Title: Diagnosing and Treating Mood Disorders: The Science and Ethics
1Diagnosing and Treating Mood Disorders The
Science and Ethics
Chris Trimble, Leo Huizar, Fredah Kabbech, Megan
Sieveke, Brandon Butler
2Mood Disorders
3Depression
- Can refer to either
- A mood a pervasive and sustained emotional
response - A clinical syndrome a combination of emotional,
cognitive and behavioral symptoms
4How To Distinguish Depression From Normal Sadness
- The mood change is pervasive across situations
and persistent over time - The mood change may occur in the absence of any
precipitating events - The depressed mood is accompanied by impaired
ability to function in usual social and
occupational roles - The change in mood is accompanied by a cluster of
additional signs and symptoms - The nature or quality of the mood change may be
different from that associated with normal
sadness
5Four Types of Symptoms Associated With Mood
Disorders
- Emotional
- Cognitive
- Somatic
- Behavioral
6Emotional Symptoms
- Depressed or dysphoric mood is the most common
and obvious symptom of depression - People who are depressed describe themselves as
feeling utterly gloomy, dejected and despondent - Manic patients experience euphoric like symptoms
7Cognitive Symptoms
- Involve changes in the way people think about
themselves and their surroundings - Depressed people may have trouble concentrating
and are easily distracted - Preoccupation with guilt and worthlessness
- Manic patients report sped up thoughts and ideas
8Somatic Symptoms
- Related to basic physiological or bodily
functions - Include fatigue, aches and pains, and serious
changes in appetite or sleeping patterns
9Behavioral Symptoms
- Changes in the things that people do and the rate
at which they do them - Psychomotor retardation often accompanies the
onset of depression - Manic patients show energetic, provocative and
flirtatious behavior
10Diagnosing Mood Disorders
- Defined in terms of episodes
- discrete periods of time in which the persons
behavior is dominated by either a depressed or
manic mood
11Major Depressive Episode
- Five or more of the following symptoms must have
been present during the same two week period and
represent a change from previous functioning - At least one of the symptoms is either
- Depressed mood
- Loss of interest or pleasure
12Major Depressive Episode Symptoms
- Depressed mood most of the day, nearly every day
- Diminished pleasure in all, or almost all
activities - Significant weight loss (without dieting) or
weight gain - Insomnia or hypersomnia nearly every day
- Psychomotor agitation or retardation
- Fatigue or loss of energy
- Feelings of worthlessness or guilt
- Diminished ability to think or concentrate
- Recurrent thoughts of death or suicidal ideation
13Manic Episode
- A distinct period of abnormally and persistently
elevated, or expansive mood, lasting at least one
week - During the period of mood disturbance, three of
more of the following symptoms have persisted and
have been present to a significant degree
14Manic Episode Symptoms
- Inflated self esteem or grandiosity
- Decreased need for sleep
- More talkative than usual
- Flight of ideas
- Distractibility (drawn to unimportant stimuli)
- Increase in goal directed activity
- Excessive involvement in pleasurable activities
that have a high potential for painful
consequences
15Mood Disorders
- Two primary types
- Unipolar mood disorder the person experiences
only episodes of depression - Bipolar mood disorder the person experiences
episodes of mania as well as depression
16Types of Mood Disorders and Frequency
17Types of Mood Disorders
- Unipolar Mood Disorders
- Major Depressive Disorder
- Dysthymic Disorder
- Bipolar Mood Disorders
- Bipolar I Disorder
- Bipolar II Disorder
- Cyclothymic Disorder
- Subtypes
18Major Depressive Disorder
- One or more major depressive episodes
- No manic or unequivocal hypomanic episodes
- Lifetime prevalence of 15
- Major Depressive Disorder 15 suicide mortality
- VA 1991 Study
- Major Depressive Disorder mortality 38.7
- 13 no psychiatric monitoring
19Major Depressive Disorder
- Course is variable
- Some having episodes years apart, clusters of
episodes, and some with frequent episodes
throughout life - Only about 20 have chronic episodes
- After the first episode, 50- 60 chance of a
second , and a 5-10 chance of a manic episode
(i.e. developing bipolar I disorder) - After second episode, 70 chance of a third
- After third episode, 90 chance of a fourth
- The greater number of previous episodes is an
important risk factor for recurrence
20Major Depressive Disorder
- By definition, Major Depressive Disorder cannot
be due to - Physical illness, alcohol, medication, or street
drug use. - Normal bereavement.
- Bipolar Disorder
- 7Mood-incongruent psychosis (e.g.,
Schizoaffective Disorder, Schizophrenia,
Delusional Disorder, or Psychotic Disorder Not
Otherwise Specified).
21Major Depressive DisorderCo-occurring Disorders
- Substance Abuse
- Anxiety
- 80 to 90 of individuals with Major Depressive
Disorder also have anxiety symptoms (e.g.,
anxiety, obsessive preoccupations, panic attacks,
phobias, and excessive health concerns). - Cancer, COPD (Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary
Disease), Pain, eating disorders - Causation
- Meds steroids
- Diseases hypothyroidism
22Dysthymic Disorder
- Depressed mood for at least two years
- Never without at least two of the following
symptoms for more than two months - Poor appetite or overeating, insomnia or
hypersomnia, low energy, low self esteem, poor
concentration, feelings of hopelessness
23Dysthymic Disorder
- No major depressive episode during the first two
years - Lifetime risk of 3
24Bipolar I Disorder
- One or more manic episodes
- Lifetime risk of 1
25These positron emission tomography scans of the
brain of a person with bipolar disorder show the
individual shifting from depression, top row, to
mania, middle row, and back to depression, bottom
row, over the course of 10 days.
26Bipolar II Disorder
- One or more major depressive episodes
- At least one hypomanic episode
- A hypomanic episode is a less severe version of a
manic episode. - No manic episodes
27Subtypes of Mood Disorders
- Melancholia describes a particularly severe type
of depression - Psychotic features when hallucinations or
delusions were present during the most recent
episode - Rapid cycling the person experiences at least 4
episodes within a 12 month period
28Subtypes of Mood Disorders
- Postpartum Onset when episodes begin within 4
weeks after childbirth - Seasonal affective disorder when the onset of
episodes is regularly associated with changes in
seasons
29Prevalence of Mood Disorders
- Depression accounts for more than 10 percent of
all disabilities in the US - Younger generations are experiencing higher rates
of depression, and those who become depressed are
doing so at an earlier age - Depression affects 13-14 million people each year
30Prevalence of Mood Disorders
- Ratio of unipolar to bipolar is at least 51
- Lifetime prevalence of all mood disorders is 8,
ranked third behind substance abuse disorders and
anxiety disorders
31Gender Differences
- Women are two or three times more vulnerable to
depression than men - Sex hormones, stressful life events, childhood
adversity, etc - May be more likely to seek treatment
- May be more likely to be labeled as depressed
- No differences seen in bipolar disorders
32Children Statistics
- Up to 2.5 of children in the US suffer from
depression - Up to 8.3 of adolescents in the US suffer from
depression - Girls entering puberty are twice as likely to
experience depression as boys
33Causes of Mood Disorders
34Types of Causes
- Environmental Factors
- Psychological Factors
- Biological Factors
35Environmental FactorsStress
- Levels of stress may vary from person to person.
- Depressive episodes can make a person more
vulnerable to further episodes, so small amounts
of stress can activate depression - Learner Helplessness- after experiencing
chronic or repeated stressful events, people can
learn to feel helpless
36Environmental Factors Substance Abuse
- Depression that is a result of drug abuse,
medication, or toxin exposure - Associated with use and withdrawl from alcohol,
amphetamine, cocaine, hallucinogens, inhalants,
opioids, phencyclidine, sedaitves, hypnotics and
anxiolytics - Exposure or habitual use of chemicals can alter
brain structure and function resulting in
depression
37Environmental FactorsChildhood Difficulties
- Depression can develop in children who have
experienced a traumatic event including but not
limited to - Death of family member or friend
- Natural disaster
- Divorce
- Loss of parents job, home, etc...
- Many of these children are emotionally damaged or
lack emotional development and often have
difficulties adjusting - Traumatic Event may affect the development of the
Limibic System
38Depression In Disease
- Estimated 1/3 people with chronic disease have
depression. - Alzheimers
- Boston Study
- 14 had history of depression
- HIV
- 1/3 estimated to have depression
39Continued
- The rate for depression occurring with medical
illness - Heart attack 40-65
- Coronary artery disease (without heart attack)
18-20 - Parkinson's disease 40
- Multiple sclerosis 40
- Stroke 10-27
- Cancer 25
- Diabetes 25
-
- Reviewed by the doctors at The Cleveland Clinic
Department of Psychiatry and Psychology.
40Psychological Factors
- Cognitive Vulnerability
- People responding differently to the same
negative experience involving loss, failure and
disappointment
41https//www.depressionadvances.com/animation/brain
Animations.html
https//www.depressionadvances.com/animation/brain
Animations.html
42(No Transcript)
43Biological Factors
- Neurotransmitters and Neurons
- The signal enters the neuron through the dendrite
and proceeds through the cell body to the axon
where it is switched from a electric signal to a
chemical one - Theses chemical signals are called
neurotransmitters - Neurotransmitters can fit into many receptors,
but receptor sites can only receive specific
transmitters - Upon release the transmitter is broken down by
mono amine oxidase (MAO) or its taken back in by
the neuron that released it, called reuptake
44Biological Factors
- Of the 30 or so known neurotransmitters,
depression effects Serotonin, Norepinephrine, and
Dopamine - Depression has been linked to both low and
elevated Norepinephrine concentrations.
45Biological Factors Serotonin
- The permissive hypothesis of serotonin function
postulates that the deficit in central
serotonergic neurotransmission permits the
expression of bipolar disorder but is not
sufficient to cause it. - According to this theory, both the manic and the
depressive phases of bipolar illness are
characterized by low central serotonin function
but differ in high versus low norepinephrine
activity.
46Biological FactorsNorepinephrine
- The catecholamine hypothesis of affective
disorders proposes that some forms of depression
are associated with a deficiency of catecholamine
activity (particularly norepinephrine) at
functionally important andrengeric receptor sites
in the brain, whereas mania is associated with a
relative excess.
47Biological FactorsDopamine
- Evidence is substantial that enhanced dopamine
activity may play a primary role in psychotic
depression.
48Biological Factors Hormones
- About one half of all depressed persons have a
high level of the hormone cortisol in their blood - A person with a depressive mood disorder may not
have their hypothalamus regulating the cortisol
production in the adrenal gland correctly - Normal cortisol levels peak at 800a.m. and
400p.m. for non depressed person, while a person
with depression may have the hormone released at
a constant level
49Biological Factors Genetics
- There is a 1.5 to 3 greater chance for a person
to develop a depressive disorder if a parent or
sibling has it as well - 50 of those with bipolar disorder have a parent
with history of clinical depression - 25 of children of a parent who is bipolar
develop a depressive disorder - 50-75 of children of two parents with bipolar
disorder develop a depressive disorder
50Biological Factors Twin Studies
- If one twin develops depression there is a 76
chance that the other twin will develop a
disorder as well - When raised apart the percentage is 67
- Because this number is not closer to 100, there
is indication that other factors are also
responsible - Fraternal twins have a 19 chance of developing a
depressive disorder if the other develops one
51Bipolar Causes
52Causes of Depression
- Depression has been linked to size/function in
the temporal and frontal lobes and the cingulate
gyrus. However, it is unclear as to whether the
depression causes the abnormalities or the
depression is a result of the abnormalities.
53(No Transcript)
54Treatment of Mood Disorders
55Treatments
- Unipolar Mood Disorders
- Cognitive Behavioral Therapy
- Antidepressant Medication
- Bipolar Mood Disorders
- Lithium
- Anticonvulsant Medication
- Psychotherapy
- Others
- Electroconvulsive Therapy
- Vagus Nerve Stimulation
- Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation
56Cognitive Behavioral Therapy
- CBT combines both cognitive therapy and
behavioral therapy - Cognitive Therapy teaches a person how certain
thinking patterns are causing their symptoms-by
giving them a distorted picture of what's going
on in their life, and making them feel anxious,
depressed or angry for no good reason, or
provoking them into ill-chosen actions.
57Cognitive Behavioral Therapy
- Behavioral Therapy helps patients weaken the
connections between troublesome situations and
their habitual reactions to them. It also teaches
them how to calm their mind and body, so they can
feel better, think more clearly, and make better
decisions
58Cognitive Behavioral Therapy
- Identification of Skill Deficits
- Help patient to identify deficits so that they
can learn better ways to manage life - Evaluation of Life-Experiences
- Help patient develop realistic expectations about
life, and help distinguish between what the
patient needs and what they want - Self-talk
- Help patient identify negative self-talk, teach
them how to combat these thoughts and to replace
them with positive thought
59Cognitive Behavioral Therapy
- Automatic thoughts
- Help patient identify negative automatic thoughts
and ways to replace these thoughts with positive
ones - Irrational ideas and Beliefs
- Teach patient how to identify their irrational
thoughts and how to differentiate between
irrational and rational thought - Overgeneralizing and Catastrophizing
- Help patient identify and change negative
overgeneralizations
60Cognitive Behavioral Therapy
- Cognitive Distortions
- Help patient determine what evaluations are
distortions by providing objective feedback of
their evaluations of the world - Pessimistic Thinking
- Help patient develop more optimistic view of
world
61TreatmentAntidepressants
- Four types of drugs are used in the treatment of
depression and other associated mood disorders - Tricyclic antidepressants
- Monoamine Oxidase Inhibitor
- Selective Serotonin Reuptake Inhibitors
- Serotonin Norepinephrine Reuptake
Inhibitors
62Tricyclic Antidepressants
- From 1960s until late 1980s, tricyclic
antidepressants represented the major
pharmaceutical treatment for depression - They still provide the surest antidepressant
response for moderately to severe depression
63Tricyclic Antidepressants
- TCAs work by increasing the concentration of
norepinephrine and serotonin in certain regions
of the CNS - TCAs impede the reuptake of norepindephrine and
serotonin - They are safe and effective for up to 80 of
patients
64Tricyclic Antidepressants
- There are two broad chemical classes
- Tertiary Amines
- They have a greater effect in boosting serotonin
than norepinephrine. - amitriptyline, imipramine, trimipramine and
doxepin - Secondary Amines
- Greater increase of norepinephrine levels
- nortriptyline, desipramine, and protriptyline
65Monoamine Oxidase Inhibitors
- MAOIs treat depression by inhibiting the effect
of monoamine oxidase which causes the
concentrations of serotonin, norepinephrine and
dopamine to increase - Most doctors will not prescribe MAOIs unless a
patient is not responding to other
antidepressants
66Monoamine Oxidase Inhibitors
- Definitely Effective
- Atypical Depression
- Major Depression
- Dysthymia
- Melancholia
- Panic Disorder
- Bulimia
- Atypical facial pain
- Anergic Depression
- Treatment-resistant depression
- Parkinsons Disease
- Other Possible Uses
- Obsessive-complusive Disorder
- Narcolepsy
- Headache
- Chronic pain syndrome
- Generalized anxiety disorder
67Selective Serotonin Reuptake Inhibitors
- SSRIs work by inhibiting the reuptake of
serotonin into the neuron that made it - Includes fluoxetine and paroxetine
68Serotonin Norepinephrine Reuptake Inhibitors
- This class of drugs is most recent addition to
the family of antidepressants and has a structure
and chemical profile that distinguishes them both
tricyclic antidepressants and SSRIs. - Work by increasing levels of Serotonin and
Norepinephrine by inhibiting their re-absorption
back into the cell.
69Venlafaxine
- Venlafaxine inhibits serotonin and norepinephrine
reuptake without significant effects on
muscarinic, cholinergic, histaminic, or
alpha-andrenergic receptors. - Therefore, venlafaxine activity is similar to
tricyclics and SSRIs but has a less adverse
side-effect profile.
70Bupropin
- Bupropin is the newest drug for treating
depression, although the exact neurochemical
mechanism is not known - Does not inhibit monoamine oxidase or inihibit
the reuptake serotonin and norepinephrine - Does inhibit the reuptake of dopamine to some
extent - It is a stimulant type drug that is used in the
treatment of major depression.
71TreatmentsAntidepressants
- 50-65 of people given an antidepressant show
much improvement over 3 months, compared to
25-30 of people given a placebo. - Indicates that although drug is effective,
antidepressants, like most medicines, may have
some benefits due to placebo affect
72TreatmentsAntidepressants
- Medication must be used every day or at every
time prescribed. If not taken correctly
treatment will not be effective and may have
adverse effects. - Antidepressants will usually take 1-2 weeks work,
however some may take up to six weeks
73TreatmentsAntidepressants
- On the basis of clinical research and experience,
the consensus is that most people can be taken
off their antidepressants after six to eight
months of clinical response without doing worse
than patients continuing on the drug
74Bipolar Treatments
- Psychiatric Management
- Acute Treatment
- Maintenance Treatment
75Psychiatric Management
- At this time, there is no cure for bipolar
disorder however, treatment can decrease the
associated morbidity and mortality.
76Bipolar TreatmentsLithium
- Lithium is prescribed to people with bipolar
disorder to even out the highs and lows. - Because bipolar disorder requires long term
treatment, a patient may have to take Lithium for
many years, often in combination with other
antidepressants
77Bipolar TreatmentsLithium
- Lithium interferes with the synthesis and
reuptake of chemical messengers by which nerves
communicate with each other (neurotransmitters).
Lithium also affects the concentrations of
tryptophan and serotonin in the brain. - Lithium's effects usually begin within one week
of starting treatment, and the full effect is
seen by 2 to 3 weeks.
78Bipolar TreatmentAnticonvulsants
- Often prescribed to patients who do not respond
to lithium - Include carbamazepine (Tegretol) or valproic acid
(Depakene) - More than 50 respond positively to these drugs
- Reduce the frequency and severity of relapse
79(No Transcript)
80TreatmentsElectroconvulsive Therapy
- Patient is put to sleep and temporarily
paralyzed, so that their muscles do not contract
and cause injuries like fractures. An electric
current is then run through the brain to initiate
a seizure. - ECT is sometimes the most effective, rapid method
of treating severe major depressive disorder
(MDD). - for patients with poor response to medications,
- poor tolerance of usual antidepressants,
- severe vegetative symptoms,
- or psychotic features
81TreatmentVagus Nerve Stimulation
- VNS stimulates the limbic system, a group of
related structures that affect mood, motivation,
sleep, appetite, alertness and other factors
commonly altered by depression. - VNS is delivered to the left cervical vagus nerve
by the NeuroCybernetic Prosthesis (NCPâ) System
which is implanted just under the skin in the
left chest area. - Delivers a pre-programmed, intermittent
electrical pulse to cervical vagus nerve 24 hours
a day
82Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation
- TMS is a procedure in which the electrical
activity in the brain is influenced by a magnetic
pulse. - This procedure can be used to alter function of
certain areas of the brain, especially those
involved in depression
83Side Effects of Treatments
84Side EffectsTricyclics
- Initially
- they cause blurred vision
- Constipation
- Light-headedness when standing or sitting up
suddenly - Dry mouth
- Difficulty urinating
- Feelings of confusion
- Cognitive Dysfunction
- A small percentage of people will have other side
effects such as - sweating, a racing heartbeat, low blood pressure,
allergic skin reactions or sensitivity to the
sun. - Side effects usually disappear once therapeutic
effects if medication take hold
85Side EffectsTricyclics
- More serious side effects, although rare, can be
aggravation of narrow angle glaucoma and seizures - Some tricyclic side effects relate to the fact
that these medications have similar effects on
other neurotransmitters in the CNS, notably
histamine and acetylcholine
86Drug InteractionsTricyclics
- Drug Interaction
- MAOIs Stroke, hypertension
- Norepinephrine Large increase in blood
pressure and incidence of arrhyhmias - Phenothiazines Psychosis, agitation
- Barbiturates Increase
heteocyclic metabolism - Cimetidine Blocks metabolism of
heterocyclics - Haloperidol Can block metabolism of
heterocyclics - Methylphanidate Blocks metabolisms of
heterocyclics -
87Side EffectsMAIOs
- The side effects of MAOIs are generally more
severe or frequent than for other antidepressants
88Side EffectsMAIOs
- Drowsiness
- Constipation
- Nausea
- Diarrhea
- Stomach upset
- Fatigue
- Dry mouth
- Dizziness
- Low blood pressure
- Lightheadedness, especially when getting up from
a lying or sitting position
- Decreased urine output
- Decreased sexual function
- Sleep disturbances
- Muscle twitching
- Weight gain
- Blurred vision
- Headache
- Increased appetite
- Restlessness
- Shakiness
- Trembling
- Weakness
- Increased sweating
89Drug InteractionsMAOIs
- Because of the extensive inhibition of monoamine
oxidase by MAOIs enzymes raises the potential for
a number of drug interactions. - Many of these interaction occur with
over-the-counter medications
90Drug InteractionsMAOIs
- Drug Interaction
- Other MAOIS Increase risk for side
effect covulsions - TCAs, Carbamazepine,
Hypertension convulsions - Cyclobenzaprine
- SSRIs Serotonin Syndrome
- Stimulants (dextromamphetamine) Increased
blood pressure - Busirone
- Meperidine Potentially fatal interaction
- Dextromethorphan Brief psychosis
- Direct Sympathomimetics
Increased blood pressure - Indirect Sympathomimetics Hypertensive
crisis possible - Oral Hypoglycemics (insulin) May worsen
hypoglycemia - Fenfluramine, L-Tryptophan Serotonin
Syndrome possible
91Food InteractionsMAOIs
- Food Restrictions
- Avoid
- Cheese, overripe aged fruit, fava beans, sausage,
salami, sherry, liquors, sauerkraut, monosodium
glutamate, pickled fish, brewers yeast, beef and
chicken liver, fermented products, red wine - Used in moderation
- Coffee, chocolate, colas, tea, soy sauce, beer,
other wines -
- MAOIs inhibit monoamine oxidase in gut that is
responsible for the break down of tyramine. A
build up of tyramine can lead to a sudden
increase in blood pressure and a chance of heart
attack or stroke.
92Side EffectsSSRIs
- loss of appetite, weight loss
- increased appetite, weight gain
- allergic reactions
- dry mouth
- irritability / anxiety
- sleeplessness
- drowsiness
- headache
- shaking
- dizziness
- fits / convulsions
- disturbance of sexual function (but this is also
a feature of depression) - sweating
- bruising
- manic or hypomanic behaviour
- shaking
- dizziness
- fits / convulsions
- disturbance of sexual function (but this is also
a feature of depression) - sweating
- bruising
- manic or hypomanic behaviour
- abnormal movements
- low sodium level
- suicidal ideas
- abnormal movements
- low sodium level
- suicidal ideas
93Drug InteractionsSSRIs
- Although the potential for interaction does
exist, SSRIs are not associated with many of the
interactions are seen with other antidepressants - Paroxetine and fluvoxamine have been associated
with increased bleeding when given with wafarin - Does not effect Lithium levels
94Suicide and SSRIs
- There is evidence that the use of
antidepressants, especially SSRIs, can cause an
increase in suicidal thoughts, however it does
not show an increase in cases. - A severely depressed patient, or those with
bipolar syndrome in a low phase, usually only
have the energy to focus on their low. As the
medication begins to take affect they will have
an increase in energy and suicidal thoughts as
they transition from their low or depressed
episode. It is this time when the patient is
still in a depressed state of mind, that they
are able to think more about and idealize suicide
because oh their higher energy level.
95Side EffectsSNRIs
- Nausea and vomiting
- Dizziness
- Insomnia
- Sleepiness
- Abnormal dreams
- Constipation
- Sweating
- Dry mouth
- Yawning
- Tremor
- Gas
- Anxiety
- Agitation
- Abnormal vision
- Headache
- Sexual dysfunction
96Side Effects Bupropin
- 28 of patients will lose five pounds or more
- 0.04 of patients will experience seizures
- Common Agitation, constipation, diarrhea,
dizziness, dry mouth, headache, increased
perspiration, insomnia, nausea, vomiting - Rare Acne, blurred vision, chest pains, chill,
coordination problems, confusion,
decrease in white blood cell count,
fainting, fever,hair color change
97WithdrawlsSNRIs
- Stopping treatment with SNRIs, especially when
done suddenly, can cause withdrawal-like
symptoms - nausea, vomiting, anxiety, diarrhea, agitation,
confusion, headaches, nightmares, coordination
changes, or skin-tingling or shock-like
sensations - Sometimes referred to as discontinuation syndrome
98Side EffectsElectroconvulsive Therapy
- Anxiety or nervousness
- Gastrointestinal distress (nausea and diarrhea)
- Headache
- Insomnia
- Rash
- Slight weight loss
- Sexual impotence in men (about 10)
- Lose of interest in sex for both men and women
inability to achieve orgasm
99The Chris Pittman Case
- In 2001, the 12 year boy shot and killed his
grandparents while being under the influence of
Zoloft, a popular antidepressant for the previous
couple of days
100The Chris Pittman Case
- Defense attorneys argued that Chris suffered
adverse reactions to the drug including akathisia
(a neurological reaction characterized by extreme
internal restlessness, which has been associated
with suicide and violence), emotional blunting,
mania and psychosis with testimonies by Chriss
aunt and sister
101The Chris Pittman Case
- Former FDA scientist Dr. Richard Kapit, who had
approved Zoloft for human clinical trials even
testified in Chriss defense stating that some
antidepressants can alter the behavior of people
under 18, causing mania and even suicide - Chris was charged and
sentenced as an adult on
February 15, 2005, and is
now serving 30 years in
prison
102Ethics
103Ethics
- Ethical issue arises over a depressed patients
ability to make decisions concerning treatment. - An elderly patient that has been diagnosed with
depression has recently become gravely ill,
requiring dialysis.
104Ethics
- If you are not given an effective dosage of
antidepressant medication, suicide rates
increase. Is the hit-or-miss method of treatment
with medication ethical? - Untreated Depression has a high risk of suicide
that accompanies the disorder
105Ethics
- 54 of patients with bipolar disorder are
misdiagnosed as having depression - Misdiagnoses and treatment of patients with
bipolar disorder as having a unipolar disorder
can magnify the patients symptoms - Many antidepressants can cause a patient with
bipolar disorder to have exaggerated and
prolonged highs and lows - Should we be quick to treat Depression with
medication when misdiagnosis can have serious
consequences.
106References
- Downing-Orr, Kristina. Rethinking Depression -
Why Current Treatments Fail. 1st ed. New York
Plenum Press, 1998. - Higgins, Edmund S. "Is Depression a Neurochemical
or Neurodegenerative?." Current Psychiatry 3.9
(2004) 39-40. - Kline, Nathan S., M.D., Factors in Depression,
Rockland State Hospital, Raven Press Books, Inc.,
1974 - Lazarus, Jeremy A. "Ethics in Split Treatment."
Psychiatric Annals 31.10 (2001) 611-614. - Oltmanns, Thomas F., Case studies in Abnormal
Psychology, 3rd, John Wiley and Sons, Inc., 1991 - Oltmanns, Thomas F., and Robert E. Emery.
Abnormal Psychology. 5th ed. Upper Saddle River
Prentice Hall, 2004. - Schatzberg, Alan F., and Charles B. Nemeroff.
Textbook of Psychopharmacology. 2nd ed.
Washington American Psychiatric Press Inc.,
1998. - Spitzer, Robert L., Psychopathology, A case book,
Columbia University, McGraw-Hill, Inc., 1993 - Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental
Disorders. IV txt revision ed. Washington
American Psychiatric Association, 2000. - "Depression Caused by Chronic Illness." Web MD.
July 2005. WebMD Inc.. 02 Apr. 2006
lthttp//www.webmd.com/content/article/45/1663_5121
5.htmgt. - "Neurotransmitter Animation." Depression
Advances. 2006. Eli Lilly and Company. 05 Apr.
2006 lthttps//www.depressionadvances.com/animation
/brainAnimations.htmlgt.
107END