Start-up to Exit - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

1 / 56
About This Presentation
Title:

Start-up to Exit

Description:

The Les Kilpatrick Students to Start-ups Entrepreneurial Skills Workshop Series Start-up to Exit Workshop 6: Midcourse corrections ReShape Medical, Inc. Midcourse ... – PowerPoint PPT presentation

Number of Views:226
Avg rating:3.0/5.0
Slides: 57
Provided by: Rakh4
Category:

less

Transcript and Presenter's Notes

Title: Start-up to Exit


1
The Les Kilpatrick
Students to Start-ups
Entrepreneurial Skills Workshop Series
  • Start-up to Exit
  • Workshop 6 Midcourse corrections


2
  • Schedule
  • My background
  • Midcourse correction
  • Start-up process
  • I do not like to make presentations
  • You all need to participate in the discussion
    (ask questions)
  • Help the process Write down two questions
  • What do I want to learn about midcourse
    corrections?
  • What do I want to learn about the start-up
    process?

3
  • Workshop 6 - Objectives
  • Discuss the cause of major deviations in the
    start-up process and how to manage these events
  • Midcourse corrections during the evolution of a
    start-up
  • Discuss some tools you can use to manage the
    process
  • Help you gain a better understanding of the
    start-up process through my experience

4
  • George Wallace
  • Background

5
  • Personal
  • 50 years old
  • Married, 3 Daughters (25 yrs, 24 yrs, 20 yrs)
  • 2 Colorado,1 UCI
  • 29 years in medical devices (last 20 years in OC)
  • Active lifestyle, fitness, sports, beach.OC
  • BMI 29

6
  • Why I am here?
  • Serial entrepreneur in medical devices (Orange
    County)
  • Raised significant venture capital
  • Managed companies from start to exit
  • Still starting and managing medical device
    companies
  • Some level of success in this process
  • I like entrepreneurs (informed risk takers) ?
    Some of You?
  • I have worked through many midcourse
    corrections

7
  • Professional Experience
  • Edwards Labs sales, sales management,
    marketing, marketing management
  • Vaser Inc. VP Marketing Sales, clinical
    regulatory
  • Applied Medical VP Sales, general management
  • Micro Therapeutics, Inc. (MTI) Founder, CEO,
    Independent Director
  • Intersect Partners Founder, CEO, Director
  • Sub-Q, Inc.
  • Trans1, Inc.
  • ReShape Medical, Inc.
  • MindFrame, Inc.
  • Altura Interventional, Inc.
  • SV Life Sciences Venture Partner

8
  • Interest in Start-Ups Early Stage Companies
  • American Edwards Laboratories, Inc.
    (1980) Entrepreneurs
  • Advanced Cardiovascular Systems, Inc.
    (1982-1985) Exciting/ s
  • Balloon angioplasty
  • Friend was an early employee
  • Successful sale to Eli Lilly (IOX)
  • Cardiometrics, Inc. (1986) Tech Development
  • Continuous cardiac output
  • Investor consultant previous experience
  • Changed directions technology
  • Cram down financing/revise split ? sold later
  • Lost most of my invested capital 25K
  • Vaser, Inc. (1986-1989) Reg/Clin strategy
  • Laser angioplasty peripheral/coronary Reimburse
    ment
  • VP Sales Marketing (Regulatory/Clinical
    Affairs) BOD communication
  • Marginal clinical results

9
  • Definitions
  • Start-up from the beginning
  • Individually driven entrepreneur
  • Define the business opportunity not the
    invention?
  • Develop the product
  • Take the early risk!
  • Develop a detailed plan
  • Resources required
  • Timing
  • Financing/exit
  • Communication tool!
  • Lesson learned from an early entrepreneur
  • Informed Risk Taking

10
  • An Early Entrepreneur Christopher Columbus
  • Opportunity more direct route to Asia (land
    trading)
  • Plan maps, resources, time
  • Financing Spain (ships supplies) Terms
  • Assumption miss ran into Americas Midcourse
    Correction

Columbus
Spain
Americas
Asia
11
  • Definition - Midcourse Correction
  • Assumes you are on a journey Opportunity
  • Assumes you have a map Plan
  • Assumes an unexpected event Wrong assumption
  • Negative Positive
  • Assumes you still plan on going You are still in
    charge,
  • to the destination you did not get fired
  • Assumes you may have to Resources, time, returns
  • modify your plan Communicate to Stakeholders

12
  • Start-Up Experience Founder
  • Companies
  • Micro Therapeutics, Inc. (1993) neuro/cath lab
  • Sub-Q, Inc. (1995) vascular/cath lab
  • TranS1, Inc. (1997) orthopedic/spine
  • ReShape Medical, Inc. (2003) obesity
  • MindFrame, Inc. (2006) neuro/cath lab
  • Altura Interventional, Inc. (2008) vascular/AAA
    repair
  • Review
  • History of the company
  • Midcourse corrections
  • Outcome

13
  • Midcourse Corrections

14
  • Micro Therapeutics, Inc. (1993) (MTIX)
  • History
  • Business strategy developed while working full
    time (Andy Cragg, MD)
  • 4th business plan became MTI (significant
    planning)
  • All cost (100K) were absorbed by Founders (20-30
    hrs/wk)
  • Notified employer of intention to leave
    (terminated 30 days)
  • Seed financing friends family (investing in
    You!)
  • Sent out 15 business plans to qualified venture
    groups
  • Presented to 7 venture groups in 3 cities over 2
    weeks
  • Received a term sheet on day 3
  • Negotiated term presented in parallel
  • Signed term sheet closed financing in 9-10
    weeks
  • Management facility in place (financing)
  • Business strategy / product development
  • Peripheral blood clot therapy (2 products)
  • Neuro/hemorrhagic stroke aneurysm AVM
    embolization

15
  • Micro Therapeutics, Inc.
  • Midcourse correction 1 product development
  • Situation
  • 3 product development programs in parallel
  • Infusion catheters late development / process
  • Mechanical thrombectomy design validation
  • Brain aneurysm embolization concept testing
  • Brain aneurysm testing balloon
    exclusion/scleroses
  • 2 pigs died immediately
  • 1 pig died in follow-up testing

Did not work
16
  • Micro Therapeutics, Inc.
  • Midcourse correction 1 product development
  • What are you thinking? Group
  • Balloon, catheter, protocol, model, agent did not
    work?
  • What am I going to tell my investors?
  • What am I going to tell the employees?
  • What if I take that product out of the plan?
  • How much time, money milestones are on this
    project?
  • Is there a better way to achieve the objective?
  • Can I achieve the plan with a different approach?
  • Do we have the capability/resources?

17
  • Micro Therapeutics, Inc.
  • Midcourse correction 1 product development
  • What did I do?
  • Reviewed case results can we make it work?
  • Hired a Ph.D. biochemist with device experience
  • Reviewed other approaches 3 categories/56 ideas
  • Re-planned the project longer more money
  • Talked to the investors BOD (discussed options)
  • Accomplishments with current capital
  • Financing strategy changes/return at exit
  • Moved forward with the NEW STRATEGY

18
  • Micro Therapeutics, Inc.
  • Midcourse correction 1 product development
  • How did the company do?
  • Completed the revised aneurysm product
  • Completed a successful Series B financing
  • Completed development introduced both
    peripheral/BCT products
  • Completed development of full line of neuro
    support products
  • Raised capital from corporate investors
    (distribution)
  • Initiated clinical trials on 2 neuro products
  • Completed an IPO
  • Raised private equity in public market (PIPE)
  • Change of control financing (Warburg/ev3) /
    merger
  • Currently neuro division of ev3 (250M)
  • More time money successful investment

19
  • Sub-Q, Inc. (1995)
  • History
  • Business strategy developed while running MTI
    (release)
  • This is when Intersect Partners was formed
    (100K)
  • Sub-Q formation much easier 2nd time (much larger
    existing market)
  • Two rounds of seed financing friends family
  • Raised small Series A from a known second tier
    VC
  • Converted consulting team to full time employees
  • VP/GM raised Series B (very difficult) talked
    to 4 groups
  • George Wallace leaves MTI and joins Sub-Q as CEO
  • Sub-Q completes and files PMA Vascular Closure
    Device
  • Start the Series B financing with venture
    corporate targets
  • Went to big medical meeting to negotiate terms
    sheet (TCT)

20
  • Sub-Q, Inc.
  • Midcourse correction 2 financing/exit
  • Situation
  • Initiated commercialization in US (direct)
  • Completing development on second generation
    product (clinicals)
  • Raising 10 million to 15 million (continue
    commercialization)
  • Less than 1 million (400K/month burn)
  • Negotiated Bridge financing (timing)
  • Left for TCT to meet with 4 venture groups/4
    corporate groups
  • 9/11 ATTACK
  • Did not get to Washington DC for TCT
  • No return calls from venture or corporate groups

21
  • Sub-Q, Inc.
  • Midcourse correction 2 financing/exit
  • What are you thinking? Group
  • Were any potential investors on those planes?
  • Will anyone want to invest in this environment?
  • Can I continue commercialization in this
    environment?
  • Will my existing investors still complete the
    Bridge financing?
  • How long will the Bridge need to last?

22
  • Sub-Q, Inc.
  • Midcourse correction 2 financing/exit
  • What did we do?
  • Put a pause on the commercialization process
    convert to clinical
  • Went back to vendors and asked for payment terms
  • Revised the plan to lower burn, stretch cash
  • Went back to investors/BOD with revised Bridge
    plan
  • Contacted current potential venture investors
    (none died)
  • Contacted current potential corporate groups
    (none died)
  • Focused financing on corporate groups for
    financing vs. purchase
  • Completed corporate financing with BSC
    (financing/distribution/purchase option)
  • Corporate Financing
  • Talked to 4 groups
  • Signed term sheet with another group
  • Last minute term sheet came in from BSC

23
  • Sub-Q, Inc.
  • Midcourse correction 2 financing/exit
  • How did the Company do?
  • Completed the financing
  • 15 million (10M 5M tranche)
  • Worldwide distribution with sales minimums
  • Option to purchase the company at pre-determined
    value (2 time periods)
  • Trained the BSC sales organization (target
    specialist)
  • Support target account introduction (1st
    generation)
  • Completed 2nd generation clinicals OUS
  • Prepared for manufacturing ramp up (BSC audit)
  • 1 yr. later first option to purchase
  • Business development/Sr. management
  • RD/marketing group
  • Sales management

24
  • Sub-Q, Inc.
  • Midcourse correction 2(B) financing/exit
  • Situation
  • BSC has option to purchase _at_ 100 million
  • They are challenging the design, but positive
  • Second generation product addresses remaining
    issues
  • BSC is distracted by roll out of drug eluting
    stents
  • If BSC does not exercise the option, 5M
    financing required
  • We are confident they will meet and exercise
    option to purchase
  • BSC declines the purchase option
  • Want the performance of the next generation
  • Sales force focus on drug eluting stents

25
  • Sub-Q, Inc.
  • Midcourse correction 2(B) financing/exit
  • What are you thinking? Group
  • Why did they really turn this down?
  • Price better price after rejection
  • No longer interested in the space
  • Focus on stents (sales force)
  • Did we miss the performance?
  • Will BSC be interested based on Generation II?
  • Will BSC invest the second 5 million?
  • Will BSC buy up to the minimums?
  • How will other potential investors/buyers view
    this?
  • What will my investors/BOD reaction be?

26
  • Sub-Q, Inc.
  • Midcourse correction 2(B) financing/exit
  • What did we do?
  • We pressed BSC for the basis of their decision
  • Too much sales time required (effect on stents)
  • Second generation may address this in future
  • Lack of management commitment competitive
    technology
  • Negotiated a plan to go direct with BSC
  • Accelerated development of Generation II and III
    products
  • Completed the 5 million BSC financing
  • Went back to other corporate groups to determine
    interest
  • Expanded sales clinical specialists and moved
    forward direct

27
  • Sub-Q, Inc.
  • Midcourse correction 2(B) financing/exit
  • How did the Company do?
  • Sales began to increase, cash burn increased
    faster
  • Introduced Generation II product with improved
    results
  • Accelerated Generation III product development
  • Determined that commercialization would require 2
    yrs. longer 20M
  • Corporate interest from 4 groups (including BSC)
    all with distribution
  • Terminated all marketing sales
    activities/people
  • Focused on Generation III product corporate
    deal
  • Three term sheets (BSC)
  • Accepted term sheet for purchase from relatively
    unknown group
  • Never completed the deal
  • Successfully completed a SMOKE sale

28
  • TranS1, Inc. (1997)
  • History
  • Business strategy developed while running MTI,
    managing Sub-Q
  • Used consultants to manage development process
  • Two rounds of seed and Series A raised without
    management
  • Completed successful clinicals OUS
  • Determined 510K on first product was feasible

29
  • TranS1, Inc.
  • Midcourse correction 3 achieve milestones
    early (positive)
  • Situation
  • Everything was ahead of schedule
  • Product development
  • Clinical validation
  • Regulatory approval process
  • Created a need for resources
  • Financing
  • Dedicated management
  • Commercialization strategy
  • George Wallace was not available
  • CEO, MTI
  • Managing Sub-Q part time
  • Supporting TranS1

30
  • TranS1, Inc.
  • Midcourse correction 3 achieve milestones
    early (positive)
  • What are you thinking? Group
  • Should we hire resources local George Wallace
    manage?
  • Hire CEO local?
  • Hire CEO move company to this location?
  • Raise money (Series B) then hire management?

31
  • TranS1, Inc.
  • Midcourse correction 3 achieve milestones
    early (positive)
  • What did we do?
  • We hired a recruiter and targeted So Cal
    Minneapolis
  • We scrubbed our network for candidates
  • Hired an experienced CEO in Wilmington N.C.
    (early stage/known)
  • Moved the company

32
  • TranS1, Inc.
  • Midcourse correction 3 achieve milestones
    early (positive)
  • How did the Company do?
  • Transition to Wilmington was smooth
  • Product development clinical trials on both
    products continued positive
  • Recruited strong management team
  • RD V.P. (TranS1 consultant)
  • Regulatory (former FDA director)
  • Sales marketing (veteran/spine)
  • Secured Series B Series C venture financing
    (terms)
  • Launched the 1st product
  • IPO in 2007 (TSON)
  • Growing public company

33
  • ReShape Medical, Inc. (2003)
  • History
  • George Wallace sells Sub-Q, starts as Venture
    Partner (SV Life Science)
  • Working on multiple projects at Intersect
    Partners including obesity
  • Complete the business strategy and present to
    SVLS first
  • Term sheet for Seed financing
  • Intersect Partners completes concept development
    under contract
  • Present to 4 potential Series A investors
  • Complete Series A financing (4.5M)
  • Complete development and prepare for OUS
    clinicals
  • US regulatory strategy will be critical (bad
    history)

34
  • ReShape Medical, Inc.
  • Midcourse correction 4 management
  • Situation
  • Product design testing were 90 complete
  • OUS clinical trials were set up and ready to go
  • Discussion with FDA were positive (without
    commitment)
  • We had money in the bank to complete near term
    milestones
  • George Wallace suggested hiring CEO early

35
  • ReShape Medical, Inc.
  • Midcourse correction 4 management
  • What are you thinking? Group
  • Product development is complete
  • Positive experience at TranS1 (new model)
  • Management of the US regulatory strategy is key
  • Management of the OUS clinicals requires
    significant resources
  • Allows time for RD transfer recruiting
  • Prepare for Series B financing

36
  • ReShape Medical, Inc.
  • Midcourse correction 4 management
  • What did we do?
  • Revised the operating plan for earlier management
  • Hired a recruiter targeted experienced CEOs
  • Scrubbed our networks for candidates
  • Hired an experienced CEO in Minneapolis, MN
  • Heavy negotiation for severance agreement
  • Managed sold two prior early stage companies
  • Former GE Medical executive
  • Moved the company to Minneapolis
  • Facility
  • Recruit key people
  • Transfer RD knowledge vendor contacts

37
  • ReShape Medical, Inc.
  • Midcourse correction 4 management
  • How did the Company do?
  • Transition did not go well
  • CEO decisions were questioned at early stage
  • CEO did not like the Intersect Partner contract
  • CEO treated Intersect personnel poorly
  • CEO terminated all consulting relationships
  • CEO hired average people
  • Product development issues delays came up
  • CEO attacked Intersect Partners over issues
    delays
  • CEO approach BOD about Intersect termination
  • BOD decided to terminate CEO pay severance

38
  • ReShape Medical, Inc.
  • Midcourse correction 4 management
  • What did Company do?
  • Manage the departure of the CEO
  • Revise the operating plan under Intersect
    Partners management
  • Extend the Series A financing by 3 million
  • Terminate the employees/close Minneapolis
    facility
  • Complete the design testing start OUS
    clinicals
  • Design improvements OUS testing
  • Met with FDA on US clinical trial design
  • Start recruiter on CEO search (So Cal target)
  • Hired CEO (OC) recruited team
  • Initiated transfer from Intersect Partners
  • Completed Series B financing (new plan)
  • Completed 100th OUS clinical
  • Focused on US clinical trial strategy (PMA)

39
  • MindFrame, Inc. (2006)
  • History
  • Neuro opportunity investigated with industry RD
    executive
  • Business strategy developed with RD executive
  • Presented business strategy to SVLS (ReShape
    Medical)
  • Term sheet for Seed financing (with full time
    employee)
  • Intersect employee complete concept development
    (3 products)
  • Present to 2 venture groups with neuro experience
    (Series A)
  • SV Life Sciences submits term sheet as sole
    investor
  • Complete OUS clinicals/US clinicals, exit early
  • Return metrics work for single investor/not
    multiple
  • Product development focuses on single approach

40
  • MindFrame, Inc.
  • Midcourse correction 5 unanticipated clinical
    results
  • Situation
  • Product design testing demonstrated positive
    results
  • Two competitors were building the market with
    inferior products
  • New product testing was showing encouraging
    results
  • MindFrame had an experienced neuro team
  • Waited two months for our first patient
  • Treated our first patient
  • Product worked well (as designed)
  • Poor clinical result
  • Treated two additional patients same results

41
  • MindFrame, Inc.
  • Midcourse correction 5 unanticipated clinical
    results
  • What are you thinking? Group
  • There must be an issue with patient selection
  • The physician might not be using the product
    correctly
  • Did the product work the way it was suppose to?
  • Why did competitive products work in similar
    circumstances?
  • Will the physician, hospital other
    investigators continue?
  • My plan has just changed significantly (cash)

42
  • MindFrame, Inc.
  • Midcourse correction 5 unanticipated clinical
    results
  • What did we do?
  • Suspended clinicals at 1st clinical site
  • Reviewed case results with clinical experts
  • Modified the protocol
  • Age of blood clot
  • Length of blood clot
  • Location of blood clot
  • Completed site expansion process to improve
    enrollment
  • Modified the device so that it is longer
  • Proposed 5 different operating plans to BOD
  • Clinical results prior to financing or sale

43
  • MindFrame, Inc.
  • Midcourse correction 5 unanticipated clinical
    results
  • How did the Company do?
  • Reduced burn rate by 50, buy time
  • Intersect Partners fees
  • Operating expenses
  • Expanded clinical sites
  • Completed product change
  • Looking for patients

44
  • Midcourse Correction Takeaways
  • Deviation from your plan happen continuously
  • Change in your assumptions
  • Identification of a critical need
  • Significant event
  • Midcourse corrections can be generated by
    negative positive events
  • Direction changes require communicationrevised
    plan
  • Bigger the change, more communication required

45
  • Midcourse Correction Timing Anytime
  • Company formation
  • Intellectual property development
  • Financing
  • Product development
  • Clinical evaluation
  • Regulatory approval
  • Marketing sales
  • Reimbursement
  • Distribution
  • Product offering
  • Pricing
  • Promotion
  • Exit

46
  • Lessons Midcourse Corrections
  • Take time to plan
  • Challenge your assumptions
  • Model sensitivity of changes
  • Have contingency plans for key assumptions
  • Model changes caused by events or results
    communicate
  • Communicate informally formally on all key
    changes
  • Only change your operating plan formally (BOD)

47
  • Start-Up Process

48
  • Developing Your Plan
  • Your plan is the best communications tool you
    have in the start-up process
  • Communications Requirements
  • Investors individuals, venture capital, private
    equity, corporations, debt, Wall St.
  • Team management, employees, BOD
  • Advisors lawyers, accountants, consultants,
    vendors, banks
  • Customers physicians and hospitals
  • Every plan will change continuously
  • Major changes require communications

49
  • The Planning Process (example)
  • Start from the exit and work backwards
    (opportunity value)
  • Build value through the accomplishment of key
    milestones
  • Define the key assumptions resources required
    for each milestone
  • Series Investing
  • Measure report each key assumption
  • Review results against plan with management
    advisors frequently
  • Good Bad Results
  • Planning is a Communications Process

50
  • 5-7 Year Operating Plan
  • Develop your own opportunity specific model
  • PL
  • Balance Sheet
  • Cash Flow
  • Make it flexible model changes
  • Sub document (detail)
  • Project schedule /cost
  • Clinical data accumulation / cost (OUS/US)
  • Hiring plan
  • Regulatory time line
  • Milestones

51
Milestones 2008
1st OUS Clinicals 11/08
OUS Clinicals Complete 06/09
CE Mark Approval 09/09
IDE Approval 10/09
US Trial Start 11/09
Hire CEO 02/10
File 510(k) 11/10
Complete US Trial 04/11
FDA Approval 11/11
1M Series A Extension 06/09
Series A Cash Out 12/09
Series B Financing 11/09
  • Examples

52
  • Intersect Partners, LLC Medical Device
    Incubator
  • George Wallace Andrew Cragg, MD (Interventional
    Radiology)
  • Medical device incubator start manage
    multiple companies simultaneously
  • 3 experienced RD managers/engineers, 1 business
    development analyst
  • 5,000 sq. ft./San Clemente Quality System
    supports multiple opportunities
  • Consultants vendors experts in IP, legal,
    development, quality, regulatory clinical
  • Define opportunities, start and finance
    companies, develop products
  • Equity ownership, development fees
  • Twice as fast on half the capital

53
  • Medical Device Start-Up Process (Communications)
  • Define the un-met clinical need
  • Develop a plan to address this need
  • Raise capital to finance your plan
  • Recruit needed resources
  • Develop your product or service
  • Prove that your product works Intersect Partners
  • Gain approval to sell your product
  • Market penetration
  • Served market
  • Un-served marked
  • The Plan

54
  • Intersect Partners Incubation
  • Internally developed (all functions)
  • Review 3-5 un-met clinical problems
  • Develop unique solutions (device)
  • IP protection prototyping
  • Develop business strategy plan
  • Review with venture firm (SV Life Sciences)
  • Select best opportunity and negotiate financing
    (more than 1)
  • Develop the product to clinical proof of concept
  • Recruit management team
  • Support at BOD level (Exit?)
  • Manage 3 opportunities different states

55
  • Intersect Partners Incubation
  • Externally generated (partial functions)
  • From venture firms, entrepreneurs, physicians,
    investors, industry contacts
  • Different phases of development financing
  • Negotiated fees ownership
  • Have not completed a deal yet
  • Dont like the area or approach (opportunity)
  • Control of process (vs. financing)

56
  • Intersect Partners, LLC - Capabilities
Write a Comment
User Comments (0)
About PowerShow.com