects of 2-stroke
  PM are largely lacking
• Vehicle designed to meet stringent emission
  standards have less PM emissions

13
CONTROL OF PM EMISSIONS OF 2-STROKE ENGINES
(3/3)

• India has mandated the use of low smoke (JASO
  FC smoke index) 2-stroke engine (2-T) oil.
• National Capital Territory of Delhi has mandated
  dispensing 2-T oil only pre-mixed with petrol
• All post-2000 2-stroke engines in India use
  oxidation catalytic converters
• Limited tests on post-2000 2-stroke engines with
  catalytic converters, using the current diesel
  test method show PM levels lower than 0.05 g/km
  (below Euro III)

14
EMISSION STANDARDS - IN-USE VEHICLES

• In-use standards ensure proper vehicle
  maintenance
• Typical in-use standards regulate CO under idle
  -some countries regulate idle HC and/or smoke
  (opacity)
• Tight in-use standards can be used to force
  older, higher polluting vehicles to be retired or
  moved away from hot-spots
• Test procedure for in-use standards should be
  capable of accurately defining gross polluters
• Experience shows that, to be effective, capacity
  for a strong enforcement is necessary

15
IN-USE EMISSION STANDARDS FOR 2 3 WHEELERS OF
SOME ASIAN COUNTRIES
Introduced in India from 1st
October 2004 for post - 2000 vehicles
16
PAKISTAN NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY STANDARDS
FOR MOTOR VEHICLE EXHAUST (source
www.punjab.gov.pk/epa/index.htm)

• 1. Smoke
• 40 or 2 on the Ringleman Scale During engine
  acceleration mode.
• To be compared with Ringleman Chart at a distance
  of 6 meters or more.
• 2. Carbon Monoxide
• New Vehicle 4.5
• Used Vehicle 6 Under idling conditions
• non-despersive infrared detection through gas
  analyzer.

17
TWO-STROKE VERSUS FOUR-STROKE ENGINES - current
position

• Historically, two-stroke engines are known to
  emit higher levels of PM and HC, but lower levels
  of NOx.
• Due to high ambient PM levels in many Asian
  cities, there is a great interest in replacing
  them or cleaning them up
• Advanced technologies such as fuel injection
  systems have a potential to reduce emissions
• Introduction of stringent emission standards in
  India and changing customer preferences have led
  to an increasing preference for 4-stroke engines
• Penetration of 4-stroke engines in the low-cost
  segments (mopeds and scooters) remains low due to
  advantages of 2-stroke

18
RAPIDLY INCREASING PROPORTIONS OF 4-STROKE
MOTORCYCLES IN INDIA IN RECENT YEARS
19
FUEL CONVERSION PROGRAMMES

• Important alternate fuel options are CNG, LPG,
  Hydrogen and electricity
• Two-wheelers not attractive candidates for
  alternate fuels
• Three-wheelers successfully converted to CNG
  (India) and LPG (India and Thailand).
• Coordinated effort between government and the
  energy sector required to evolve a comprehensive
  alternate fuel programme that encompasses
• Life cycle analysis (well-to-wheel)
• provision of fuelling infrastructure
• quality and approval systems for safety of the
  modified vehicles

20
BAJAJ AUTOs ALTERNATE FUEL VEHICLES

• CNG AUTO-RICKSHAW
• Presently in series production. Deployed over
  38,000 in Delhi, over 15,000 in Mumbai and over
  10,000 in Dhaka.
• LPG AUTO-RICKSHAW
• Presently in series production. Volumes low at
  present due to limited demand
• ELECTRIC AUTO-RICKSHAW
• Successfully developed. Uses an Advanced
  technology Axial Flux Motor, with gt 85 drive
  cycle efficiency, Flooded lead-acid batteries.

21
COMPARATIVE EMISSION PERFORMANCE OF BAJAJ AUTOs
ALTERNATE FUEL VEHICLES
NMHC Non-Methane Hydrocarbons RHC Reactive
Hydrocarbons
22
FUELS AND LUBRICANTS

• Fuel
• Lead free petrol a must for using catalytic
  converters
• Low sulphur content necessary to improve
  durability
• Low benzene content reduces exhaust toxicity
• Oxygenates blended in fuel reduce CO emissions
• Lubricating oil
• Low smoke (JASO FC) oils reduce smoke and PM
  emissions
• Supply of 2-T oil pre-mixed with petrol at
  filling stations can control excessive oil
  consumption

23
TYPICAL STRATEGIES ADOPTED BY MAJOR ASIAN
COUNTRIES TO REDUCE TWO WHEELER POLLUTION

• ENFORCEMENT OF PROGRESSIVELY STRINGENT EMISSION
  STANDARDS FOR NEW VEHICLES
• ENFORCEMENT OF EMISSION STANDARDS FOR IN-USE
  VEHICLES
• STRENGTHENING EMISSION INSPECTION MAINTENANCE
• INTRODUCTION OF IMPROVED 2-STROKE LUBRICATING
  (2-T) OILS
• MANDATING/PROMOTING USE OF LOW SMOKE 2-STROKE
  LUBRICATING OILS
• MANDATORY DISPENSING OF 2-T OIL PRE-MIXED WITH
  PETROL
• PROMOTION OF ALTERNATIVE FUELS (CNG/LPG) FOR
  THREE WHEELERS
• COMPLETE PHASE OUT OF LEADED PETROL

• TAIPEI,CHINA, INDIA, THAILAND
• MANY COUNTRIES
• TAIPEI,CHINA
• JAPAN, THAILAND, TAIPEI,CHINA, INDIA
• INDIA, THAILAND
• INDIA
• INDIA, THAILAND
• MANY COUNTRIES

24
THE WAY FORWARD

• Introduce new vehicle mass emission standards
  - adopt stringent standards similar to India
  
• Introduce in-use standards to ensure proper
  vehicle maintenance.
• Build capacity for strong enforcement of
  standards
• Make lead free petrol abundantly available to
  facilitate use of catalytic converters
• Introduce supply of Low Smoke (JASO FC)
  2-stroke oil pre-mixed with petrol at filling
  stations to control excessive consumption of
  inferior oil to reduce smoke and PM emissions
  from 2-strokes engines
• Promote use of alternative fuels like CNG/LPG on
  three wheelers