Media imperialism, its critics, and its apologists - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

1 / 60
About This Presentation
Title:

Media imperialism, its critics, and its apologists

Description:

US and Western European-controlled TNCs dominate the world ... Jurassic Park, Planet of the Apes, Terminator. Titanic, The Perfect Storm. Mission Impossible ... – PowerPoint PPT presentation

Number of Views:1218
Avg rating:3.0/5.0
Slides: 61
Provided by: davidw9
Category:

less

Transcript and Presenter's Notes

Title: Media imperialism, its critics, and its apologists


1
Media imperialism, its critics, and its apologists
  • November 6, 2006

2
Media imperialism
  • Theory usually attributed to Herbert Schiller
    (1919-2000)
  • UCSD communication professor
  • Leading scholar of critical political economy of
    the media
  • Most influential publication
  • Mass Communication and American Empire (1969)

3
Schillers key claims
  • US and Western European-controlled TNCs dominate
    the world market (1-way flow)
  • All goods and services
  • And, most important, what he called
    communications-cultural output
  • What is often called modernization is in fact
    Westernization
  • Only one form of modernity is available

4
As a result
  • The media content produced and distributedaround
    the worldby these Western TNMCs
  • Promotes/develops popular support for
    values/artifacts of capitalism as a whole
  • And for TNCs in particular
  • Enables further growth/spread of Western economic
    interests

5
Taking this further
  • Worldwide exportation of Western TV shows and
    movies
  • Is like an electronic invasion of local
    cultures and lifestyles
  • Threatens to destroy local cultures, eroding
    historical traditions
  • Result the cultural and ideological
    homogenization of the world

6
The underlying idea
  • For a nation (say, the US!) to dominate the
    world
  • Its not necessary to take over by force
  • It may be easierand more desirableand certainly
    less bloody!to control images and opinions

7
Challenging/revising MI
  • Since Schiller, a number of critics have offered
    opposing views
  • Although still accept some basic premises of
    Schiller
  • particularly, that US is responsible for vast
    majority of media exports
  • many critics have countered with claims grounded
    in active audience and encoding/decoding
    theory

8
What do you think this means?
  • Even though media products are distributed
    worldwide, it doesnt mean
  • they affect everyone identically
  • everyone reads them the same way
  • Rather (critics of MI claim), audiences
  • Read them differently
  • Overlay their own cultural understandings
  • May be either oppressed by them or liberated by
    them

9
In other words
  • Lets not forget that magic bullet theory was
    discredited long ago!
  • Yet Schiller would have us believe that
    transnational media texts work just that way!
  • Lets consider some specific anti-MI (or post-MI)
    studies

10
Liebes Katz (1991) the Dallas study
  • Israel Arabs, Russian Jews, Moroccan Jews,
    Israeli kibbutz residents
  • US
  • Japan
  • Readings of Dallas varied depending on viewers
    cultural backgrounds
  • How real it seemed, cultural messages,
    political messages

11
Dallas study (ctd.)
  • Americans criticized how well/badly the story was
    written, produced, acted
  • Russians criticized politics (capitalism)
    inherent in Dallas
  • Arabs criticized dangers of Western culturethe
    moral degeneracy of US life

12
Dallas (ctd.) summary
  • Audiences draw on their own national/ ethnic
    identities when decoding TV shows
  • Decoding process may even strengthen an
    audiences sense of ethnic identity
  • You compare whats on the screen (for good or
    bad) to your own culture
  • And in doing so, become more in touch with who
    you are culturally

13
Studies in Africa
  • Davis Davis (1995) studied Moroccan youth
    exposed to Western TV (1980s-90s)
  • Found young paper re-imagined aspects of their
    own lives
  • Desire for more autonomy
  • Awareness of career options
  • New approaches to romantic relationships

14
US soap operas and traditional Zulu culture
  • Strelitz (2004) interviewed young man (Khulani)
    raised in South Africa in traditional Zulu family
  • From watching variety of US soaps, came to new
    understandings of
  • Male-female romantic relationships
  • Son-father relationships
  • Womens right to speak their minds

15
But a negotiated reading!
  • Khulani did not just accept or endorse every
    value he saw in US soaps
  • Rejected idea of 15-year-olds being in
    relationships
  • Rejected US approach to dealing with elderly

16
Another (non-media-specific) challenge to media
imperialism
  • MI assumes that prior to TV/movies
  • There was no contact between industrial West and
    more traditional cultures
  • Non-Western cultures were pure
  • Non-Western cultural values were/are universally
    superior to Western values

17
Reality
  • Theres been cross-cultural contact for centuries
  • Most forms of culture in the world are already
    hybridized
  • Many values of non-Western cultures are not
    necessarily admirable
  • e.g., how women are treated in many Arab
    cultures taboo against fathers and sons sharing
    feelings in Zulu culture

18
Another challenge glocalization
  • As weve seen with
  • Who Wants to Be a Millionaire?
  • Desperate Housewives
  • Even when US/European TV shows are exported,
    theyre usually adapted to make sense to local
    cultures

19
Another angle Promotional Culture
  • Even if the US-dominated media dont act as media
    imperialists
  • And even if audiences around the world read US
    media actively, and through their own cultural
    lenses
  • We cant deny that the worldwide explosion in
    media and popular culture texts are part of a
    larger trend promotional culture

20
Promotional culture
  • Media/cultural texts as consumer products
  • Media/cultural textsand visual imagery more
    broadlythat are used to create (and sell) brands
    and brand images
  • Media/cultural texts as both
  • Advertising-supported
  • Forms of advertising, themselves

21
Historical perspective
  • Its impossible to separate the invention,
    development, and growth of media from that of
    promotion (esp. advertising)
  • Newspapers
  • Radio
  • Television
  • The Internet

22
Parallel to growth of media
  • Has been the growth of the promotional
    professions
  • Advertising
  • Public relations
  • Sales promotion
  • And these professions themselves are increasingly
    pervasive and powerful
  • Examples?

23
Penetration of the promotion professions
  • So much more than simply the way sellers promote
    products to buyers
  • Promotion professions influence
  • Fashion, politics, policies, values, ideas
  • The development of market systems
  • The development of democracies
  • Our own, and those of other nations

24
All supply?or supply and demand?
  • Todd Gitlin considers this question
  • We know whats in it (media imperialism) for the
    TNMCs
  • But whats in it for the worlds media consumers?
  • That is, what is it about US media products that
    is uniquely appealing worldwide?

25
Gitlins Media Unlimited
  • Core arguments
  • Media engagement IS our lives
  • We are caught up in a flowor torrentof media
    images
  • The flow is global
  • And it emanates from the US
  • But why?beyond the obvious economic answers

26
American popular culture a global lingua franca
  • Analogous to (American) English being the worlds
    most common second language
  • American popular culture is the worlds most
    common second culture
  • It hasnt wiped out indigenous cultures
  • But it co-exists alongside them
  • Thus, around the world, peopleespecially young
    peopleare bicultural

27
The global semi-culture
  • People around the world dip into and out of the
    comforting, familiar, and highly accessible
    aspects of US popular culture
  • Movies, music, fast food, advertising, logos,
    brands, clothing styles

28
Whats the appeal?
  • A loose sort of social membership that requires
    little but a momentary (and monetary) surrender
  • Sampling American goods, images, and sounds,
    they affiliate with an empire of informality
  • Consuming a commodity, wearing a slogan or a
    logo, you affiliate with disaffiliation
  • What does this mean?

29
A limited-liability connection
  • You just borrow some of the effervescence of
    the American ethos
  • You hope to be recognized as one of the elect
  • That is, at no big cost to you, you get to
    borrow Americanness
  • And its various associations
  • What are those associations?

30
The supply side
  • Percentage of US-produced media products non-US
    revenues (in 2000)
  • Theatrical movie releases 51
  • TV shows 41
  • Videos 27
  • As weve seen, once enough copies are made for
    the huge US market, additional copies for non-US
    market are cheap to make

31
But this isnt a new phenomenon
  • 1925 90 of movies shown in UK, NZ, Australia,
    Brazil, Mexico, and many other countries were
    US-made films
  • Percentages dropped in the 1930s
  • But European devastation of WW2 made it harder
    for Europe to recover its popular culture
    industries
  • So US swept in again

32
The non-US side of supply side
  • More than ever, non-US music, TV shows, movies,
    etc
  • Reflect US influence, are built on US formulas
  • Westerns, hip-hop, action heroes, soap operas
  • Why?
  • US formulas are proven successes

33
But the supply side doesnt tell the whole
story!
  • This is Gitlins key argument
  • To understand success of US pop culture around
    the world, we must look at the demand side
  • Why do non-US audiences want/love US pop cultural
    products?

34
Put another way
  • What is it about US pop-cultural products that
    resonates so strongly with non-US audiences (as
    well as US)?

35
Some of Gitlins explanations
  • Our own culture is in fact multi-cultural,
    multi-lingual
  • US is a melting pot
  • Still highly heterogeneous
  • To be successful here, our pop-culture products
    have to speak to a wildly diverse population

36
So-called US culture is itself multicultural
  • Our most popular music and dance
  • Derives from descendants of African slaves, among
    others
  • Our comic sense
  • Derives from the English, Eastern European Jews,
    African Americans, Hispanics
  • Our stories
  • From everywhere

37
US culture is populist
  • Unlike in Western Europe, popular culture in US
    never had to compete against entrenched high
    culture
  • Unlike in Western Europe, producing music, art,
    stories, etc. purely to entertain was never
    considered bad or low
  • Culture as entertainmentas funwas never
    seriously looked down upon

38
And now
  • With English (esp. American English) as the
    worlds most popular second language
  • It is the language of business
  • It is the language of media
  • But much of US pop culture is not language-based
  • It is visual-image-based
  • And visual images translate even easier than
    language (think action movies)

39
Why else does American pop culture export so
easily?
  • Much of it is NOT truly American
  • Consider recent Disney films
  • Little Mermaid
  • Lion King
  • Mulan
  • Beauty and the Beast
  • Aladdin
  • Pinocchio

40
Why else does American pop culture export so
easily?
  • Much of it is NOT American in origin
  • Consider recent Disney films
  • Little Mermaid Denmark
  • Lion King Africa
  • Mulan China
  • Beauty and the Beast France
  • Aladdin Arabia
  • Pinocchio Italy

41
How American are our directors and stars?
  • Alfred Hitchcock, Charlie Chaplin, Michael
    Curtiz, Ridley Scott, Ang Lee
  • Cary Grant, Sean Connery, Arnold Schwarzenegger,
    Kate Winslet, Catherine Zeta-Jones, Antonio
    Banderas

42
How American are our movies locations?
  • Star Wars, Alien, Star Trek
  • Jurassic Park, Planet of the Apes, Terminator
  • Titanic, The Perfect Storm
  • Mission Impossible

43
Gitlins 3 formulas
  • Many US movie and TV genres/formulas that have
    succeeded globally
  • Cop stories, horror films, ensemble melodramas,
    beach movies, romantic comedies, soap operas,
    sci-fi, spy films
  • But 3 in particular are at the core of
    Hollywoods global appeal
  • Westerns, action movies, and cartoons

44
Westerns core narrative and thematic elements
  • Mix of primitivism, romance, individualism,
    patriotism, moral purity, civilization taming
    wilderness
  • Hero
  • outsider without a past
  • plainspoken skeptic
  • straight-shooter who sees through pretense
  • friend of the downtrodden

45
The eternal appeal of Westerns
  • News reports and novels in US since 17th century
  • Buffalo Bill Cody (1880s-1910s) performs for
    pope, Queen Victoria, packed houses in Europe

46
Earliest days of film and TV
  • The Great Train Robbery (1903)
  • 20 of US films1910 17 in 1931-35
  • TV in 1959 Westerns are 24 of prime-time
    offerings
  • Consistently among top-rated shows through early
    1970s
  • So where are Westerns today?

47
Westerns today
  • Dirty Harry, Star Wars, Blade Runner
  • 60 Minutes (and other investigative TV
    journalism)
  • Good guy breezes into town, uncovers evil,
    defends the community
  • Urban action movies, TV cop showsthe Westerns
    of today
  • Dangerous frontiers saved by brave, independent
    loners from outside

48
Why wouldnt this capture imaginations worldwide?
  • The rugged individualist in service of the
    community
  • The person who reinvents himself (or herself)
  • The hero who masters the wilderness

49
Or, similarly, the road movie
  • Hero flees community
  • Roots are traps
  • Re-invent yourself (or find yourself) as you go
    along
  • Born to be wild

50
Action movies
  • Variety of sub-genres
  • Rogue cop adventure, Vietnam vet revenge,
    futuristic hot pursuit, Eastern martial arts,
    battle epic, others
  • But what do they have in common?
  • Kinetic shock
  • Disposable sensation jolt of fear, rageful
    satisfaction of revenge

51
Action movies payoff the quintessential now
phenomenon
  • Objective to jab, startle, shock
  • Problem by now, were all over-stimulatednothing
    shocks us
  • So action movies have to keep raising the stakes
  • What happens, as a result?

52
Action films domesticate brutality
  • Safe in our comfy seats with our popcorn, we test
    our toughness
  • Were cut loose from the gravity of real life
  • Can experience violence in a way that puts us at
    no risk
  • Get to vicariously live out our aggressions and
    yet always survive
  • We can master violence in the cinema in a way
    increasingly cant in real life

53
Cartoons
  • Packaged innocence
  • As epitomized by Disney, the master of efficient,
    factory-like production of cheery, chirpy fun
  • Clean, safe, innocent, and shallow
  • But there must be more

54
What explains the hold of US-made cartoon(ish)
fiction around the world?
  • American mass culture appeals to
  • The child the audience would like to be
  • The child they remember being
  • The child they still feel themselves at times to
    be
  • Universally shared experience being young,
    biologically dependent, playful, naĂŻve

55
America the eternal child?
  • Were the child of the West
  • The youngest of civilizations
  • Cherished and despised globally for this
  • But our cartoons ability to speak to the
    universal experiencehaving been a child in a
    world run by adultshits a universal nerve
  • We all protect our young, and thus respond
    positively to anything that smacks of juvenility

56
The other pleasures of cartoons
  • Twitting authority
  • The joy of being the little guy who thumbs his
    nose at power
  • The joys of flouting social convention
  • And who better than Americans at having fun,
    making fun, being fun?

57
Transcending genres other traits of US pop
culture products
  • Celebration of material excess costumes, cars,
    technical wizardry, excessively perfect
    bodies/faces
  • And the lushness of productions themselves
  • At the same time, the rich and powerful in US
    movies are almost always vulnerable
  • Leaving audiences satisfied with their own lives
    when the mighty (on screen) fall

58
Transgressions and happy endings
  • Regardless of genre, many US movies pit the
    little guy (or little gal) up against more
    powerful forces
  • And the little guy/gal wins
  • US films often contain speaking truth to power,
    David vs. Goliath element
  • Not just individualism
  • But anti-authoritarianism and rambunctiousness

59
Comfort and convenience
  • Popularity and pure entertainment have always
    been foremost for US producers of popular culture
  • Especially appealing now, in an age increasingly
    jarring, multi-tasking, schizophrenic

60
But this doesnt mean local cultures are being
eradicated
  • To Gitlin, the emergence of a global semiculture
    co-exists with local sensibilitiesit does not
    simply replace them
  • Our movies (and TV shows) speak to our desires
    for convenience, escape, and play
  • And, overall, our desires to feel
  • To feel good, to feel with others, to feel
    conveniently
Write a Comment
User Comments (0)
About PowerShow.com