Title: History of Research Project on CCA-Treated Wood Presented January 10, 2003 Coral Gables, Florida
1History of Research Project on CCA-Treated
WoodPresented January 10, 2003Coral Gables,
Florida
2Funding Received from Florida Center for Solid
and Hazardous Waste Mngt. Florida Power and
Light Sarasota County Florida Department of
Environmental Protection Florida International
University/NIEHS Rutgers University/NIEHS
3Active Faculty Researchers
- Helena Solo-Gabriele, Ph.D., P.E.,
- Assoc. Prof., Civil/Environ. Engrg
- Lora Fleming, M.D., Ph.D.
- Assoc. Prof., Epidemiology/PH
- Timothy Townsend, Ph.D.
- Assoc. Prof., Environ/Solid Waste Engrg
- Yong Cai, Ph.D.
- Assist. Prof., Chemistry
4Students Supported on Project
- Brian Messick
- Tom Moskal
- Jennifer Penha
- Donna May Sakura
- Catalina Santamaria
- Ajay Seth
- Tomoyuki Shibata
- Jin-Kun Song
- Kristin Stook
- Sheena Szuri
- Thabet Tolaymat
- Lakmini Wadanambi
- Sean Bennie
- Kenneth Brown
- Vandin Calitu
- Zhangrong Chen
- Brajesh Dubey
- Tim Franklin
- Kelvin Gary
- Myron Georgiadis
- Naila Hosein
- Kendiro Iida
- Gary Jacobi
- Jenna Jambeck
- Bernine Khan
- Monika Kormienko
5Background
- CCA-Treated Wood is the most common wood
preservative used today - CCA ---gt Chromated Copper Arsenate
6Background
Saltwater Immersion Pole/Pilings
Structural Poles Saltwater Splash
Above Ground
pcf pounds of CCA per cubic foot of wood
7Background
- As toxic to humans, carcinogen
- Cr toxic to humans, carcinogen
- Cu toxic to aquatic organisms
- Soil background levels for As in Florida are low
- Strict disposal guidelines
8Original Motivation For Project
Ash Disposal Problem
9Year 1 (1996-1997)
10Year 1 Disposal Forecast
11 CCA-WoodRemoved from Service
CD Debris Recycling Facilities
Wood Fuel Facility
Ash
Processed Wood (6 CCA in 1996)
MSW Landfill
CD Landfill
12Year 2 (1997-1998)
13Year 2
Develop Tools for Disposal End Management
- Leaching Studies, ash
- Hazardous when CCA-treated wood represents 5 of
wood burned - Solvents can extract metals from ash, citric acid
very promising (40 to 100 As removed)
------gt Explore Potential Recycling?
14Year 2 (continued)
Untreated
Treated
- Sorting Studies, Laboratory
- Chemical stains, low capital costlabor
intensive - X-ray methods, high capital costsuitable for
on-line system
15Year 3 (1998-1999)
16Year 3
- Disposal-End Management
- Field Demonstration of Sorting Technologies
Stains suitable for sorting small quantities of
wood - Evaluation of Pyrolysis Technology Appears
promising for ultimate disposal - Resource book for Wood Disposal Sector
17Year 3 (Continued)
- Alternative Chemicals
- Four Promising Alternative Chemicals for CCA
ACQ, CBA, CC, CDDC - All standardized for applications requiring 0.25
0.4 pcf Comparable to CCA efficacy - Leach less As but generally more Cu
- Cost 10 to 30 more at retail establishment
18Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
19The Research Team Was Invited to the Minnesota
Proceedings
- Minnesotas Listed Metals Advisory CouncilCd,
Pb, Hg, and Cr(VI) - Speciation Debated
- In-Service Issues Debated
- Lack of Scientific Data
-
20Year 3 Supplemental
- Impacts of CCA on Soil during In-Service Use
- Use Sectors for CCA-Treated Wood
- Leaching of CCA-treated Wood and CD Debris Wood
Mulch - Literature Reviews, Alt. Chem.Cr As Speciation
Deck Study
Use Sectors
Minnesota
Leaching Wood Mulch
Lit Reviews Alt Chem, As, Cr Spec
21Leaching of CCA During In-Service Use
Year 3 Supplemental
22Leaching of CCA-Treated Wood During In-Service Use
Year 3 Supplemental
23Leaching of CCA-Treated Wood During In-Service Use
- Chemicals Do Leach from CCA-treated Wood During
In-Service Use
24Leaching of CCA-Treated Wood During In-Service Use
- Approximately 39 square miles of Florida land
covered by CCA-treated decks. - Top 8 inches of this area would correspond to 60
million tons of soil.
25Use Sectors for CCA-Treated Wood
Year 3 Supplemental
26Use Sectors for CCA-Treated Wood
Year 3 Supplemental
2728,600 tons of As, Cumulative
?1600 tons As imported per year
In-service losses (10) 2900 tons Disposed to
date 1600 tons Future disposal (for that
imported through 2000) 24,100 tons
Year 3 Supplemental
28Leaching of CCA-treated Wood and CD Debris Wood
Mulch
Year 3 Supplemental
29Leaching of CCA-Treated Wood
30(No Transcript)
31Leaching of Mulch
Samples No. No. Exceeding GWCTL for As No. Exceeding GWCTL for Cr
CD Debris 20 18 5
Yard Waste 3 1 1
Colored Mulch 3 2 0
Vegetative Mulch 3 0 0
Year 3 Supplemental
32Ash Problem
Inventory
Sorting Lab
Ash Char Trt
Deck Study
Sorting Field
Alt. Chem. Lit Review
Use Sectors
Minnesota
Leaching Wood Mulch
Lit Review Alt Chem, As, Cr Spec
33Innovative Recycling Grant
laser
x-ray
34Output signal for detection of treated wood
35(No Transcript)
36(No Transcript)
37Questions?Comments?Reports available
atwww.ccaresearch.org