Title: Proven Strategies for Making Existing Buildings Energy and Operationally Efficient
1Proven Strategies for Making Existing Buildings
Energy and Operationally Efficient
- REMOVING OBSTACLES TO ENERGY EFFICIENCYTHROUGH
BUSINESS CASE AND REAL RESULTS - John W. Conover IV, President, Trane Commercial
Americas At Fairleigh Dickinson University
2About John W. Conover IV
- Leader for the Trane commercial business in the
Americas 14,200 employees in the U.S., Canada
and Latin America - Been in the HVAC-R industry for 30 years
- During tenure with Trane, played integral role in
better understanding customer expectations and
market needs such as the growing search for
energy efficiency solutions. - Focus heavily on gaining innovative insights on
what it takes to acquire, satisfy and retain
customers. - Earned a bachelors of science degree in civil
engineering from Lehigh University and is a
registered professional engineer. - Attended the Executive Leadership Program at the
Wharton School of Business at the University of
Pennsylvania. - John and his wife Marsha live in New Jersey and
are the proud parents of four children
3About Ingersoll Rand
- 17 billion diversified industrial company
- 64,000 employees worldwide
- More than 100 manufacturing facilities worldwide
- Operate in every major geographic region
- Strategic brands are 1 or 2 in their markets
About Trane Commercial Equipment
Systems Residential Products Aftermarket
Parts Trane Building Services
4How Ingersoll Rand Walks the Talkabout Energy
Efficiency
- INGERSOLL RAND IS REDUCING ITS OWN ENVIRONMENTAL
FOOTPRINT - Trane and Ingersoll Rand active with the U.S.
Environmental Protection Agency - Members of Climate Leader Program
- Joined Smart Way Program To reduce environmental
impact of transportation activities - Members of the Green Chill program Energy
efficiency in the supermarket industry - Member of the Dow Jones North American
Sustainability Index, various investing indicies
- Established internal goals for reduction of
energy use and climate change emissions - Energy audit program to understand energy
use/strategies for reducing consumption - Established a Sustainability Strategy Council to
further integrate Sustainability principles
throughout our business - Created green teams in all locations to engage
employees and champion reduction - Established national patch program with Girl
Scouts of the Americas called BTU Crew to
encourage girls to reduce energy use in community
buildings - LEED certified buildings in the U.S. and Asia
5Why Trane is Talking About Energy Efficiency
- WHAT WE DO
- Trane works with leaders who take a broad view of
organizational performance - We offer most energy efficient systems along with
energy management and optimization service that
leverages operational savings to support business
objectives - OUR EXPERIENCE
- 1 out of every 2 buildings in the U.S. has a
Trane system - More LEED certified Accredited Professionals (AP)
in the industry - Most energy efficient large chilled water system
on the market today - More than 125 performance contracting projects
- Average project in the range of 2M with 10 year
contract - OUR ENVIRONMENTAL CONTRIBUTION (ENERGY SAVINGS
EQUIVALENT) - 18,722 cars taken off the highway
- 11,323,812 gallons of gasoline saved
- 21,843 planted mature trees
- 68,074,062 gallons of water saved
- 224,666,420 pounds of CO2 saved
6Perfect StormFactors Influencing Energy
Efficiency Building Owners Today
- ENERGY USE IN EXISTING BUILDINGS A PRIORITY
- Buildings consume 1/3 of energy worldwide and
expected to grow Population growth,
urbanization, developing countries - Energy use in buildings projected to grow
- Up to 40 of total operating expenses of some
buildings - Single greatest contributor to global warming
- Tremendous amount of energy-related policy
- Improve environment and reduce oil reliance
- Stimulate the economy and create jobs
- Reduce risk and increase business confidence
7Perfect StormFactors Influencing Energy
Efficiency Building Owners Today
- ESPECIALLY IN CHALLENGING ECONOMIC ENVIRONMENT
- Reduced operating budgets and deferred
maintenance - New construction outlook remains weak
- Considered to be operating in a global
recessionary market - Businesses pinched more than ever
- Operating costs continue to rise with intense
pressure to reduce - Access to cash and credit more limited than ever
- Limited appetite for capital investments without
clear payback
8What This MeansFor Building Owners and Business
Leaders
- ENERGY EFFICIENCY IS A BUSINESS IMPERATIVE
- More than a nice to do or method for being
socially responsible - There are tangible business results directly
associated with energy efficiency - Financial, customer satisfaction, employee
productivity - Not to mention that it makes assets more valuable
- And theres a positive environmental contribution
- As business leaders, our job is to remove
obstacles to energy efficiency - Must be C-level owned / championed
- Need a financially-motivated business plan
- Dont get caught up in the noise there are
proven strategies and technologies for making
existing business more efficient
9Why A C-Level ImperativeFor Building Owners and
Business Leaders
CONSERVATION IS FOR THE BOILER ROOM EFFICIENCY
IS FOR THE BOARD ROOM
- ENERGY CONSERVATION
- Using less energy, without necessarily increasing
the output - Fewer truck runs to / from warehouse
- Turning off unused equipment on weekends /
off-hours - Modifying behaviors and practices
- Low hanging fruit / low first cost / fast payback
projects - Holding the Gains depends on culture
- ENERGY EFFICIENCY
- Using less energy and achieving more output
- Rightsizing / replacing infrastructure
- Process / product improvement
- Less environmental impact in the supply chain
- Often higher initial cost, but better life cycle
payback (need to understand the financials) - Holding the gains depends on automatic controls
and monitoring
The Value of Efficiency Reduce production
losses, spoilage, downtime while increasing good
will and customer impact
Alliance to Save Energy Strategic Industrial
Energy Efficiency
10Getting Started A Financially-Motivated Business
Case
11Making the Case for Energy Efficiency
- Critical question Is your building overhead or
an asset?
Owners who view their buildings as assets link
the physical environment to business outcomes
customer and employee satisfaction, productivity,
operating expense reduction, among others. These
buildings can be high performance and tie to
the mission, values and results of a business
- Value to people the building serves (environment,
comfort, safety) - Value to customers and community (competence,
environmental responsibility) - Value to the bottom line (cost savings,
avoidance, ROIC)
12Making the Case for Energy Efficiency
Public Private
Improve Infrastructure Stay Competitive (Attract Tenants, Customers, Talent)
Reduce Maintenance Costs Reduce Maintenance Costs
Reduce Operating Costs Reduce Operating Costs
Optimize Capital Budget Optimize Capital Budget
Improve Indoor Environment (Comfort Occupant Performance) Improve Indoor Environment (Comfort Occupant Performance)
Be Socially Responsible Add Asset Value
- Critical question What are your driving factors
for change?
- Every building, project and customer is different
making each project unique - Modeling begins with understanding
- Why project was initiated
- Goals and objectives
- Appetite for risk
13Making the Case for Energy Efficiency
- Critical question How will you fund your
project?
- Three budget categories
- Energy budget
- Operating expense budget
- Capital improvement budget
- Potential for more robust projects
- Evaluate benefits beyond payback period
- Energy projects reduce operating and capital
improvement budgets
14Making the Case for Energy Efficiency
- Critical question How will you fund your
project?
- Goal Allocate potential savings from operating
budgets and avoidance from capital budgets to
fund project - Operating budgets should reflect the funding of
the debt service for the project with offsets to
energy and maintenance budgets. - Capital budgets should also reflect the funding
of debt service...this is the amount of capital
avoided as a result of the project. - Projects that take a comprehensive approach
create a consistent funding expectation and help
mitigate unexpected spikes in funding
requirements.
15Making the Case for Energy Efficiency
- Critical question How will your project be
delivered?
- Performance criteria examples
- Reliability (uptime, of unplanned incidents)
- Efficiency (kW/Ton, mcf/BTU, etc.)
- Operating status (state of readiness,
availability) - Field conditions (clean towers, condensers, air
intake) - Output (BTUs, cooling tons, cfm, gpm)
- Capacity (peak output matched to load)
- Quality (power quality, load factors, IAQ)
- Rate of economic return (sustained energy
efficiency)
- Though capital remains the same, performance can
be guaranteed by providers - Providers compensated based upon success in
achieving goals - Contracts typically stipulate how incentives will
be paid out for elevated performance or penalties
assessed for missed targets.
The Aberdeen Group, February 2007
16Making the Case for Energy Efficiency
- Critical question What changes can be made based
upon financial objectives?
Quick Return (0-3 yr payback) Intermediate (3-8 yr payback) Long-term
Retrofit lighting Install new building automation system Replace high efficiency equipment (major systems chiller/boilers)
Update existing building automation systems Improve HVAC systems (CV to VAV) Building envelope improvements
Conduct retro/re-commissioning Implement water conservation Apply renewable technologies
Make behavioral changes (Turn lights off, program systems) Use fans and motors (VFDs, high efficiency change outs) Apply on site/distributive power generation
Explore utility procurement options Apply load shifting technology (ice storage) Implement comprehensive maintenance and repair strategies
- Purpose of the building determines the investment
strategy - If a lifecycle return / financial approach is
taken, owners can enjoy the benefits of
everything listed on the chart significant
energy, operating, environmental and business
benefits
17Making the Case for Energy Efficiency
- Breaking a myth We need to wait for new
technology or need emerging technology to improve
energy efficiency
Proven technologies available for all buildings
types meeting various payback requirements
- DISTRICT COOLING/HEATING SYSTEM
- Multiple buildings/ campus/ industrial
- Higher overall system efficiency
- Beautify city outlook
- GEOTHERMAL HEAT PUMP SYSTEM
- Residential and commercial buildings
- Pump energy from underground
- Enjoy energy saving all seasons
- THERMAL STORAGE SYSTEMS
- Large city with high peak demand
- Shift demand from daytime to night
- Reduce blackout during hot summer
- HIGH EFFICIENCY CHILLED WATER SYSTEMS
- Large commercial/industrial buildings
- Generate chilled water for cooling
- Reduce energy consumption by half
- ENERGY RECOVERY
- Less energy to cool fresh air brought into the
building in summer - Less energy to pre-heat cold fresh air from
outside in winter - Free energy to provide hot water
- INDOOR AIR QUALITY
- Proper ventilation with minimum energy
- Temperature and humidity control
- Filtration options ensure good IAQ
18Making the Case for Energy Efficiency
- Critical question What costs need to be
considered when financially modeling an energy
project?
- Total cost of ownership approach
- All of these factors need to be addressed at some
point - Modeling the building as a long-term asset
- Offers greater financial transparency
- Will ultimately save energy and operating dollars
throughout the life of the asset
Visible Costs
Price/Time
Engineering Charges
Energy Costs
CFC Issues
Maintenance Costs
Equipment Shutdown Costs
Construction Change Orders
Legal Costs
Security Costs
Start-up Delays
Indoor Air Quality
Being Green Costs
Fire Protection Cost
Performance Problems
Hidden Costs
19Making the Case for Energy Efficiency
- Critical question How do owners ensure ongoing
performance of energy projects?
- Proactive maintenance strategy
- Ensure that desired outcomes as assured
throughout the life of the asset - Deliver an agreement that is cost-beneficial to
Trane customers and provides value-driven service - Doing so will avoid capital, energy and repair
costs
- Return on investment 10 times
- Reduction in maintenance costs 25 to 30
- Elimination of breakdowns 70 to 75
- Reduction in downtime 35 to 45
- Increase in production 20 to 25.
- --- FEMP Guide, page 5.4
20Making the Case for Energy Efficiency
- Breaking a myth Maintenance is more than just
break / fix being proactive is a conscious
strategy
21Making the Case for Energy Efficiency
- Critical question What is the financial model
(example)?
22Making the Case for Energy Efficiency
- Critical question What is the financial model
(example)?
- Model offers comprehensive view
- Driving factors, funding and budget allocations,
capital expenses, total cost of ownership and
financial return - Analyzes cash flow over project life
- Model incorporates more ECMs
- If owner considers only energy savings in
financial decision - Project would yield a 11.7 year payback
- If owner considers energy, operating cost,
maintenance and asset replacement cost savings
over the life of the project - Project yields a 3 year payback and it generates
positive cash flow
23Making the Case for Energy Efficiency
Critical statement Different payback, same
return on investment
- Return calculations dependent on benefits
received beyond initial payback - Guaranteed returns support analysis beyond simple
payback calculations and provide financial basis
for long term investment in sustainability - Simple payback calculations help assess risk
- Guaranteed savings minimize risk of evaluating
longer term projects
24How To Get Started And Hold the Gains
- Make efficiency a c-level imperative
- Create a shared vision and create a mindset of
high performance - buildings rather than overhead
- Make the business case to understand appetite for
risk, payback and - realistic measures / actions that can be
taken - Make decisions and initiate your project
- Integrate energy efficiency into business
strategies, build - employee engagement
- Measure progress to ensure continuous improvement
25Proving the Model Case Examples of Large Energy
Projects
26Energy Project Makes Manufacturing Facility More
Competitive
- Situation
- Campus-style 102.200-sq-meter (1,1 million-sq-ft)
heavy industrial manufacturing plant - Aging infrastructure with low energy efficiency
and reliability and high operating and
maintenance costs - Dramatic downturn in product sales
- While experiencing 70 increase in energy costs
- Corporate goal of 15 reduction in energy cost by
2013 - Approach
- Factors driving improvements
- Need to stay competitive
- Reduce maintenance and operating costs
- Add asset value
27Energy Project Makes Manufacturing Facility More
Competitive
- Identifying investment benefits
1. Assessment
2. ECM Selection
3. Payback
Analyzed HVAC systems, compressed air and
lighting for efficiency, capacity and effective
operating and maintenance practices. Evaluated
remote monitoring application potential.
Lighting retrofits, building automation upgrades
and hot water boiler
Selected ECMs offer quick return
2.1 million project investment in new air
compressors, hot water boiler, lighting retrofit
and remote monitoring
- Results
- Two-year payback with projected 1.13 million in
annual energy savings 275,000 in annual labor
cost reduction - Energy reduction of 11.5 MKWH equivalent to CO2
emissions from 11 tanker truckloads - On track to achieve mandated 15 reduction by
2013 - Safer, more reliable and more energy-efficient
plant operations
28Infrastructure Improvements Generate Increased
Production
- Situation
- Single-story 32.500 square-meter (350.000
square-foot) manufacturing facility with 1,100
employees - Needed stable ambient environment for optimized
consumer product manufacturing - Outdated, unreliable infrastructure systems
- Approach
- Factors driving improvements
- Need to stay competitive, improve indoor
environment - Guaranteed performance of the upgraded system for
one year, offering on-call maintenance support if
ambient conditions were not met - Assurance of improved performance and plant
reliability, with available on-call support,
convinced management to complete the upgrades
29Infrastructure Improvements Generate Increased
Production
- Identifying investment benefits
1. Assessment
2. ECM Selection
3. Payback
Analyzed chiller and air handling systems and the
pneumatic building automation system (BAS) for
reliability, efficiency, capacity and performance
High-efficiency chiller systems with variable
flow water pumps, upgraded air handling systems
and centralized BAS --
Quick return BAS Solid return Chiller and air
handling systems
8 million system upgrade
- Results
- Customer able to more effectively compete
- Increased production in improved environment
- Maintained near-perfect system performance
- Completed needed adjustments within hours
- Project finished on time and on budget with
minimal production downtime
30Five Star Hotel Increases Comfort and Efficiency
- Situation
- Five-star Le Meridian Hotel on three-acre complex
- High operating expenses and service costs
- Outdated systems lacking centralized control
- Noise levels compromising guest and employee
comfort and government regulations - Approach
- Factors driving improvements increase
competitiveness, reduce operating costs, add
asset value - Identifying investment benefits
1. Assessment
3. Payback
2. ECM Selection
Selected ECMs offer solid return
Evaluated efficiency, capacity, noise, safety and
maintenance
New chiller systems and a centralized (BAS)
31Five Star Hotel Increases Comfort and Efficiency
- Deliverables
- 375K project with reduction of operating costs,
increasing reliability with a 3.5 year payback
included systems and remote monitoring - Results
- Significant reliability increase and 30
improvement in chiller plant energy efficiency - BAS achieved additional 6-8 energy savings
- Project completed in tight timeframe with minimal
guest inconvenience - Ongoing maintenance contract reduced service
costs 30 - Noise level reduction of 40 improved guest and
employee comfort and brought systems to code
32Hotel Hosts Upgrades for Increased Reliability
- Situation
- 20-story hotel with 518 guest rooms, casino and
meeting and exhibition - Frequent breakdowns, reduced efficiency and high
operating costs from outdated systems - Difficult-to-access plant room and decentralized
system control - Infrastructure systems generating noise
complaints from guests - Approach
- Factors driving improvements
- Increase competitiveness
- Reduce operating costs
- Increase asset value
- Environmental responsibility in compliance with
2010 mandate
33Hotel Hosts Upgrades for Increased Reliability
- Identifying investment benefits
2. EMC Selection
1. Assessment
3. Payback
High-efficiency chiller systems with variable
flow water pumps to reduce energy use and a
centralized BAS
Evaluated central plant comfort systems for
performance, energy consumption, operational
efficiencies and maintenance access
Selected ECMs offer medium timed return
Delivered 2 million integrated systems solution
with projected six year payback
- Results
- 15 improvement in overall building energy
efficiency (30 system improvement) - Significantly reduced carbon emissions to meet
2010 mandates - Increased comfort by reducing system noise by
25dbA - Reduced system breakdowns to near zero (reduction
in maintenance costs) - Completed project off-season without disrupting
hotel operations
34Municipality Conserves Resources, Increases
Comfort
- Situation
- Master-planned city of 36,000 residents
- Aging infrastructure, high energy consumption and
mechanical system and comfort issues in city
buildings - Approach
- Factors driving improvements Improve
infrastructure, reduce operating costs, improve
comfort, be environmentally and socially
responsible - Identifying investment benefits
1. Assessment
3. Payback
2. ECM Selection
Analyzed HVAC and lighting efficiency, and
capacity and effectiveness of maintenance
practices
Medium return Water, lighting, building envelope
and insulation Life cycle return BAS and HVAC
High-efficiency HVAC, lighting, water saving
fixtures, BAS, building envelope and insulation
1.3 million performance contracting with 11.5
year payback including annual savings of 120,000
based on todays utility rates
35Municipality Conserves Resources, Increases
Comfort
- Results
- No capital funding increase to make significant
physical improvements - Project guaranteed energy savings of 877,266 kWh
per year, equivalent to recycling 215 tonnes of
waste - First full year following renovations showed 10
energy savings above predicted savings - Project has also saved 18,448 therms of natural
gas and 1.2 million gallons of water - Comfort and maintenance issues resolved
36Bottom Line Business Case
37(No Transcript)