Title: MADRID: MANAGEMENT MODEL FOR FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS Proposal for the location of financial activities in Madrid and for the international provision of financial technology services
1MADRID MANAGEMENT MODEL FOR FINANCIAL
INSTITUTIONSProposal for the location of
financial activities in Madrid and for the
international provision of financial technology
services
2INDEX
- 1. Market research (KPMG) 1
- 2. Efficiency / Value Chain (Deloitte)
8 - 3. Innovation (PWC) 13
- 4. Technology and Infrastructure (Cap Gemini)
...20 - 5. CONCLUSION Comprehensive SWOT Analysis25
3Market research
- KPMG has prepared a market research as part of
the technology and innovation working group. The
work has consisted primarily of an analysis of
key market indicators and the related value chain
to extract the success factors of the Spanish
market. - The study is part of the main tasks to be
performed for the strategic diagnosis of the
Financial Center in Madrid and will outline the
strategy that best suits its capabilities. - An important financial centre is identified by
its ability to attract funds towards the
different markets located within it.
4Market researchRegulation, supervision and risk
management
- Madrid is the financial capital of Spain and is
the Financial Centre where most of the activity
of the Spanish market is focused. - One of the great strengths of the Spanish market
is confidence. - Trust is a rising variable, especially today as a
result of current events in the markets. - Regulating and supervising bodies play a key role
in ensuring the security of the financial market,
risk management in financial institutions having
become particularly relevant. - The establishment of risk management systems
integrated into the culture of organizations, in
addition to complying with regulation, help
ensure that companies are better run, more
transparent and therefore more attractive to
investors. - Asking shareholders to support companies that
take risks and embark on projects with long-term
return requires trust. The Spanish market
provides confidence to its agents and emphasizes
the solidity of its financial institutions.
5Market researchRegulation, supervision and risk
management (cont)
- The tasks of regulation and supervision by the
Bank of Spain have helped consolidate the Spanish
financial system. - Specifically, the Spanish monitoring system has
proven to be effective, in both the
interpretation and adjustment of international
regulations, notable for having applied a
pragmatic approach that has made the adoption of
these standards by the Spanish authorities much
less traumatic and more homogeneous than in the
experience of other european institutions. - Likewise, the prudential supervision performed by
the Bank of Spain has allowed our financial
institutions to cope with the current crisis and
has been recognized both nationally and
internationally. - The Bank of Spain has also stood out as a pioneer
in introducing measures to mitigate
procyclicality, with wide and deserved
recognition of its experience in implementing
advanced models of risk management and solvency
in the context of Basel II. - The Bank of Spain model combines regulatory and
supervisory tasks in a single body, resulting in
a competitive advantage over other financial
markets..
6Market researchRelevant aspects
KPMG has identified 16 key success factors in the
markets
Market resilience Security Perception Liquidity Technology Customer needs Wealth movement Efficiency
Risk Management Capital requirements Regulator Financing and credit needs Real estate management Interest rate and exchange rate tensions Knowledge management and innovation Other environment variables
7Market researchOther relevant aspects
Given the current crisis in the markets, a critical factor in the success of the Madrid Financial Centre is its resilience and ability to recover. Spain has the advantage of having a strong banking model, based on customer-centered retail operations, based on the attraction of savings to loan it to families and businesses, which allows it to have a solid deposit and capital base and a diversified business. While it is true that an adjustment in our financial system is pending, no changes are expected to the model itself. Recovery will depend largely on proper risk and real estate asset management, on the capitalization of our financial institutions and enterprises, on the strains of interest rates and exchange rates, and on the restoration of the credit and the financing system. The Spanish stock market is recognized as one of the most secure, providing maximum security and transparency and ensuring for investors the existence of the securities that are bought or sold and of the money at stake. It is vital to enhance measures which increase liquidity in the system and which increase the offer of listed shares and trading in products offered both in the equity and debt markets. The good Spanish market response to this crisis must be used to strengthen the image and reputation of our financial system and create a brand. It is important to design and implement a marketing plan to raise the actual position of the Madrid Financial centre and increase the attractiveness of the region to market players.
8Market researchRelevant aspects
The technological resources of the major financial institutions in the Madrid Financial Center are good and are its stronghold. One of the critical threats to the financial market is the emergence of competing centres with more advanced, more secure, faster technology, with better connectivity. It is therefore recommendable to develop new technological developments and investment in specialized technology, strategic alliances within the market players as well as technology and communication systems suppliers, in order to improve the efficiency of productivity and market competitiveness. The market environment is constantly changing and increasingly competitive assuming one of the critical risks that of not having an innovative offer tailored to customer needs. It is important to make a thorough study on the needs of customers and different market players, their profiles and new products demanded, so there is a match between supply and demand to provide a differential value to the Madrid Financial Centre. Financial markets move in an increasingly competitive environment resulting in greater mobility of capital, more active participation of local markets and increased competition in different geographical areas. Therefore, one of the greatest threats to the financial markets of Madrid is the shifting of pockets of wealth to other, more attractive, places. It is advisable to know where the masses of wealth are displaced to and the differential characteristics of the receiving centres.
9Market researchConclusion
Our financial institutions have stood out for having efficient models assuming a competitive advantage, but improvements still have to be made through investments in technology and innovation, changes in organizational models and increased productivity. Spain has the advantage of having major financial institutions of international prestige which have been noted for the excellent management of new businesses, the proper management of synergies and integration process and whose headquarters are in Madrid. The brand image they have created is a stronghold for the Madrid Financial Centre. Madrid drives the Spanish economy and has plans for major investments in infrastructure and communications that will help in the positioning of the Madrid Financial Centre and which must be promoted. It is very important to have incentives and tax measures to encourage domestic and foreign investment in the financial markets of Madrid. In Spain we face a crisis but not a shift in the banking business model and this gives us an advantage we must exploit. One of the major challenges faced by the Madrid Financial Centre is the ability to adapt to the changing environment and particularly to the current crisis. Anticipation of the changing environment is a key to the success of any strategy and therefore the management of expectations is vital. We recommend continuous monitoring of the main key success factors and implementation of an action plan to enhance competitive advantages in line with the strategic objectives of Madrid International Financial Centre.
10 Efficiency
- Spanish financial institutions are leading the
global benchmark for efficiency ranking in the
sector. - Madrid has an optimal response to the operational
requirements of the value chain of any financial
activity, both for the front and back office. - DELOITTE has analyzed the value chain of various
business and financial activities, showing the
differential values of Madrid compared to other
locations.
11Analysis of the Value ChainPerspectives
- The value proposition Madrid can provide as a
possible recipient of the activities contained in
the value chain of the financial sector has been
analysed, so that competitive advantages can be
extrapolated from the region as it intends to
establish itself as a center of international
reference.
- The conclusion is that Madrid can provide a clear
differential value in the execution of certain
activities in the value chain.
- Two perspectives considered in the analysis
- Local Perspective Analysis of the competitive
advantages gained by an entity established in
Madrid for business and leveraging of the
existing local market. - Global Perspective Analysis of the competitive
advantages which and entity would obtain by
centralizing certain administrative and support
processes in Madrid, with the aim of providing
these services to its entire multinational
structure. In this case, the business entity
would be local or global, although run
(supported), in whole or in part, from Madrid.
12Analysis of the Value ChainPerspectives
- From the Local Perspective of the analysis, the
activities in which Madrid can provide greater
value are the following - Those requiring appropriately skilled human
resources. Madrid provides access to qualified
human resources in implementing various stages of
the value chain. - Access is needed to specialized suppliers and of
a certain standard. Madrid provides adequate
access to the various suppliers necessary for the
conduct of various defined tasks, with varying
degrees of expertise and experience in the
industry. - The aim is to exploit the local market. Madrid is
presented to financial institutions as an
attractive market, according to the analysis, as
one of the major poles of development at a
national and European level and also as an
excellent entry point to other markets such as
Latin America and the Mediterranean basin. - Access is desired to more competitive costs for
resource-intensive tasks. Compared with other
countries in their socio-economic environment,
Spain, in general, is more cost competitive,
which directly implies lower operating costs and
increased profit.
- In this respect, the activities where Madrid
provides more value are - Study of customer needs,
- Technology,
- Administrative Management,
- Multichannel Distribution,
- Risk Management and
- Customer Service.
13Analysis of the Value ChainPerspectives
- For the Global Outlook of the analysis conducted
in relation to the provision of differential
value by Madrid in the execution of tasks defined
in the value chain presented, one can conclude
that this value is larger and more spread in
relation to other financial centers in conducting
tasks that require - Access to skilled human resources and expertise
in the implementation of various activities of
the value chain, such as technological support
functions and administrative activities. - Access to specialized providers. Madrid offers
providers nationally and globally for the tasks
defined in the value chain. - Access to competitive costs, compared to
surrounding countries. This factor, present in
all the activities in Madrid, will be more
decisive the more intensive the activity is in
the use of the Region's own resources, such as
human resources or office space.
- Thus, the activities in which Madrid will provide
more value are Technology and Administrative
Management. - Additionally, Madrid offers its successful
experience to other activities of the value
chain, with examples of international reference
on banking and insurance that can be exportable
to other markets.
14Analysis of the Value ChainComprehensive SWOT
- Madrid offers a wide range of highly qualified
human resources. - Access to suitable suppliers and experience in
most of the activities of the value chain. - More cost competitive than other financial
centers, which directly implies lower operating
costs and increased profit. - Proliferation of technology parks and clusters
with a high level of expertise and development. - Madrid is known as one of the cities with the
best quality of life.
- Establishment of Madrid as a financial center of
reference for Latin America. - Establishment of Madrid as a hub of support
activity for Europe. - The current economic climate will cause the
concentration of the financial industry, so that
Madrid can be positioned as the recipient of
these concentrations in some or all stages of the
value chain.. - Ostensible improvement in the perception of the
Spanish financial system and its regulators at an
international level.
Weaknesses
Threats
- Local orientation of both human resources and
suppliers. - Knowledge of English among the general
population. - Lack of labor market flexibility is seen by
companies as a serious problem to solve,
especially in relation to the cost of redundancy. - Excessive bureaucratic processes of business
establishment and start-ups. - Lower level of investment grants than other parts
in Spain. - Within Spain, Madrid is one of the most
expensive socio-economic areas. - Spain appears on the last positions of the
productivity rankings among the neighboring
countries.
- The existence of other European financial centers
such as Paris or Frankfurt and even in some
emerging countries attractive for their low cost. - Latin American financial centers are evolving
such as Chile, Panama and Brazil that can take on
the role of bridge for access to the Latin
American market and oust Madrid from its current
position. - The advantage based on "lower cost" may not be
sustainable. - Forecasts indicate that Spain will undergo, like
most developing countries, a shortage of highly
skilled human resources.
15 Innovation
- Madrid is the center of innovation in many
economic, social and business activities. - On the financial front this is clearly reflected
in the global leadership of our financial
institutions in the development of products and
services, the introduction of new models of
customer service, the use of new distribution
channels and access to customers and markets, the
use of models for risk management and, of course,
the innovative use of information technology and
communication. - PricewaterhouseCoopers has assessed the
capabilities that Madrid offers the financial
world for innovation in its strategic positioning
in the development of products and services.
16Innovation Excellence in innovation is not the
result of chance or good intentions
- The innovativeness of a financial center is
supported by a set of variables (of the
environment or specific to the financial sector)
Environmental and Demographic Variables
Sector and Market Variables
- Level of internal competence
- Size of financial entities
- Level of internationalization
- Level of technological development
- Level of profitability
- Experience of regulating bodies
- Population size and critical mass
- Access to qualified human capital
- Level of language use
- Cost of living
- Quality of life
- Level of job satisfaction
- Level of infrastructures
- Systemic economies of scale
- Orientation of the environment to RD
- Existence of RD centres
Variables analysed in this presentation
17Inovation Contributing factors 1. Access to
qualified human capital
- Three schools in Madrid (IE, IESE, ESADE) are
among the best in all international rankings
(Source FT, Business Week, Wall Street Journal.
January 2009). - In Madrid, numerous graduate studies specializing
in finance are taught
(eg Master in Banking and
Finance in CEF, Master of Quantitative Finance at
CIFF, Master in Management of Financial
Institutions in IEB). - Madrid, with 43,246 people, is among the leading
regions in terms of number of researchers
(Source Eurostat. Total R D personnel by
sectors of performance (employment) and region.
2006) - Madrid is the 3rd most important region in Europe
according to the number of professionals employed
in high tech sectors (Source Eurostat. "Regional
employment in high technology sectors." 2007). - Madrid is the fifth most important city in
quality of life, making it easier to attract
skilled human capital (Source IDF Magazine
"European Cities and Regions of the Future
2008/09").
Madrid is an ideal environment for access to
highly qualified human capital, the driving force
of innovation strategies
18Innovation Contributing factors 2. Favourable
environment for RD (1)
- Madrid, with 1.96, is the region that invests
more in R D relative to GDP (Source INE 2007). - There are numerous public initiatives to support
innovation - Plan Avanza 2 financed by the Central Government
and the Madrid Region - Business Innovation Plan implemented by IMADE
- In Madrid, there is an extensive network of
scientific and technological parks and has been
chosen as headquarters for many multinational
companies for their R D centers of excellence
(Source Interes Invest 2007). - An additional attraction of Madrid compared to
other places is the favorable international tax
treatment of R D.
From the perspective of the performance of
government, Madrid is an ideal framework for the
development of R D
19Innovation Contributing factors 2. Favourable
environment for RD (2)
- The high technological development of Spanish
financial entities has been a catalyst for
creating an environment conducive to R D. - The intensive use of technology has enabled
Spanish financial institutions to be leaders in - Use of compensation systems for electronic
processing of cheques, transfers, receipts, etc. - Data integration to support the advanced
management activities of clients. - Development of models of transactional
integration for the automation of back office
processes. - Development of advanced models for risk
management. - Implementation of multichannel management
strategies.
The development of financial institutions
complements the action of Public Administration
to create a suitable environment for RD.
20Innovation Contributing factors 3. Existence of
systemic economies of scale and the
internationalization of financial institutions
- The Madrid Region has the largest concentration
of business in Spain (500,000 active
enterprises). - Most large international companies in Spain (60)
are headquartered in Madrid
(Source Forbes-The Global 2000.
2009). - Several Spanish financial institutions with
headquarters in Madrid have an international
scope with a competitive presence in the banking
and insurance markets in Europe and Latin
America. - Madrid is the decision-making center of two
financial institutions among the world's top 30
institutions by asset size, also among the top 10
for profit.. (Source Bankers-Almanac 2008).
The innovative capacity of Madrid benefits from a
developed business fabric and the size and level
of internationalization of financial
institutions, which encourages competition and
allows the incorporation of knowledge and
innovations from other sectors and markets.
21Innovation
Conclusion
- The Spanish financial sector, especially in
retail banking, shows high levels of innovation
in different fields product, process,
organization and marketing innovation. - This innovation is based on a combination of
factors including the access to skilled human
capital, the orientation of the environment for
innovation, systemic economies of scale as well
as size and level of internationalization of
financial institutions. - Additionally there are several levers that have
enhanced the innovation capabilities of financial
institutions - Technological developments
- The sophistication of customers
- Increased competitiveness
- Changes in regulation
- In summary, Madrid meets the required skills to
be an international financial center in the
generation of financial products and services.
22Technology and Infrastructures
- Capgemini has examined the extent to which
technology is a differential driver for Spanish
financial institutions and how Madrid provides
resources, skills and technological
infrastructure that place it in a position for
global leadership.
23Technology and InfrastructuresSpanish financial
institutions have been internationally
recognized as models of success
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
"Boosting the generation of results through a
constant evolution of customer relationships and
a strong orientation towards cost efficiency"
European Leader in cost to income ratio 2004-06
"New dynamic of profitable growth and value
creation with a very strong business with
innovation as a lever for growth"
Global presence and growth leveraged on a common
platform that improves short-term operational
efficiency"
"Model relationship with specific segments of
customers leveraged on a multi-channel
relationship strategy"
Specific Trade Policies for customer segments,
offering expertise and personalized customer
profiles for guidance"
Technology awards New channels 2007
"International expansion driven by
standardization of best practices on a common
operating platform"
Automotive Insurance Solutions Provider Award
Latibex entry gate to Latin America and
European and American equity market bridge".
Diversification of products and services,
innovation and internationalization anticipating
future competition "
Technology has been a key impetus for the
realization of business strategy
24This business strategy has been realized in a
model of management of the financial business
where technology has driven efficiency along the
value chain
Value Chain of the Financial Sector
Internal knowledge management
Knowledge of the customer
Experience of the customer
Operational efficiency
Risk management
Regulation and Supervision
Financial institutions in Spain are examples of
how technology applied to business generates
tangible results
25Technology and InfrastructuresMadrid has become
the hub of knowledge and experience in the
financial sector
- Locate in Madrid high-value financial
activities - Business Process Outsourcing
- Centralized areas of technology development
- Develop solutions and technologies for regulatory
compliance - Development and maintenance of solutions and
technologies applied to industry - Specialized R D
- Exportar el conocimiento experto y mejores
- practices
- Development of Madrid as a consultancy hub for
specialized processes and technology in the
sector - Promote a software development cluster for the
financial business management - Establish business models co-leveraged on shared
experience and knowledge gathered
Madrids opportunity is to exploit and capitalize
on these capabilities
- Cluster specialized in the financial sector
- Presence of entities, suppliers, regulators and
"market makers" (BME) - Specialized human resources
- Experience in technology projects of high value
- Applied Innovation Hub
- Excellent infrastructure for multichanneling
By offering value focused on
26Technology and InfrastructuresComprehensive SWOT
Strengths
Opportunities
- Improve the acknowledgement that technology has
contributed to the growth strategy of financial
institutions in Spain - Make better known the current capacities for
which Madrid is a financial "cluster"
specialized in retail banking - High capacity to attract multilingual talent to
Madrid - Positioning Madrid as a financial reference and
exporter of best practices to Latin America - Synergies with other established financial
centers in the world
- Successful model of Spanish financial
institutions making the value of technology apply
to business - Wide network of service companies with high
expertise in the sector, without technological
dependence - Proposal for competitive costs and high capacity
to generate synergies in Spain and Latin America - Communications infrastructure network with such a
strong world-recognized partner as Telefónica - Sample surveys in times of reflection on the
future of regulation
Weaknesses
Threats
- Increasing recognition of Madrid as a specialized
technological center - Promote the systematization of technological
know-how - Improve learning English as a communication tool
at work - Encourage the development and marketing of
specific solutions in the financial sector - Facilitate administrative processes and aid
management for R D - Develop the presence of Spanish entities in
other, non-retail financial sectors
- Countries such as India, Chile, Brazil or Panama,
are a threat to Spain at the level of
technological expertise and development costs - International financial centers directly manage
their relocation models without considering
Madrid as a manager in this process - A value proposition based solely on costs is not
sustainable in the long term - Mexico, Brazil, Chile, etc. are being
consolidated as centers of support for financial
markets in the U.S., Spain and Portugal - Difficulty of building sustainable barriers to
entry in time
27CONCLUSIONS Comprehensive SWOT Analysis (part I)
STRENGTHS OPPORTUNITIES
Good image of our financial institutions with good management of market liquidity and no excessive debt Business model established on a solid base of deposits and diversified business Banking without toxic products, non-Spanish market loans not considered of poor quality Madrid offers a wide range of highly qualified human resources Access to suppliers and experience in most of the activities of the value chain without technological dependence Proliferation of technology parks and clusters with a high level of expertise and development Successful model of Spanish financial institutions to make the value of technology applied to business Proposal for competitive costs and high synergy generation capacity in Spain and Latin America Communications infrastructure network with such a strong, internationally recognised partner as Telefónica Recognised supervision model in times of reflection on the future of regulation Madrid is known as one of the cities with the highest quality of life Safer centre compared to other surrounding and emerging countries Success depends on the ability to attract additional groups of wealth compared with the lack of security in other markets Madrid to be established as a financial centre of reference for Latin America Establishment of Madrid as a hub of support activities for Europe The current economic climate will cause the concentration of the financial industry, so that Madrid can be positioned as the recipient of these concentrations in some or all stages of the value chain. This adjustment is an opportunity to improve system efficiency. Ostensible improvement in the perception of the Spanish financial system and its regulators at the international level, because of the solvency and prudential regulation that they show respectively Improve the recognition that technology has contributed to the growth strategy of financial institutions in Spain Publicising the current capacities of Madrid as a Financial "cluster" specialized in retail banking High capacity to attract multilingual talent to Madrid Synergies with other established financial centers in the world
28CONCLUSIONS Comprehensive SWOT Analysis (part II)
WEAKNESSES THREATS
Increase the recognition of Madrid as a specialized technological center Promote the systematization of technological know-how Ratings under review for the majority of the entities of the financial system Excess real estate assets held by financial institutions in Spain Local orientation of both human resources and suppliers Improve learning English as a communication tool at work Encourage the development and marketing of specific solutions in the financial sector Lack of labour market flexibility is seen by companies as a serious problem to solve, especially in relation to redundancy costs Excessive bureaucratic processes in business establishment and start-ups Credit needs in the market Excessive leverage and potential capital needs by some entities. The existence of other European financial centres such as Paris or Frankfurt highly technological and highly competitive like Madrid in cost advantages The value proposition based solely on costs is not sustainable in the long term International financial centres manage their relocation models directly without Madrid as a manager of this process Latin American financial centers are evolving, such as Chile, Panama and Brazil, which can provide access to the Latin American market and oust Madrid from its current position. Mexico, Brazil, Chile, are being consolidated as centers of support for financial markets in the U.S., Spain and Portugal. Advantage based on "lower cost" may not be sustainable over time Forecasts indicate that Spain will undergo, like most developing countries, a shortage of highly skilled human resources More favorable tax policies in other countries System of R D subsidies need improvement Difficulty of building sustainable entry barriers in time
29(No Transcript)