Title: Pesticide Exposure and Health Top Ten Reasons to Use PPE
1Pesticide Exposure and Health Top Ten Reasons to
Use PPE
- Julia F. Storm, MSPH
- Dept. of Environmental Molecular Toxicology
- College of Agriculture and Life Sciences
- NC State University
2Top Ten Reasons to Use PPE
3Top Ten Reasons to Use PPE
- 10. Bad habits are like a comfortable bed, easy
to get into, but hard to get out of.
4Risk of Harmful Health Effects Toxicity x
Exposure
- Toxicity
- The measure of the abilityof a substance to
causeharmful effects. - Exposure The total amount of substance that gets
in or on an organism route, frequency, and
duration of exposure are important.
5Relative Potential Pesticide Exposure
- HIGH
- Applicators (backpack sprayers, airblast)
- Mixers/Loaders
- Flaggers
- Fumigators (confined spaces)
- Animal dippers
- MEDIUM
- Applicators (open groundrig)
- Fumigators (greenhouse, field, orchard, vineyard)
- LOW
- Mixer/loader (closed systems)
- Applicators (aerial, closed cab groundrig)
- Fieldworkers
6Relative Toxicity, rat LD50, mg/kg
Caution Caution Warning
Danger-Poison
- Sugar (sucrose)
- Alcohol
- Glyphosate (Roundup)
- Salt (sodium chloride)
- Malathion
- Aspirin
- Metalaxyl (Ridomil)
- Ammonia
- Arsenic (arsenic acid)
- Nicotine
- Aldicarb (Temik)
- Dioxin (TCDD)
- Botulinum toxin
- 29700
- 14000
- 5600
- 3000
- 1375
- 1000
- 633
- 350
- 48
- 1
- 0.93
- 0.001
- 0.00001
7Top Ten Reasons to Use PPE
- 9. If you can remember anything about the
sixties, you werent really there. - 10. Bad habits are like a comfortable bed, easy
to get into, but hard to get out of.
8The Dose Makes the Poison
All substances are poisons,the right dose
differentiatesa poison from a remedy. Paracelsu
s (1493 - 1541)
9Relative Toxicity, rat LD50, mg/kg
Caution Caution Warning
Danger-Poison
- Sugar (sucrose)
- Alcohol
- Glyphosate (Roundup)
- Salt (sodium chloride)
- Malathion
- Aspirin
- Metalaxyl (Ridomil)
- Ammonia
- Arsenic (arsenic acid)
- Nicotine
- Aldicarb (Temik)
- Dioxin (TCDD)
- Botulinum toxin
- 29700
- 14000
- 5600
- 3000
- 1375
- 1000
- 633
- 350
- 48
- 1
- 0.93
- 0.001
- 0.00001
10Top Ten Reasons to Use PPE
- 8. Just because you can hold your liquor
doesnt mean your liver loves you. - 9. If you can remember anything about the
sixties, you werent really there. - 10. Bad habits are like a comfortable bed, easy
to get into, but hard to get out of.
11As Dose Increases, Response Worsens
RESPONSE
Alcohol DOSE
12Top Ten Reasons to Use PPE
- 7. Shirts and skins are fine for basketball or
soccer, but not for pesticide application. - 8. Just because you can hold your liquor
doesnt mean your liver loves you. - 9. If you can remember anything about the
sixties, you werent really there. - 10. Bad habits are like a comfortable bed, easy
to get into, but hard to get out of.
13Exposure Routes
O R A L
D E R M A L
14Means of Exposure to Pesticides
- Oral
- Unwashed Hands
- eating
- smoking
- Unwashed Foods
- Inhalation
- Dusts
- Vapors
- Dermal (Skin eyes)
- Spills and splashes
- Open cuts
- Inadequate protective clothing
- Unwashed clothing
- Unwashed hands
15Top Ten Reasons to Use PPE
- 6. Parts may be parts, but skin is not skin.
- 7. Shirts and skins are fine for basketball or
soccer, but not for pesticide application. - 8. Just because you can hold your liquor
doesnt mean your liver loves you. - 9. If you can remember anything about the
sixties, you werent really there. - 10. Bad habits are like a comfortable bed, easy
to get into, but hard to get out of.
16Chemical Absorption by Human Skin
Foot arch 1 Palm 6 X Forearm 8 X Back 12
X Scalp 25 X
Armpit 26 X Forehead 43 X Jaw 93
X Scrotum 300X
17Surface Area Exposed in a Casually Dressed
Individual
- UnclothedSurface
- Face
- Hands
- Forearms
- Back of Neck
- Front of Neck Vof Chest
- Surface PercentArea (sq ft) of Total
- 0.70 22.0
- 0.87 27.6
- 1.30 41.3
- 0.12 3.8
- 0.16 5.1
18Exposure to Hands Without Gloves
19Exposure to Hands With Gloves
20Top Ten Reasons to Use PPE
- 5. Youll live to watch the next Super Bowl or
World Cup. - 6. Parts may be parts, but skin is not skin.
- 7. Shirts and skins are fine for basketball or
soccer, but not for pesticide application. - 8. Just because you can hold your liquor
doesnt mean your liver loves you. - 9. If you can remember anything about the
sixties, you werent really there. - 10. Bad habits are like a comfortable bed, easy
to get into, but hard to get out of.
21Acute Effects
- Adverse effects that may appear immediately after
exposure to a pesticide (usually within 24 hours)
22Poisoning Cases
- 37 year old farmer
- Spilled endosulfan on hands while mixing about
noon - Experienced nausea and vomiting at 330 pm
- Kept working till 430 pm
- Found unresponsive at 6 pm
- Pronounced dead at hospital 2 hrs later
- 43 year old farmer
- Mixed (no PPE or hand-washing) applied
endosulfan with boom sprayer - Developed seizures and overturned tractor, but no
traumatic injury found - Never regained full consciousness
- 5 years later still impaired neurologically
23Poisoning cases
- 20 yr old Mexican male
- Emptying 14 bags of aldicarb burning bags
- No protective equipment
- 2 hours later found crushed by tractor
- Test results
- No drugs low cholinesterase activity
- Blood, tissue levels of aldicarb 3x gt cholinergic
symptoms (body burden18.2mg) - Contaminated clothing
- Conclusion physical incapacitation led to
tractor roll-over
24Incidence of Pesticide IllnessTop 20 Pesticides
ImplicatedCalifornia, 1998-2000
- Not determined
- Adjuvant
- Sulfur
- Metam-sodium
- Chlorpyrifos
- Sodium hypochlorite
- Petroleum oil
- Glyphosate
- Methomyl
- 509
- 251
- 202
- 194
- 156
- 110
- 59
- 55
- 54
25Incidence of Pesticide IllnessTop 20 Pesticides
ImplicatedCalifornia, 1998-2000
- Carbofuran
- Diazinon
- Myclobutanil
- Naled
- Copper hydroxide
- Iprodione
- Spinosad
- Oxydemeton-methyl
- Methyl bromide
- Esfenvalerate
- Mancozeb
- 40
- 38
- 38
- 36
- 36
- 35
- 33
- 32
- 31
- 28
- 26
26Acute Poisoning Cases Top 10 CropsCalifornia,
1997-2000
- Grapes
- Soil
- Oranges
- Cotton
- Packing/processing
- Almonds
- Alfalfa
- Ornamentals
- Lettuce
- Tomatoes
- Broccoli
- Strawberries
- Subtotal
- All other crops/sites
- Unknown
- Total
- 331
- 222
- 124
- 116
- 99
- 98
- 58
- 54
- 44
- 40
- 38
- 32
- 1283
- 488
- 128
- 1899
27Pesticide Illness Circumstances California
- 1998-2000
- 51 due to drift
- 55 involved violations
- 25 dermal contact with residues
- 43 involved violations
- Conclusion apparent compliance failed to protect
workers - 1997-2001
- 572 pesticide-related field observations
- 33 had 1 or more violations
- Common violations
- PPE (88 employer failure to provide, 12 worker
failure to use) - Inadequate or no washing/decontamination
facilities - Fieldworker access to pesticide information
-
28Hospitalized Pesticide Poisoningin North
Carolina, 1990-1993
- 61 Insecticides (OP, pyrethrins)
- all groups
- 19 Rodenticides
- adult intentional
- childhood
- 10 Fungicides Herbicides
- occupational
29Incidence of Pesticide Poisoning
- Occupational OP Incidents Reported
- Poison Control Centers 1993-1996
- 3205 exposures
- 336 significant illnesses (23 of all pesticides)
- 18 life-threatening
- 38 of all pesticides
- highest of 18 types of pesticides (2x average)
- 1468 treated
30Top Ten Reasons to Use PPE
- 4. Just because you have 2 legs, not 6, doesnt
mean an insecticide cant kill you. - 5. Youll live to watch the next Super Bowl or
World Cup. - 6. Parts may be parts, but skin is not skin.
- 7. Shirts and skins are fine for basketball or
soccer, but not for pesticide application. - 8. Just because you can hold your liquor
doesnt mean your liver loves you. - 9. If you can remember anything about the
sixties, you werent really there. - 10. Bad habits are like a comfortable bed, easy
to get into, but hard to get out of.
31Organophosphate (OPs) Carbamate Insecticides
- OPs
- acephate, Orthene
- disulfoton, Di-Syston
- chlorpyrifos, Lorsban
- fonofos, Dyfonate
- malathion, Malathion
- diazinon, Spectracide
Carbamates carbaryl, Sevin aldicarb,
Temik oxamyl, Vydate L carbofuran,
Furadan methomyl, Lannate
32Common Symptomsof OP Carbamate Exposure
- excessive tears
- excessive sweating
- excessive salivation
- pinpoint pupils (eyes)
- dizziness
- nausea
- vomiting
- diarrhea
- excessive urination
33Organophosphates
- Mode of Action
- Irreversible inhibition of acetylcholinesterase
(AchE) - Treatment
- Atropine
- 2-PAM
- Supportive therapy
34Carbamates
- Mode of Action
- Reversible inhibition of acetylcholinesterase
(AchE) - Treatment
- Atropine
- Supportive therapy
35Monitoring OP/Carbamate Exposure
- Blood cholinesterase analysis
- Baseline determination is important
- Depression of 25 or moreis indicative of
serious overexposure
36Conditions Confused With Pesticide Poisoning
- Heat stressfatigue, dizziness, severe thirst,
heavy sweating, altered behavior, headache,
nausea, chills - Green tobacco sicknessstomach cramps, nausea,
vomiting, difficulty breathing, dizziness
37Emergency Response
- Remove the personfrom exposure
- Follow label first aid instructions orcall
Poison Control1-800-222-1222 - Call 911 or takevictim to ER or MD
- Give EMTs label, MSDS exposure information
38Skin Conditions Associatedwith Pesticide Exposure
39Pesticides Associatedwith Allergic Reactions
- lindane, Drexol, Lindane
- esfenvalerate, Asana XL
- permethrin, Pounce, Ambush
- rotenone, various
- maneb, Maneb
- dazomet, Basamid
- benomyl, Benlate
- captan, various
- dichloropropene, Telone II
40Importance of Allergic Reactions
- Permanent
- Worsen with recurrent exposures
- Can be fatal
- Allergy to similar substances
41Top Ten Reasons to Use PPE
- 3. Because somebody loves you and wants you to be
healthy and be around a long time. - 4. Just because you have 2 legs, not 6, doesnt
mean an insecticide cant kill you. - 5. Youll live to watch the next Super Bowl or
World Cup. - 6. Parts may be parts, but skin is not skin.
- 7. Shirts and skins are fine for basketball or
soccer, but not for pesticide application. - 8. Just because you can hold your liquor
doesnt mean your liver loves you. - 9. If you can remember anything about the
sixties, you werent really there. - 10. Bad habits are like a comfortable bed, easy
to get into, but hard to get out of.
42Delayed Effects
- Adverse effects that do not appear immediately
(within 24 hours) after exposure to a pesticide
43Chronic Health Effects Associated with Certain
Pesticides
- Developmental
- Nervous System
- Immune System
- Cancer
- Reproductive Effects
44Evidence of Carcinogenicity of Pesticides from
Animal studies
- National Toxicology Program
- 107 pesticides tested in animals
- 54 had some carcinogenicity
- International Agency for Research on Cancer
- 26 pesticides with sufficient evidence
- 8 still registered for use in U.S.
- 19 pesticides with limited evidence
- 15 still registered for use in U.S.
45Summary of Agricultural Health
- Health Problems
- Higher risk of injury
- Risk of lung disease(not lung cancer)
- Skin conditions
- Higher rates of certain cancers
- Other immune, nervous, reproductive system
- Health Pluses
- Live longer
-
- Lower heart disease death rate
- Lower death rate due to some cancers
- Lung
- Esophagus
- Bladder
- Colon
46Agricultural Health Study First 12 years
- Associated with Chemicals
- Pesticides, solvents, diesel tractors
- Fungicides
- Methyl bromide
- Alachlor
- Pesticide use
- Symptom or Disease
- Wheeze(lung symptom)
- Retinal degeneration (vision problem)
- Prostate cancer
- Multiple myeloma and leukemia (immune system
cancers) - Abnormal menstrual cycles(female reproductive
health)
47Risk
- Toxicity
- Nature of the chemical (dose/response)
- Interaction with other chemicals
- Exposure
- Dose
- Route
- Duration
- Frequency
48Top Ten Reasons to Use PPE
- 2. The label says so, and its the law.
- 3. Because somebody loves you and wants you to be
healthy and be around a long time. - 4. Just because you have 2 legs, not 6, doesnt
mean an insecticide cant kill you. - 5. Youll live to watch the next Super Bowl or
World Cup. - 6. Parts may be parts, but skin is not skin.
- 7. Shirts and skins are fine for basketball or
soccer, but not for pesticide application. - 8. Just because you can hold your liquor
doesnt mean your liver loves you. - 9. If you can remember anything about the
sixties, you werent really there. - 10. Bad habits are like a comfortable bed, easy
to get into, but hard to get out of.
49To Minimize Pesticide Exposure
- Know the chemical and associated hazards
- Read and follow the label instructions
50Top Ten Reasons to Use PPE
- 1. Because it just makes common sense.
- 2. The label says so, and its the law.
- 3. Because somebody loves you and wants you to be
healthy and be around a long time. - 4. Just because you have 2 legs, not 6, doesnt
mean an insecticide cant kill you. - 5. Youll live to watch the next Super Bowl or
World Cup. - 6. Parts may be parts, but skin is not skin.
- 7. Shirts and skins are fine for basketball or
soccer, but not for pesticide application. - 8. Just because you can hold your liquor
doesnt mean your liver loves you. - 9. If you can remember anything about the
sixties, you werent really there. - 10. Bad habits are like a comfortable bed, easy
to get into, but hard to get out of.
51To Minimize Pesticide Exposure
- Wear Personal Protective Equipment (PPE)
- Mix and load pesticides in a spill containment
area
52To Minimize Pesticide Exposure
- Use integrated pest management (IPM) techniques
to minimize pesticide use
53To Minimize Pesticide Exposure
- Use techniques that minimizesurface and ground
water contaminationand drift - Recycle pesticide containers
54To Minimize Pesticide Exposure
- Comply with intervals for re-entry harvest
- Wash hands before eating, smoking,and using the
bathroom
55To Minimize Exposure to Others
- Wash pesticide contaminated clothing separately
- Store mix pesticides in original containers
labeled mixing equipment -- never in food
containers - Lock pesticides away from children
56For More Information Contact
- Greg Cope
- 919-515-5296
- greg_cope_at_ncsu.edu
- Julia Storm
- 919-515-7961
- julia_storm_at_ncsu.edu
Wayne Buhler 919-515-5369 wayne_buhler_at_ncsu.edu