Title: Business challenges for the Torvald Klaveness Group in the information age
1Business challenges for the Torvald Klaveness
Group in the information age
Nils Arne Bakke, Director projects TKG Maritime
Logistics Professor Technology Management, NTNU
- NTNU,
- Trondheim 03.04.2003
2Content
- (1) The Torvald Klaveness Group
- (2) The Dry bulk Challenge Logistic
rationalisation through industry shipping or
commodity shipping - (3) Challenges within The Maritime Services and
implications for IT-solutions - (4) Challenges within The Maritime Logistic
division and implications for IT-solutions
3(1)The Torvald Klaveness Group
4The TKG group 2002 Organisation Chart
5Key figures of The Torvald Klaveness Group 2001
- Financial highlights
- Revenue 600 mill. USD
- Operating profit 36 mill. USD
- (TKG Maritime Logistics Revenue ca. 180 Mill.
USD, operating profit ca. 20 mill. USD - TKG Maritime Services ca. 350 Mill. USD
Operating profitca 5 mill. USD)
- Shipping acitivities
- Cargo carried 54,161 mill.tons
- Average daily operated vessels 100 (today ca.
140) - Owned or partly owned vessels 24
- TKG Maritime services the worlds largest operator
of Panmax vessels, and large commercial
operations within the handymax and handysize
segments - TKG Maritime logistics with strong presence in
the iron-ore, alumina/caustic and coal industries
6TKG Maritime logistics Vision and business
mission
Vision
Making a difference to the industries we operate
in
Business mission
- Maritime Logistics focuses on changing industries
by improving their logistics efficiency - Efficiency is achieved through standardization of
technology and systems, and consolidation of
volume, capacity and information - We share the gains with our customers and partners
7Infrastrukturen / IT fundamentet
82. The Dry bulk challengeLogistic
rationalisation through industrial shipping
and/or commercial pools ?
- Understanding the business logic within different
industries vessel segments and deriving some
consequences for business logic and IT-systems
9OVERALL VIEW The space for competitive advantage
based on special vessels technology niche
solutions is shrinking
- Standardization
- Technology (vessels, harbors, terminals, handling
technology interchangeable units liquid
markets) - Contracts business procedures (based on 19th
century british standards) - Information systems (content protocols, open
standards) - Consolidation
- Consolidation of capacity (vessels, harbors,
terminals) - Consolidation of cargo (3PLs, shared
infrastructure for operational logistics) - Consolidation of information (market places,
3PLs) - Global information networks with timely high
quality information - Gloabal real-time knowledge about available
cargoes capacity units ( closer to perfect
markets) - Synchronisation integratrion of supply chains
- Vessels sizes lot-sizes needs to be harmonised
with the rest of the supply chain - Focus specialisation
- Specialization within the value chain
(concentration on core competencies) - Outsourcing of non-core business
- Alliances strategic partnerships within
logistic chains - Our attitude We want to utilize and promote
trends as opposed to enter backwards into the
future - In the future relativly more value will be added
by means of information handling and coordination
development of concepts then through ownership
of vessels
10Key drivers influencing Klaveness long term
IT-strategy needs
- Long term ownership to std. vessels not
profitable - Easy to buy services related to both technical
commercial mng. - Capital not a bottleneck
- Competitiveness superior performance requires
superior skills competencies (from asset based
to competency based business model) - Liquid standardised, global markets for std.
Maritime transportation services open
information networks require ability to
continously collect, process convert large
amounts of data to produce decision relevant
information optimal decisions (Maritime
Services Division) - Industry focus on core competencies
accelerating outsourcing to 3PL providers
requires the Maritime Logistic division to
develop capabilites of modelling controlling
larger supply chains. This presupposes IT-systems
capable of collecting processing decision
relevant information to make optimised
decisions balancing complex supply chains - The role of information changes fundamentally
- - Previously utilising imperfect distribution
availability of information to own advandage - - Today taking advantage of the global
availability of information by establishing
superior ability to process, analyse information
to make faster and better decisions than the
competitors
11Segmentation of shipping along the variables
standardisation of capacity, global information
availability and market liquidity
Commodity shipping market making, asset play
hedging through pools
Degree of standardisation of capacity global
info. availability
Industry shipping logistic rationalisation
Information Exhange through Market places
brokers
Information Exchange B2B
Degree of Market liquidity
Transloaders (20 ???)
Handymax (1140)
Cape (586)
Cement carriers (480)
Panmax (1080)
Handysize (2800)
12Industry shipping Logistic rationalisation
improves suppliers margin and reduces customer
cost
Revenue/cost
Profit margin
Revenue per t. (CoA) share high
Cost of operation per t.
- Cargo pooling
- Scheduling
- Vessel technology
- Load discharge technology
- Harbour turnaround
- Multi modal chain optimization
Time
Rationalisation strategies
13Key success factors of industry shipping
- Target industries do not have access to
standardised, logisticly efficient and
market-liquid logistic services. Reliable and
cost-efficient logistics are business critical,
but not core business. - Logistic chains charachterised by unique
combinations of constraints that must be
overcome/circumvented to achieve logistic
efficiency (prod. capacities, inventories,
harbour restrictions, load discharge
technologies, etc.) - Supplier must have in depth understanding of the
business logic and business processes of the
target industries - Technological and operational skills essential
core competencies (e.g. Scheduling, load
discharge systems, harbour operations, vessel
technology, operational stability
predictability etc.) - A mix of long term contracts essential to, 1)
Vindicate investments in non-liquid assets, 2) To
achieve combinations of cargo that takes down
total cost - IT-systems integrating the supply chain (
information about all capacity units all
processes in the supply chain available for a
central planning coordination unit typically
a 3PL or a dominating actor in the chain)
14Commodity Shipping Profit for pools through
market making, asset play hedge strategies
(Cape, panmax, handymax)
Revenue for std. vessels
Cost of std. vessels
Rationalisation strategies from a capacity pool
perspective
- Market influence
- Spot optimizing
- Hedging through FFA/CoA
- Asset play
- Cost optimising through volume
Rationalisation strategies from a cargo pool
perspective
15Martime Logistics challengesKey success factors
for commercial pools
- Globally accepted institutions information
systems to establish a global, real-time market
enabling the use of derivates (papers, e.g. FFAs
similar) - Standardised vessels with equal predictable
performance - Scope of logistic rationalisation limited
- Availability of standard products for ship mng.
commercial mng. - Liquid market (critical of similar vessels
critical of buyers of freight global open
information networks) - Owners of vessels without resources/interest to
maintain own commercial operation - Volatile market making pools attractive for
risk mng. purposes - Offering of flexible and individual hedging
strategies, with individual risk profiles. - Capability of outperforming spot indexes
- Capability to make CoAs FFAs effective hedging
instruments for ship-owner (High liquidity makes
cargo based strategies less attractive for
ship-owner) - Market influencing opportunities through
controlling critical of vessels - Buying power through volume (bunkers, purchasing
agreements, port cost, etc.) - Transaction cost reduced through volume
(efficient systems routines) - Pool manager to achieve profitability at fee of
2-3 or lower adm. efficiency
16TKG Maritime logistics involved in both industry
commodity shipping Maritime Services only in
commodity shipping
TKG minimize cost for customer improve own
margin through logistic rationalisation
Industry customer
TKG chooses mix of tools based on what gives most
efficient logistic chain
TKG Maritime logistics
Commodity Shipping Counterpart to std. vessel
owners (e.g.pools)
Industry-shipping TKG ownership to Assets incl.
Landbased installations
17Commodity shipping vs. industry shipping
challenges
- Commodity shipping challenges
- Requires high volumes and administrative
efficiency - Requires homogenous, liquid market of sufficient
size - With low liquidity and low volatility hedging
products less applicable - Liquidity presupposes standardised vessel
technology vessels must be interchangeable for
the cargo volumes considered - Liquidity presupposes real-time global
information systems creating a meeting
marketplace for cargo-owners ship-owners - The creation of a paper market (derivates) for
dry-bulk freight services requires reliable
(trusted) institutions information systems to
establish reliable market rates
- Industry shipping challenges
- High CoA share makes operational efficiency key
to margins (50 of time in harbours today). - Players without integrated commercial
operational mangement long term capital basis
have disadvantages - Right combination of cargoes essential for
logistic efficiency - SCM information systems key to achieve
operational excellence - The uniqueness of the combinations of trades,
cargoes, harbour-restrictions etc. makes
taylor-made solutions superior to standardised - High investments in non-liquid assets systems
long term contracts essential
183. Klaveness Maritime Services business
challenges implications for IT-systems
- From traditional commercial shipping to optimised
scheduling optimised spot management and
portifolio management
19TC rates the Panmax segment USD/day (source
Baltic exchange) Benchmark for pool manager
20Long term decline of CoA contracts increase of
spot contracts for transportation needs satisfied
by standard vessels (example steam coal source
BHP Billington)
21IT-systems requirements adapted to handle
spot-optimisation paper-based market for dry
bulk transportation services
- Basis for competitiveness a spot pool producing
consistently better results then benchmark - Real time knowledge about all relevant cargoes
all relevant capacity units - Scheduling software enabling tactical
optimisation of capacities given available
cargoes - Strategic decision making based on
macro-ecconomic knowledge about world ecconomy
(e.g. Positioning of fleet in basins regions) - In addition offerings based on financial
instruments enabling customers to define
individual hedge profiles to protect against
volatility - Requires understanding of risk-mng.,
macro-ecconomic industry specific knowledge
about markets (e.g. Skills from financial
energy markets) - Understanding of developments at the capacity
side (incl. Yard capacities, order-books,
IMO-rules etc.) - The fundamental basis required reliable
institutions reliable information systems to
set the market - Trust in institutions and reliability of
information as precondition for a
well-functioning market
22Institutional framework for construction of
market rates for standardvessels in dry
vet-bulk segments (real-time trusted information)
23Effektivisering
500 /d målsettingen
Mer perfekt prising i fremtiden gjør det
vanskelig å slå Benchmark vesentlig
- 500 /d har høyere risiko enn først antatt
- Kan vi long-term outperforme et perfekt
marked?
/dag over BPI
500
?
100
Tid
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
24Hvor ligger 500/d bidragene?
Hovedbidragene for å nå dette målet kommer fra
følgende fokusområder i Spot poolen
- 1. Stordrift operasjonell
effektivitet (kostnader) 10 (15?) - 2. Geografisk posisjonering basseng 20
- 3. Durasjon positiv negativ
lagging 15 - 4. Arbitrage 15
- 5. Kortsiktige posisjoner (T/C, CoAs) 25
(20?) - 6. Markedsmakt merkenavn 10
- 7. Utnytte gapet mellom FFA fysiske
instr. 5
25High anticiapated growth in the the dry bulk FFA
market
26New derivates related pool-products from
Klaveness Maritime Services
Spot pool
Mngd. hedge
Fixed
Floor
Collar
27Baumarine Spot pool Example product sheet
- Obtain a margin on top of the spot market.
- Participate in the volatility of the spot market.
- Reduce positional, operational and credit related
risks. - Outsource daily chartering and operation of
vessels. - As a basis for combining with Baumarine hedging
tools.
Why use it
- Vessel is traded in the spot pool.
- The pool optimizes the short term freight market
risk. - You earn a share of the pools total income.
- Your share is calculated according to vessel
characteristics.
How it works
- Full advantage of increases in the spot market.
- First Class Counterpart curtails credit risk.
- Baumarines size and pooling system reduces
operational risk. - Active positioning geographically and timewise
ensures earnings that are comparable to the BPI
Average 4 tc routes. - Saved time and cost in the daily running of your
fleet.
Reward
- Exposure to low spot markets.
Risk
Example
- Vessel trades spot together with the rest of the
pool.
Settlement
- Pool result paid semi-monthly in arrears.
- Counterpart Baumarine AS
284. The Maritime Logistic DivisionKey challenges
business challenges implications for IT-systems
- Logistic provider with end-customer control or
supplier to 3PLs?
29Transportation providers face numerous challenges
that will continue to increase competitive
intensity and change the rules of the game
Globalization of networks
- Logistics leaders have expanded their services
globally, acquiring capabilities where it is
slower or harder to build them - With most players rooted in Europe or the U.S.,
geographic expansion has included a focus on Asia
previously highly fragmented, and untapped by
the major global players
Consolidation of services
Increased outsourcing of logistics services
- Service providers are expanding their offerings
across all or several logistics domains - Companies offer one-stop shopping solutions to
their customers, and are gaining synergies from
their network of complementary services
- Companies outsource larger components of their
annual logistics budgets to 3PLs - The outsourcing of purchasing and IT functions is
an area which has generated interest and may be
growth areas in the future
3PL and Freight Forwarder Industries
Customer preference for dealing with fewer
logistics providers
- Customers are utilizing fewer service providers
for their logistics needs, placing 3PLs in a
strong market position. - Among customers who already outsource logistics
to 3PLs, there has been a growing trend to move
to one service provider to handle all of a
companys needs
30Traditionally, shipping companies have been asset
based providers. Now they are challenged by
system-based providers.
Customer relationship
Market
Asset based provider
Customer
System based provider
Scenario 1
Scenario 2
Customer relationship
Supplier
- Asset based provider develops system based
capabilities or cooperates with system based
provider - Asset based provider maintains customer
relationship
- System based provider takes over customer
relationship - Asset based provider operates as supplier to
system based provider
31 Trends on the capacity side the lack of
logistic perspective on investments in dry-cargo
vessels
- Optimisiation of individual voyages vs. supply
chain optimisation
32The Development of the world fleet of bulk
carriers
33Vessel technology as a means not an end in
itself
34Supply chain modelling to determine optimal
vessel size as opposed to vessel size as only
parameter
- To benchmark and evaluate logistic efficiency we
need more than seatransport cost. It makes sense
to use the approach from current logistics
trends, which is to focus on the total cost of
the supply chain. Then its easy to see that it
does not make sense to use a Panamax vessel if
the yearly requirement is covered by 2 voyages
per year. Main parameters in a simplified model,
which we are using to calculate total supply
cost, are - The annual volumes required
- The FOB value of the product (High FOB value
gives a significant cost impact if the product
stay in stock for many additional weeks with the
use of a Panamax vessel as compared to a
Handysize vessel) - The seatransport cost
- As Bulk shipping is based on combination of
cargoes and that the best vessel size on one
transport leg will not necessarily be best on the
next one, supports using a heuristic rule that a
vessel will be competitive as long as its cost
does not exceed 20 on the most competitive on
that transport leg. -
35When is Handysize the most ecconomical solution?
E.g. Alumina
36Offering integrated logistics solutions requires
several new services to be developed. Competitive
solutions have to be based on superior
understanding of industry and customers
IT-capabilties
Scale in development,
partly existing, existing
37The challenges of bulk shipping in a logistic
perspective IT skills essential!
- How to keep and develop the relationships with
the end-customers (cargo owners) - Standardisation of ships and liquid markets
making ownership of std. vessels non-profitable
in the long term - Changing focus from beeing an asset provider to
become a systems and competence-based provider.
Ownership only to strategic assets (either
vessels or land based installations) - The bulk-dilemma Larger ships and lots as
opposed to logistic needs for higher frequency,
smaller lots and synchronised supply chains - The cultural challenge of changing pespective
from seeing vessels as an end in itself towards
looking at vessels as means change from
technology focus to customer focus - The need for combined industrial shipping skills
commodity shipping skills - Ability to establish develop information
systems for coordinating optimising complex
supply chains in challenging operational contexts - Ability to use sophisticated IT-based modelling
tools for business development, marketing sales
(Sales as a consultative endeavour)