Title: Cancer Pain Management: Alternative Treatment Options to the Use of Narcotics
1Cancer Pain Management Alternative Treatment
Options to the Use of Narcotics
- Bernard J. Lapointe
- Chief, Palliative Care Division
- Associate Professor, Department of Oncology
Department of Family Medicine, McGill University
2Disclosure
- Collaborated to clinical research sponsored by
- Janssen-Ortho
- Wex Technology
- Lab Pharma
- Pfizer
- Clinical advisor
- Janssen-Ortho
- Purdue Pharma
- Wex Technology
- Pharmascience
- Received in the past speaker fees from
- Janssen-Ortho
- Purdue Pharma
3Cancer Pain
- Significantly affects the diagnosis, quality of
life and survival of patients with cancer. - Cancer Pain can arise
- Direct tumour infiltration/ involvement
- Result of diagnostic / therapeutic surgery
- Side effect or toxicity of therapies
- Mechanism-Based Understanding of Cancer Induced
Pain is helping us designing targetted
therapeutic approaches.
4Todays agenda
- Genesis of the signal in the periphery
- Pain secondary to bone metastasis
- Neuropathic pain
- The interneurone
- Normal pain
- Central sensitization
- Central integrationtotal pain
5Can we relieve cancer pain ?
- Pain relief is now possible in 90 of patients
with relatively simple approaches. - Optimal relief is achieved in remaining 10 using
a slightly more complicated approach - multitherapy
- anaesthetic approaches
- No single drug is likely to be completely
effective in managing persistent cancer induced
pain.
6Treatment Options for Chronic Cancer Pain
7The Treatment Continuum
More available
Less available
Less expensive
More expensive
Fewer side effects
More side effects
Less invasive
More invasive
Physical
Psychological
Pharmacological
Interventional
8Pharmacological management of cancer pain
9The Opioids
10Opioids for cancer induced pain
- Experience suggest that cancer pain can be
relieved in more than 70 of patients using a
simple opioid-based regimen. - Despite all the fears of respiratory depression,
addiction or diversion, opioids have never been
shown to cause organ damage when taken
therapeutically - Some pain may impart a relatively lesser degree
of opioid responsiveness -
11(No Transcript)
12Adjuvant analgesics
- Adjuvant any drug with a primary indication
other than pain, but with analgesic properties in
some painful conditions. - Often administered as first-line drugs in the
treatment of chronic non-malignant pain. - Conventional practice has evolved to view opioids
as first-line drugs, and adjuvant analgesics
typically are considered after opioid therapy has
been optimized.
13Transduction
S.P. c.g.r.p
Tumor
Prostaglandins Endothelins NGF
Damage Inflammation Plasma leakage
Bk
Immune cells
PGe2
cytokines.
Primary Nociceptor Afferent C Fiber
14(No Transcript)
15Dealing with inflammation
16corticosteroids
- Very useful when there is a pain crisis
- cooling effect
- Relative risks and benefits of the various
corticosteroids are unknown - Dexamethasone is often selected because of low
mineralo-corticoid - Methylprednisolone
17- Long term corticosteroid is generally well
tolerated - may increase the risk of peptic ulcer disease (
role for proton-pump inhibitor) - the concurrent administration of an NSAID and a
corticosteroid increases the risk of peptic ulcer
substantially - Corticosteroid drugs have several other
indication (capsular distension, hollow viscus
obstruction, headache sec brain mets, sudden
nerve compression) -
18NSAIDS including COX-2 inhibitors
- NSAIDS exert both
- Anti-inflammatory
- Analgesic
- By inhibiting PG synthesis via the COX enzyme
- Indiscriminate inhibition of COX activity leads
to a range of undesirable side-effects (including
gi ulceration-bleeding)
19Non-steroidal anti-inflammatory agents
- Ceiling effect
- start treatment at the lowest recommended dose
- wide inter-individual variability
- monitor closely patients ( acute renal
insufficiency) - Cytoprotection of gastric mucosa is indicated
- Clear evidence to support superior safety or
efficacy of one NSAID over another is lacking.
20NSAIDs in Chronic PainThe Risk of GI Toxicity
- 4 risk of P/U/B per year
- 12 risk of P/U/B per year with concomitant use
of SSRI - Taking an NSAID for two months or more
- 1 in 5 risk of endoscopic ulcer
- 1 in 70 risk of symptomatic ulcer
- 1 in 150 risk of bleeding ulcer
- 1 in 1200 risk of dying from a bleeding ulcer
- Risk factors
- Highly significant risks previous history of
ulcer or bleed, age 50, - Less significant risks females, prednisone,
alcoholic liver disease, NSAIDs in combination,
COPD and other chronic diseases
McQuay HJ, Moore RA. In Proceedings of the 10th
World Congress on Pain. Jonathon O. et al.
Progress in Pain Research and Management Volume
24, pp 499-510, IASP Press, Seattle.
21NSAIDs better than COXIBs ?
- Optimal analgesia may require COX I and COX II1
- Increased risk of CV events with COXIBs2, 3,4
- COXIBs block prostacyclen but not thromboxane5
- COXIBs have no antiplatelet activity and do not
substitute for ASA - Delayed healing of fractures in animals6
-
1. McCormack, 2002 2. Mukheriee D. Jama 2001
3. Howard PA, Jam Coll Cardiol, 2004 4. Topol
E, NEJM 2004 5. Marcus A.J. NEJM 2002 6. Simon
AM. JBMR 2002
22however
- COX-2 inhibitors significantly decrease both
ongoing and movement related pain (bone
metastasis induced pain) - Acute administration of COX-2 inhibitors reduces
PG - Chronic inhibition of COX-2
- Decreases osteoclastogenesis
- Decreases bone resorption
- Decreases tumour burden
23Mantyh Nature Reviews Neuroscience 7, 797809
(October 2006) doi10.1038/nrn1914
24Acidosis in bone cancer pain
- Osteoclasts contribute significantly to aetiology
of bone cancer pain - Osteoclasts maintain acidic micro-environment
- Both osteolytic and osteoblastic cancers are
characterized by osteoclast proliferation and
hypertrophy - Role for biphosphonate
- Zoledronic acid, pamidronate, Alendronate,
- ibandronate
- Promising role for osteoprotegerin (OPG) which
prevents activation and proliferation of
osteoclasts.
25Other adjuvant analgesics for bone pain
- Calcitonin limited evidence does not support
its use to control pain from bone mets. - New targets in development
- Endothelin antagonists (prostate cancer)
- Nerve growth factor
26Pain afferent pathways
27Neuronal damage
- Direct invasion
- Compression
- changes in function of Na channels appear within
24hrs of the injury - lower threshold
- reduced recuperation time
28- All anticonvulsants
- 1. block voltage gated sodium channels
- 2. directly or indirectly enhance inhibitory
GABA-ergic neurotransmission or - 3. inhibit excitatory glutamatergic
neurotransmission - or some combination of the above
29Anticonvulsant drugs Gabapentin.
- Good evidence that the anticonvulsant drugs are
useful in the management of neuropathic pain. - Expanding role for the anticonvulsants began with
the introduction of gabapentin. It is now widely
used to treat cancer-related neuropathic pain.
NNT 2,2 - Advantages - proven analgesic effect
- good tolerability
- rarity of drug-drug interactions
- first line agent
- initiated 100-300 up to 3,600
- adequate trial 1-2 weeks at the maximum tolerated
dose. - Somnolence can be a limiting factor.
30- Lamotrigine. Was reported to relieve
non-malignant neuropathic in several randomized
trials. However adverse effects ( somnolence,
dizziness, ataxia) require slow titration.
Potential for Stevens-Johnson syndrome. - Pregabalin with a mechanism identical to that of
gabapentin and strong evidence of analgesic
efficacy. Multi-centre study for cancer induced
bone pain. Lack significant drug-drug
interactions. - Among the older drugs, evidence of efficacy is
best for carbamazepine , phenytoin, valproate. - Frequent side-effects (sedation,
dizziness,nausea, unsteadiness) and potential for
drug-drug interactions, use has declined.
31- Voltage-gated ion channel modulators sodium
channel blockers - intravenous lidocaine
- oral mexiletine
- there are at least ten identified sodium channel
subtypes
32Oral and parenteral local anesthetics
- Due to their potential for serious side effects,
second line therapies reserved for crescendo
neuropathic pain. - Brief infusion of xylocaine. 1-5mg /kg over
30min. ecg monitoring. - If appears to be effective, oral local
anesthetic, mexilitine. - Role of Lidocaine 5 transdermal patch is
unclear.
33Spinal cord the Pain Gate
- Sensory signals are carried to the dorsal horn
- Excitatory inter-neurones
- The spinal cord relays signal to the brain
- Dorsal horn is the site of a two-way network the
gate - either allows the signal to pass unadjusted,
dampens the signal or boosts it.
34(No Transcript)
35(No Transcript)
36Acetaminophen
- Inhibitor of COX-3
- Used for mild-moderate nociceptive pain
- Evidence in post-op pain
- A single dose of 1000 mg had an NNT of 3.8
(3.4-4.4) for at least 50 pain relief over 4-6
hours in patients with moderate or severe pain (a
single dose of 600-650 mg had an NNT of 4.6) - May use in combination with opioids for more
severe pain - Dose ceiling with short-term use of 4gm / day
- (12 x 325mg)
Case, 2003 Zimmerman, 1995, 2000 Bromer, 2003
Perneger, 1994 Garcia Rodriguez, 2001 FDA
Sept. 2002 Health Canada Feb. 2003 Curhan 2002.
37Acetaminophen Chronic Pain
- No placebo-controlled evidence in chronic pain
(usually compared to other study meds) - Recent concerns re
- hepatic toxicity
- renal toxicity
- Long-term risk of renal impairment
- Medium to high risk if 1000 tablets and 2
pills per day - Restricting dosage to incidence of ESRD by 8-10
Case, 2003 Zimmerman, 1995, 2000 Bromer, 2003
Perneger, 1994 Garcia Rodriguez, 2001 FDA
Sept. 2002 Health Canada Feb. 2003 Curhan 2002.
38Acetaminophen- Suggested Dose Ceilings
- 4 gm/day short-term use in healthy patients
- 3.2 gm / day chronically in healthy patients
- 2.6 gm / day chronically in at risk patients
- Daily alcohol consumption, warfarin, fasting, a
low protein diet, cardiac or renal disease
increase the risk of hepatotoxicity
Latta, 2000 http//pain.mc.duke.edu/mild_pain.cfm
39Tramadol
- Synthetic analgesic developped by Grunenthal in
1962. - Used clinically since 1977 in Germanyl, 1995 in
the US, 1997 in the UK, in Canada since 2005. - Tramadol is a racemic mix of 2 enantiomers ()
tramadol and (-) tramadol. - Was for a long time considered as a weak opioid,
we now know that it has at least 3 mechanisms of
action, at the interneurone.
40(No Transcript)
41Tramadol for neuropathic pain
- Recent meta-analysis (2005) from The Cochrane
Collaboration - NNT 3,5
- Significant impact on
- Paresthesia
- Allodynia
- Pain to touch
- Conclusion Tramadol is useful for the
managment of neuropathic pain
42Tramacet in Canada
- Association of 2 analgesics
- Acétaminophen 325mg
- Tramadol 37,5mg
- Indication management of acute pain
- However extensive litterature on its use for
cancer pain. - Suggested dosage
- 1-2 tabs qid
- Maximum daily dosage 8/day
- In the elderly start slow go slow
43Tramadol/acétaminophen
Effets indésirables
(Rosenthal et al., JAGS 2004)
44Antidepressant drugs
- Tertiary amines ( amitriptyline, imipramine,
doxepin, clomipramine) and the secondary amines
(nortriptyline, desipramine) are analgesics. - 10-25mg qhs as starting dose, usual effective
dose 50-150 qhs. - Tricyclic may be limited by occurrence of
side-effects - sedation, confusion
- orthostatic hypotension
- weight gain
- tachycardia, arrhythmia,
- anticholinergic effects ( dry mouth, blurred
vision, urinary hesitancy) - patients who have significant heart disease
should not be treated with a tricyclic.
45- The secondary amine tricyclic (desipramine-nortrip
tyline) are less anticholinergic and better
tolerated. - Beneficial analgesic effect is usually observed
within a week after achieving an effective dose
of tricyclic. - Other antidepressants
- Some evidence from randomized controlled trials
that several other antidepressants are
analgesic.However this evidence is far less than
that which supports the efficacy of tricyclic. - Indication for patients with neuropathic pain
whose response to opioids has been inadequate,
also justified when pain is accompanied by
depression. - Sedating tricyclic insomnia
- Anxiolytic SSRIs anxious
- Bupropion sedated or fatigued patients.
46Alpha2-adrenergic agonists
- Alpha-2 adrenergic agonists. (clonidine)
- Supporting data is limited and the potential for
side-effects ( somnolence and hypotension) is
relatively great. - Trials of these drugs are considered after others
have proved ineffective. - Intraspinal clonidine has been shown to reduce
pain. - Potential role for tizanidine (Zanaflex) an
antispasticity agent.
47cannabinoids
48DISCOVERIES
- 1964 ?9-THC identified as main psychoactive
ingredient of the Cannabis Sativa plant - 1988 CB1 receptor identified (A. Howlett and W.
Devane) - 1990 CB1 is cloned and found located in the
brain (L. Matsuda and M. Herkenham et al.) - 1992 Anandamide is discovered_ a naturally
occurring substance in the brain that acts on
cannabinoid receptors (R. Mechoulam and W.
Devane) - CB2 receptor is identified (Kaminski)
- 1993 CB2 receptor is cloned (S. Munro)
- 1998 Endogenous ligands shown to be analgesic
Mack 2001
49ACTION ON SYSTEMS
- Pain pathway Cannabinoids
- Serotoninergic Stimulation suppresses GABA
- Norepinephrine Stimulation suppresses GABA
- Glutamate/NMDA Blocks NMDA in dorsal horn
- Inflammatory Response Blocks inflammatory
action of -
Prostaglandins and substance P - Opiate System Act on opioid
receptors kappa, delta and
mu
Russo E. Pain management A practical guide for
clinicians. 31 - 2002. 357-375
50SYNERGY WITH OPIOID
- THC enhances the potency of opioids such as
morphine. - Studies have determined that the analgesic effect
of THC is, at least in part, mediated through
delta and kappa opioid receptors, indicating an
intimate connection between cannabinoid and
opioid signaling pathways in the modulation of
pain perception.
Cichewick D., 2004
51PHARMACOKINETIC
Néron 2001, Product monographs 2005
52Other systemic drugs
- Baclofen (GABA agonist) 20mg-200mg/day
- Sedating
- Attention to withdrawal reaction
- Benzodiazepines conflicting evidence
- Psychostimulants
- Dextroamphetamine
- Methylphenidate 2,5-5mg am-pm po
- Caffeine
- Neuroleptics not recommended as adjuvant
analgesics unless agitated delirium
53Central Sensitization
- Facilitate the transmission and conscious
awarenes of both noxious and non-noxious sensory
information - Progresive neurochemical and cellular remodelling
of both the peripheral and central nervous
systems
54Chronic pain is not merely a temporal extension
of acute pain
- neuroplasticity
- synaptic potentiation
- wind up
- sensitization (hyperalgia / allodynia)
- additional nerve connections can develop in the
spine in response to chronic pain, boosting the
number of channels carrying the signal - neurotransmitters can also increase in number. A
more powerful pain signal manages to bridge the
synapses between the nerves
55(No Transcript)
56N-methyl-D-Aspartate Receptor blockers
- Antagonist at the nmda receptor may offer another
novel approach to the treatment of neuropathic
pain in cancer patients. - Dextromethorphan
- Ketamine
- Amantadine
- Memantine
- Most of these drugs have been shown to have
analgesic effects in non-malignant neuropathic
pain.
57NMDA receptors antagonists
- Ketamine, iv or po is effective in relieving
cancer pain and reducing opioid requirements. - The side-effect profile of ketamine can be
daunting. - Starting dose 0,1-0,15mg/kg/hr by brief infusion
or by sc infusion. - Oral administration is easy, 11 ratio
- It is also recommended to lower the opioid dose
when starting ketamine. - Dextromethorphan 45-60mg /day up to 1g.
- Amantadine, limited data.
- Memantine. Controlled trials have been
disappointing so far.
58New interest for methadone
- Acts clinically as an antagonist of the NMDA
receptor. - Indicated for troublesome neuropathic pain
syndromes.
59Pain prevention ?
- Early detection
- Early intervention
- will prevent the development of plasticity and
chronicity of the pain syndrome
60Superior cortex
- Cognitive factors
- e.g. past experience of pain / conditioning
- Psychological factors
- pain tresholds (sensation, perception,
tolerance, tolerance with encouragement) - personality
- meaning of pain
- anxiety / depression
61Total Pain
- Physical
- emotional / psychological
- social
- spiritual
62- To Cure Sometimes,
- To Relieve Often,
- To Comfort Always,
- Anonymous author, XVI century