Title: Response to Intervention (RtI) at the Secondary Level: Keys to Implementation
1Response to Intervention (RtI) at the Secondary
Level Keys to Implementation
- Madi Phillips, Ph.D. NCSP
- I-ASPIRE Regional Coordinator
2Big Ideas about Todays Presentation
- Were aligning a delivery system to educational
needs. - Were increasing the quality of teaching, tools,
and support across 3-Tiers instead of moving the
problem. - Were shifting mind sets Every problem learning
(or behaving) becomes a special education
problem. - In a perfect world, we shouldnt have RtI (as
an eligibility process) at the secondary level. - Were shifting Interventions focus from
reactive, punitive, and/or restrictive to
proactive, preventative, inclusive. - We have the tools and we have experience, but
there is a gap.
3Without Problem Solving
Special Education
Sea of Ineligibility
General Education
4Student Profiles
- 8.7 million 4th-12th graders cant cope with
academic demands - 74 of all 9th graders scored at Unsatisfactory
or Basic Level on state assessment - Unsatisfactory 3ile WR 1ile RC
- Basic9ile WR 8ile RC
- 70 of adolescents graduate 50 of students with
color do - Students who stay on track in freshman year
(earn 5 credits and no more than 1 F) 3.5 times
as likely to graduate
5Student Profiles (cont)
- On-track Indicator
- Students who stay on track in freshman year
(earn 5 credits and no more than 1 F) 3.5 times
as likely to graduate - One semester F decreases likelihood of graduating
from 83 to 60 - 2 Fs decreases likelihood to 44
- 3 Fs decreases likelihood to 31
6The Old Problem Solving Heuristic
7What is NOT RtI Its not your fathers Oldsmobile
- Its Not About SE Eligibility with a new label
(e.g., pre-referral intervention, old team-new
name). - Its Not About SE Business as Usual with
programs that meet the needs of adults more than
students. - Expecting GE Teachers to meet the needs of ALL
students (180 students-180 different
interventions).
8Presentation Intended Outcomes
- Describe a heuristic for multi-tiered service
delivery for middle and high schools to meet the
academic and socio-emotional/behavioral needs. - Provide illustrations of effective reading
assessment for - Universal Screening,
- Problem Identification
- Progress Monitoring in Reading Intervention.
- Provide illustrations of effective assessment and
intervention tools necessary for - Basic Reading Skills
- Success in Content-Area Classes
- Behavioral Support
- Give you strategies for implementation.
9Bridging the Gap
10Problem Solving Steps
11The VISION To Provide Effective Interventions
to Meet the Needs of ALL Students Through Early
and Scientifically Based Interventions Through
Careful Systems Planning
Batsche, G. M., Elliott, J., Graden, J., Grimes,
J., Kovaleski, J. F., Prasse, D., et al. (2005).
Response to intervention Policy considerations
and implementation. Alexandria, VA National
Association of State Directors of Special
Education, Inc.
12Information Explosion/Instructional Time Dilemma
1960
Time
1980
Content
2000
13The Performance Gap
/
The University of Kansas Center for Research and
Learning
14The Performance Gap
/
Grade Level Expectations Demands Skills
Existing Support
Years in School
The University of Kansas Center for Research and
Learning
15The Performance Gap
Grade Level Expectations Demands Skills
- Infrastructure Support
- Flexible Scheduling
- Planning Time
- Professional Development Time
- Extended Learning Time
- Smaller Learning Communities
/
Existing Support
Years in School
The University of Kansas Center for Research and
Learning
16The Performance Gap
/
Instructional Core System Learning
Supports Infrastructure Supports Current
Supports
Grade Level Expectations Demands Skills
Years in School
The University of Kansas Center for Research and
Learning
17The Performance Gap
/
Instructional Core System Learning
Supports Infrastructure Supports Current
Supports
Grade Level Expectations Demands Skills
Years in School
The University of Kansas Center for Research and
Learning
18School Improvement Cycle
Problem Solving Process
http//www.ncrel.org/sdrs/school.htm
Similarities?
19http//www.nsdc.org/connect/projects/resultsbased.
cfm
20School Improvement Activity
- What are your current SI Goals?
- What content is covered in the current
professional development plan? - What problems or issues often come up at your
school?
21So...WHAT is RTI?
- 1. An eligibility process for determining if a
student has a learning disability? - 2. An opportunity to redress years of
dissatisfaction with both special education and
general education? - We See IT as Both
22How We See It
Needs-Based Service Delivery Systems
Problem-Solving Service Delivery System
23Program vs. Framework
- Response to Intervention (RtI) and School-wide
Positive Behavior Support are not programs, but
frameworks for designing and implementing
proactive, preventative programming using data.
24Basic Skills or
Functional Literacy
Pr
oblem?
No
Y
es
Instruction in Content
What
Instruction in Basic or
Ar
ea Knowledge
Literacy Skills
Service?
Dir
ect Service
Thru
Dir
ect Service
Thr
ough
How?
Special Education
GE Indirect
Service
Thru SE or GE Interventions
Master
Basic or
Literacy
Master
Content
Ar
ea
Goal
Skills
Knowledge
Evaluation
Mainstream
Consultation
CBM
Agreements
T
ool
CTMs VM
A
Secondar
y Pr
oblem-Solving Model
25Who Do We Serve in a Problem-Solving Model?
- We identify
- 1. Students with Basic Skills or Severe Literacy
Deficits for Direct Service - 2. Students without these Deficits who Need
Indirect Service for Success in Content Area
Courses
26A Model of Secondary Special Education Service
Delivery Should Be Predicated On
- 1. Students with serious functional literacy or
basic skills deficits receiving instruction in
these skills via special education - 2. Students without serious functional literacy
or basic skills deficits receiving instruction in
content area courses via general education with
relevant special education assistance or general
education interventions
27Scientific Standards for Progress Monitoring
28Typical High School Reader
29A Simple, Economical Way of Identifying
Educational Need
30High School Student with Severe Reading Problem
31A Severe Performance Discrepancy
32Likelihood of Passing the High Stakes Test
33Obvious and Potentially Severe Educational Need
34Testing in Even Easier Material
35Graph the Results and See the Problem Severity
36What Does R-CBM Measure?
Beware the Trap of the BOXES- Low Scores in the
Box Mean You Must TEACH the Things in the Box
37The Bigger Deficits Here
And Here
Oral Reading is the EASIEST to Measure--Lets Get
This Down and Add MORE Tools
And the MOST Unmotivated Here
For Some, the Hardest Thing Theyll Ever Do
The Easiest Thing To Teach
The Longer It Takes...
modified slightly from presentations by Joe
Torgesen, Ph.D. Co-Director, Florida Center for
Reading Research www.fcrr.org
38Case StudySevere Basic Skill Problem Provide
Intense Basic Skill Intervention!
39Predicted Not to Pass High Stake Test
40Determine the Severity of the Problem Using
Survey Level Assessment and Write an IEP
41Provide a Powerful Basic Skill Intervention and
Monitor Progress
42Conduct a Survey Level Assessment to Estimate
Basic Skill Discrepancy
43Possible Data Sources Activity
- Brainstorm the potential data sources in your
school - Examples may include
- Dean Referrals, Tardies, Suspensions, Expulsions,
Outside Placements, Drop Outs - Common Assessments, CBM, Yearly Progress Pro,
Failure Rates
44The High School Solution Building Continuously
Improving Tier 1 General Education Instruction
5
15
Use of Teaching Routines and Learning Strategies
(Kansas) Well-Designed Curriculum with a Big
Ideas Focus or Ability to Distill Curriculum
to Big Ideas Effective Secondary Classroom
Management Study and Organizational
Skills Curriculum Modification
80 of Students
45Increase the Capacity of General Education to
Teach ALL Students Critical Content
- All students learn critical content required in
the core curriculum regardless of literacy
levels. - Teachers compensate for limited literacy levels
by using - Explicit teaching routines,
- Adaptations, and
- Technology to promote content mastery.
- For example The Unit Organizer Routine
46Key Skills Sets for Secondary Support(http//www.
ku-crl.org/)
47A Major Source of Support for Secondary
48http//www.kucrl.org/iei/sim/ceroutines.html
49Content Enhancement Routines (Creating
learning-friendly classrooms)
- A way of teaching academically diverse classes in
which - The integrity of the content is maintained
- Critical content is selected and transformed
- Content is taught in an active partnership with
students
The University of Kansas Center for Research and
Learning
50Content Enhancement Teaching Routines
- Planning Leading Learning
- Course Organizer
- Unit Organizer
- Lesson Organizer
- Exploring Text, Topics, Details
- Framing Routine
- Survey Routine
- Clarifying Routine
- Ordering Routine
- Teaching Routines
- Concept Mastery Routine
- Concept Anchoring Routine
- Concept Comparison Routine
- Increasing Performance
- Quality Assignment Routine
- Question Exploration Routine
- Recall Enhancement Routine
The University of Kansas Center for Research and
Learning
51(No Transcript)
52(No Transcript)
53(No Transcript)
54Elida Cordora
The Unit Organizer
NAME
BIGGER PICTURE
4
1/22
DATE
The roots and consequences of civil unrest.
LAST UNIT
/Experience
NEXT UNIT
/Experience
CURRENT UNIT
3
1
2
CURRENT UNIT
The Civil War
The Causes of the Civil War
Growth of the Nation
is about...
8
UNIT SCHEDULE
UNIT MAP
5
1/22 Cooperative groups -
over pp. 201-210
Sectionalism
was based on
was influenced by
1/28 Quiz
pp. 201-236
1/29 Cooperative groups -
Leaders
over pp. 210-225
Areas of
across the
emerged because of
became greater with
the U.S.
U.S.
"Influential Personalities"
project due
Differences
Events in
1/30 Quiz
between
the U.S.
the areas
2/2 Cooperative groups -
over pp. 228-234
2/6 Review for test
2/7 Review for test
2/6 Test
6
descriptive
What was sectionalism as it existed in the U. S.
of 1860?
compare/contrast
UNIT SELF-TEST QUESTIONS
UNIT RELATIONSHIPS
How did the differences in the sections of the
U.S. in 1860 contribute to the start of the Civil
War?
cause/effect
What examples of sectionalism exist in the world
today?
7
55CONCEPT DIAGRAM
À
CONVEY CONCEPT
Â
Á
Key Words
À
Democracy
a form of government
Á
OFFER OVERALL
CONCEPT
Â
NOTE KEY WORDS
CLASSIFY
Ã
CHARACTERISTICS
Always Present
Sometimes Present
Never Present
leaders accountable by elections
direct representation
rule by king
Athens
citizens have equal voting rights
indirect representation
rule by dictator
individuals can oppose government
centralized power
censorship of press
decentralized power
all views are tolerated
hereditary transfer of power
leaders
accountable
separation of power
statement of civil political rights
unified power
Examples
Ä
Nonexamples
EXPLORE EXAMPLES
views
tolerated
United States
China in 1993
direct
England in 1993
England under Henry VIII
Athens (500 B.C.)
Macedonia (under Alexander)
indirect
Å
PRACTICE WITH NEW EXAMPLE
rule by dictator
A democracy is a form of government in which
leaders are accountable to the people through
elections, citizens have equal voting rights,
individuals can oppose the government, all views
are tolerated, and there is a statement of civil
and political right
Æ
TIE DOWN A
DEFINITION
56a period of social change in the U. S.
Social Problems
57Learning Strategies Curriculum
The University of Kansas Center for Research and
Learning
58Acquisition Strategy Self-Questioning
- Attend to clues as you read
- Say some questions
- Keep predictions in mind
- Identify the answer
- Talk about the answers
The University of Kansas Center for Research and
Learning
59Embedded strategy instruction- Example of ASK IT
Strategy Implementation
- All teachers teach the steps of a
self-questioning strategy (ASK IT), regularly
model its use, and then embed paraphrasing
activities in course activities through the year
to create a culture of active reading. -
The University of Kansas Center for Research and
Learning
60Storage StrategyFirst-Letter Mnemonic
- Form a word with first letters
- Insert a letter
- Rearrange the letters
- Shape a sentence
- Try combinations
The University of Kansas Center for Research and
Learning
61Expression StrategyError Monitoring
- Write on every other line using PENS
- Read the paper for meaning
- Interrogate yourself using the COPS questions
- Take the paper to someone for help
- Execute a final copy
- Reread your paper
The University of Kansas Center for Research and
Learning
62- GOOD NEWS!!
- SASED has identified several local certified
trainers - and is planning to offer a workshop series on
the -
- University of Kansas
- Content Enhancement Routines
-
- Learning Strategies Curriculum
- for the 2008-2009 school year.
63How will Content-Area Strategy Instruction be
provided?
- Middle School
- Embedded into content-area courses
- Strategy Instruction course as part of the fine
arts rotation - Strategic tutoring in place of foreign language
- High School
- Embedded into content-area courses
- Strategic tutoring in place of study hall
- Strategy Instruction as an elective
64A Major Source of Support for Secondary
65Components of Well-Designed Syllabi
- Contact Information
- Course Goals and Big Ideas
- Instructions and Directions as to How to Get Help
- Course Materials
- Behavior Expectations and Consequences
- Detailed Information About the Grading System
- Course Calendar and Due Dates
- Self Monitoring Checklists
- Access to Models for Papers, Projects, Tests
66Evaluate Components of Syllabus
67(No Transcript)
68(No Transcript)
69Introduction to Poetry
1. Understanding form Journals
20 2. Understanding content Papers
60 3. Reflecting on reader Class
20 responses
Discussions
Empowering students to learn what poetry is,
what poetry does, and how poetry works.
Critical vocabulary Class demo Paraphrasing
Class demo Note-taking
Class demo
1. How do poets resemble/differ from writers of
other types of literature? 2. What kinds of
information do poems present? 3. What writing
tools and strategies do poets use? 4. Why do
some readers like poetry and others dislike
it? 5. What are the key traditions in poetry
that will most usefully contextualize poetry
for todays readers? 6. What are common themes
in poetry, and how do the themes speak to
readers experiences?
Ray Pence, Graduate Teaching Assistant, English
70Introduction to Poetry
Listening Persistence Mutual Self-respect Openmi
ndedness
Group presentations Visual representations Papers
Websites
Small-group collaborations Reading
journals Public poetry events Finding poetry in
your immediate environment Student-teacher
conferences
Voice Figurative Language Performance Rhythm Poeti
c traditions Art Diction Poetic
forms Use-value Persona Oral histories
Poetry as Reflection illumination of world
Poetry as Storytelling
Poetry as Journey and exploration
Poetry as Social History
Poetry as Autobiography
Ray Pence, Graduate Teaching Assistant, English
71Not Everything We Teach Is Equally
ImportantThe sheer quantity of information
requires us to constantly determine what to
include in a courseKeith Lenz, 2003
http//www.ku-crl.org/archives/classroom/smarter.h
tml
72(No Transcript)
73Students need intensive intervention to work on
basic literacy components.
- Students develop the foundational phonics,
fluency, and comprehension skills through
specialized, direct, and intensive instruction in
reading. Intensive instruction in listening,
speaking, and writing is often a part of these
services. - For example Courses in researched-based reading
- programs such as the SRA Corrective Reading
Program or REACH.
74How will basic literacy skill instruction be
provided?
- Requires a double-block schedule of
English/Language Arts and Reading. - Where does the time come from?
- High School Option
- Reading as an elective
- Middle School Options
- Reading instruction instead of foreign language
- Reading course within the fine arts rotation
75An intensive multi-faceted option for those who
need it.
- Students with underlying language needs learn the
linguistic, related cognitive, metalinguistic,
and metacognitive underpinnings they need to
acquire content literacy skills and strategies. - For example Speech-language pathologists,
special education teachers, and social workers
engage students in educational language and
literacy instruction using a researched-based
program such as the Sopris West Language! Program.
76http//www.corelearn.com/PDFS/Briefing20Papers/CO
RE20Briefing20Paper20Secondary20Reading.pdf
77Read the Carnegie Documentshttp//www.carnegie.
org/literacy/why.html
78(No Transcript)
79 Websites for Scientifically Based Behavior
Support
- National Technical Assistance Center on Positive
Behavioral Interventions and Supports (PBIS)
www.pbis.org - Safe and Civil Schools www.safeandcivilschools.co
m
80At the School Level
81At the School Level
82(No Transcript)
83At the Referral Level
84High School Tier 1 Example
- English Dept. prior to 1993
- Reading and writing skills were not taught in a
consistent manner at LFHS - Members of the English Dept. began learning about
Nancie Atwells reading and writing workshops and
developed a proposal to bring this concept to
LFHS - The School Board approved the proposal and all
teachers were trained in the program for the
1994-95 school year
85Writing Workshop
- PRINCIPLES AND REQUIREMENTS
- Each student must produce 3 pieces of writing
that go through the conferencing process - Each student must produce a portfolio of the
writing process - The focus is on the writing process
- Students must have ownership and their written
work must be student-generated
86Reading Workshop
- PRINCIPLES AND REQUIREMENTS
- At least 12 days/year must be devoted to reading
workshop - Students should be provided time to read
- Students should gain ownership over texts by
selecting what they read - Students should respond to text in a variety of
ways and there must be teacher/student
interaction regarding reading
87English Dept 2005-06
- High level of satisfaction with the writing
skills of students at LFHS - Less satisfaction with reading skills and overall
enjoyment of reading (based off of 1st semester
English finals and anecdotal information)
88Vocabulary The Broad Context..
- Of the many compelling reasons for providing
students with instruction to build vocabulary,
none is more important than the contribution of
vocabulary knowledge to reading comprehension.
Indeed, one of the most enduring findings in
reading research is the extent to which students
vocabulary knowledge relates to their reading
comprehension. - Lehr, F., Osborn, J., Hiebert, E.H. (2004). Focus
on Vocabulary, San Francisco Pacific Resources
for Education and Learning.
89Bringing Words to Life Isabel Beck M. McKeown L.
Kucan Guilford Press
90Vocabulary Matching
91English (VM)
92Science (VM)
93Social Studies (VM)
94Results
- Tier One - Basic words
- chair, bed, happy, house
- Tier Two - Words in general use, but not common
- concentrate, absurd, fortunate, relieved,
dignity, convenient - Tier Three - Rare words limited to a specific
domain - tundra, igneous rocks
95How can we use this information?
- Vocabulary Matching Screening can be completed in
about 15 minutes - Using the cut scores provided we have reason to
believe that students with scores - less than 15 are likely to require strategic or
intensive assistance - between 16 and 25 may require strategic
assistance - above 25 are likely to be on track and can
continue with instruction as planned - in order to meet academic expectations for
Illinois State Achievement test in 10th grade
96Maze
97(No Transcript)
98R- CBM
99(No Transcript)
100Program Options
- Tier 1
- Pre-teaching Key Vocabulary
- Tier 2
- Co-taught English/Reading Block with REWARDS
- Co-taught Course on before, during, and after
reading strategies with a focus on content-area
text - Tier 3
- Social Opportunities Academic Readiness(SOAR)
Includes Language! Social Language Skills
Vocational Opportunities Post-Secondary
Exploration
101Intermediate and Secondary Reading Interventions
102Intensive Reading Intervention
103High School Tier 2 Example Freshman Reading
Classes
- Class A guided reading, modeling, class
discussions, comprehension checks, oral reading,
graphic organizers, REWARDS - Class B guided reading, modeling, class
discussions, comprehension checks, oral reading,
graphic organizers
104WRC Mean Rate of Growth Per Week
- Class A mean rate of growth 0.67 WRC/week
- Class B mean rate of growth -1.22 WRC/week
105Instructional Planning FormGoal In 32 weeks,
Cary will read 95 cwpm with at least 95
accuracy.
106Carys Progress
107Next Steps
- Math!
- Math Department Proposal
- Screening Progress Monitoring
- Yearly Progress Pro (YPP) McGraw-Hill
- Includes CBM Custom Tests
108YPP Examples
7th Grade Math Class
8th Grade CBM Probe
109YPP Algebra Geometry Skill Clusters
110(No Transcript)
111(No Transcript)
112(No Transcript)
113Developing Components
- Systems
- General survey of priorities, Effective Behavior
Support Survey, Team Implementation Checklist
tell you what you want to do - Practices
- School-wide Evaluation Tool tells you how much is
in place - Data
- Curriculum Based Measures and Office Referral
Data tell you with whom to focus
Steve Romano and Hank Bohanon
114School wide Expectations
- Identify expectations of the setting
- Develop team/plan/support
- Directly teach expectations
- Consistent Consequences, Acknowledge/Reinforce
(Tall, Vente, Grande) - Collect Data
- Communicate with staff
- On-going evaluation
115Accessed 3-7-06 http//web.utk.edu/swpbs/school
s/data/hchs/HCHS20SET20920282005.doc
116(No Transcript)
117(02-03 compared to 03-04 X2 53.199, df 2,
p .000)
(03-04 compared to 04-05 X2 6.324, df 2,
p .042)
118Systems/Data
- System - SET Information
- Overall Score approximately 80
- Teaching _at_ 70
- Acknowledgment _at_ 50
- Impact data
- School has access to discipline and attendance
data
119Practice
- To address tardies (high school) names of
students from class were put into a drawing. Four
students names were drawn at random weekly, if
they had no tardies, they could choose a prize.
120Report from School
- Teachers were not able to sustain, teachers did
not remember to conduct drawings. - We can use department chairs to provide reminders
and support to staff (System)
121Control Classrooms
122Treatment Classrooms
123At least at the school-wide level you are
trying to get 80 of your staff teaching!
- In Illinois when schools get to 80/80
- Fewer risk factors
- More protective factors
- More likely to have tried interventions beyond SW
- More students with fewer discipline problems
http//www.pbisillinois.org/ (see FYO5 Report)
124Examples of Targeted Interventions
- Behavior Education Program (BEP)
- Check-In, Check-Out
- Functional Behavioral Assessment/ Behavior
Support Planning
???
125Behavior Education Program (BEP)Features
- Students identified and receive within a week
- Check-in and check-out daily with an adult at
school - Regular Feedback and reinforcement from teachers
- Family component
- Daily performance data used to evaluate progress
Taken from Hawken March, 2004
126General Data Decision Rules
127Step 1 Problem Identification
- Question What is the discrepancy between what is
expected and what is occurring? - 2/3 of Maples individual student referrals were
due to lack of on-time assignment/homework
completion.
128- A homework assignment is defined as any academic
assignment assigned by a core academic, foreign
language, allied arts, or physical education
teacher to be completed after school. Homework
does not include bringing appropriate supplies to
class, turning in forms of any kind, or
participation in fundraising activities. - A homework assignment that is turned in on time
is defined as being received by the assigning
teacher at the requested day and class period.
129Comparison of Fall 2003 and Fall 2004 homework
completion
- 2003
- Average student had 18 assignments
- Average student turned in one assignment late
- Average student had 7 of homework late
- 2004
- Average student had 18 assignments
- Average student turned in one assignment late
- Average student had 6 of homework late
130Total Number of Homework Turned in Late
3
3
Fall 2003
Fall 2004
2
2
0-1 assignments
0-1 assignments
131Step 2 Problem Analysis
- Question Why is the problem occurring?
- Teachers determined a number of hypotheses
including - Lack of time
- Lack of skill
- Lack of motivation/interest in the subject area
132Step 3 Plan Development
- Question What is the goal?
- All students would turn in at least 80 of their
homework on time. - Question How will progress be monitored?
- Teachers will meet weekly and calculate the
average work turned in per week for all students
attending Homework Extension.
133- Question What is the intervention plan to
address the goal? - Homework Extension takes place during lunch
periods. Students assigned to Homework Extension
will go to the lunchroom to get their lunch (if
purchasing their lunch) and then report to the
Homework Extension classroom. - Homework Extension is supervised by one/two of
the lunch room supervisors in a separate
classroom.
134- Homework Extension lasts the entire lunch period
for the course of five school days. Students are
then reevaluated. If work completion exceeds
80, the student may return to the lunchroom. If
not, he/she will be reassigned to Homework
Extension. - If a student attends Homework Extension for three
consecutive weeks, then the student is
automatically referred for individual student
problem solving.
135Step 4 Plan Implementation
- Question How will implementation
- integrity be ensured?
- The principal required a weekly e-mail sent out
to report which students qualified for Homework
Extension and which attended Homework Extension
and met their goals. - The principal and assistant principal found a
classroom and staff who would assist and monitor
students work completion during lunch.
136Step 5 Plan Evaluation
- Question Is the intervention plan effective?
- Are the students making progress toward the goal?
- Yes, 66 of students were in HE for 1 week.
(33-2 weeks 3-3weeks 11 students total.) - Is the student decreasing the discrepancy between
him/her and the general education peers? - Yes, 77 of students were in HE only 1x. (11-2x
8-3x 4-4x 6 students total.) - Is the plan able to be maintained in the general
education setting? - No, 34 of students were involved in HE
Universal not targeted problem.
137Plan Evaluation Outcomes Form