Title: Entrepreneurship: Successfully Launching New Ventures, 2/e
1Entrepreneurship Successfully Launching New
Ventures, 2/e Bruce R. Barringer R. Duane Ireland
Chapter 3
2Chapter Objectives(1 of 3)
- Explain what a feasibility analysis is and why
its important. - Discuss the proper time to complete a feasibility
analysis when developing a business venture. - Describe the purpose of a product/service
feasibility analysis and the two primary issues
that a proposed business should consider in this
area. - Identify three primary purposes of concept
testing. - Explain a concept statement and its contents.
3Chapter Objectives(2 of 3)
- Define the term usability testing and explain why
its important. - Describe the purpose of industry/market
feasibility analysis and the three primary issues
to consider in this area. - Explain the difference between primary research
and secondary research. - Describe the purpose of organizational
feasibility analysis and list the two primary
issues to consider in this area.
4Chapter Objectives(3 of 3)
- 10. Explain the importance of financial
feasibility analysis and list the most critical
issues to consider in this area.
5What Is Feasibility Analysis?
- Feasibility Analysis
- Feasibility analysis is the process of
determining whether a business idea is viable. - It is the preliminary evaluation of a business
idea, conducted for the purpose of determining
whether the idea is worth pursuing. - Feasibility analysis takes the guesswork (to a
certain degree) out of a business launch, and
provides an entrepreneur with a more secure
notion that a business idea is feasible or viable.
6When To Conduct a Feasibility Analysis
- Timing of Feasibility Analysis
- The proper time to conduct a feasibility analysis
is early in thinking through the prospects for a
new business. - The thought is to screen ideas before a lot of
resources are spent on them. - Components of a Properly Conducted Feasibility
Analysis - A properly conducted feasibility analysis
includes four separate components, as shown in
the figure on the next slide.
7Feasibility Analysis
Role of feasibility analysis in developing
successful business ideas
8Four Forms of Feasibility Analysis
Product/Service Feasibility Analysis
Industry/Market Feasibility Analysis
Organizational Feasibility Analysis
Financial Feasibility Analysis
9Product/Service Feasibility Analysis
- Product/Service Feasibility Analysis
- Is an assessment of the overall appeal of the
product or service being proposed. - The idea is that before a prospective firm rushes
a product or service into development, it should
be confident that the product or service is what
its prospective customers want. - The two components of a product/service
feasibility analysis are - Concept testing.
- Usability testing.
10Preparing a Concept Statement(1 of 3)
- Concept Statement
- Before a company undertakes product/service
feasibility analysis, a concept statement should
be developed. - A concept statement is a one page description of
a business that is distributed by a startup
entrepreneur to people who are asked to provide
feedback on the potential of the business idea. - The feedback will hopefully provide the
entrepreneur (1) a sense of the viability of the
business idea, and (2) suggestions for how the
idea can be strengthened or tweaked before
proceeding further.
11Preparing a Concept Statement(2 of 3)
- Information to Include
- A description of the product or service being
offered. - The intended target market.
- The benefits of the product or service.
- A description of how the product will be
positioned relative to similar ones in the
market. - A description of how the product or service will
be sold and distributed. - Information about the founder or founders of the
firm.
12Preparing a Concept Statement(3 of 3)
New Venture Fitness Drinks Concept Statement
13Usability Test(1 of 2)
- Usability Testing
- Is the method by which users of a product are
asked to perform certain tasks in order to
measure the products ease-of-use and the users
perception of the experience. - Usability tests are sometimes called user tests,
beta tests, or field trials, depending on the
circumstances involved. - While it is tempting to rush a new product or
service to market, conducting a usability test is
a good investment of an entrepreneurs or firms
resources. - Many products that consumers find frustrating to
work with have been brought to market too
quickly.
14Usability Test(2 of 2)
- Usability Testing (continued)
- Prototype
- Conducting a usability test typically requires
the development of a prototype. - A prototype is the first physical depiction of a
new product, which is usually still in a rough or
tentative mode. - Virtual Prototype
- A virtual prototype is a computer-generated 3D
image of an idea. It displays an invention as a
3D model that can be viewed from all sides and
rotated 360 degrees.
15Product/Service Feasibility Analysis in Action
Role of feasibility analysis in the development
of successful business ideas at Activision (an
electronic games company)
The Activision Green Light Process
16Industry/Market Feasibility Analysis(1 of 6)
- Industry/Market Feasibility Analysis
- Is an assessment of the overall appeal of the
market for the product or service being proposed. - For industry/market feasibility analysis, there
are three primary issues that a proposed business
should consider - Industry attractiveness, market timeliness, and
the identification of a niche market. - Industry Attractiveness
- A primary determinant of a new ventures
feasibility is the attractiveness of the industry
it chooses.
17Industry/Market Feasibility Analysis(2 of 6)
Characteristics of attractive industries for new
ventures
- Are large and growing (with growth being more
important than size). - Are important to the customer.
- Are fairly young rather than older and more
mature. - Have high rather than low operating margins.
- Are not crowded.
18Industry/Market Feasibility Analysis(3 of 6)
- Industry Attractiveness
- Although the criteria shown on the preceding
slide is an ideal list, the extent to which a new
businesss proposed industrys growth
possibilities satisfy these criteria should be
taken seriously. - In addition to evaluating an industrys growth
potential, a new venture will want to know more
about the industry it plans to enter. - This can be accomplished through both primary and
secondary research, as explained in the next
slide.
19Industry/Market Feasibility Analysis(4 of 6)
Role of Primary and Secondary Research in
Investigating Industry Attractiveness
Type of Research
How It Is Conducted
This is research that is original and is
collected by the entrepreneur. In assessing the
attractiveness of a new market, this typically
involves an entrepreneur talking to potential
customers and key industry participants.
Primary research
This is research that probes data that are
already collected. Examples of where this data
might come from are industry-related
publications, government statistics, competitors
Web sites, and industry reports from research
firms like Forrester Research.
Secondary research
20Industry/Market Feasibility Analysis(5 of 6)
Market Timeliness Considerations
Nature of Product or Service Introduction
Major Considerations
- Is the window of opportunity open or closed?
- Is now a good time for a new market entrant
(i.e., - are customers buying, are industry incumbents
- making money?)
Improvement on something already available in the
marketplace
- Should we try to capture a first-mover advantage?
Breakthrough new product or service, which should
establish a new market segment
21Industry/Market Feasibility Analysis(6 of 6)
- Identification of a Niche Market
- A niche market is a place within a larger market
segment that represents a narrower group of
customers with similar interests. - For a new firm, selling to a niche market makes
sense for at least two reasons. - It allows a firm to establish itself within an
industry without competing against major
competitors head on. - A niche strategy allows a firm to focus on
serving a specialized market very well instead of
trying to be everything to everybody in a broad
market, which is nearly impossible for a new
entrant.
22Organizational Feasibility Analysis(1 of 4)
- Organizational Feasibility
- Is concerned with determining whether the
business itself has sufficient skills and
resources to bring a particular product or
service idea to market successfully. - There are two primary issues to consider in this
area - Management prowess.
- Resource sufficiency.
23Organizational Feasibility Analysis(2 of 4)
- Management Prowess
- A firm should candidly evaluate the prowess, or
ability, of its management team to satisfy itself
that management has the requisite passion and
expertise to launch the venture. - Two of the most important factors in this area
are - The passion that the solo entrepreneur or the
founding team has for the business idea. - The extent to which the solo entrepreneur or the
founding team understands the markets in which
the firm will participate. - Solo entrepreneurs or founding teams with
established social and professional networks also
have an advantage. -
24Organizational Feasibility Analysis(3 of 4)
- Resource Sufficiency
- This topic pertains to an assessment of whether
an entrepreneur has sufficient resources to
launch the proposed venture. - The focus here should be on nonfinancial
resources in that financial feasibility is
considered separately. - To test resource sufficiency, a firm should list
the 6 to 12 most critical nonfinancial resources
that will be needed to move the business idea
forward successfully. - If critical resources are not available in
certain areas, it may be impractical to proceed
with the business idea.
25Organizational Feasibility Analysis(4 of 4)
Examples of nonfinancial resources that may be
critical to the successful launch of a new
business
- Availability of affordable office or lab space.
- Likelihood of local and state government support
of the business. - Quality of the labor pool available.
- Proximity to key suppliers and customers.
- Willingness of high quality employees to join
the firm. - Likelihood of establishing favorable strategic
partnerships. - Proximity to similar firms for the purpose of
sharing knowledge. - Possibility of obtaining intellectual property
protection in key areas.
26Financial Feasibility Analysis(1 of 5)
- Financial Feasibility
- For feasibility analysis, a quick financial
assessment is usually sufficient. - The most important issues to consider at this
stage are - Total start-up cash needed.
- Financial performance of similar businesses.
- Overall attractiveness of the proposed venture.
27Financial Feasibility Analysis(2 of 5)
- Total Start-Up Cash Needed
- The first issue refers to the to the total cash
needed to prepare the business to make its first
sale. - An actual budget should be prepared that lists
all the anticipated capital purchases and
operating expenses needed to generate the first
1 in revenues. - When projecting start-up expenses, it is better
to overestimate rather than underestimate the
costs involved. - Murphys Law is prevalent in the start-up
worldthings will go wrong. It is a rare
start-up that doesnt have some setbacks in
getting up and running.
28Financial Feasibility Analysis(3 of 5)
- Financial Performance of Similar Businesses
- Estimate the proposed start-ups financial
performance by comparing it to similar, already
established businesses. - There are several ways to doing this, all of
which involve a little ethical detective work. - First, there are many reports available, some for
free and some that require a fee, offering
detailed industry trend analysis and reports on
thousands of individual firms. - Second, simple observational research may be
needed. For example, the owners of New Venture
Fitness Drinks could estimate their sales by
tracking the number of people who patronize
similar restaurants and estimating the average
amount each customer spends.
29Financial Feasibility Analysis(4 of 5)
- Overall Attractiveness of the Investment
- A number of other financial factors are
associated with promising business startups. - In the feasibility analysis stage, the extent to
which a business opportunity is positive relative
to each factor is based on an estimate rather
than actual performance. - The table on the next slide lists the factors
that pertain to the overall attractiveness of the
financial feasibility of the business idea.
30Financial Feasibility Analysis(5 of 5)
Financial Factors Associated With Promising
Business Opportunities
- Steady and rapid growth in sales during the
first 5 to 7 years in a clearly - defined market niche.
- High percentage of recurring revenuemeaning
that once a firm wins a - client, the client will provide recurring
sources of revenue. - Ability to forecast income and expenses with a
reasonable degree of - certainty.
- Internally generated funds to finance and
sustain growth. - Availability of an exit opportunity for
investors to convert equity to cash.
31Chapter 3 Feasibility Analysis
32Review Question 3 - 1
- What is a feasibility analysis? What is it
designed to accomplish? - Answer Feasibility analysis is the process of
determining if a business idea is viable. As a
preliminary evaluation of a business idea, a
feasibility analysis is completed to determine if
an idea is worth pursuing and to screen ideas
before spending resources on them.
33Review Question 3 - 2
- Briefly describe each of the four areas that a
properly-executed feasibility analysis explores. - Product/service feasibility analysis is an
assessment of the overall appeal of the product
or service being proposed. - Industry/market feasibility analysis is an
assessment of the overall appeal of the market
for the product or service being proposed. - Organizational feasibility analysis is conducted
to determine whether a proposed business has
sufficient management expertise, organizational
competence, and resources to successfully launch
its business. - Financial feasibility analysis provides a quick
financial assessment of the viability of a
business idea.
34Review Question 3 - 4
- What is a concept statement?
- Answer A concept statement is a preliminary
description of a business. A concept statement
represents the first step in a feasibility
analysis. Feedback from the concept statement
helps direct the remaining stages of the
feasibility analysis.
35Review Question 3 - 5
- What is a concept test, and what does it
accomplish? What are the three primary purposes
for it? - Answer A concept test entails showing a
representation of a product or service to
prospective users to gauge customer interest,
desirability, and purchase intent. The three
primary purposes of a concept test are to - (1) validate the underlying premise of a product
or service, - (2) to help develop the idea, and
- (3) to estimate the potential market share the
product or service might command.
36Review Question 3 - 6
- What is a usability test, and what does it
accomplish? - Answer A usability test is a test that requires
the user of a product to perform certain tasks in
order to measure the products ease of use and
the users perception of the experience. The
purpose of a usability test is to work the kinks
and bugs out of a product before it is offered
for sale to the general public.
37Review Question 3 - 7
- Define prototyping.
- Answer A prototype is a mock-up of a real
product that is used to gauge customer interest
in the product and to conduct usability tests.
38Review Question 3 - 8
- Describe what a virtual prototype is and how it
differs from a physical prototype. - Answer A virtual prototype is a
computer-generated 3D image of an idea. It
displays an invention as a 3D model that can be
viewed from all sides and rotated 360 degrees.
39Review Question 3 - 11
- Describe the difference between primary and
secondary research. Provide an example of each. - Answer
- Primary research is research that is original and
is collected by the entrepreneur. An example
would be an entrepreneur distributing a concept
statement of a business idea and asking for
feedback. - Secondary research probes data that are already
collected. An example would be an entrepreneur
studying industry publications to gain
information about potential customers and
competitors.
40Review Question 3 - 18
- Why is it usually to a firms advantage to be
located near similar firms in its industry? - Answer When similar firms are located near each
other, it is easy for the employees of the firms
to network with one another. If several similar
firms locate near one another, there is also an
incentive for the firms suppliers to locate
nearby, which helps reduce shipping costs.
41Chapter 3 Feasibility Analysis
42Application Question 3 1(1 of 2)
- Jason Palmer has an idea for a new approach to
personal finance software. He plans to use the
200,000 inheritance he recently received to
produce the product and bring it to market. When
you ask Jason if he has conducted a feasibility
analysis, he acts alarmed and says, I knew Id
have to write a business plan, but Im not
familiar with what you are calling a feasibility
analysis. I dont want to blow the 200,000 I
just inherited, so if a feasibility study is
necessary, Im game. Can you tell me how to
conduct one? What would you tell him?
43Application Question 3 1(2 of 2)
- Jason should be told that feasibility analysis is
the process of determining if a business idea is
viable. - It is completed to determine if an idea is worth
pursuing, or whether it should be dropped or
revised, before a lot of resources are invested.
- Jason should be told about the importance of
writing a concept statement, and using it to get
feedback on his idea. - He should also be told about the four stages of
feasibility analysis, and be informed regarding
the most important issues to consider in each
stage.
44Application Question 3 6(1 of 2)
- Marc Blair is planning to open a fitness center
that will feature a set of exercise machines that
he designed himself. He would like to do some
usability testing of the machines, but doesnt
know how to go about it. If Marc asked you for
your advice, what would you tell him?
45Application Question 3 6(2 of 2)
- Answer Marc should be told that usability
testing requires that users of a product perform
certain tasks in order to measure the products
ease of use and the users perception of the
experience. As a result, Marc should ask a group
of people who would be likely to join his center
to try using his equipment and give him feedback
on its ease of use and their overall impressions
of the equipment. Marc should also observe this
test group to gain his own impression of how
easy it is for people to use the equipment. One
note Marc should be careful to set up the
usability test with safety in mind. If exercise
equipment is used incorrectly or by inexperienced
users, it can cause injury.
46Application Question 3 7(1 of 2)
- Carrie Wells is planning to open a store to sell
DVDs in Nashville. As part of her feasibility
study, she hands out a questionnaire to 500
people in her trade area, asking them to indicate
whether they would shop at her store. Carrie is
pleased to find that 75 percent of the people
surveyed said they would either definitely or
probably shop in her store at least once a
month. Should Carrie plan her business based on
the 75 percent figure? Why or why not?
47Application Question 3 7(2 of 2)
- Answer The 75 percent figure is probably
optimistic. One caveat regarding survey research
is that people who say that they intend to
purchase a product dont always follow through.
Nonetheless, the 75 percent figure is
encouraging.
48Application Question 3 11(1 of 2)
- Kate Wilson has developed an innovative suite of
software products for K12 schools. She is
wondering if now is a good time to launch a
business to sell her products. What factors
should Kate consider in making this determination?
49Application Question 3 11(2 of 2)
- Answer
- First, Kate should determine whether the window
of opportunity to launch a suite of software
products for K-12 schools is open or closed. She
can make this determination by doing both primary
and secondary research on her industry, to
establish how crowded it is with competitors or
if there are one or two firms that dominate the
industry. If the industry is excessively
crowded, or there are strong brand leaders in the
same part of the industry that Kate plans to
enter, the window of opportunity may be closed.
Ultimately, the answer to this question is a
judgment call on Kates part. - Second, Kate should study the simple economics of
the marketplace. She should try to determine (1)
if K-12 schools are currently buying new software
products, and (2) if the current companies in the
industry are making money. If the answer to one
or both of these question is no, the industry may
not be hospitable to new firms at this time.
50Application Question 3 15(1 of 2)
- What are some of the red flags that would
suggest that the overall financial attractiveness
of a proposed new venture is poor?
51Application Question 3 15(2 of 2)
- There are a number of red flags that would
suggest that the overall financial attractiveness
of a proposed new venture is poor, including the
following - Difficult to accurately project the total amount
needed to launch the venture - Difficult to project gross sales and net income
- High capital investment relative to the returns
anticipated - Risky business
- Slow growth in sales during the first several
years of the venture - Low percentage of recurring revenue
- High costs involved with obtaining customers
- Unclear exit opportunities.
52You Be the VC
- Company Bones In Motion
- www.bonesinmotion.com
- Business Idea
- Turn nearly any cellphone into an automatic
journal that allows walkers, runners, and bikers
to record their activities, and benefit to from
the motivational aspects of keeping track of
their progress.
53You Be the VC Bones In Motion
- Company
- Bones In Motion
- Business Idea
- Pitch
- Most people know that they need to exercise to
stay healthy. But simply buying a pair of
running shoes or a bicycle is rarely the answer.
People must be motivated to stay committed to an
exercise plan. One thing that sports
psychologists have found helps people stay
committed is to keep track of their daily
progress. Its also very motivating to people to
graphically see the results of their exercise
efforts and to be able to share their progress
with their family and friends. - Bones in Motion was created to fit this exact
need. In the first of what it hopes will be many
outdoor applications, the company has turned the
ordinary cellphone into a virtual coach using a
software application called BiMActive. BiMActive
is an online service, which is currently
available to Sprint and Nextel cellphone
customers, at a cost of 9.99 per month. Bones
in Motion is negotiating with other cellphone
service providers and hopes to have more signed
up soon. - Continued
54You Be the VC Bones In Motion
- Heres How It Works
- Heres how the service works. When you start the
application, you have to wait for a few seconds
for it to hone in on your GPS location (you do
need a GPS-equipped cell phone). For the GPS to
work, you need to be outdoors with a view of the
sky. Once you start to run, walk, or bike, it
records your distance, speed, pace, location,
elevation, and estimated amount of calories
burned. All you need to do is keep your
cellphone with you. Once finished, your workout
data is wirelessly uploaded to a Web page with
the route you just covered superimposed on a
Google map. A complete set of stats for your
workout is available, including the distance
covered, splits, and estimated calories burned.
You can also keep track of the distance youve
covered by week, month, or year. - If youre community-minded you can share your
results with other BiMActive members. You can
also post the route you just covered for other
BiMActive members to see. The difficulty of the
route is rated by BiMActive based on topography,
changes in evaluation, and other data. You can
also look at the routes that other BiMActive
members have posted. - BiMActive is just the first in a series of mobile
lifestyle applications planned by Bones in
Motion. - Continued
55You Be the VC Bones In Motion
- Rate Bones In Motion on a scale from 1 5 on the
following attributes - Strength of the New Venture Team
- Strength of the Opportunity
- Strength of the Industry
- Strength of the Business Model
- Continued
56You Be the VC Bones In Motion
- Strength of the New Venture Team
- 3 (on a scale of 1 5)
- CEO Andrew Graham has 22 years of experience in
management and marketing with Motorola, including
12 years as Founder and CEO of industry design
automation consortium Si2, Inc. - CTO Jon Werner has 20 years of software
experience with IBM and several start-ups. - VP of Operations Spencer Nassar has 22 years of
experience in product development and operational
management. - Continued
57You Be the VC Bones In Motion
- Strength of the Opportunity
- 2 (on a scale of 1 5)
- This opportunity falls into the same category as
Riya and Segwayit is novel and interesting but
has yet to prove that it has a clearly-defined
market. The BiMActive system will enhance the
ability of runners, bikers, hikers, and other
outdoor enthusiasts to record their activities
and share relevant information with others.
Were skeptical of the companys ability to gain
traction in this market for two reasons. First,
there are an increasing number of devices that
provide a similar functionality (such as sports
watches that have GPS capability) that do not
require a monthly subscription fee and are not
tied to specific cellphone providers. Second,
its hard to believe that a large number of
people, beyond hard-core running, cycling, and
hiking enthusiasts, will take the time and incur
the expense necessary to learn the BiMActive
system. - Continued
58You Be the VCBones In Motion
- Strength of the Industry
- 3 (on a scale of 1 5)
- The industry is outdoor enthusiasts that want to
track their activities and share relevant
information with others. This strikes us as a
fairly narrow vertical market, rather than the
more horizontal market that Bones in Motion seems
to be gearing up to service. The market should
be fairly easy to reach, through running and
cycling stores, periodicals, and Web sites.
While there are large numbers of runners, bikers,
and hikers in the U.S., its hard to know how
many of them would be interested in the product
that Bones in Motion hopes to bring to the
market. - Continued
59You Be the VCBones in Motion
- Strength of the Business Model
- 3.0 (on a scale of 1 5)
- The business model is to sell a monthly
subscription to the service (called BiMActive)
through a cellphone company. Nextel and Sprint
are currently participating, and more companies
will presumably sign on. - Continued
60You Be the VCBones In Motion
61You Be the VCBones In Motion
- Decision
- In our judgment, even though the BiMActive system
may be an exciting product that works, it is
entering a crowded marketplace with low barriers
to entry and other products that provide similar
functionality for a lower price. There is also
nothing particularly innovative about the
companys business model. Once they sign up a
customer, they earn a monthly subscription fee
(which they share with the cellphone provider)
until the subscriber decides to drop the plan.
As far as we can tell, there are no additional
opportunities to earn revenue from subscribers. - We would not fund this idea.
62Case 3.2 Intuit
- The Value of Validating Business Ideas
63IntuitDiscussion Question 1
- Refer to Table 3.2 in the chapter. To what extent
does Intuit capture each of the benefits of
conducting a product/service feasibility analysis
listed in the table? - Answer Intuit clearly captures each of the five
specific benefits listed in Table 3.2.
64IntuitDiscussion Question 2
- Compare Intuits approach to feasibility analysis
and usability testing to Salesforce.coms
approach (Salesforce.com is the subject of the
Partnering for Success feature in the chapter).
In what ways are their approaches similar and in
what ways are they different? - Answer Both companies have a very user-centric
approach to creating products and services, and
solicit a high level of feedback from their
users. In terms of differences, it appears that
Salesforce.com involves their customers more in
the actual design of products, while Intuit
involves their customers more in assessing ease
of use. This difference most likely stems from
the fact that Salesforce.com is strictly a B-to-B
company, while Intuit is more of a mix of B-to-B
and B-to-C therefore Salesforce.com is probably
selling to a more sophisticated clientele, which
is in a better position to provide input on the
actual design of products.
65IntuitDiscussion Question 3
- To what extent do you think Intuits industry is
attractive? If Intuit conducted an
industry/market feasibility analysis on the main
industries in which it participates, what do you
believe would be the outcome? - Answer
- Most will argue that Intuit is in a very
attractive marketplace. The number of small
businesses in the U.S. and across the world
continues to increase, expanding the need for
Intuits products and services. Intuit should
score high on all three dimensions of
industry/market feasibility.
66IntuitDiscussion Question 4
- Why do you think Intuit puts so much effort into
collecting primary research about its users and
their experiences? Would it be cheaper for Intuit
to hire a marketing research firm to collect data
on user preferences? What would Intuit lose if it
pursued this approach? - Answer
- Intuit has apparently adopted the philosophy that
it will collect the lions share of its own
research. Although hiring a marketing research
firm to conduct the same research might be
cheaper, moving in that direction would cost
Intuit the personal, one-to-one interactions that
is has with its customers (and potential
customers).