TAP2002 Ships

1
Objectives of the meeting

• Define the main inputs of the Expert Panel to
  project team of editing authors (consultant) to
  restructuring the Guidebok
• Provide the project team of editing authors with
  all information and all relevant underlying
  material (methods/emission factors) useful to
  update the guidebook

2
Preparation of the meeting

• The meeting was prepared
• Sending an invitation to all the people in
  Thessaloniki meeting
• Individuating a list of industry reference people
  (the list was extracted from IPPC BREF
  documentation)
• Sending a specific invitation to industry
  representative from the TFEIP chair
• Inviting the Acting Head of the European IPPC
  Bureau in JRC

3
Invited industry organizations

• CONCAWE (the oil companies' European organisation
  for environment, health and safety)
• European Aluminium Association
• CEPI- Confederation of European Paper Industries
• EUROFER - European Confederation of Iron and
  Steel Industries
• CEMBUREAU - representative organisation of the
  cement industry in Europe
• Eurometaux
• CPIV - Comite Permanent des Industries du Verre
  Européenne Avenue Louise 89
• COTANCE - Confederation of National Associations
  of Tanners and Dressers
• CERAME-UNIE Liaison Office of the Europ. Ceramic
  Industry
• CIAA - Confederation of Food and Drink Industries
  of the EEC

4
List of partecipant

• Carlo Trozzi co-leader of the Expert Panel on
  Combustion and Industry
• Riccardo De Lauretis co-leader of the Expert
  Panel on Transport
• Tinus Pulles TNO Built Environment and
  Geosciences
• Jeroen Kuenen TNO Built Environment and
  Geosciences
• Nadine Allemand Expert Group on Techno-Economic
  Issues UNECE
• Lourens Post CONCAWE (oil companies' Eur. org.
  for env. healt safe.)
• Brian Smithers CONCAWE
• Ole Restad CEMBUREAU (organisation of the cement
  industry in Europe)
• Eirik Nordheim European Aluminium Association
• Fabrice Rivet CPIV (European Glass Industries)
• Rémi Bussac EURELECTRIC (Union of the Electricity
  Industry)
• Javier Pérez Rodríguez Universidad Politécnica de
  Madrid
• Antonio Ferreiro Análisis Estadístico de Datos

5
(No Transcript)
6
(No Transcript)
7
(No Transcript)
8
Presentation of the Guidebook project

• Tinus Pulles, project leader for the Guidebook
  project, presented the background and approach of
  the project and Jeroen Kuenen described the
  analyses on the emission factors as included in
  the present version of the Guidebook
• A discussion about the needs and methodologies of
  the update work followed
• The discussion will follow in this meeting

9
Contribution of the Expert Group on
techno-economic issues to GB project (1)

• Nadine Allemand presented EGTEI work
• EGTEI has considered a set of reduction
  techniques for 50 sectors. On average there are 2
  or 3 techniques per sector. This includes
  emission reduction efficiency, associated
  emission factors and concentrations of pollutants
  in waste gases
• EGTEI has also developed a methodology to
  estimate total annual costs of reduction
  techniques, as well as projections and scenarios

10
Contribution of the Expert Group on
techno-economic issues to GB project (2)

• Data
• is available via the EGTEI website
  (http//citepa.org/forums/egtei/egtei_index.htm)
• can be used as Tier 2 or Tier 3 estimation
  methods
• are provided on a country specific basis
• are not available for all European countries

11
Sectors contributions (1)

• Oil industry (Lourens Post)
• CONCAWE has published a report in 2005 with
  specific emission factors for the industry to
  bring together all emission factors available in
  the open literature
• This information is delivered to the Expert Panel
  and implemented in the 2006 Guidebooks process
  chapters
• The combustion chapters still need such an update
• Power plant sector (Rémi Bussac)
• The EU power industry has established a working
  group to develop an emissions estimation guidance
  document for the industry, similar to the CONCAWE
  one

12
Sectors contributions (2)

• Cement industry (Ole Restad)
• Restrictions for sharing data (partly
  confidential) occur and a ToR for co-operation
  needs to be agreed
• Co-operation could be possible on the basis of
  already running projects within the cement
  industry
• Glass industry (Fabrice Rivet)
• The current Guidebook contains a number of errors
• It is important to consult the industrial sector
  in the revision project
• The Guidebook should be consistent with the
  revision of the BREFs started in January 2007

13
Sectors contributions (3)

• Aluminium industry (Eirik Nordheim)
• Emission data (TSP, but now also PM10 and PM2.5)
  measurements are available are available per
  plant (2005 set of emission data for the EU, used
  for LCA studies.
• Comments on earlier versions of the Guidebook
  have been sent to EP leader

14
Sectors contributions (3)

• Domestic sector (Carlo Trozzi)
• there is a suitable methodology for emission
  estimates in Tier 1 (previous Simpler
  methodology)
• for Tier 2 are available a suitable set of
  emission factors already (in previous Detailed
  methodology)
• as already pointed out in EP session in
  Thessaloniki there are no indication to obtain
  activity indicators (fuel consumptions) for use
  in detailed methodology
• a general description of Tier 3 (model) approach
  to evaluated emissions was reported the request
  has been renewed, already indicated in
  Thessaloniki, to financial support the
  development of such a methodology

15
Conclusion (1)

• Industry clearly expressed its interest in
  co-operating with the Guidebook project
• The Guidebook project team is eager to intensify
  the co-operation with industry
• Its important to involve the organizations
  already invited but that have not participated
  and eventually to extend the list
• Industry representative are invited to send all
  the relevant documentation to EP leader, as
  already in the case of oil and aluminium
  industry) in such a way that this information can
  be evaluated for the GB update

16
Conclusion (2)

• in analogy with oil industry contribute to the
  2006 update of the Guidebook, the other
  industries will have involved in the comment to
  the chapters of the new Guidebook of their
  interest, also if the responsibility of the
  revision of the Guidebook will be on Commission
  supported by the Advisor Editorial Group
• the Guidebook project team is ready to retrieve
  all the relevant information on the new
  technologies available in the Expert Group on
  techno-economic documentation