International Recommendations for Industrial Statistics (IRIS)

1
International Recommendations for Industrial
Statistics (IRIS)

• Workshop on Economic Statistics
• and Informal Sector
• UN Statistics Division/ESCAP
• Teheran, 10-13 November 2007

2
International Recommendations for Industrial
Statistics (IRIS)

• Outline of presentation
• 1. Background
• 2. Need for revision of IRIS
• 3. Main recommendations
• a. Scope and coverage
• b. Statistical units
• c. Treatment of ancillary activities
• d. Data items
• e. Valuation
• f. Data items for international reporting
• Annual
• Quarterly

3
1. Background

• Since 1950s, UN has published international
  recommendations to establish a coherent and
  uniform measurement of industrial activities
  1953, 1960, 1968 and 1983
• UNSC in 2006 reviewed the industrial statistics
  and endorsed the proposal for revision of IRIS.
• Expert Group Constituted to guide the revision
  which met in
• Sept 2005 considered proposals for revision and
  
• July 2007 considered the draft IRIS

4
2. Need for revision

• Some important factors which necessitated
  revision are
• 1993 SNA update
• Units undertaking ancillary activities treated as
  a separate establishment in some specific
  circumstances,
• Additional element for the measure of COE like
  employees stock option
• Treatment of goods sent abroad for processing,
• Changes in terminology and classification of
  assets,
• Capitalisation of database development, and
  capitalisation of RD expenditures
• Revision of International Standard Industrial
  Classification of all economic activities (ISIC
  Rev. 4) and Central Product Classification (CPC
  Ver. 2).
• Consistency with changes in concepts, definition
  and terminology in publications and regulations
  of other international organisations. For
  example, revision in the IMF manual on BOP, EU
  regulations on statistical units, structural
  business statistics etc.

5
2. Need for revision Cont.

• Inclusion of aspects of globalisation of the
  industrial production process including
  outsourcing and use of e-ecommerce,
• Efforts of countries to minimise the differences
  between the concepts of census value added and
  national account value added,
• Change in valuation of industrial output to basic
  prices in accordance with the SNA valuation
  principle,

6
2. Need for revision Cont.

• Extension of the link between the economy and the
  environment by extending the coverage of the data
  items to include the use of natural resources
  like energy, water, mineral, generation of solid
  waste and waste water and by-products,
• Experience of countries both in developing an
  industrial statistics system and conducting an
  integrated system of annual and infra-annual
  industrial inquiries adapted to the needs of NA
  and the measurement of industrial sector for the
  economy as a whole

7
3a. Scope of industrial sector

• Economic activities included in terms of ISIC
  Rev. 4 are
• Mining and quarrying (section B)
• Manufacturing (section C)
• Electricity, gas, steam and air conditioning
  supply (section D), and
• Water supply sewerage, waste management and
  remediation activities (section E)
• (Scope has been broadened as compared to the 1983
  recommendations with inclusion of sewerage, waste
  management and remediation activities)
• Industrial activities in international waters,
  such as the operation of petroleum and natural
  gas wells, should be included if these activities
  are subject to the laws, regulations and control
  of the country concerned.

8
3a. Scope of Manufacturing

• Manufacturing
• Includes the physical or chemical transformation
  of materials, substances, or components into new
  products.
• Substantial alteration, renovation or
  reconstruction of goods is generally considered
  to be manufacturing.
• Assembly of the component parts of manufactured
  products is considered manufacturing. This
  includes the assembly of manufactured products
  from either self-produced or purchased components

9
3a. Scope of Manufacturing

• Manufacturing
• Specialized maintenance and repair of industrial,
  commercial and similar machinery and equipment is
  included in manufacturing. However, the repair of
  computers and personal and household goods and
  the repair of motor vehicles are not included in
  this section.
• The recovery of waste - the processing of waste
  into secondary raw materials - though may
  involve, physical or chemical transformations, is
  not considered to be a part of manufacturing.

10
3a. Scope of Manufacturing

• Manufacturing
• The boundaries of manufacturing and the other
  activities can be somewhat blurry. As a general
  rule, the activities in the manufacturing section
  involve the transformation of materials into new
  products.
• Some activities, although sometimes involving
  transformation processes, are not classified as
  manufacturing. They include
• Logging - classified in Section A (Ag, forestry
  fishing)
• Construction of structures and fabricating
  operations performed at the site of construction
  - classified in section F (construction)
• Activities of breaking bulk and redistribution in
  smaller lots, including packaging, repackaging,
  or bottling products mixing paints to customer
  order and cutting metals to customer order,
  produce a modified version of the same product
  are classified to section G (wholesale and retail
  trade repair of motor vehicles and motorcycles

11
Boundary between Mfg and Wholesaling

• Outsourcing
• Principal unit (principal) contracts another
  production unit (contractor) to carry out
  specific aspects of the production activity of
  the principal, in whole or in part in the
  production of a good or a service.
• It should be noted that the activity
  classification of the contractor does not change
  with the outsourcing but that of the principal is
  very much affected by the nature and extent of
  the outsourcing

12
Boundary between Mfg and Wholesaling

• Trend of outsourcing the mfg activities has been
  growing recently. Criteria for the classification
  of the principal need to be clarified to ensure
  international consistency in its classification.
• Classification of the principal should be based
  on its ownership of the physical input materials

13
Boundary between Mfg and Wholesaling

• 1. Outsourcing of support functions
• Principal carries out the core production process
  but outsource certain support functions, such as
  accounting or computer services, to the
  contractor.
• In such a case, the principal remains classified
  to the same ISIC class that represents its core
  production process.
• The contractor is classified to the specific
  support activity it is carrying out, e.g. ISIC
  class 6920 (Accounting, bookkeeping and auditing
  activities tax consultancy) or 6202 (Computer
  consultancy and computer facilities management).

14
Boundary between Mfg and Wholesaling

• 2. Outsourcing of part of the production process
• The principal outsources a part of the production
  process to the contractor.
• The principal owns the (material) inputs to be
  transformed by the contractor and thereby has
  ownership over the final outputs.
• The principal is to be classified as if it were
  carrying out the complete production process.
• The contractor is classified according to the
  portion of the production process that it is
  undertaking. In case of the transformation of a
  good, the contractor is classified in the same or
  separate ISIC category.

15
Boundary between Mfg and Wholesaling

• 2. Outsourcing of the complete production process
• Outsourcing of mfg activities to contractor
  whereby the principal does not physically
  transform the goods at the location of its unit
• (a) Principal owns the material inputs and has
  economic ownership of the outputs,
• Principal is classified to section C
  (manufacturing), specifically to the
  classification category that corresponds to the
  complete (outsourced) manufacturing activity.
• Contractor is classified to section C
  (manufacturing), specifically to the
  classification category that corresponds to the
  mfg activity performed by the contractor.

16
Boundary between Mfg and Wholesaling

• 2. Outsourcing of the complete production process
• Outsourcing of mfg activities to contractor
  whereby the principal does not physically
  transform the goods at the location of its unit
• (b) Principal has the production done by others,
  but does not own the material inputs,
• Principal is classified to section G (wholesale
  and retail trade repair of motor vehicles and
  motorcycles) .
• Contractor is classified to section C
  (manufacturing), specifically to the
  classification category that corresponds to the
  mfg activity performed by the contractor.

17
3a. Coverage of industrial activities

• In conformity with the 1993 SNA production
  boundary all units engaged in economic activities
  within the scope should be covered.
• Units of all sizes (with and without fixed
  locations) and
• Units of all types of ownership including the
  govt. and household units
• Household unincorporated enterprises
• Goods produced by households engaging in
  industrial activities for own consumption should
  also be covered.

18
3a. Coverage of industrial sector cont.

• Departments, establishments and similar units in
  general Govt. should be included if they are
  mainly engaged in production of goods and
  services within the scope and identifiable by
  accounting records kept by them.
• Some of units may not be operating for profit, or
• May not dispose of their output in the market.
  Produce of such units may be sold at prices below
  cost of production because of govt policy.
• Govt. units may furnish goods and services to
  itself of a kind provided by privately owned
  establishments printing and publishing
  services, ammunitions, etc.
• All types of units not necessarily covered
  through the same survey instrument.

19
3a. Coverage of industrial sector cont.

• Actual enumeration of establishments in the
  various activities will in practice vary
  according to the
• Frequency with which the data are required
• Difficulty of obtaining them,
• Existence of alternative sources and the
  resources available to the statistical
  authorities.
• Recommended coverage may be attained by a
  complete enumeration of relevant establishments
  or by using sample surveys.
• The method of enumeration chosen will depend on
  the circumstances in each country.

20
3b. Statistical unit

• 1993 SNA recommends establishment as the most
  appropriate statistical unit (SU) for production
  and employment data
• Countries are encouraged to use establishment as
  a SU for industrial statistics
• Choice of establishment vs enterprise as SU
  reflects balancing of data availability against
  homogeneity of economic activity.
• Using establishment as a unit enables
• Homogeneity in the measurement of the economic
  activity
• More accurate presentation of regional economic
  reality
• Choice of SU may be guided by factors such as
  purpose of study, the availability and quality of
  requisite data, therefore, enterprise can also be
  used as SU
• In majority of cases establishment and the
  enterprise are same except in case of
  multi-establishment enterprises.

21
3c. Treatment of Ancillary activities

• A productive activity undertaken with the sole
  purpose of producing services for intermediate
  consumption within the same enterprise is defined
  as an ancillary activity. Examples are record
  keeping, personnel management, warehousing etc
• Ancillary activities are integrated with the
  establishments they support. This approach
  depicts the production process as it is performed
  but has the following disadvantages
• Not recognized by its own activity, structural
  decomposition of GDP by economic activities not
  depicted correctly, and
• Regional GDP can not be compiled accurately when
  the ancillary unit and the establishments it
  serves are located in different regional
  economies

22
3c. Treatment of Ancillary activities cont.

• Units undertaking ancillary activities to be
  treated as an establishment in certain cases
• Enterprise in which different kinds of activities
  undertaken by it or either horizontally or
  vertically integrated
• When an establishment undertaking ancillary
  activities is statistically observable, i.e.
  records of its transactions are readily
  available, and
• When the ancillary units are in a geographical
  location different from the establishments they
  serve.
• Such an establishment should be classified
  according to its own principal activity.

23
3c. Treatment of Ancillary activities cont.

• Output of ancillary establishment
• Output of ancillary establishment should be
  derived on sum of cost basis i.e. all costs of
  its production including the cost of the capital
  used.
• Output deemed to be market output when the parent
  enterprise is a market enterprise and non-market
  otherwise.
• Output of the ancillary unit is treated as
  intermediate consumption of the establishments it
  serves and should be allocated to them using an
  appropriate indicator such as their value added,
  output or employment.

24
3d. Data items

• Characteristics of statistical units
• Location
• Type of economic organisation
• Type of legal organisation and ownership
• Size (in terms of persons employed)
• Recommended size classes (1-9, 10-19, 20-49,
  50-249, 250)
• Kind-of-activity
• Type of unit
• Period of operation

25
3d. Data items cont.

• Employment (by gender)
• No. of persons employed
• Working proprietors, Unpaid FW, employees
• Employees engaged in own-account production of
  intellectual property products (software
  database, RD, mineral exploration and
  evaluation, entertainment, literary and artistic
  originals)
• Employees engaged in own account fixed asset
  formation and construction)
• Average number of persons employed
• Hours worked
• Leased employees

26
3d. Data items cont.

• Compensation of employees in cash and in kind
• Additional element pursuant to 1993 SNA revision
• Stock options (income in kind)
• Employer giving employee an option to buy stocks
  (shares) at some future date at a given price
  (strike/exercise price) subject to certain
  conditions (employee is still on the enterprise
  pay roll).
• Employee may not exercise the option
• Share price is now lower than his option price
• No longer in the employment of the company
• The grant date is when the option is provided,
  the vesting date is the earliest date when the
  option can be exercised (or lapses)
• Value of the stock option may be estimated as the
  difference between the market price and the stock
  price at vesting date or using using a stock
  option pricing model.

27
3d. Data items cont.

• Other expenditures
• Cost of material, parts and supplies except gas,
  fuels and electricity (purchased form other
  enterprises and delivered by the other
  establishments of the same enterprise)
• Cost of gas, fuels and electricity purchased
• Cost of water and sewerage services
• Purchase of services except rental
• Cost of industrial services purchased and also
  delivered by other establishments of the same
  enterprise
• Cost of non-industrial services purchased and
  also delivered by other establishments of the
  same enterprise
• Purchase of goods and services for resale in the
  same condition as received
• Rental payments
• Non-life insurance premiums payable on
  establishment property

28
3d. Data items cont.

• Data items on Quantity
• Quantity of individually important materials and
  supplies
• Quantity of gas, fuels purchased
• Quantity of electricity (Kwh)
• Purchased
• Generated
• Sold
• Total energy consumed (tera joules)
• Cost of water
• Purchased
• Abstracted for own use
• Sold
• Total water used
• Quantity of waste water
• Treated on site prior to discharge
• Discharged without being treated

29
3d. Data items cont.

• Sales/shipments and other revenues
• Sales/shipment of goods produced
• Sales/shipment of goods and services purchased
  for resale in the same condition as received
• Receipts for industrial work done
• Other receipts
• Value of own account fixed assets
• E-commerce sale/value of shipment/receipt for
  services and other revenues
• Quantity
• Quantity of individually important products
• (UN list of Industrial Products)

30
3d. Data items cont.

• Inventories
• Capital formation
• Dwellings
• Other buildings and structures
• Machinery and equipment
• Transport equipment
• ICT equipment
• Other machinery and equipment
• Intellectual property products
• Computer software and database
• RD
• Mineral exploration and evaluation
• Entertainment, literary and artistic originals
• Others
• Orders
• New orders received
• Unfilled orders during the reference period
• Environmental protection expenditures

31
3d. Data items cont.

• Environmental protection expenditures
• Environmental protection groups together all
  actions and activities that are aimed at the
  prevention, reduction and elimination of
  pollution as well as any other degradation of the
  environment. This includes measures taken in
  order to restore the environment after it has
  been degraded due to the pressures from human
  activities
• As environmental protection is prime objective,
  actions and activities which have a favourable
  impact on the environment but which serve other
  goals do not come under environmental protection.
  
• Excluded are activities from field of
  environmental protection, which while beneficial
  to environment primarily satisfy technical needs
  or the internal requirements for hygiene or
  security of an enterprise.

32
3e. Valuation

• Value added at basic prices (preferred)
• Situations where it is difficult to segregate
  taxes and subsidies on products and production -
  Value added at factor cost (second best option)
• Total value added vs Census value added
• National account value added (total value added)
  recommended.
• Census vale added optional - if countries desire
  to maintain their earlier time series

33
3f. Data items for International Reporting
Annual statistics
Data item Level of details Reporting level (in terms of ISIC Rev. 4) Time-lag After close of yr
Demography
Number of enterprises By economic activity and size class 3-digit by economic activity 1-digit level for size class distribution 18 months
Employment
Total number of persons employed --do-- ----do--- 18 months
Total number of employees --do-- ---do--- 18 months
34
3f. Data items for International Reporting
Annual statistics
Data item Level of details Level of details Reporting level Reporting level Time-lag
Compensation of employees Compensation of employees Compensation of employees Compensation of employees Compensation of employees Compensation of employees
Wages and salaries in cash and in kind of employees Wages and salaries in cash and in kind of employees By economic activity By economic activity 3-digit level of ISIC, Rev.4 18 months
Output Output
Gross output at basic prices Gross output at basic prices By economic activity By economic activity 3-digit level of ISIC, Rev.4 18 months
Value added Value added
Total value added at basic prices Total value added at basic prices By economic activity By economic activity 3-digit level of ISIC, Rev.4 18 months
Gross fixed capital formation 18 months Gross fixed capital formation 18 months Gross fixed capital formation 18 months Gross fixed capital formation 18 months Gross fixed capital formation 18 months Gross fixed capital formation 18 months
35
3f. Data items for International Reporting
Annual statistics
Data item Level of details Level of details Reporting level Reporting level Time-lag
Environment Environment Environment Environment Environment Environment
Environmental protection expenditure Environmental protection expenditure By economic activity By economic activity 3-digit level of ISIC, Rev.4 18 months

Total energy consumed (terajoules) Total energy consumed (terajoules) By economic activity By economic activity 3-digit level of ISIC, Rev.4 18 months

Total water used (cubic meters) Total water used (cubic meters) By economic activity By economic activity 3-digit level of ISIC, Rev.4 18 months
36
3f. Data items for International Reporting
Quarterly statistics
Data item Level of details Reporting level Time-lag
Employment
Total number of persons employed By economic activity 2-digit level of ISIC, Rev.4 3 months
Total number of employees By economic activity 2-digit level of ISIC, Rev.4 3 months
Compensation of employees Compensation of employees Compensation of employees Compensation of employees
Wages and salaries in cash and in kind of employees By economic activity 2-digit level of ISIC, Rev.4 3 months
Orders New orders received --- do --- - -- do --- Unfilled orders --- do --- --- do --- Orders New orders received --- do --- - -- do --- Unfilled orders --- do --- --- do --- Orders New orders received --- do --- - -- do --- Unfilled orders --- do --- --- do --- 3 months 3 months
Index of industrial production 2-digit level Index of industrial production 2-digit level Index of industrial production 2-digit level 3 months
37
Data Sources

• Two basic sources for economic data
• (a) Administrative sources Administrative
  processes are set up in response to legislation
  and regulation. Each regulation results in a
  register of the institutional units
  enterprises, persons, etc. bound by that
  regulation and in data resulting from application
  of the regulation. The register and data are
  referred to collectively by the statistical
  office as an administrative source
• Main advantages of the administrative source
• Complete coverage of the concerned population
• Avoidance of response burden the responding
  units make available the information as part of
  the administrative procedure
• Cheaper for the statistical office to acquire
  data from an administrative source than to
  conduct a survey
• Negligible non-response
• No sampling errors and
• Data reported may be more accurate because of
  intense data checks by administrative
  authorities.

38
Data Sources contd.

• Main disadvantages of the administrative source
• Discrepancy between administrative and
  statistical concepts,
• Poor integration with other data of the
  statistical systems. AUs do not correspond to
  SUs even if does matching problem can
  prevent from using them.
• Risks with respect to stability Administrative
  processes are subject to change in response to
  new legislation - may cause systematic bias.
• Data may become available with unacceptable delay
• Legal constraints with respect to access and
  confidentiality
• Privately controlled administrative data sources
  can serve as an important supplement to
  official statistics should be thoroughly
  checked for coverage and quality and considered
  for use only when found to be of acceptable
  quality.

39
Data Sources contd.

• (b) Statistical surveys
• Both, the census and the sample survey techniques
  are used for collecting economic data.
• Sample survey is less costly way of data
  collection of precision with high frequency
• Disadvantages of survey approach
• Resource intensive (both financial and manpower),
  
• Additional respondent burden,
• Higher non-response rates and sampling errors.
• Respondents may not trust the confidentiality
  clause.

40
Data Sources contd.

• Two types surveys
• (i) Enterprise Survey
• Sampling frame of enterprises engaged in relevant
  economic activities from current up-to-date BR,
  is a prerequisite
• For countries with no BR, list of enterprises
  drawn from EC conducted in the past
• Depending upon the source of the sampling frame
  surveys may also be classified as either
  list-based or area-based.
• In list-based survey the initial sample is
  selected from a pre-existing list of enterprises,
  
• In an area-based survey the initial sampling
  units are a set of geographical areas. After one
  or more stages of selection, a sample of areas is
  identified within which enterprises or households
  are listed. From this list, the sample is
  selected and data collected.

41
Data Sources contd.

• Two types surveys
• Mixed household-enterprise surveys
• Sample of households is selected
• Each household is asked whether any of its
  members own and operate an unincorporated
  enterprise.
• The list of enterprises thus compiled is used as
  the basis for selecting the enterprises from
  which desired data are finally collected.
• Mixed household-enterprise surveys are useful to
  cover only unincorporated (or household)
  enterprises which are numerous and cannot be
  easily registered.

42
Data Collection strategy

• For complete coverage of the industrial activity,
  data collection strategy should be based on an
  integrated approach covering in principle all
  production units across all class sizes including
  micro and small enterprises.
• The legal organisation (incorporated or
  unincorporated), size (from large to small and
  micro enterprises) and the ownership pattern
  (public sector, privately owned and foreign
  controlled) of units within the scope of the
  industrial statistics differ significantly.
• At one end of the spectrum are the corporate
  units which are incorporated under the statute of
  a country and are comparatively large, while at
  the other end are the unincorporated enterprises
  characterised by low level of organisation.
• In view of this diversity, it is difficult, if
  not impossible, to devise a single strategy for
  data collection that is appropriate for all units
  in the scope.

43
Data Collection strategy

• Incorporated units - popularly known as
  companies, a list of such units is always
  available.
• Public sector enterprises Complete enumeration
• The coverage of the private and foreign
  controlled incorporated enterprises should be
  achieved by dividing them into two segments
• large-scale units complete enumeration, and
• the rest cover through sample survey

44

• Data collection strategy

Universe of units engaged in industrial activities
In BR (list-frame segment)
Not in BR (Non-list frame Segment)
Without Fixed Premises
With fixed premises
Small units
Large units
Covered either Through sample Surveys
or Administrative data
Area frame
?1?
Private Sector
Public sector
Should be covered through Sample surveys
?2?
Segment 1 Large units should be covered on a
complete enumeration basis
Complete enumeration
Segment 2 Remaining through sample surveys
1. All units on the business register are
excluded from the area frame (i.e. non-list frame
segment). 2. All units in the sample that are
part of a list frame segment and included therein
are excluded from the sample of non-list
frame segment.
45

• Thank You