Title: A Year of Change, a Return to APIC
1- A Year of Change, a Return to APICs Roots!
- Annual Membership Meeting
- Association of Professional Investment
Consultants - June 9, 2005
2Association of Professional Investment
Consultants (APIC) Organizational Chart 2005-2006
APIC Membership
Updated June 9,2005
Committees and Chairperson (s)
Professional Development Janet Bolton
Private Wealth Management
Research Evaluation Kent Cox
Conference Oversight Elaina Spilove
Technology Jon Webster
Legal and Regulatory John Collier
Membership Jim Gill
Corporate Services Brian Penzel
Website/ Street Smarts Tom Davis
Endowment/ Foundation
Oracle Bill Teeple Barbara Griffin
Endowment/ Foundation gt25 Million Lori Van
Dusen Scott Thayer
gt 5 Million Steve Thacker Scott Wilson
Endowment/ Foundation lt 25 Million Doug Berger
lt 5 Million Susan Yelen
Agenda Planning 2006 Gregg Paulson Jeff Wigbells
Logistics Planning 2006 Elaina Spilove
Susan Yelen Brian Kelly Bob Scherer
Lori Van Dusen Scott Thayer Doug Berger
Janet Bolton
George Dunn
Elaina Spilove
Brian Hein
Skip Sussman
Mark Curtis
Al Eaton
Mike Engel
Committee Board Liaisons
Governance Paul Compton
APIC Board of Directors
Secretary/Treas Douglas Berger
President/ Spokesperson Chris Aitken
Executive Committee
Pres. Elect/VP Tim Kneen
Past President Jim Pupillo
Nominating Tim Kneen
Finance Comm. Douglas Berger
Best Practices Tim Kneen Phil Shaffer
Advisory Group Jim Pupillo Chris Aitken
Steering Committee Jim Pupillo
Exec Director Eric Scharf
President George Bush once said Great Leaders
are defined by those people around them..
Association Staff
3Welcome Newly Elected Board MembersThree-year
terms
Janet Bolton, Chicago, IL Steve Thacker,
Baltimore, MD Mike Engel, Washington, D.C. Phil
Shaffer, Columbus, OH
Appointed one-year term Skip Sussman, San
Rafael, CA
Special Thanks to Outgoing Board Members
Sandee Smith, Kansas City, MO Mike Melko,
Chicago, IL
4Honoring our Charter Members
- Chris Aitken
- Bill Ankeny
- Dan Biederman
- Ed Clissold
- Rusty Cooer
- Mark Curtis
- George Dunn
- Larry Eckstrom
- Barry Giller
- Rich Gleason
- Austin Heberger
- Kathleen Hegenbart
- Mary Lynne Hickey
- Laree Hulsoff
- Steve Jackson
- Brian Kelly, Sr.
- Ted Lucien
- Chris Poch
- Dan Rolan
- Mike Sasser
- Robert Scherer
- John Scott
- Sandee Smith
- Gene Trudeen
- Jeff Wigbels
- Howard Zumsteg
5A Year in Review
- Rewrote APICs Mission Statement and five-year
Strategic Plan including new membership criteria - Made structural changes to the conference
- Dramatically reduced APICs expenses
- Created new committees
- Partnered with the Firm on new initiatives
- Developed Professional Standards Guide
6Accomplishments in 2004 - 2005
- Governance Committee
- Facilitated the 5 year strategic planning effort
including new membership standards. - Developed Board Orientation Program
- Continued improvements to the Board Operating
Manual - Finance Committee
- Established a Finance/Audit Committee Doug
Berger, Bob Scherer, Paul Compton George Dunn - Developing a records retention and emergency back
up/recovery procedure. - Produced a new APIC budget for the recently
adopted policy that avoids potential conflicts of
interest
7Accomplishments in 2004 - 2005
- Conference Oversight Committee
- Planned the 2005 Annual Educational Conference in
Naples, FL on June 9 10, 2005 with an
attendance of more than 230 members present. . - Reoriented the conference away from an event
supported by and involving the providers of money
management services to a self-supporting program
paid for directly by the membership - Initiated planning for the 2006 conference,
- Legal/Regulatory Committee
- FC Team Agreement
- Franchise Protection Plan (FPP)
- Staff Compensation
- Outside software programs
- Personal Computers NNPC (Non-Networked Personal
Computers) - PWM lt 5 Million Committee
- Integrated Wealth Management. 33 Done, 3 out of
9 items completed - Inconsistencies in Tax Reporting Done, 9 out of
12 items completed - Friction List from 2004. 28 Done, 21out of 75
items completed
8Accomplishments in 2004 - 2005
- Steering Committee
- Worked with the Governance Committee to complete
the development of the Strategic Plan - Continued development of the Industry
Professional Standards project which has
included - a. Fine tuning and dissemination of the Code of
Ethics - b. Finalization of the Professional Standards
Guide which will be ready for release at the
Annual Conference. - Oversaw the development of the Industry Advisory
Council (IAC) - Research/Evaluation Committee
- 50 additional managers covered in CES year to
date along with several level commitments.
- An improved salary and bonus structure was put in
place which has improved morale and reduced
turnover in the research department. - Consideration is being given to a second tier of
investment managers who will work for a fee level
between FS and their current fee with lower
minimums. This would improve our access to high
quality managers.
9Accomplishments in 2004 - 2005
- Foundation/Endowment lt 25 Million Committee
- Developed Initial Committee Responses,
- Developed Priorities for this committee to pursue
- a. Support CG in developing marketing materials
for this market - b. Support development of better RFP Response
Capabilities ( Will assist CG in populating it's
new software "The RFP Machine") - c. Support development of Finals Presentation
Resources - d. Focus on Marketing Opportunities -
Philanthropic Services - Rockefeller
Philanthropic Advisors - Industry Advisory Council
- Building a Culture that embraces Ethics and
Professional Standards - Portfolio Construction
- Behavioral Finance Research
- Member Internet Services Committee
- Worked with StreetSmarts technology provider,
Involve Technology, to enhance its member
communication tool with improved features and
usability. These include - Reworked the categories in the Website Members
Exchange to conform with StreetSmarts and then
placed all of the current items into the
categories with descriptive information. - Reworked the committee report module to make it
easier to post reports.
10Accomplishments in 2004 - 2005
- Membership Committee
- Performed and reported major study of membership
composition - Researched and recommended new Qualifications for
Membership - Created presentation/assisted with Board
Membership campaign - Since July 2004, responded to 123 applications of
which 91 were recommended for approval by the
Board. APIC began the year with 372 Voting
members and 168 Non-Voting members as of May 30,
2005 there were 223 Voting members and 108
Non-Voting members. - Worked with the Internet Members Services
Committee to implement further upgrades to Online
Application Process and continued the process of
improving and simplifying the Online Application
Process
11New Mission and Five-Year Plan
A Community of Colleagues Fostering
Professionalism Through a Culture of Consulting
12APIC Membership Requirements Effective January 1,
2005
- In order to qualify for voting membership, a
member must have one of the following
credentials - Senior Institutional Consultant (SIC)
- Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA) 06/2005
- Certified Investment Management Analyst (CIMA)
- Private Wealth Management Advisor (PWMA)
- Corporate Client Group Director (CCG Dir.)
- Senior Investment Management Consultant (SIMC)
- Individuals who were voting members prior to
January 1, 2005, and do not possess any of these
credentials will have two years from 1/1/05 to
obtain one of the listed credentials OR, members
will be grandfathered if they have been members
in good standing for at least five years as of
1/1/05.
13Structural Changes to the Conference
- Avoid all perception of conflicts of interest
- APIC no longer accepts investment advisor
sponsorships for any functions - Return APIC to its roots, when the conference was
educationally focused featuring FCs exchanging
ideas and networking - APIC members will be the beneficiaries of
Returning to Our Roots and to spending more
time sharing ideas with our friends and fellow
practitioners
14Budgetary Changes
- Conference last year netted a surplus for APIC.
With that reserve we were able to make needed
changes - We cut over 150k from the budget including over
75k from conference planning, over 10k from
meetings, 21k from printing, 15,000 by having
the firm absorb the cost of FundFire and 8k from
credit card fees - Today we are a leaner organization, completely
focused on providing value to our colleagues You
the APIC member
15New Committees New Problem Solving
- Best Practices Committee is generating great
ideas that are shared with the entire membership - George Dunns ideas on allocating to commodities
- Scott Thayers finals presentations, etc.
- Professional Development Committee
- Committed to raising the knowledge level and
differentiating our practices - The Mitch Anthony Program that was conducted
today - New management structure at APIC Exec team will
stay for another year to provide continuity
during this current transition period - Chris Aitken, President
- Tim Kneen, President-Elect, June 2006
- Jim Pupillo, Past President 2004
- Doug Berger, Secretary and Treasurer
- Elaina Spilove, Conference Oversight
16Partnering with The Firm
- FundFire cost savings
- Board meetings held at CG and other firm events
to create cost sharing - Top priorities list
- Conference planning
172005 - 2006 Top Priorities of APIC
- Create and/or buy Performance Reporting that is
accurate and the standard of the industry. - Research
- Change structure and expand research capabilities
- Focus on adding managers that add Alpha
- Collaborate with 18 manager analysts in Private
Bank - Expand asset classes to include more alternatives
- Umbrella Pricing
- Expand Advisor to include all products and
asset classes - Friction Items
- Tax Recordkeeping and Reporting
- Questionnaires
- Qualitative and Quantitative Client Discovery
Process - Improved Risk Questionnaires integrating
behavioral finance - Comprehensive Fee Calculator with transparency
including all discretionary and non discretionary
fee based solutions - Industry Custodial Reporting
- Deliver a workable strategy
18Looking Forward Our Challenges
- APIC is only as good as how involved its members
are. - We need to find ways to engage each of you!
- Your Board of Directors has Committed to
- Run a financially tight ship with the elimination
of investment advisor sponsorships - Better communicate to the membership more of what
each committee is doing and what APIC is
accomplishing - Encourage a free flow of idea sharing using
cutting edge technology that addresses the
usability issues with the old Chalkboard list
serve and current StreetSmarts system. - Continue to attract the best practitioners to APIC
19Looking Forward Our Challenges
- Continue to push the firm to provide us with the
latest in technology at the branch and for the
mobile consultant - Continue to push the firm on our highest
priorities and items that enhance best practices
like team training - Continue to push the firm to be leaders in the
investment management consulting industry and not
be satisfied with past success - Insist that the Firm execute on what they promise
us they will do
20- Paul Compton
- Chair, APIC Governance Committee
- Board Liaison, Membership Committee
- Led the APIC Board of Directors through the
Strategic Planning Process and implementation of
its key elements - that will bring APIC
- Back to the Future
21Association of Professional Investment Consultants
- A community of colleagues
- fostering professionalism
- through a culture of consulting
22Structure
- Professional Association
- Bylaws, Policy and Governance, Procedures
- Professional Expectations of members
- Qualifications Skill-set
- Committees of members principal activity
- Standing Committees
- Functional Committees
- Annual Educational Conference
23Vision
- In a dynamic world, our clients, our firm and our
industry need professional financial consultants
who respond to their needs with customized
comprehensive solutions. - Our association supports an atmosphere of
intellectual accomplishment and encourages
reciprocal exchange of ideas. - Our passion for perfection enhances the financial
consultants effectiveness and the quality of the
clients experience. - APIC is the communication link between unified
financial consultants and Smith Barneys senior
management.
24Mission
- APIC
- advocates for our standards and for our members
needs - innovates to provide creative solutions to client
problems - educates to raise the skill of its members and
- communicates to support free interchange of our
best practices, ideas and information, and to
build the collective wisdom of our members and
our association.
25Core Values
- Client-Centered business practices
- Highest ethical standards
- Collaborative, professional colleagues
- academically inquisitive thinkers who share our
intellectual capital - State-of-the-art solutions
- for our clients and our consulting practices
- Advocate
- dedicated to being a positive influence within
our firm - a unified voice representing the business needs
of the membership
26Education Professional Development
- Best Content Systems for Development
- Best Practices Committee
- Innovative Educational Content
- Educational Conferences
- Members Practices
- Outside Industry Leaders
- Align Educational Content with CG Track
- FCs prepared to qualify
- Professional Development Committee
- Electronic Communication
27Advocacy
- Stakeholders
- Inform the Firm
- Profitable use of Firm capital
- A willing, qualified membership
- Support Program-oriented Committees
- Industry Advisory Council
- Behavioral Finance
- Portfolio Construction
- Professional Standards Guide
28Communication
- Unified communication strategy
- Oracle upgrade / APIC Journal
- Website upgrade path
- Media relations
- APIC archives publish history
- Annually itemize accomplishments
29Innovation
- Drive change by teaching innovations
- Ongoing member prospecting
- Conference content
- Industry Advisory Council
30Member Expectations
- Share the Vision
- Professional Standards
- Ethical Practices
- Leadership
- Committee Service
- Challenge
- Natural talent willing to learn
31Association of Professional Investment Consultants
- A community of colleagues
- fostering professionalism
- through a culture of consulting
32- Jim Pupillo
- Immediate Past President
- Chair, Steering Committee
- Chair, Industry Advisory Council
- Guided APICs Initiatives in Two Key Programs
- Professional Standards
- Maximizing APICs Industry Relationships
33Focus on Standards and Innovation
- Creating resources for building a culture that
values high professional standards - Tapping into the best of the investment
management consultant industry to create
innovation and new directions for the
practitioner
34Professional Standards Project
- Initiated by former President Jim Stoker with the
guidance of the Steering Committee - Assisted by the resources of Don Trone and the
Foundation for Fiduciary Studies
35Partnership with the Foundation for Fiduciary
Studies
- Distribution partners with the Foundation of
their publication Prudent Investment Practices
Handbook - APIC members receive a special discounted price.
36APIC Code of Ethics
- In 2004 the Board of Directors approved an APIC
member Code of Ethics - Designed as a membership guideline, it provides
you with a resource to demonstrate to clients how
you operate your practice in a highly ethical
fashion
37APIC Code of EthicsI recognize that this Code of
Ethics, its principles, and obligations are in
addition to those set forth by any other code
which governs my professional and ethical conduct.
- To my consulting clients, I will
- Act with honesty and integrity, and seek to avoid
conflicts of interest, real or perceived. - Ensure the timely and understandable disclosure
of relevant information that is accurate,
complete, and objective including any actual or
potential conflicts of interest. - Be responsible when determining the value of my
services and my form of compensation, taking into
consideration the time, skill, experience, and
special circumstances involved in the performance
of my services. - Know the limits of my expertise, and refer to
colleagues and/or other professionals on issues
beyond my knowledge and skill. - Respect the confidentiality of information
acquired in the course of my work. I will not
disclose such information, except when authorized
or otherwise legally obligated to do so. I will
not use confidential information acquired in the
course of my work for my personal advantage.
38APIC Code of Ethics
- To APIC, I will
- Proactively promote and be an example of ethical
behavior as a responsible partner among peers, in
the work environment, and the community. - Ensure that my fee structures and the overall
promotion of my practice are implemented in the
best interests of the profession. - Seek, accept, and offer honest criticism of
technical work acknowledge and correct errors
and properly credit the contributions of others. - Use corporate assets and resources employed or
entrusted to me in a responsible manner. - Continue to improve my knowledge and skills,
share ideas and information with my colleagues,
and assist them in their professional
development. - Approved by the APIC Board of Directors as a
membership guideline on March 1, 2004.
39Promoting Professional Standards
The Professional Standards Guide for Investment
Management Consultants is a new tool to use in
growing your practice. The standards were
developed in conjunction with Prudent Investment
Practices and provide a common set of operating
standards that should be used by all professional
investment management consultants. Working with
Smith Barneys legal compliance team, APIC has
created a guide that you can use internally and
as a valuable marketing tool to demonstrate how
you operate your practice.
40Eight Standards for Professional Practice
41Sample Standard
42How to Use the Professional Standards Guide in
Your Practice
- Benchmark how you operate your practice.
- Training of new staff and colleagues to practice
the APIC way. - Demonstrate to clients that you work at a high
level of professional standards
43How to Obtain the Guide
- APIC is placing a .pdf copy of the Guide on the
members only section of the website yours free
to download as a member benefit. - Attractive color copies will also be available to
purchase. - First 25 copies 7.00 each
- Next 25 copies 6.00 each
- Next 50 copies 5.00 each
- Over 100 or more copies 4.00 each
- We are offering a 25 pre-publication discount
for 1,000 copies ordered.
44Creating innovation and new directions for the
practitioner
- Mission of the Industry Advisory Council is
two-fold - Industry Communication Bridge Function as a
communication link with key industry leaders to
stay abreast of cutting edge technological
innovations and other developments. - Industry Think Tank Function as an exploratory
investment consulting research and developmental
think-tank.
45Industry Leadership
- The IAC consists of such key leaders as
- Frank Sortino
- Bob Seaberg
- Donald Trone
- Bob Padgette
- Ron Surz
- APIC leadership is actively involved in leading
this effort.
46Projects that the IAC is Focused On
- Building a Culture that embraces Ethics and
Standards - Implementing a Code of Ethics for APIC Members
- Developed the APIC Standards of Practice
- Collaborating with the Foundation for Fiduciary
Studies to foster a culture that values ethical
behavior within a standard set of practices - Portfolio Construction
- Blending Active/Passive Investment Strategies
- Alpha Through Enhanced Asset Allocation
- Research of Minimum Acceptable Returns (MAR)
- Behavioral Finance Research
- Obtain Better Understanding of Behavioral
Finance - Provide Informational Resources for Financial
Consultants
47In Closing Two Thank Yous
- First To the conference committee
- No committee has ever faced bigger challenges!
Please give them constructive ideas and more
importantly, Thank them Elaina Spilove, Steve
Thacker and Mike Engel - Second The APIC Board and Committee Chairs
- If you would all stand - Thank YOU
- You do the day-to-day work of APIC!
- Finally, in closing, I would like to read you an
email exchange between my Vice President and one
of our members. It speaks to who we have always
been!
48- First, thanks for your comments. We can only
serve better by listening. Second, I couldn't
agree with you more about getting Value. If APIC
is not providing value to you and your practice
then you should leave and find it elsewhere.
However, let me share a few thoughts about how
APIC is providing value in my life and practice
and see what you think in the end - 1) When I first joined APIC I was a pretty good
producer (1st quintile type) and I did OK
bringing in new clients and I did pretty good
managing my clients assets. I attended my first
conference and was struck with the awesome
reality that what I thought was pretty good was
in fact pretty average. The best practitioners
were using cutting edge ideas that I had not even
thought of. The best practitioners were thinking
about asset allocation problems that were coming,
not here yet, but just around the corner. The
best were not simply satisfied with being pretty
good at manager selection they demanded and had a
plan to b better. Let me give you some examples - The best practitioners were thinking about
alternative asset classes 10 years ago, sourcing
out hedge funds and other opportunities so that
when the difficult markets came their clients
were prepared. They were there teaching me what
these asset classes could do to risk and return
so I would have my clients prepared.
49- The best practitioners were thinking 10 years ago
about the brick wall that most FC's hit where
there are just not enough hours in the day to do
any more bizz and taught me how to leverage my
time through the building of a high performance
team. - The best practitioners were there years ago when
they saw that our reporting systems were not
adequate to serve our market and lead the way in
helping design Orion and other reporting
tools..yes that was an APIC project. - The best practitioners were there years ago when
research was causing us lots of problems in
firing managers that we had just hired. They led
the way in creating the new warning system that
is in place....yes that was an APIC project too - I could keep going on but the point is who was
going to be my advocate with the firm, who was
going to teach me all of these things if the best
practitioners who are the members of APIC and
constantly share with us were not there. I can
honestly say I would not have gotten to where I
am with out this organization! - 2) So what has APIC done for me lately? Look
on the APIC website and you will see a list of
great closing presentations recently posted by
Scott Thayer, you will see a great study on
commodities and how they can affect asset
allocation posted by several FC's including Bill
Hendrix and George Dunn, you will see a new
Morningstar report that Mary Deathridge has found
to give a snap shot look at MPT stats on a series
of SMA portfolio's, you will see an idea by
George Cook to use SMA's inside of 401k's there
by reducing participant cost, you will see
competition updates, etc. I use all of these and
you will see a lot more.
50- What you wont see is what you will get most any
other place...people who are not willing to share
because they view you as their competition. I
don't know of anywhere else where you will go and
the best practitioners in the world will openly
share their very best ideas for you to use. Why
will they do that? Because, like me, they have
gotten so much from this place we call APIC it is
a honor to give back. - 3) APIC is my place to be part of the solution
rather than part of the problem! We have real
problems at this firm like all other firms. Like
all firms this one has limited resources to
address those problems. APIC provides a forum
with Sr Mng to understand what our top concerns
are, prioritize them and fund them. Someday we
should list out in one document the hundreds of
things that have been accomplished at this firm
that started on an APIC priority list. You would
be amazed at how much it has affected your daily
working life. I want this to continue, in fact I
need this to continue if my practice is going to
continue to grow. -
51- APIC is my place to be part of the solution
rather than part of the problem! We have real
problems at this firm like all other firms. Like
all firms this one has limited resources to
address those problems. APIC provides a forum
with Sr Mng to understand what our top concerns
are, prioritize them and fund them. Someday we
should list out in one document the hundreds of
things that have been accomplished at this firm
that started on an APIC priority list. You would
be amazed at how much it has affected your daily
working life. I want this to continue, in fact I
need this to continue if my practice is going to
continue to grow. - Finally, I will leave you with this thought.
Some of my closest friends in the world have
come from my time at APIC. In these
relationships I find the things that make me a
better practitioner and a better person. My hope
is that you will get more involved in APIC. If
you wait for all of these things to come to you,
you are probably correct in leaving. However, if
you embrace wanting to be cutting edge then allow
us to help you find one of our committee's that
most closely aligns with your business I think
you will get from APIC everything that I have.
It was the best decision I ever made and one I
hope you will make as well. - Thanks for listening and allowing me to share my
experiences with you. - Timothy B. Kneen, APIC Vice President
- The good news to this letter is that the member
has now - renewed their 2005 membership!
52A Community of Colleagues Fostering
Professionalism Through a Culture of Consulting