Development of an Integrated Assessment Program for the Sustainability, Safety and Security of Urban Underground Infrastructure

1
?????-????????????? ???????????????
??????????????? ??????????? ?????????
?????????? ??????? "????????????? ?????
?????????? ????/??????? ???????? ???????.
??????? (??????) ?????????. ?????????????????
??????. ?????? ?????. ???. ??????? ???????
??????????? E-mail nikolaibobylev_at_daad-alumni.de
Skype nikolaibobylev Tel. [phone]
?????? 0 ????? ????? ???????? ??????? ?
?????????????????? ?????
2
?????????? ?????? 0

• ?????????? ??????? ? ????? ??????
• ??????? ?????
• ?????? ????? ? ???????????? ?????? ?????????
  (????, ?????????)
• ???????????? ??????? (????)
• ??????????
• ??????? ??????
• ?????????? ? ??????\????????

3
MCDA Methods

• American school
• Analytic Network Process
• Analytic Hierarchy Process
• by Thomas Saaty
• http//www.superdecisions.com/
• European school
• MACBETH (Measuring Attractiveness by a
  Categorical Based
• Evaluation Technique)
• by Carlos Bana e Costa et.al.
• http//www.m-macbeth.com/index.html

4
MCA software

• http//www.krysalis.co.uk/
• On Balance
• http//www.expertchoice.com/
• Expert Choice
• http//www.decidewise.com/uk/default.htm
• Decide Wise
• http//www.catalyze.co.uk/
• Hiview
• http//www.logicaldecisions.com/
• Logical Decisions
• http//www.hipre.hut.fi/
• HIPRE
• http//www.decisioneering.com/

5

• Analytic Network Process
• Analytic Hierarchy Process
• by Thomas Saaty
• http//www.superdecisions.com/

By Creative Decisions Foundation
4922 Ellsworth Avenue Pittsburgh,
PA 15213 Phone [phone]
Fax [phone]
6
?????????? (???????)

• ?. ?. ????? ???????? ??????? ??? ???????????? ?
  ???????? ??????. ????????????? ???? ????????????
  ????????, 2011 ?. ?????? ???????, 360 ???. ISBN
  978-5-397-01622-3
• ????? ?.?. ???????? ??????? ? ??????????????????
  ????? ?????????????? ??????. - ?. ?????????,
  2002.
• Group Decision Making Thomas L. Saaty, and Kirti
  Penwati 2008, 352 pp. paperback ISBN
  1-888603-08-9

7
?????????? (??? ?????? ???????)

• Bobylev, Nikolai (2011) Comparative analysis of
  environmental impacts of selected underground
  construction technologies using analytic network
  process. Automation in Construction, Elsevier.
  26p. 10.1016/j.autcon.2011.04.004
• Bobylev, Nikolai (2010) A study of the
  effectiveness of environmental assessment using
  the analytic network process. EASY-ECO Conference
  on Sustainable Development Evaluations in Europe.
  17-19 November 2010 Brussels, Belgium.
  http//www.sustainability.eu/easy/?kconferencess
  brussels
• Bobylev, Nikolai (2010) A methodological
  framework for using Analytic Hierarchy Process in
  Environmental Assessment. In Ilarionova, T.S.
  (ed) Science and Innovations in Modernisation of
  Russia and the World Development. Alexander von
  Humboldt Colloquium. pp. 200 206. ISBN
  978-5-904843-01-4
• ??????? ?.?. (2011) ?????????? ??????
  ????????????? ????? ? ??????? ??????????.
  ??????-??????????? ????????? ??????. 3(121)2011
  ??? 113-117.

8
??????? ??????

• Examples of cases (general)
• The city where better to live
• Choosing a career
• Choosing a brand
• Vendor Selection
• Cost minimization

9
?????????? ? ??????\????????

• ?? ???????? ?????????? ? ?????? ??????????
  ?????? ? ????????? ?????
• ??????????
• ???????????? ?????? (????)
• ???????????? ???????? ?????? ? ?? ??????? (????)
• ???????????? ??????????? ?????? (???? ppt)
• ?????? ?????????? ???????????? (????????) ?????
  ?? ????????? ????????

10
?????? ?????? ?? ??????? (????)

• ????????? ???? ???????
• ?????? (100-200 ???? ?? ??????? ? 100-200 ??
  ??????????
• ?????????? ?????? ??????????????????? ???????
  (???), ???????? ????????
• ?????????????? ???????
• ????????
• ????
• ???????? ?????? (????? ????)
• ?????? ????????????????
• ?????????
• ?????????? ???????

11
?????? 0???????? ???????

• ???????? ? ?????????
• ?????????? ?? ??????? ????? ?? ???
• ???????????? ???????? ?? ??? ???????
• ???? ?? ??? (???????)
• ???????? ?
• ?????????? ??? ??? ??? ??????
• ????? ??????? ( ??????? ???????? ??????????)
• ????????? ????