Lake Winnipeg PreBudget Announcement - PowerPoint PPT Presentation


PPT – Lake Winnipeg PreBudget Announcement PowerPoint presentation | free to download - id: 11d1f1-ZjIzN


The Adobe Flash plugin is needed to view this content

Get the plugin now

View by Category
About This Presentation

Lake Winnipeg PreBudget Announcement


Under 33 years of Tory and NDP rule the phosphorus levels and algal blooms in ... strategies in 5-15 model watersheds like Killarney Lake, Lake Irwin, Seine River. ... – PowerPoint PPT presentation

Number of Views:30
Avg rating:3.0/5.0
Slides: 11
Provided by: admi1201
Learn more at:


Write a Comment
User Comments (0)
Transcript and Presenter's Notes

Title: Lake Winnipeg PreBudget Announcement

Lake Winnipeg Pre-Budget Announcement
State of the Lake
  • Years of government neglect has resulted in Lake
    Winnipeg becoming Manitobas greatest
    environmental failure.

Government Failure
  • Under 33 years of Tory and NDP rule the
    phosphorus levels and algal blooms in Lake
    Winnipeg have undergone major increases.
  • In 2007 NDP adjourned debate rather than discuss
    Liberal bill to ban phosphorus in dishwashing
  • Water Stewardship Minister mocked the proposal in
    the Legislature calling it a mere dishwasher
  • Minister of Water Stewardship set a goal to
    reduce the phosphorus load in Lake Winnipeg by 10
    percent. However, the Lake Winnipeg Stewardship
    Board report shows that a reduction of 58 per
    cent may be needed.
  • Government introduced its own dishwasher bill
    does half the job in twice the time

  • Government Inaction Continues
  • Presently no real targets set for reducing
    phosphorus in Lake Winnipeg
  • No plan for clean up of lake
  • Stonewalling of Liberal bills which would improve
    the situation in the lake
  • Government bill wont come into effect until July

Liberals lead the way
  • The Phosphorus-Free Dishwashing Detergent, the
    first in Canada legislation, to ban the use of
    phosphorus in dishwashing detergent
  • The Municipal Water System Phosphorus Control act
    prohibits the use of phosphorus based additives
    to control the leaching of lead into water pipes
  • Bill to ban the winter spreading of manure
  • Liberals call for Killarney Lake to be used as a
    model to study Lake Winnipeg

Pre-Budget Announcement Include Lake Winnipeg as
an Environmental Liability
Environmental Liability
  • Full accounting of Lake Winnipeg clean up
  • Costing for clean up
  • Comprehensive plan for clean up

  • Manitoba Liberal Plan
  • Implement sewage treatment in Winnipeg based on
    phosphorus only reduction rather than both
    nitrogen and phosphorus, saving about 600
  • Use some of the savings to reduce phosphorus
    outside of Winnipeg including
  • - implementation of a province-wide ALUS
  • - implementation of a small dams/water
    retention program modeled after South Tobacco
  • - implementation of improved phosphorus
    reduction approaches for municipal waste outside
  • - implementation of model phosphorus reduction
    strategies in 5-15 model watersheds like
    Killarney Lake, Lake Irwin, Seine River.
  • - a thorough assessment of the impact of the
    Hecla Island Causeway

  • Manitoba Liberal Plan
  • Liberals would spend in a more balanced and more
    effective way with about 200 million on a
    phosphorus only reduction approach for Winnipeg,
    and 100-200 million to help farmers and
    municipalities outside Winnipeg reduce phosphorus
    going into Lake Winnipeg.

Manitoba Liberals
First on the Environment