Critical Theory

1
Critical Theory
2
The Frankfurt School

• Associated with the Institute of Social Research
  at the University of Frankfurt in Germany in
  1923.
• Key Theorists Max Horkheimer (1895-1973),
  Theodor Adorno (1903-1969), Herbert Marcuse
  (1898-1979) and Erich Fromm (1900-1980)

3
To the U.S.

• All of the key theorists came from middle class
  Jewish backgrounds. All fled Germany for America
  by the mid 1930s.
• Later Adorno and Horkheimer returend to Germany
  and re-established the Institute in 1949.
• Over time the group diverged.

4
Understanding Critical Theory- The Centrality of
Class

• As a derivative of Marxism, studies of class and
  class movements were central. In addition to the
  continuing changes wrought by industrialization,
  and today post-industrialization (shift to
  service sector economy) that significantly
  impacted the standard of living of many.

5
The Critiques of Critical Theory

• Criticisms of Marxian Theory
• Criticisms of Positivism
• Criticisms of Sociology
• Critique of Modern Society
• Critique of Culture

6
(No Transcript)
7
Understanding Critical Theory

• Two Propositions
• 1) People are a product of the society in which
  they live. Hence this implies that their is no
  such thing as an objective fact that can be known
  outside of structure.
• 2) Intellectuals should not try to be objective
  and separate value judgments from their work

8
Cultural Analysis

• Critical Theory applied theory to culture. It is
  a harbinger of Cultural Studies.

9
Whats Different About Critical Theory?

• The magpie approach of blending pieces for a
  range of theories is a noteworthy shift.
• This consumption of multiple theories in some
  ways mirrors the mass culture that critical
  theory critiques.
• Is this irony problematic for critical theorists?

10
Do Knowledge and Truth Exist?

• For a critical theorist, knowledge and truth do
  exist. Not all critical attitudes are equal.
• However, one must recognize that ones own work
  is not objective, but a product of a person
  limited by time and location.
• The normative approach of critical theory brings
  one closer to truth and knowledge than positivist
  social science.

11
Marxist Influences

• The Dialectical Method -Studies patterns of inner
  conflict. Each system contains within it a
  series of contradictions that eventually
  overburden the system and led to its
  destruction.
• Importance of societys economic organization
• Critique of class relations

12
Areas of Study

• Culture, Personality, and the Administered
  Society
• The Critique of Mass Culture
• Rationalization and Communicative Action
• Evolution and Crisis
• Rationalization and the Lifeworld
• Reason and Rationalization

13
Culture, Personality and the Administered Society

• Materialist perspective- ie. Fascism is rooted in
  capitalism.
• However, the bulk of work focuses on aspects of
  personality, culture, and thought, not social
  institutions.
• Analyses focus on the ways that the economic
  system distorts personality.

14
Culture, Personality and the Administered
Society- Two Examples

• Adorno, in The Authoritarian Personality-
  demonstrates how prejudice is more likely to
  occur in those raised in authoritarian
  environments.
• Fromm expands Marxs alienation to examine
  creativity and identity. Modern man has
  everything a car, a house, a job, kids, a
  marriage, problems, troubles, satisfactions He
  is nothing

15
The Critique of Mass Culture

• Culture and ideology as a semi-autonomous realm
  (Different from Marx)
• Culture, especially mass culture, operates to
  maintain and strengthen the existing order.
• Popular culture is a means of manipulating
  inhabitants of a totally administered society.

16
Examples of the Mass Culture Critique

• Adorno- attacked Jazz and popular music for being
  standardized and distracting them/passifying.
  (Im a rebel because I listen to rock and roll)
• Adorno- attacked astrology as operating to
  reproduce the social order.
• Marcuse- One Dimensional Man- technical progress
  has made possible a system of domination and
  coordination that defeats all protest. We
  surrender to mass media produced fall needs. We
  have no cultural alternatives.

17
Rationalization and Communicative Action- Habermas

• Role of individuals perceptions in maintaining
  or realizing social change
• Evolution and Crisis- Habermas identifies a
  number of social formations
• Builds on Marxs dialectic but he focuses on the
  role of ideas and consciousness.
• Tackles the problem of legitimacy. Why are some
  orders recognized and others are not.

18
Liberal Capitalism and the Depoliticization of
Class

• Prior to liberal capitalism, relations are clear.
  The control of the state by a small group was
  of central importance.
• Under capitalism, a cumulative process of
  rationalization occurs. There is a shift from
  the sacred to the secular.
• How validity claims are made shifts from myth,
  religion, philosophy to ideology.
• Legitimation crisis is inevitable as
  contradictions of capitalism undermine
  legitimation.

19
Rationalization and the Lifeworld

• Lifeworld- how evolutionary change is actually
  experienced by individuals (Habermas).
  Rationalization changes what our taken for
  granted lifeworld is.

20
Reason and Rationalization
21
Reason and Rationalization

• The order can be rational without rationalized.
• Habermas argues that one can provide the
  grounding for the ultimate norms that govern our
  lives and thereby replace the void left by
  modernitys disenchantment.

22
Legitimation Crisis and Flint Michigan

• Economic crisis- How does the economic situation
  in Flint Michigan exemplify Habermas Ideas?

23
The Example of Walter Benjamin

• Benjamin argues that the shift to the mechanical
  production of art undermines its revolutionary
  potential.
• Benjamin theorizes that the changes in perception
  and how we perceive reflects social
  transformations.
• To an ever greater degree the work of art
  reproduced becomes the work of art designed for
  reproducibility.

24
The Culture of Fear and Fascism

• How does the culture of fear fit into Benjamins
  analysis?

25
Benjamin on the Dangers of Fascism

• Fascism- A system of government that exercises a
  dictatorship of the extreme right, typically
  through the merging of state and business
  leadership together with belligerent nationalism.
• Spectacle and Fascism-
• The formation of masses are two aspects of the
  same process- fascism and false self-expression
• All efforts to render politics aesthetic
  culminate in one thing War.