Title: Power Transmission Technology: The Second Revolution Superconductor-Based Technologies and Regulatory Reform Strategies To Boost Grid Capacity, Improve Reliability and
1Power Transmission TechnologyThe Second
RevolutionSuperconductor-Based Technologiesand
Regulatory Reform StrategiesTo Boost Grid
Capacity, Improve Reliabilityand Break the
Gridlock
Massachusetts Restructuring Roundtable Boston,
MA November 16, 2001 John B. Howe Vice
President, Electric Industry Affairs
2American Superconductor Corporation
Nasdaq AMSC
- We are a world leader in developing and
manufacturing products using superconducting
wires and power electronic switches for the power
infrastructure
3Overview
- Todays Power Grid is Severely Stressed
- The Grid Never Violates the Laws of Physics
- New Grid Technologies Description and Benefits
- High-Capacity HTS TD Power Cable
- Distributed SMES for Voltage Stability
- Network Effects of a Stronger Power Grid
Component Benefits -- System-level Benefits - Regulatory and Legislative Reforms That Can Speed
the Adoption of New Grid Technologies
4A Convergence of Many Factors...
- Demand Growth
- Siliconization
- Siting Obstacles
- Erratic Pace of Deregulation
- Eroding Reliability
Has Brought Us to Power Gridlock --
And A Demand for New Power Technologies
5The Power Struggle Summer 2001
6Grid Investment Lagging in U.S.
7Power Grids Have Limited Capacity
- The amount of power that can be transmitted
through a particular grid is limited by a number
of factors, chiefly - Thermal Limits
- Line/cable conductors reach physical capacity
- Overload leads to excessive sag, degraded
insulation, burnout and outright failure - Stability Limits
- Lines reach limit of safe operation by standards
of Prudent Operating Practice - Overload puts system at risk of fast collapse
during a contingency (line outage, plant trip)
8The Changing Role of the Power Grid
- Pre-1990s Vertically-Integrated Monopoly
- Mid-1990s Rise of DG -- Is the Grid Obsolete?
- 2000s The Grid Isnt Going Away Soon --
But It Needs a Major Upgrade Now!! - The Grids New Role Platform for Competition
The Lesson from Other Regulated Industries The
Key to Robust Competition Lies in a Robust
Physical Network
9Superconductor Technology Benefits
- Raise Energy Efficiency
- Increase Capacity
- Improve Reliability and Power Quality
- Reduce Environmental Impacts
- Put Scarce Real Estate to Higher Value Uses
Component Benefits of Superconductivity are
Leveraged into even Larger System-Level Benefits
10HTS Wire 140x Increase in Wire Capacity
The Basis for the Revolution
11HTS Wire Price/Performance Trend
Performance and Yields are Rising -- Costs are
Falling
1200
Actual
1000
Target
800
Price/Performance Ratio, /kA-m
600
400
200
0
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
Price of One Meter of Wire Carrying 1,000
Amperes
12First Commercial HTS Wire Plant --Devens
Commerce Park, Massachusetts
8/00 Broke Ground
8/01 First Employees
1/02 Fully Equipped
8/02 High-Yield Production
13HTS Power Cable Alliance
- Exclusive commercial agreement
- Alliance since 1990
- 30 million in funding to AMSC
- First HTS cable in 1996 - Beta-phase about to
start
14High Capacity HTS Power Cables
More power carried in same right of way at much
lower voltages and system costs.
15HTS Cable The 3-to-1 Advantage
(3, 4) Three HTS Cables Are Installed --
Six Conduits Free for Expansion/Other Uses
(1, 2) Nine Existing Copper Cables Are Removed
16Urban Re-Electrification Virtual Bus
2
3
17Urban Re-Electrification Urban Ring
18HTS Re-electrification Reclaiming Corridors
19HTS DC Transmission Uses and Benefits
- Integrate Markets Tap the Large Interregional
Price Disparities Exposed by Deregulation - Special Delivery Serve Congested Urban Load
Pockets with Virtual Power Plant - Operation Avoid Parallel Path / Loop Flows
- Environment Avoid AC Line Siting, EMF Issues
- 2020 Vision Separate Grid into AC Islands
Connected by Controllable DC Bridges - Improved Stability and Reliability
- Make the System Function as the Economists Want
it to!
20Distributed SMES Attacks the Power Bandwidth
Problem
- Power Transmission Lines Never Operate at Full
Capacity (or Bandwidth) - Our Least Expensive New Grid Capacity
The Capacity that Already Exists but Cant be
Used - At What Fraction of Maximum Bandwidth are Your
Utilitys Power Lines Operating? - U.S. Average 35 !
21Old Solution- String More Lines!
22A New Solution - SMES
- Power electronics and superconductors
- Most effective
- Lowest cost
- Quickest solution
- No environmental permits
23SMES Basics
Proprietary Storage Technology...
- Coil of LTS wire stores enough energy to deliver
3 megawatts of power in one second.
24SMES Products
Plus Proprietary Power Electronics Technology
Delivers megawatts of real power instantaneously
and simultaneously with megaVARS of reactive
power.
25PQ SMES Precise Power Quality Protection
LINE VOLTAGE (IN)
LOAD VOLTAGE (OUT)
26D-SMES Wide Area Grid Stabilization
1.1
1
D-SMES
0.9
0.8
Base Run - 115kV
0.7
0.6
Relative Voltage
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
Time in Seconds
27D-SMES vs. Conventional Overhead Lines
- Effective alternative where existing lines are
stability-limited (vs. thermally limited) - Eliminates siting political obstacles
- Quick installation
(2 days) - Mobility -- avoids
stranded asset risk
28WPS Northern Loop (No. Wisconsin)
D-SMES
- First permanent use of superconductors in a
live grid - 6 units deployed in July 2000
- 3 MVAR reactive power capacity (2.3x short term
overload capability)
100 miles
29WPS Northern Loop
350
Thermal Limit
300
Current Operation
250
200
Available Load Serving Capability, MW
150
100
50
0
Six D-SMES 15 Safe Increase in Power Bandwidth
30Entergy Gulf States (East Texas)
D-SMES
- Two units in 2001, two more in 2002
- 8 MVAR reactive power capability (2.3x overload)
- D-SMES built into Entergys strategic planning
process
31Entergy Gulf States
1900
Thermal Limit
1800
1700
1600
Current Operation
Available Load Serving Capability, MW
1500
1400
1300
1200
1100
1000
Four D-SMES 20 Safe Increase in Power
Bandwidth
32D-SMES Uses and Benefits
- Utility Increase Load Serving Capability Over
Existing Lines -- Maintain Reliability Objective - Trader / Marketer Increase Import / Export /
Transfer Capacity -- For a Slice of the Benefit - System Planner / IPP Facilitate Interconnection
of New Merchant Generators -- and Fill in
Holes Caused by Retirement of Older Generators - Environmental / Emissions Trading Reduce Need
for Dirty Reliability-Must-Run (RMR) Units --
Generate / Claim / Trade Valuable Credits
33A Stronger Grid Gives Rise toSystem-Level
Benefits
- Enable Closer Adherence to Economic Dispatch
(Fuel Efficiency and Air Quality Benefits) - Better Integration of Remote Resources including
Coal/Nuclear and Renewables (Solar/ Wind) - Integrated National Grid Can Save 10Bs in
Generation Investment to maintain Reserve Margin - Reduced Congestion Is Essential to Ensure the
Success of New Retail Competitive Frameworks
34The Problem
For Utilities that Operate Under Traditional
Cost-of-Service Regulation, Investing in
Transmission Assets to Reduce Congestion is
Unprofitable or Worse.
35Some Level of Transmission Constraints is
Economically Efficient
Benefits of Relieving Constraint
Dollars Invested
Economically Desirable Level of Constraint
Cost of Relieving Constraint
Number of Hours Constrained
36What Determines Optimal Constraint?The Form of
Regulation Matters!!
Large RTO Internalizing All Congestion Costs
Dollars Invested
Vertically-Integrated, Local Regulated Utility
Unbundled DISCO under Cost of Service
Unbundled DISCO under Multi-Year Price Cap
VI Utility with Non-Regulated Marketing/Generating
Affiliate
Number of Hours Constrained
37Network Investment The Key to Robust Competition
- Telecom, 1970s No One Will Replicate the
Existing Communications Network
(1980s-90s Fiber Optic, Wireless Networks) - Natural Gas, Early 1980s A Sunset Industry
(1990s New Pipelines, Compression, IT) - Airlines Landing Gates Key to Mitigating
Incumbent Market Power (the OHare Problem)
Competition in Commodities Spurred by
Competition in the Building of Network Facilities
38Incentives to Strengthen the Grid Regulatory
and Legislative Actions
- Move RTO Focus From Congestion Management to
Congestion Relief! - Performance-Based Regulation (a la UK)
- Mandatory Reliability Standards
- Coordinate Development of Road, Railway and
Utility Infrastructures - In the Long Run, the Most Stable End Point Will
Be True Network-Based Competition.
39Stimulating New Grid InvestmentExempt
Transmission Facilities
- Applies to New Facilities -- Not Existing AC
Network - Must Meet Low Environmental Impact Standard
- Technologies with Controllable Current
(Avoid Impact on Underlying AC Network Flows) - ETFs Have No Recourse to Eminent Domain
- Show Absence of Market Power (Size, Ownership)
40Proposed Benefits of ETF Status
- Exemption from Rate Regulation under FPA
- Eligibility for Streamlined/Federalized Siting
Process Modeled on Interstate Natural Gas
Pipelines - Exemption from Open Access Requirements under
FERC Order 888 / 2000
41Break the Gridlock!Thank You!Questions?jhow
e_at_amsuper.comwww.amsuper.com